Bill C-36, In Force 1 Month, Any Developments?

Probably true, but as others have said - it seems likely they will go for the low hanging fruit, as it were.


That presumes a desire to go after Johns, which I don't think has been expressed by any LE.

They won't just pass this and not enforce it. But they also won't just go after Johns. Public opinion is clear that we don't care to go after the activities of consenting adults.

If this bill is for optics, what makes sense is to go after trafficking, underage, drugs, etc. and then lay some charges on whoever is caught up when the net is cast. Public opinion will NOT support a John who is caught buying sex from someone who is underage or trafficked.
 
That presumes a desire to go after Johns, which I don't think has been expressed by any LE.

They won't just pass this and not enforce it. But they also won't just go after Johns. Public opinion is clear that we don't care to go after the activities of consenting adults.

If this bill is for optics, what makes sense is to go after trafficking, underage, drugs, etc. and then lay some charges on whoever is caught up when the net is cast. Public opinion will NOT support a John who is caught buying sex from someone who is underage or trafficked.
Now this makes sense. Hope they do start going after those Open 24/7 sweat shops that clearly bring the " I speeeek Nooo Engeeesh " Girls into the Country & Human Traffic , slave Labour them :mad:
 
So far LE it seems has acted very responsible and only gone after the scum of the industry.
 
So far LE it seems has acted very responsible and only gone after the scum of the industry.

Still early days. The purpose of bill C36 as per the government: "Its overall objective is to reduce the demand for prostitution with a view to discouraging entry into it, deterring participation in it and ultimately ABOLISHING it to the greatest extent possible."
 
Still early days. The purpose of bill C36 as per the government: "Its overall objective is to reduce the demand for prostitution with a view to discouraging entry into it, deterring participation in it and ultimately ABOLISHING it to the greatest extent possible."

there is a problem with that. nobody wants to go after consenting sexwork
 
The purpose of bill C36 as per the government: "Its overall objective is to reduce the demand for prostitution with a view to discouraging entry into it, deterring participation in it and ultimately ABOLISHING it to the greatest extent possible."
Yes, but that 'objective' has already been debunked to such an extent even the Conservatives must accept it is nothing but rhetoric.

This industry/trade is not going away anytime soon; it may change, but it most certainly will not be abolished, and anyone who thinks otherwise is foolish to do so.
 
With all due respect...boooooooring.

Nothing's changed :dance:


I remember in one the 5 million c-36's threads, everyone was talking about how they were going to get out of the hobby after D-day. Many of them asking what there plans were going be after D-day and all kinds of other stupid questions.


I told them nothing going to change and that most would all be back in a few months and to stop acting like retards. I also said I was going to revive the thread. I'm just waiting a few more months and then I'll revive the thread to show them how idiotic they were all being...lol.
 
i remember in one the 5 million c-36's threads, everyone was talking about how they were going to get out of the hobby after d-day. Many of them asking what there plans were going be after d-day and all kinds of other stupid questions.


I told them nothing going to change and that most would all be back in a few months and to stop acting like retards. I also said i was going to revive the thread. I'm just waiting a few more months and then i'll revive the thread to show them how idiotic they were all being...lol.
+1 indeed ;)
 
I remember in one the 5 million c-36's threads, everyone was talking about how they were going to get out of the hobby after D-day. Many of them asking what there plans were going be after D-day and all kinds of other stupid questions.


I told them nothing going to change and that most would all be back in a few months and to stop acting like retards. I also said I was going to revive the thread. I'm just waiting a few more months and then I'll revive the thread to show them how idiotic they were all being...lol.

thats so ignorant though. you cant be claiming there arent going to be any stings. thats kind of the point of changing the law. to arrest us guys for paying for sex and handjobs. its only a matter of time.
 
thats so ignorant though. you cant be claiming there arent going to be any stings. thats kind of the point of changing the law. to arrest us guys for paying for sex and handjobs. its only a matter of time.


Sure I can, because I'm telling you that this thing is so over hyped and LE won't be going after high end agencies. The only thing they'll target is the same thing they always have, which is minor's and forced prostitution. Now I'm going to tell you the same thing, in one year from now, you will not hear about any of these high end agencies, or reputable indies talking about how there clients have been charged. I'll re-quote this in one year just for you.

