Gun-control in the US

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think you missed my point. So I'll try to elaborate.

60% are suicides. While tragic, suicides are a choice and are often avoidable.
Suicides however pose no threat to the general public as most of them simply kill one person.

3% are accidents. Again, this is tragic, but accidents are very difficult to avoid.

4% are justified. This usually means self-defense. In that case its good riddance.

80% of homicides are gang-related. This usually means one gangbanger knocking off another gangbanger.
In this case again, good riddance.

So that basically leaves 1,712 deaths by firearm [Nope. It leaves the same 35,000 deaths by firearms your boy began with] in a country of 330 million people which is flooded with guns.
Thats a very low ratio so long as you're not in any of the risk groups, which most people arent.

Bottom line: there is no gun problem for law-abiding citizens for the most part


[Edited out the poster jpg. easily and often found above]
That miniscule percentage the poster-producer calculated is just the remainder un-assignable to other specific causes. Do tell us how it includes all us law-abiding citizens, so we can be sure we're behaving like proper members of that class. If you imagine we as a community don't or shouldn't care about preventing even a gang-banger suiciding by cop, then you have a problem, and we have one if you're armed.

I'm sorry, but you haven't made a point to be missed. Suicides are "…deaths by firearms", as are all the other specific cases. So until you say who is in that tiny group of the dead you haven't accounted for, you can't say you've 'proven' "…there's no gun problem". Or whatever you were trying to prove.

Clearly intentional self-inflicted death isn't usually a danger to any but the shooter, but they're still gun deaths. As are those accidents, and all the others. In that country "… flooded with guns" how many of those 'discounted' deaths you're telling us to ignore would/could have been prevented but for that flooding?

You give no evidence for your assertions about self-defense, or gang-bangers being careful to shoot only guilty gang-bangers (ten yr olds watching TV? Party-goers on Danzig Ave? Eaton Centre Shoppers? Jane Creba?), but I could imagine excluding the general population from being at risk of being shot in a 'justifiable' homicide. Then I recall the TPS shooting of a guy over an apartment noise dispute. Because they had nothing but guns to use.

All you and your poster 'prove' is that one in ten-thousand Americans will die by gunfire or in traffic.

But we register cars and require they be insured and license their owners and require they pass tests, and we assign serious police personnel to make as sure as we can that they are not used for deadly purpose or in dangerous ways. Even in the land of the free.

And the Orlando dead are there in the unjustified homicides, along with the Sandy Hook kids.
-----------
P{S: Where did you clip that poster from? Since it gives no source for any of the numbers (CDC publishes libraries full of stuff each and every year and the population numbers are way outta date), I'm curious what supporting material might be on the site.
 
ATF officials say that only about 8% of the nation's 124,000 retail gun dealers sell the majority of handguns that are used in crimes. They conclude that these licensed retailers are part of a block of rogue entrepreneurs tempted by the big profits of gun trafficking

http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/guns/procon/guns.html

Yes many guns used in crimes are attained illegally but that is misleading because to the average person it sounds like they are buying it on the corner from a guy with a trench coat but it looks like if you trace those guns it comes from so called legit dealers of guns.

So this suggests to me that the problem is that there needs to be a way to monitor which dealers are selling these guns tht end up on the streets.
 
They are purchased illegally. That isn't going to change. Even if you eliminated every gun store in the United States they would be smuggled in from Mexico along with all the drugs. It's not a cat you can put back in the bag.

According to the link I provided in another post many guns in crimes from from dealers within the country so actually shutting down those places would have an effect.

Sure maybe some other criminal enterprise would try and fill the void but is that really a reason to not do it? I mean by that rationale why try and stop any crime because someone else will just fill that void.
 
If you imagine we as a community don't or shouldn't care about preventing even a gang-banger suiciding by cop, then you have a problem
No, we shouldnt care. People make bad choices and have to suffer the consequences of their own actions

I'm sorry, but you haven't made a point to be missed. Suicides are "…deaths by firearms", as are all the other specific cases. So until you say who is in that tiny group of the dead you haven't accounted for, you can't say you've 'proven' "…there's no gun problem". Or whatever you were trying to prove
I'm saying people that kill themselves with a gun are almost always no threat to the rest of society when it comes to guns.

Are you having trouble comprehending this??

Clearly intentional self-inflicted death isn't usually a danger to any but the shooter, but they're still gun deaths
Exactly. And somebody who wants to commit suicide will find a way, even if they dont own a gun

In that country "… flooded with guns" how many of those 'discounted' deaths you're telling us to ignore would/could have been prevented but for that flooding?
Again, somebody who wants to commit suicide will find a way, even if they dont own a gun

You give no evidence for your assertions about self-defense, or gang-bangers being careful to shoot only guilty gang-bangers (ten yr olds watching TV? Party-goers on Danzig Ave? Eaton Centre Shoppers? Jane Creba?)
Thats why in my previous post I said its USUALLY one gangbanger knocking off another gangbanger.
I didnt say this was always the case, and yes sometimes innocents get shot in the process

