Gun-control in the US

Status
Not open for further replies.
You say "… that basically leaves 1,712 deaths by firearm" right above your poster's boldface announcement there are 32,000 deaths by firearm, an appalling total. Can't have it both ways. Those other 30,000 deaths by guns still happened. I am reluctantly left to conclude that your unstated point is that we should all just blithely pretend they didn't.

You appear quite capable (not to say proud of) of such self-deception, but I'm not.

No one's pretending they didn't happen, just illustrating that it's no reason to go punish the vast majority of gun owners for the misdeeds of the few. No different that discriminating against ethnic minorities, those who adhere certain religions or even responsible drivers.

Shit happens.
 
Yes - all of those firearms are the favourites of terrorist mass murderers.

Please don't encourage these simple minded people who try to ban guns based on how scary they look.


You missed my point. Joe average has no business owning the types of guns i was describing.

I am trying to meet you gin nuts half way. Sure you can have a gun just not any gun.
 
Yup, the gun "debate" is filled with slippery slopes, there will always be something else that gun haters will say gun owners don't "need". They're trying to get rid of lever actions in Australia, for fuck's sake.

Are you saying rights to free speech, religion and association supercedes public safety?

I think it's stupid that I have to ask permission to transport and shoot my AR-15. I think it's stupid that although I can legally discharge a non-restricted rifle on Crown Land or a back 40 of private property, in rural Canada, I can't do that with a pistol.

So I guess there are Canadian Laws that neither of us like, the balance isn't so great after all.

Lever action is okay with me. Like i said certain guns i can understand but others should be flat out banned.

No idea what you are talking about with those freedoms you listed.
 
No one's pretending they didn't happen, just illustrating that it's no reason to go punish the vast majority of gun owners for the misdeeds of the few. No different that discriminating against ethnic minorities, those who adhere certain religions or even responsible drivers.

Shit happens.

Fucking hopeless.

People on a daily basis are restricted because of dumb people in the past. There are limits in society so why should guns be exempt?

The proposed laws would not have punished legal gun owners. The nra is unreasonable.

Not sure why a shit happens attitude cant also be applied to gun lovers and the law.
 
I would respect gun owners so much more if they were just honest and admitted that they like guns and don't want bans or restrictions.

Instead they trivialize deaths, cry about their rights and incorrectly rationalize why they should be able to own a gun.

Flat out people are more likely to be shot in a household thst has a gun rsther than one that doesn't.
 
Idiotically you misrepresented the premium suppliers in Afghanistan get for their product as if it were equivalent to a premium on what buyers pay.

Another fail.

Here's an article that mentions the same increase in supplier premiums while also discussing street price:

http://www.forbes.com/sites/jacobsu...rugs-is-doomed-by-economics-101/#d194f215f61b

And I quote:

“illegal drug prices have generally decreased while drug purity has generally increased since 1990. "

pointless to argue with a demented nut case

Nowhere did I say anything of the sort - you seem to have a compulsion to constantly misrepresent what other people say, I guess that is part of your pathology.

Here is my statement "The prohibition premium on "illegal drugs" is up to 90% of the cost."

I don't care what the street price is - whether it has risen or fallen is not the point. The point is that (whatever the cost is) up to 90% of the cost is due to prohibition.

I'm really not surprised you fail to see the point.
 
You missed my point. Joe average has no business owning the types of guns i was describing.

I am trying to meet you gin nuts half way. Sure you can have a gun just not any gun.

You clearly have missed the point. How many murders or crimes are being committed by legal gun owners with .50 calibre rifles, UTAS-12 shotguns or .22 calibre rifles with 100 round magazines?

Simple ignorance is the reason why most people have no clue about the second amendment and the reasons why the founders wanted citizens to have the right to bear arms.

 
pointless to argue with a demented nut case

Nowhere did I say anything of the sort - you seem to have a compulsion to constantly misrepresent what other people say, I guess that is part of your pathology.

Here is my statement "The prohibition premium on "illegal drugs" is up to 90% of the cost."

I don't care what the street price is - whether it has risen or fallen is not the point. The point is that (whatever the cost is) up to 90% of the cost is due to prohibition.

I'm really not surprised you fail to see the point.

Post reported to moderator: insulting other members.
 
I don't care what the street price is - whether it has risen or fallen is not the point.

That IS the point. The context is whether or not a ban on guns would make them more expensive for criminals. The war on drugs was brought up as an example: the street price of illegal drugs DID NOT decline.
 
You say "… that basically leaves 1,712 deaths by firearm" right above your poster's boldface announcement there are 32,000 deaths by firearm, an appalling total. Can't have it both ways. Those other 30,000 deaths by guns still happened. I am reluctantly left to conclude that your unstated point is that we should all just blithely pretend they didn't.

You appear quite capable (not to say proud of) of such self-deception, but I'm not
The point of that poster (as you call it) was completely lost on you, wasnt it??!

No one's pretending they didn't happen, just illustrating that it's no reason to go punish the vast majority of gun owners for the misdeeds of the few. No different that discriminating against ethnic minorities, those who adhere certain religions or even responsible drivers.

Shit happens
^^^ this guy gets it
 
Exactly. There are many reasons why people commit suicide, and having access to guns isn't one of them.
You are partly right.

Having a gun is not a "reason" for suicide. It is a method of suicide.

And it is logical to understand that having the easiest method at your ready disposal will increase the number of suicides.

But you are pro-gun so I expect you won't comprehend this.
 
You are partly right.

Having a gun is not a "reason" for suicide. It is a method of suicide.

And it is logical to understand that having the easiest method at your ready disposal will increase the number of suicides.

But you are pro-gun so I expect you won't comprehend this.

The data doesn't support your claim. There are numerous studies that show GUN suicides are reduced by gun control legislation, but there are other studies that show TOTAL suicides do not decline. In other words, people intent on suicide are not deterred by lack of access to a firearm. They find another way.

This is actually a hotly debated topic with studies from both sides reaching different conclusions and no definitive answer.

The conclusion is therefore that if there is a statistically significant effect it isn't a large one or the debate wouldn't still be going on about it.

You can argue the "if even one life" thing and say even a small effect is worth banning all guns for, but I don't agree. If it's a small effect it isn't worth banning guns.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.