I love Stamkos, and think McDavid will be great. But don't like the idea of paying one guy 10 to 15 million a year. If you shadow one elite player, its possible to shut him down all night.
But shutting down 2-3 scoring lines, isn't so easy.
I'd much rather the leafs sign 3 guys for $5/million deals. I've already said before how I dislike how soft the Leafs (or NHL in general is now) or the lack of heart. I'd like to see Toronto acquire players with guts, and heart.
Both Stamkos and McDavid are huge talents. But also huge 'names' for shirt sales, endorsements, commercials, etc. I often wonder how much that 'seduces' a player when you convince him he is larger than life.
How about seeking players that are notorious for being healthy, who play with heart and show up every night?
I'd rather Toronto seek out names like Ladd, Byfuglien, and Lucic. Go back to being a team others hated playing, not looked forward to.