And the Orlando dead are there in the unjustified homicides, along with the Sandy Hook kids
And your point is?? If that Orlando shooter didnt have access to guns he probably would have constructed a homemade bomb and caused just as much carnage

P{S: Where did you clip that poster from? Since it gives no source for any of the numbers (CDC publishes libraries full of stuff each and every year and the population numbers are way outta date), I'm curious what supporting material might be on the site
They are sourced from FBI and CDC statistics
 
No, we shouldnt care.
[ AK's cut and paste tit for tat can be seen in full above]
They are sourced from FBI and CDC statistics
Duh. Again you repeat the phony poster, and ignore the point. Where can we find them? Let's see the CDC and FBI saying anything like the the number the poster made up. And read them saying — as both you and your 'source' do — first that there are 32,000 firearms deaths, then that there are less than two-thousand. I can't believe or imagine real statisticians doing that sort of hocus-pocussing to make up a small-subset and saying it has anything to do with the general population. Or being so inept at expressing their important finding. Where are their real numbers and what thy really say about them?

I think you imagine you've made a point about gun-control, but you haven't said what that is, any more than you've said who makes up your class of 1,702 — apart from them all being as dead as the rest of the thirty thou. I certainly take your point about building homemade bombs, but why ever would anyone do that much hard dangerous work when all you have to do is walk into a gunstore to equip yourself to kill fags, schoolkids or Batman fans? Or check Dad's nightstand when you're down in the dumps.

When gun deaths are as common as car deaths in your society, you're doing it wrong. How to do it right is debatable. That poster's just pointless noise.
 
The overwhelming majority of those deaths are by suicide. If you compare the rate of suicide in Canada to the United States, you discover that it's exactly the same. When people want to kill themselves, they find a way to do it, with or without guns.
Very interesting that I just looked up that 16% of suicides in Canada are via guns.

In the U.S. 51% of the deaths are by gun.

Obviously having more guns available facilitates suicide. It takes just a split second. Something like hanging (#1 in Canada) takes more of an effort and is a more unpleasant way to die. Guaranteed there would be less suicides in the U.S. if people had to resort to something more involved than pulling a trigger.
 
I'm saying people that kill themselves with a gun are almost always no threat to the rest of society when it comes to guns.

Are you having trouble comprehending this??
Ever hear of murder/suicide cases? Very common.

I'm sure you comprehend.
 
Ever hear of murder/suicide cases? Very common.

I'm sure you comprehend
No, its not very common (relative to regular suicides).
Stats Canada lists it as "relatively rare"

http://www.statcan.gc.ca/pub/85-002-x/2013001/article/11805/11805-2-eng.htm

Although murder-suicides in Canada are relatively rare, previous studies have shown that they frequently tend to involve members from the same family (Aston and Pottie Bunge 2005). Family-related murder-suicides represent the most fatal outcome of family violence

In the US there are approximately 1,200 murder/suicides a year.
Source: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/josh-sugarmann/the-gun-violence-we-arent_b_8461358.html

Yet there are 42,000 regular suicides in the US every year.
Source: https://afsp.org/about-suicide/suicide-statistics/

That means murder-suicides make up less than 3% of total suicides.
You fail again, shackie :yo:
 
That poster's just pointless noise
Its pointless to you because you apparently still dont get the point it was trying to make.
(although I'm quite frankly not really surprised by this)
 
Its pointless to you because you apparently still dont get the point it was trying to make.
(although I'm quite frankly not really surprised by this)
Guess the poster, and the guy putting it up, weren't very good at making their point. Or at supplying references for it that would be worthy of a Grade Nine essay.

Feel free to quote the point you say I missed, but no more reposts from Facebook you won't back up.
 
No, its not very common (relative to regular suicides).
Stats Canada lists it as "relatively rare"

http://www.statcan.gc.ca/pub/85-002-x/2013001/article/11805/11805-2-eng.htm



In the US there are approximately 1,200 murder/suicides a year.
Source: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/josh-sugarmann/the-gun-violence-we-arent_b_8461358.html

Yet there are 42,000 regular suicides in the US every year.
Source: https://afsp.org/about-suicide/suicide-statistics/

That means murder-suicides make up less than 3% of total suicides.
You fail again, shackie :yo:
I didn't hear a response as to why the suicide rate by gun in the US is triple that of Canada and how that has nothing to do with guns being more accessible.

By the way, 1,200 is a lot of murder/suicides. My point stands.

I guess if only 3% of drivers drove while intoxicated you'd be ok with that as well?
 
It's there ecause the poster-maker chose to put it in his picture. Nowhere did he or she refer to "lawful gun-owners". Where are you reading that in, and on what basis?

Noting the Orlando shooter was just one of several recent mass murderers who were a 'lawful gun-owners' where they lived and killed.
He was also a "lawful Muslim" until he wasn't, so...ban Muslims?

:rolleyes:
 
Very interesting that I just looked up that 16% of suicides in Canada are via guns.

In the U.S. 51% of the deaths are by gun.

