Gun-control in the US

Status
Not open for further replies.
My point is that thanks to people driving drunk we have ride programs, thanks to speeders we have speed limits, thanks to bad drivers we have an application process etc.

Cars kill a lot more people so it makes sense that we have more regulation around cars than guns .
 
As do gun owners, crimes face criminal punishments.

FYI, water is wet and fire is hot.

Oh man please just focus on what I write. Did I say that there are no punishments for gun criminals? My point was that you said "not all cars are for transportation" and my counter to that was to agree with you that yes not all cars are used for transportation BUT those that abuse it can have it taken away.
 
Cars kill a lot more people so it makes sense that we have more regulation around cars than guns .

Also there are things more lethal that both guns and cars and they are not as regulated..... see heart disease and cancer. They kill more people so than cars so should you have to get a licence to buy a big mac?
 
Are you living in your car ??? You are actually arguing for gun licensing with your statement because it isn't harder for sober people to drive cars - their license isn't affected but pulling the license from a drunk driver prevents him from legally driving with a possible penalty of jail time if he gets caught. You can't stop a drunk driver if no license is required. Is the light shining a little brighter now - it is your own logic illuminating the way.

Are people only allowed to buy cars that just meet their basic transportation needs or do people have the freedom to make decisions based on other factors like luxury, sportiness and prestige?

Think of it like having to install an interlocking device, which ensures that BAC is sufficiently low before turning the engine, on every single vehicle. Think of it as having to do a "background check" on a private sale and if you privately sold a vehicle to someone who has had a DUI, you're culpable. Think of it as, if you were the victim of a theft and your car was stolen, that you'd be at fault for not providing adequate security.
 
Because it's like generalizing that all Muslims are terrorists or that all black people are criminals.
Generalizing that all muslims are terrorists is an assumption and a false one at that. Same with your blacks statement. There are no assumptions that all those deaths were gun related. It matters not who was involved. Having a gun facilitated a shooting death.

Sorry. Your analogy is a clear fail.
 
Oh man please just focus on what I write. Did I say that there are no punishments for gun criminals? My point was that you said "not all cars are for transportation" and my counter to that was to agree with you that yes not all cars are used for transportation BUT those that abuse it can have it taken away.

So what makes you think it's any different with a gun? People have their rights taken away through due process, they shouldn't be treated as guilty until they can prove themselves innocent.
 
Assuming all muslims are terrorists is an assumption and a false one at that. Same with your blacks statement. There are no assumptions that all those deaths were gun related. It matters not who was involved. Having a gun facilitated a shooting death.

Sorry. Your analogy is a clear fail.

No, my point is sound and still stands no matter how much you want to dance around the issue. Criminal use of firearms is not representative of lawful use. If you can't see that, it's because you have an agenda.
 
Automobile registration works because cars are big and it's easy to see the license plate on a car on the road in front of you. If somebody near you has a gun, you can't exactly read the serial number as they walk by.

If a person walks by and does not have a permit/ license to possess a gun because of a previous criminal/ mental record - the gun serial number is a moot point. He can go to jail. The NRA does not want any restriction on the sale, use or tracking of the weapon. License plates on cars control the vehicles as far as pollution, safety, and obviously a revenue opportunity. If a license driver drives an unlicensed car - then he can still get in trouble as could a licensed gun owner with stolen guns.

I see licensing of guns and users no different than the motor vehicles and drivers. It controls the vehicles and the drivers both of which can cause fatalities when unregulated.
 
So what makes you think it's any different with a gun? People have their rights taken away through due process, they shouldn't be treated as guilty until they can prove themselves innocent.

You need to get over the whole rights argument.

Your health care bills via taxes are high because lots of people don't take care of themselves and end up with heart disease or cancer. This is just one of many examples of where you as a person doing the right thing have to pay in one way or another for people who do not do the right thing.

I would agree with you argument if legal gun owners were the only ones getting the shaft.
 
If a person walks by and does not have a permit/ license to possess a gun because of a previous criminal/ mental record - the gun serial number is a moot point. He can go to jail. The NRA does not want any restriction on the sale, use or tracking of the weapon. License plates on cars control the vehicles as far as pollution, safety, and obviously a revenue opportunity. If a license driver drives an unlicensed car - then he can still get in trouble as could a licensed gun owner with stolen guns.

I see licensing of guns and users no different than the motor vehicles and drivers. It controls the vehicles and the drivers both of which can cause fatalities when unregulated.
If a person has previous criminal history or "mental illness", it's already unlawful for them to possess a firearm.
 
If a person walks by and does not have a permit/ license to possess a gun because of a previous criminal/ mental record - the gun serial number is a moot point. He can go to jail. The NRA does not want any restriction on the sale, use or tracking of the weapon. License plates on cars control the vehicles as far as pollution, safety, and obviously a revenue opportunity. If a license driver drives an unlicensed car - then he can still get in trouble as could a licensed gun owner with stolen guns.

I see licensing of guns and users no different than the motor vehicles and drivers. It controls the vehicles and the drivers both of which can cause fatalities when unregulated.

I don't see any value in trying to track guns, we know that registries are useless.

I disagree with the NRA on background checks. I think they are useful. Though background checks shouldn't become an excuse to create a registry of gun owners.

You can get a certified police extract that shows you have no criminal record without telling the police why you need it. Maybe you are applying for a job working with children, handling money, or buying a gun. The seller can verify that you have a clean record, the police don't need to know you bought a gun.
 
No, my point is sound and still stands no matter how much you want to dance around the issue. Criminal use of firearms is not representative of lawful use.
You are the one doing a dance trying to avoid the basic concept that guns were involved in 30,000 deaths.

More guns=more deaths. Next you will argue that more and more cars do not increase traffic.
 
You are the one doing a dance trying to avoid the basic concept that guns were involved in 30,000 deaths.

More guns=more deaths. Next you will argue that more and more cars do not increase traffic.

More responsible drivers =/= more DUIs much in the same way that more law abiding gun owners =/= more gun crime. Criminals are the minority and do not reflect the majority of people, duh.
 
You are the one doing a dance trying to avoid the basic concept that guns were involved in 30,000 deaths.

More guns=more deaths. Next you will argue that more and more cars do not increase traffic.

It isn't clear to me that there is any relationship between legally owned guns and deaths. Maybe accidental deaths, but that's better answered by safety training.
 
312 million people 357 million guns..... you can't put the geni back in the bottle and you can't ban guns in the us there are too many out there allready!

Doesn't prevent the US from instituting better policy to control new gun sales and prevent dirty dealers from selling to criminals.
 
No dummy, that CDC stat is from ALL gun deaths:

And how many of those guns were purchased through the legal loopholes that the US allows? As I said, a huge percent of the guns used in crimes are traced back to a small group of dealers that US law prevent effective investigation of.
 
If a person has previous criminal history or "mental illness", it's already unlawful for them to possess a firearm.

But not unlawful for a person to sell to them. They can't "knowingly" sell to a criminal etc. but since no background checks are needed for private sales it leaves a pretty huge loophole.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.