I understand the point of changing the law, so thanks for pointing that out to me. There are way more factors to this thing than just passing a bill. For starters, the resources it would take alone posses a serious challenge to LE agencies, and our already back logged courts.
 
Sure I can, because I'm telling you that this thing is so over hyped and LE won't be going after high end agencies.

What makes you so sure? I've heard rumours to the contrary. Who's right?

Now I'm going to tell you the same thing, in one year from now, you will not hear about any of these high end agencies, or reputable indies talking about how there clients have been charged.

Agreed. but that doesn't mean it won't happen or that it isn't happening.

I understand the point of changing the law, so thanks for pointing that out to me. There are way more factors to this thing than just passing a bill. For starters, the resources it would take alone posses a serious challenge to LE agencies, and our already back logged courts.

You're talking about a focused, deliberate effort to enforce C36 on Johns, right? Putting aside the fact that LE budgets are enormous, they won't be starting at a baseline of zero. There exists budget for sex crimes already; what we're debating is whether they would devote those resources to this law. IMO, wagering on either extreme is foolhardy.

IF you accept that LE will continue to crackdown on trafficking, underage, forced prostitution, then I'm sure you'll agree that there will be some sort of LE presence in the industry. Insofar as enforcement actions occur generally speaking are you saying that Johns will be ignored if LE happens to come across buyers in the course of their investigations?
 
What makes you so sure? I've heard rumours to the contrary. Who's right?

You with your damn ear to the ground. I say let them eat cake ( and whatever else is on the menu )
 
http://www.thebarrieexaminer.com/2015/01/18/police-issue-warning-after-sexual-assaults

Barrie Police not going after consenting sex work. Only the abusers

what happens when a consenting sex worker has beef with a john and walks into the police station and says "this man paid me for sex and here is the proof of it"

the police in this case did NOT 'go AFTER the consenting sex worker', but given the evidence of a crime (i.e. john paid for sex), are they not obligated to charge the john? consenting sex worker goes back to being a consenting sex worker.

I'm not saying the respectable indies or agencies do this, but even a semi respectable indy or newbie or whoever, could do this. and police have a duty to charge.
 
You're talking about a focused, deliberate effort to enforce C36 on Johns, right? Putting aside the fact that LE budgets are enormous, they won't be starting at a baseline of zero. There exists budget for sex crimes already; what we're debating is whether they would devote those resources to this law. IMO, wagering on either extreme is foolhardy.

IF you accept that LE will continue to crackdown on trafficking, underage, forced prostitution, then I'm sure you'll agree that there will be some sort of LE presence in the industry. Insofar as enforcement actions occur generally speaking are you saying that Johns will be ignored if LE happens to come across buyers in the course of their investigations?

LE budgets aren't enormous. The last few years Toronto Police budget has been cut, not expanded. In fact, since 2012 city hall has been all over them about there budget. Just google "Toronto police budget" and pick any link and you'll see how much scrutiny is going on over there budget. Now I can't speak for other LE agencies across the province, or the country for that matter, but do you really think agencies want to start putting time and effort into a bill that the liberals are going to repeal once they are back in power?

The budget that already exist for sex crimes, I'm sure is already low and detectives probably feel like they don't have enough help. Do you think they're gonna take they're already thin resources and start setting up stings to catch a bunch of johns who really arn't harming anyone, as opposed the trafficking and more serious offences? Can't wait to see the public backlash on that one. There are many things that are illegal. Weather or not LE chooses to enforce them or how they handle it is a whole other ball game. It's illegal to drink alcohol under the age of 19. When I was young, I used sit in the park with all my friends and get drunk. Periodically the cops would come. Not only was I under age, but I was also drinking in public. Never once did I get arrested. They told us to just leave, or confiscated our booze and told us to leave. My guess they had better things to do then sit at the station, filling out paper work cause some 18 had a few beers in a park.

There are a lot of moving parts to this, for instance many municipal governments are already telling the federal government to basically go fuck themselves regarding this law, and they're not supporting it.

I will say this one more time because this how confident I am. We can sit here and debate this for a year, and in a years time from now, I'll be the one saying "told you so".
 
Last edited: