Gun-control in the US

Status
Not open for further replies.
... Criminal use of firearms is not representative of lawful use....

Of course not.

But when US laws make it too easy for criminals to get guns.

For example the Senate just rejected laws that wanted mental health incidents included in a national database for gun sales. Even worse, they voted down a proposal to alert authorities when a person on a terror watch list buys a gun and a proposal to institue a longer waiting time for people on that list.
http://www.cnn.com/2016/06/20/politics/senate-gun-votes-congress/index.html

The gun lobby is pretty fucked if they are defending the rights for suspected terrorists to buy guns.
 
Of course not.

But when US laws make it too easy for criminals to get guns.

For example the Senate just rejected laws that wanted mental health incidents included in a national database for gun sales. Even worse, they voted down a proposal to alert authorities when a person on a terror watch list buys a gun and a proposal to institue a longer waiting time for people on that list.
http://www.cnn.com/2016/06/20/politics/senate-gun-votes-congress/index.html

The gun lobby is pretty fucked if they are defending the rights for suspected terrorists to buy guns.

It's called "due process", you know, innocent until proven guilty? It should be difficult to invade someone's privacy and take away their rights.
 
Gun control is hitting what you are aiming at.....

There are 5 million AR-15s in the US, how many are involved in homicides. I ignore suicide in deference to the pro-choice movement - abortion at any trimester (funny Southpark episode)

For perspective, there have been 20 stabbing homicides YTD just in Chicago....
 
So it is delusional to stop the individual interviewed 3 times because of possible ISIS connections from buying a gun but not delusional to have him and the other 800,000 no fly list suspects followed by special ops ready to take them down ???


The NRA is so moronically opposed by any restriction to purchase guns by anybody (terrorist, criminal, etc) that they abandon common sense, basic logic in a twisted delusional excuse to justify the wanton death of thousands of Americans as a normal occurrence not worth addressing. Certainly they can't really be that stupid to believe the most basic restrictions won't prevent any deaths .. or are they really that dumb ?

You don't need to follow everybody - just the ones stupid enough to buy large amounts of ammo and weapons from licensed gun dealers who have to report it to the FBI.
 
That is because motor vehicles are licensed including mandatory tests, license suspensions for drinking, etc. The NRA is against any restriction, licensing or even electronic guns personalised for one user. It's like they revel in the resulting carnage.



Yes you can. Australia did it. Even if you can't get the guns out there - you sure as hell can do something about the ~ 1.75 million sold monthly. It is simliar to suggest there is no reason to vaccinate children against polio because there was already people infected with it.



I agree with this statement but the NRA wants NO restrictions.

except those banning mentally ill, criminals, etc, etc.
 
You don't need to follow everybody - just the ones stupid enough to buy large amounts of ammo and weapons from licensed gun dealers who have to report it to the FBI.

How would you define a "large amount"? I legally purchased 1000 rounds of .223 from a dealer in BC. I regularly purchase those 1200-1500 round crates of surplus 7.62x39 whenever I see them at a decent enough price. More importantly, what's the problem with that?
 
And where do those guns come from? Oh yeah, all the loopholes and sketch gun dealers.

They are purchased illegally. That isn't going to change. Even if you eliminated every gun store in the United States they would be smuggled in from Mexico along with all the drugs. It's not a cat you can put back in the bag.
 
How would you define a "large amount"? I legally purchased 1000 rounds of .223 from a dealer in BC. I regularly purchase those 1200-1500 round crates of surplus 7.62x39 whenever I see them at a decent enough price. More importantly, what's the problem with that?

no problem - unless you are on a terrorist watch list and the FBI knows you are visiting ISIS websites
 
Of course not.

But when US laws make it too easy for criminals to get guns.

For example the Senate just rejected laws that wanted mental health incidents included in a national database for gun sales. Even worse, they voted down a proposal to alert authorities when a person on a terror watch list buys a gun and a proposal to institue a longer waiting time for people on that list.
http://www.cnn.com/2016/06/20/politics/senate-gun-votes-congress/index.html

The gun lobby is pretty fucked if they are defending the rights for suspected terrorists to buy guns.

The background check loopholes for gun shows, private sales, etc, should be closed.

Using the terrorist watch list however strikes me as bad law because the watch lists themselves are opaque, arbitrary, and secretive. How do you get off those? Especially with the many stories of innocent people being screwed over because their name is similar to someone on the list.

As for a database in which you every mental health issue is made widely available... need to make sure that isn't searched for employment, by lenders, by prospective landlords, etc.

There should be a more open process involving a judge before someone's rights are abridged.
 
guns were involved in 30,000 deaths.

The overwhelming majority of those deaths are by suicide. If you compare the rate of suicide in Canada to the United States, you discover that it's exactly the same. When people want to kill themselves, they find a way to do it, with or without guns.

That's not a gun issue. It's either a mental health issue or a perfectly sane option that somebody suffering decides to take.
 
"Watch lists" have no transparency, accountability or recourse.

precisely - which is why I said that people on a watchlist should not be banned from owning firearms - but if you are on a terrorist watchlist, visit ISIS websites and you buy weapons and ammo, they should be following you around at the very least.

 
precisely - which is why I said that people on a watchlist should not be banned from owning firearms - but if you are on a terrorist watchlist, visit ISIS websites and you buy weapons and ammo, they should be following you around at the very least.

While I don't like ISIS, that is borderline censorship and invasion of privacy, I can't support that.
 
No dummy, that CDC stat is from ALL gun deaths:
And you addressed your OP to people in general, not to those who fit some miniscule percentage of the dead your poster-maker didn't even define. How are they not accidents, or unjustified homicides, or collateral damage of gang-wars, or 'justified' police shootings? Unless someone's shown a shared characteristic, the remainder is just the rounding error in the body count.

The odds of any unspecified member of the general population being killed by gunshot — the situation you set up — are as I said. If you or your postermaker intended 350,000,000 Americans should imagine they're all in some miniscule subset, and take courage from that then one of you owes them a definition of that 'safe' group.

But let's all remember, the entry requirement is you're already dead. With gun deaths as common as traffic deaths that's not a high bar.
 
312 million people 357 million guns..... you can't put the geni back in the bottle and you can't ban guns in the us there are too many out there allready!
Exactly!!
 
Not even close. We have much more control whether we die from a gun than we do from driving. Once again have to correct faulty liberal logic. It never ends.
You have as much control over the other guy being a drunk with a death wish when you're driving as at any other time.

Same goes for guys operating guns instead of cars. And for your odds of facing an incompetent, a novice, a guy who turned into the wrong lane or didn't see the stop-light\your brake lights, or … . All that control of yours still results in about 1 traffic death in 10,000 population.

In the US, gun deaths are almost as frequent. And let's remember, the primary and most common function of vehicles has nothing to do with causing death.
 
Why should gang violence be representative statistic of lawful gun owners?
It's there ecause the poster-maker chose to put it in his picture. Nowhere did he or she refer to "lawful gun-owners". Where are you reading that in, and on what basis?

Noting the Orlando shooter was just one of several recent mass murderers who were a 'lawful gun-owners' where they lived and killed.
 
And you addressed your OP to people in general, not to those who fit some miniscule percentage of the dead your poster-maker didn't even define. How are they not accidents, or unjustified homicides, or collateral damage of gang-wars, or 'justified' police shootings? Unless someone's shown a shared characteristic, the remainder is just the rounding error in the body count.

The odds of any unspecified member of the general population being killed by gunshot — the situation you set up — are as I said. If you or your postermaker intended 350,000,000 Americans should imagine they're all in some miniscule subset, and take courage from that then one of you owes them a definition of that 'safe' group.

But let's all remember, the entry requirement is you're already dead. With gun deaths as common as traffic deaths that's not a high bar
I think you missed my point. So I'll try to elaborate.

60% are suicides. While tragic, suicides are a choice and are often avoidable.
Suicides however pose no threat to the general public as most of them simply kill one person.

3% are accidents. Again, this is tragic, but accidents are very difficult to avoid.

4% are justified. This usually means self-defense. In that case its good riddance to the dead guy.

80% of homicides are gang-related. This usually means one gangbanger knocking off another gangbanger.
In this case again, good riddance to more dead guys.

So that basically leaves 1,712 deaths by firearm in a country of 330 million people which is flooded with guns.
Thats a very low ratio so long as you're not in any of the risk groups, which most people arent.

Bottom line: there is no gun problem for law-abiding citizens for the most part


13450895_1058390107543199_832420208670887153_n.jpg
 
Status
Not open for further replies.