Obviously having more guns available facilitates suicide. It takes just a split second. Something like hanging (#1 in Canada) takes more of an effort and is a more unpleasant way to die. Guaranteed there would be less suicides in the U.S. if people had to resort to something more involved than pulling a trigger.

You've got it all wrong.

The RATE of SUICIDE is the SAME in Canada and the US. This means that it makes NO DIFFERENCE how they kill themselves.

Again that's the RATE of SUICIDE (in total), NOT the rate of suicide via gun. Guns allow people who would already commit suicide by another means to do it using a gun instead.

Your "guarantee" of less suicide in the US if people had less access to guns is ridiculous. People who want to kill themselves care little about the means with which they do it so long as it's quick. Explain to the class why people jump off bridges to kill themselves? The method of death that you find unpleasant isn't so for everybody else, and certainly not to somebody genuinely contemplating ending their own life.

For illustration purposes:

If 1000 people kill themselves in canada and 10,000 kill themselves in the US (the US having 10 times the population of Canada), do guns play a role in suicide rates? The answer is NO.
 
He was also a "lawful Muslim" until he wasn't, so...ban Muslims?

:rolleyes:
He who? The guy who made AK's dopey poster? Were you intending to reply to some other post? One about 'bans', or Muslims maybe? Or one about 'lawful gun owners' that appears somewhere else in the thread?

Anyway, all three are your topics; no interest to me.
 
Your "guarantee" of less suicide in the US if people had less access to guns is ridiculous.
Your wild assumption that people will kill themselves "no matter what" is ridiculous.

When something is easier, more people will do it. The corollary is that if something is more difficult, less people will do it.

Still no explanation as to why the suicide rate by gun is triple in the States. If other methods are just as easy why are guns used in more than 50% of the cases.

I think you have an agenda.
 
By the way, 1,200 is a lot of murder/suicides. My point stands
Your point stands because its a stupid one that you didn bother researching before you posted your reply.

1,200 murder/suicides is (relatively speaking) not a lot compared to regular suicides, which was my original point.
This is also why StatsCanada calls it a "rare event".

Also, most of these murder/suicides are committed by men. And if they really wanted to kill their wives and/or children they wouldnt need a gun to do it, they could just grab a kitchen knife or strangle her to death.

So my point stands, murder/suicides should not be blamed on guns
 
Guess the poster, and the guy putting it up, weren't very good at making their point. Or at supplying references for it that would be worthy of a Grade Nine essay
I explained the point right here: https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthrea...ol-in-the-US&p=5575719&viewfull=1#post5575719

You're just too dumb to understand the point. Here it is again, try reading slowly this time:

I think you missed my point. So I'll try to elaborate.

60% are suicides. While tragic, suicides are a choice and are often avoidable.
Suicides however pose no threat to the general public as most of them simply kill one person.

3% are accidents. Again, this is tragic, but accidents are very difficult to avoid.

4% are justified. This usually means self-defense. In that case its good riddance to the dead guy.

80% of homicides are gang-related. This usually means one gangbanger knocking off another gangbanger.
In this case again, good riddance to more dead guys.

So that basically leaves 1,712 deaths by firearm in a country of 330 million people which is flooded with guns.
Thats a very low ratio so long as you're not in any of the risk groups, which most people arent.

Bottom line: there is no gun problem for law-abiding citizens for the most part


13450895_1058390107543199_832420208670887153_n.jpg
 
Your wild assumption that people will kill themselves "no matter what" is ridiculous.

When something is easier, more people will do it. The corollary is that if something is more difficult, less people will do it.

Still no explanation as to why the suicide rate by gun is triple in the States. If other methods are just as easy why are guns used in more than 50% of the cases.

I think you have an agenda.

For people in the state of mind of taking their own life, shooting themselves, cutting their wrists, ingesting a bottle of pills, jumping out of their apartment, and so on is inconsequential.

YOU need to explain why the rate of suicide between countries is the same despite one country having guns everywhere and the other not. It simply means that guns are NOT part of the equation.

The explanation as to why suicide rate by gun is triple in the States is because more people have access to guns in the US. If they didn't have access to it, they'd kill themselves in any of 100 other ways.

People don't decide to kill themselves because they have access to guns. They decide to kill themselves because they're mentally unstable, depressed, or seriously ill.

How can you conclude there is an agenda from simple demonstrable facts?
 
For people in the state of mind of taking their own life, shooting themselves, cutting their wrists, ingesting a bottle of pills, jumping out of their apartment, and so on is inconsequential.

YOU need to explain why the rate of suicide between countries is the same despite one country having guns everywhere and the other not. It simply means that guns are NOT part of the equation.

The explanation as to why suicide rate by gun is triple in the States is because more people have access to guns in the US. If they didn't have access to it, they'd kill themselves in any of 100 other ways.

People don't decide to kill themselves because they have access to guns. They decide to kill themselves because they're mentally unstable, depressed, or seriously ill.

How can you conclude there is an agenda from simple demonstrable facts?
Very well said. Thank you
 
Status
Not open for further replies.