Is Gibby a quality coach?

261252

Nobodies business if I do
Sep 26, 2007
1,307
1,104
113
The reason Jays never made it to the World Series last year is no small ball

1 Bunts

2 Steals

3 Sacrifice


They left too many players on base against KC and same this year because of small ball management


Is this not Gibby's fault ?
 
The reason Jays never made it to the World Series is no small ball

The Toronto Blue Jays have made it to the World Series twice (and won, both times).
 
The reason Jays never made it to the World Series last year is no small ball

1 Bunts

2 Steals

3 Sacrifice
JBats, EE, Smoak, Tulo, Donaldson, Saunders/Colabello, Russ Martin. These are not small ball type players. That is 7 of 9 spots in the batting order.
 
Small ball is situational hitting.

If you got4-5 on your everyday roster who will give you 40-50 steals on a consistent basis...then yeah...
but do you really want Jbats bunting a runner from 2 to 3...?
Swing away baby!

I dont think Gibby is one of those research type coaches who has a docea on every player on his tablet on the bench...he's a go with the gut..type coach
 
I've never been a fan of Gibbons (as a coach), I believe him to be a sub par baseball manager. Look at his track record at every level, it's not very good. He lacks baseball knowledge it's so blatant when he speaks. That being said, I'm liking him more right now since he's been sticking up for his players. Last year there were so many times when we were on the short end of calls and he'd be sitting in the dugout spitting out seeds, oblivious to his surroundings.

But right now I'm even more disenchanted with Shapiro and his team. They have mishandled the Joey Bats and EE files and that trade of Revere for Storen looks abominable.
 
Totally random but I have such a crush on Gibbons! lol

That settles it. Case closed. He is a good manager :) BTW I am now practicing my Gibby impersonation
 
I'll be honest, I can't believe we even have a separate thread for this. I figured since it's an on-going discussion in the blue jays thread and it's about the blue jays, it would makes sense to just talk about this in the....I don't know.... the blue jays thread maybe???
 
I think what Steinbrenner recently said about his Yankees also applies to the Jays.

That is where any and all blame lies.
 
They need to do something. I don't know what. Fire the hitting coach? Russ Martin plays nearly everyday and NOBODY is hitting. It's almost June. They need to figure this out fast. With the way Boston is going, the Jays are going to have a tough time. I miss that Cito mentality. Never mind working the count. See your pitch and just hit it!

Philip
 
And if anyone remembers, when John Gibbons was replaced by Cito the first time, the word was THEY ARE JUST NOT PRODUCING. I hope this isn't that John Gibbons hitting production rut thing again. Those kinds of slumps are very deceiving....you keep thinking you're gonna come out of it but you never do. When AA brought John Gibbons back in as manager.... My initial gut reaction was "but what about the hitting production slump that they got rid of him for in the first place?"

Citos press conference replacing John Gibbons as manager..."We need to start looking for our pitch and swinging away and start scoring some runs. We need to score some runs. It's the number one priority here."

Philip
 
Agree with the hitting production comments. Last year the Jays were #1 BA with RISP, and this year they are dead last in the AL. They were keeping the rallies going not just hitting HR.
Only Smoak and Saunders have been hitting above their weight and everyone else has been slumping, even The big 3 JD, EE and JB.
Hopefully Travis can help spark a change even if it means just keeping automatic out Goins out of the lineup.
 
Didn't he get the 2 RBI game winning double. Clearly not automatic.

He has the lowest oWAR of any player with enough at bats and you want to quibble about the euphemism "automatic out"?
Troll on shack.
 
If someone could tell him and give him my number, that'd be great. :angel:

Nicole.....buy a ticket. Go well before hand during BP. Call anyone over. Tell them to ask him if he would come over please.

He is an old ball player who's wife is in Texas. Chat with him and slip him your number. Either it happens or it doesn't.
 
Nicole.....buy a ticket. Go well before hand during BP. Call anyone over. Tell them to ask him if he would come over please.

He is an old ball player who's wife is in Texas. Chat with him and slip him your number. Either it happens or it doesn't.

Lucky Gibby!

The Jays need to fire the hitting coach at the very least. Take advantage of this little Travis momentum they got atm.

Philip
 
Bullpen atrocious.
Batters playing way below career, let alone last year's pace.
Stroman, Happ, someone else?, all get beat up in consecutive starts meaning they can't maintain their hot start.
Brooke Jacoby was a genius hitting coach last year. He obviously took stupid pills in the winter.
Gibbons is a bad strategist.
Gibbons can't handle a bullpen.
Gibbons can't motivate.
They lose 4 in a row recently.

How the hell did they just complete a 5-2 roadtrip with all of those bad things? Is it possible that the impending Armageddon of the Jays may be a bit premature.

I'm not predicting a successful team and I do have serious concerns, but I am also not predicting a dismal season (qualifier if Shapeero dismantles). It can go either way.

Jays fans must keep in mind that we are not the only ones with deficiencies but that is what we dwell on. Every team has significant issues to deal with. So it's not the deficiencies the Jays have, it is how they compare to the deficiencies of other teams.

BTW, this is not a rookie team just learning the game. These are seasoned vets who know how to play the game, how to handle the ups and downs of a season, know how to mentally prepare for a long season. I'm sure he has mainly positive, encouraging comments for the players but Gibbons doesn't use pom poms like perry wants him to. Even still, it is evident that the players respect Gibbons and play hard for him and for eachother. Bautista giving up RBI opportunities to bat leadoff because of his high OBP.

Lots of games to play, lots can and will happen. The reality is that NOBODY (fans, players, coaches, management, media, fans, Vegas, even TERB), ABSOLUTELY NOBODY KNOWS what will happen. We have opinions, observations, guesses, hopes and wishes but NOBODY REALLY KNOWS.

Sit back, enjoy the season, hope your favourite team stays in the playoff hunt, speculate but don't pretend you know what will happen and that you know with certainty what needs to be done to correct a problem. There are just too many damn variables.