Consent or No Consent?

I love it when the left stumble over each other.
Womens rights vs migrant discrimination, have fun with this one libtards.
 
He's a member of a "protected" group.

Oh come on now. From a political point of view do you think it is better to side with a foreign rapist or the female victim.

But this assumes that the judge bends the law depending on whom is in front of him. There are checks in place for that called appeals.

Looking in the paper today I saw a list of reasons why an appeal is being pursued. Not being a lawyer I don't know if they are valid or not. But I assume the crown believes it has a chance of winning.
 
I don't see the conflict. If you have zero ability to make a rational decision (case 2) then you shouldn't be operating a vehicle (case 1). Where's the conflict?
The conflict arises when we make a drunken decision and then are held responsible for our actions. The driver is responsible but is the sex participant responsible? In most cases, I would say yes, but in some, no. This case is probably a no.
 
The conflict arises when we make a drunken decision and then are held responsible for our actions. The driver is responsible but is the sex participant responsible? In most cases, I would say yes, but in some, no. This case is probably a no.

I don't see the conflict. Inability to consent has nothing to do with criminal liability. You are responsible for your actions whether or not you can legally consent to them.
 
I don't see the conflict. If you have zero ability to make a rational decision (case 2) then you shouldn't be operating a vehicle (case 1). Where's the conflict?

Read what you just wrote: if you have zero ability to make a rational decision then why are you responsible for THE DECISION to operate a motor vehicle?
 
I don't see the conflict. Inability to consent has nothing to do with criminal liability. You are responsible for your actions whether or not you can legally consent to them.

My God. What savage time period were you born in? People are responsible for actions they can't legally consent to now?
 
Read what you just wrote: if you have zero ability to make a rational decision then why are you responsible for THE DECISION to operate a motor vehicle?

You are always responsible for your decisions. You are sloppily trying to overload the word responsible to cover two very different concepts: capacity to know right from wrong (criminal liability) versus capacity to consent.
 
You are always responsible for your decisions. You are sloppily trying to overload the word responsible to cover two very different concepts: capacity to know right from wrong (criminal liability) versus capacity to consent.
You seem to be implying that a drunk may know what's right and what's wrong but at the same time be too drunk to consent.
I don't think that it is easier to figure out what's right and what's wrong than to figure out whether you want to fuck. Even for a sober person.
The reason the law is the way it is it's only because of the public policy. We simply recognize that taking the intoxication defence away from drunk drivers and rapists and bar brawlers goes a long way in ensuring law and order. That's it. Not because it's fair or reasonable. Only because it works well.
If we were completely honest in some sort of an ideal society we would all agree hopefully that if a good citizen got so drunk that he didn't know what he was doing (which we all did) and assaulted somebody or drove drunk then intoxication should be available to him as a defense.
 
You seem to be implying that a drunk may know what's right and what's wrong but at the same time be too drunk to consent.

Absolutely. No matter how drunk I've been I've always known not to drive, commit assault, etc, but I was frequently in no condition to sign a contract, etc.

We know right from wrong at a very basic level.
 
Absolutely. No matter how drunk I've been I've always known not to drive, commit assault, etc, but I was frequently in no condition to sign a contract, etc.

We know right from wrong at a very basic level.

There is no such thing as right and wrong on a basic level or really on any level, except legal or religious. This is why there are different laws in different countries. Calling someone a motherfucker is a criminal offence in some countries. Is it right? Wrong? Who knows. Is fucking a prostitute wrong for a married person? Is smoking pot wrong?

Meanwhile wanting or not wanting to fuck someone really is as basic as it gets. A monkey knows whether it wants to fuck another monkey. That's how basic it is. And it's not really comparable to signing a contract. Being drunk doesn't enhance your enjoyment from signing. Signing is not "fun". Sex is. So people don't really drink before they sign. But they often drink or get high before sex. A lawyer who would kick a slightly drunk client out of the office may happily and legally fuck similarly slightly intoxicated person after an evening at the bar.
 
There is no such thing as right and wrong on a basic level or really on any level, except legal or religious. This is why there are different laws in different countries. Calling someone a motherfucker is a criminal offence in some countries. Is it right? Wrong? Who knows. Is fucking a prostitute wrong for a married person? Is smoking pot wrong?

Meanwhile wanting or not wanting to fuck someone really is as basic as it gets. A monkey knows whether it wants to fuck another monkey. That's how basic it is. And it's not really comparable to signing a contract. Being drunk doesn't enhance your enjoyment from signing. Signing is not "fun". Sex is. So people don't really drink before they sign. But they often drink or get high before sex. A lawyer who would kick a slightly drunk client out of the office may happily and legally fuck similarly slightly intoxicated person after an evening at the bar.

That may be your philosophy but I guarantee you that the judge who hears your case thinks breaking the law is wrong.

At any rate the point is that it's not the same standard. Consent requires an ability to reason in a way that knowing right from wrong doesn't. They're not the same concept, not the same standard. Using words like "responsible" to blur the difference muddies the discussion.

To be perfectly clear here is the standard required by the criminal code, which mere intoxication doesn't meet:

"No person is criminally responsible for an act committed or an omission made while suffering from a mental disorder that rendered the person incapable of appreciating the nature and quality of the act or omission or of knowing that it was wrong."

When you get in your car and drive drunk you KNOW it's wrong, you just don't care, or judge that you will get away with it. But drunk drivers invariably know they are breaking the law and do it anyway.
 
You are always responsible for your decisions. You are sloppily trying to overload the word responsible to cover two very different concepts: capacity to know right from wrong (criminal liability) versus capacity to consent.

The two can be the same if someone does not have the mental capacity to know or consent. But I defer to Post #76 which settles it.
 
Absolutely. No matter how drunk I've been I've always known not to drive, commit assault, etc, but I was frequently in no condition to sign a contract, etc.

We know right from wrong at a very basic level.

I've never been THAT drunk to not know better (and I don't want to be either).