Gun-control in the US

Status
Not open for further replies.
So the chance of death by a gun in the US is about the same as the chance of dying in a traffic 'accident'.
When was the last time you knew of a crusade against motor vehicle deaths? It is a fact that the odds of a suburban or rural resident of the U.S.A. who is not themselves involved in criminal activity being the victim of random murder by firearm is passingly slim!
 
Why shouldn't all deaths related to guns be included. That is the issue, deaths in which guns are involved, deaths that were made easier by the use of guns.

Because it's like generalizing that all Muslims are terrorists or that all black people are criminals.
 
For those who think banning guns is a good idea, because so many people are getting killed by guns.
Check out these stats:


13450895_1058390107543199_832420208670887153_n.jpg

312 million people 357 million guns..... you can't put the geni back in the bottle and you can't ban guns in the us there are too many out there allready!
 
When was the last time you knew of a crusade against motor vehicle deaths?

That is because motor vehicles are licensed including mandatory tests, license suspensions for drinking, etc. The NRA is against any restriction, licensing or even electronic guns personalised for one user. It's like they revel in the resulting carnage.

312 million people 357 million guns..... you can't put the geni back in the bottle and you can't ban guns in the us there are too many out there allready!

Yes you can. Australia did it. Even if you can't get the guns out there - you sure as hell can do something about the ~ 1.75 million sold monthly. It is simliar to suggest there is no reason to vaccinate children against polio because there was already people infected with it.

What I find distressing in the US debate is the NRA types seem to think that everything is a plot to take guns away. There is a sensible middle ground that allows legitimate users access but makes it more difficult for criminals to get their hands on them.

I agree with this statement but the NRA wants NO restrictions.
 
So what the OP is saying is that of the 30 some odd thousand deaths only 1700 are significant.

I would argue that all the people who knew those who died by a gun would beg to differ.

As for comparing it to cars do all those gun owners need those guns? Want to hunt or target shoot? Fine go for it. But you can't tell me that of those 300 some odd million guns they are all for sport.
 
Also for those that want to aruge that guns are great for defence. Well only 1200 of those deaths were "justified" and of those how many were cops vs average citizens. Doesn't that suggest the usefulness of a gun for self defence is very small?
 
So what the OP is saying is that of the 30 some odd thousand deaths only 1700 are significant.

I would argue that all the people who knew those who died by a gun would beg to differ.

As for comparing it to cars do all those gun owners need those guns? Want to hunt or target shoot? Fine go for it. But you can't tell me that of those 300 some odd million guns they are all for sport.

Except no one tries to reduce drunk driving by making it harder for sober people to own cars. Not all guns are for sport, some are for self defense, so what? You can't tell me that all cars are solely for transportation.
 
Except no one tries to reduce drunk driving by making it harder for sober people to own cars. Not all guns are for sport, some are for self defense, so what? You can't tell me that all cars are solely for transportation.

Lawful drivers and lawful gun owners bare the brunt of unlawful drivers and gun owners that's just a fact.
 
I'm against banning guns because it's pointless.

On the other hand I'm in favor of police background checks. They are relatively unobtrusive. The US should close the loopholes that allow people to purchase guns without a background check.

I'm also in favor of mandatory gun safety training, which can be delivered in the gun store if needed. I think making sure everybody knows the basics of safe storage and operation prevents many accidents.

But banning guns is just stupid.
 
Except no one tries to reduce drunk driving by making it harder for sober people to own cars. Not all guns are for sport, some are for self defense, so what? You can't tell me that all cars are solely for transportation.

My point is that the statistics there show that the odds of a gun being used for self defence is tiny (1200) and even smaller if you subtract out how many of those were from law enforcement agents.
 
Except no one tries to reduce drunk driving by making it harder for sober people to own cars. Not all guns are for sport, some are for self defense, so what? You can't tell me that all cars are solely for transportation.

Are you living in your car ??? You are actually arguing for gun licensing with your statement because it isn't harder for sober people to drive cars - their license isn't affected but pulling the license from a drunk driver prevents him from legally driving with a possible penalty of jail time if he gets caught. You can't stop a drunk driver if no license is required. Is the light shining a little brighter now - it is your own logic illuminating the way.
 
I'm against banning guns because it's pointless.

On the other hand I'm in favor of police background checks. They are relatively unobtrusive. The US should close the loopholes that allow people to purchase guns without a background check.

I'm also in favor of mandatory gun safety training, which can be delivered in the gun store if needed. I think making sure everybody knows the basics of safe storage and operation prevents many accidents.

But banning guns is just stupid.

I haven't stated once that guns should be banned. What I am against is the way these stats are being abused to try and make us think guns are not dangerous.
 
Lawful drivers and lawful gun owners bare the brunt of unlawful drivers and gun owners that's just a fact.

Most gun crime is committed with an illegally acquired gun. Most automobile accidents are committed with a legally acquired vehicle.

See the difference?

Automobile registration works because cars are big and it's easy to see the license plate on a car on the road in front of you. If somebody near you has a gun, you can't exactly read the serial number as they walk by.

See the difference?

Different solutions for different problems.
 
Except no one tries to reduce drunk driving by making it harder for sober people to own cars. Not all guns are for sport, some are for self defense, so what? You can't tell me that all cars are solely for transportation.

People who abuse the use of cars can have them taken away from them.
 
Most gun crime is committed with an illegally acquired gun. Most automobile accidents are committed with a legally acquired vehicle.

See the difference?

Automobile registration works because cars are big and it's easy to see the license plate on a car on the road in front of you. If somebody near you has a gun, you can't exactly read the serial number as they walk by.

See the difference?

Different solutions for different problems.

I am not suggesting that guns and cars should be controlled in the same way. The only reason I am discussing both is that other people have brought it up. The person felt it was unfair that legal gun owners are being punished. My point is that as a result of things in the past legal car owners have to act in a certain way. That's the similarity I am trying to get at which is both legal gun owners and drivers face restrictions thanks to the actions of bad users in the past.
 
Lawful drivers and lawful gun owners bare the brunt of unlawful drivers and gun owners that's just a fact.

LOL, since when? When was the last time responsible drivers were shamed and targeted, merely for owning cars, because of irresponsible ones? Discrimination against gun owners is no different from discrimination against any other group.
 
LOL, since when? When was the last time responsible drivers were shamed and targeted, merely for owning cars, because of irresponsible ones? Discrimination against gun owners is no different from discrimination against any other group.



My point is that thanks to people driving drunk we have ride programs, thanks to speeders we have speed limits, thanks to bad drivers we have an application process etc.
 
My point is that thanks to people driving drunk we have ride programs, thanks to speeders we have speed limits, thanks to bad drivers we have an application process etc.

And there are laws against criminal possession of firearms, there are background checks, not to mention existing laws against assault and murder.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.