WW II - What Ifs?

I guess you could say that ALL the large armies in WW2 - including Japan and Germany - were citizen armies. The German bank tellers, school teachers and accountants got beaten by their US counterparts.
Absolutely.

Further both the CSA and the Union Army were likewise citizen armies. That the U.S. had already had the experience of the U.S. Civil War and came into World War I very late means that the emphasis on the shock of the loses with a "citizen army" in the U.S. is on the Civil War. While in the U.K., Canada, Australia and New Zealand it is on World War I as their first war involving a "citizen" rather than a professional army.
 
It's supposed to be fun, although some of the guys on my military hobby board have said it's "Hollywood" and its grasp of tactics is weak. OTOH, they enjoyed the fact that in-tank procedures appeared accurate. I should make a point of going out to see it.

It is Hollywood, but what was refreshing is that it's WWII tank combat, with some great pyrotechnics, without the fake-looking CG. The last time I saw a tank movie was the one with Denzel Washington and Desert Storm. Fury was way better. Those were the days when men had balls, and sheep were afraid.

Edit: Brad Pitt's character kept enemy souvenirs. I'll never forget the Nazi officer dagger that my friend's dad kept and showed us when were were youngsters.
 
I remember seeing on some Nazi Mega-Weapons or similar type show about this tank, being the largest tank every built.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panzer_VIII_Maus

The Nazis had another tank which was only in the design phase, which weighted 1,000 metric tons (5 times heavier than the Panzer VIII Maus)!
 
So, more Russians died in the 30 years after the Russian Revolution than in the 100's of years before 1917?

I remember reading a heart breaking letter a soldier in the British Army wrote to his mom in the U.K. He and his fellow soldiers were tasked with repatriating captured Russian soldiers and civilians back to Russia after the war and how so many of them threw themselves under the trains than return to the "Motherland".
Indeed not far from the truth. Far more Russians, Ukrainians etc. . . were killed by their own leaders in the various purges than the Nazis killed in toto.
 
I know that's what they figured but it quite possibly was wrong headed thinking. The German military was a good step ahead of the French in both technology and tactics.
It of course all depends on what means by the terms. The French were well behind the Germans (who were actually well behind the Austro-Hungarian Army) in terms of heavy artillery, at the same time the "French 75" the French 75 mm field gun modèle 1897 was a world class weapon, indeed it was so far superior to anything the U.S. Army had that they just plain had France supply it to their field artillery units on the Western Front.
 
Hastings is wrong because the revolution in Russia still would had happened providing a continental counter force to Germany. Ultimately, the 1870 defeat of France showed that the Imperial Germany was more than willing to deal pragmatically with weaker nations. Worth noting that the Habsburgs, war or no war, were in a state of decomposition. The inevitable break up of the Habsburg Empire would had kept Germany busy for decades in the central Europe and with Russia breathing down their necks. Most importantly, the social democratic pressure would, most likely, led to weakening of the Junker class and its colonial aspirations. The age of empires was mostly dead by the beginning of 20th century. Self determination, nationalism and socialism were the forces driving the events-something the leaders of the European powers failed to notice. The WWI was a war about nothing, that solved nothing, that led to even bigger tragedy.
Sorry for the late reply. I disagree.

You forget in what a state of disarray the Bolsheviks were at the time of the Treaty of Brest-Litovsk, well into the 1930's they would have posed no threat at all to a Germany which had won the war.

The Germany of 1914 was a utterly different place than the German Confederation of 1870 that was certainly true of its avowed war aims.

Without the Assassination of Archduke Franz-Ferdinand and the war federalism (the united states of greater Austria) might well have saved the Habsburg Monarchy.
 
Technology wins wars, not men. Largely the case then and definitely the case these days.

Technology, appropriate tactics, and high morale win a traditional war.

Islandlwana comes to mind on how way better technology can lose (especially when compared to Rorke's Drift a few days later).


One speculation was that if the Brits realized the mobility of the Zulu and formed a square as if they were cavalry they could have made more effective use of their firepower.
 
Nope, haven't seen the movie but the Sherman was not a very good tank. The Nazi Tiger tank was the best WW II tank until the Russian T-34 arrived on the battlefield.

The T-34 keeps getting rave reviews as one of the best tanks ever. It was very effective but its success was huge numbers produced and the traditional Russian tactics of human (or armored) wave attacks and disregard for the lives of their troops (tactics suited to technology).

The Sherman was similarly way behind the Tigers and Panthers but numbers made the difference (and when they were up against smaller tanks worked better than the opposition including the T-34 (morale of tankers would have made a huge difference too.
 
I remember seeing on some Nazi Mega-Weapons or similar type show about this tank, being the largest tank every built.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panzer_VIII_Maus

The Nazis had another tank which was only in the design phase, which weighted 1,000 metric tons (5 times heavier than the Panzer VIII Maus)!

The very Prussian mistake of spending resources and energy on perfection instead of being happy with capable and many. Their constant innovations made for some pretty solid assault rifles (though the term wasn't used at the time) but those were much easier to produce than the massive and complex tanks.
 
It of course all depends on what means by the terms. The French were well behind the Germans (who were actually well behind the Austro-Hungarian Army) in terms of heavy artillery, at the same time the "French 75" the French 75 mm field gun modèle 1897 was a world class weapon, indeed it was so far superior to anything the U.S. Army had that they just plain had France supply it to their field artillery units on the Western Front.

It's worth mentioning that the Americans didn't really start looking at 'modern' warfare in any serious way until the shooting in Europe was pretty much underway so comparing to US WWI equipment made pretty much everyone else look good. I'm sure that in most American units in WWI there was ample equipment built or at least designed by England or France. Same thing can effectively said for the run up to WWII though the massive industrialization by the 30's made it a lot easier to catch up.
 
The very Prussian mistake of spending resources and energy on perfection instead of being happy with capable and many. Their constant innovations made for some pretty solid assault rifles (though the term wasn't used at the time) but those were much easier to produce than the massive and complex tanks.
Those Prussians also invented the ME-262 and that terror weapon the V-2, thank goodness, too late and too few in numbers.
 
Given the fact that the German army collapsed in 45 and surrendered en masse, you could probably show similar numbers for all the Allied armies.
Unlike Hitler, the German military knew the war was a lost cause by late 1944 and decided better to surrender to the Americans than die fighting the Russians. Many of Hitler's orders to destroy, kill and die were ignored after late 1944. Paris was not burned and Innsbruck (apparently the basis for the Inglorious Bastards movie) was surrendered without a shot being fired.

What is shocking is the bitter fighting and bloodshed in the Battle of Berlin. Didn't the Germans in the city know that the war was a lost cause and Hitler and his entourage had already committed suicide?
 
I guess you could say that ALL the large armies in WW2 - including Japan and Germany - were citizen armies. The German bank tellers, school teachers and accountants got beaten by their US counterparts.
I was under the impression (perhaps false) that Nazi Germany and Imperial Japan by the late 1930's had a large professional standing army prepping for war. In fact, Japan had already attacked Korea, Manchuria and large parts of Northeastern China by 1938.
 
The big one would be:

What if the Germans never double crossed the Russians and invaded Russia?

Russia stays neutral and Germany could have concentrated it's efforts on Britain?

(not a pleasant scenario)

Then the Germans would have been nuked as they had already declared war on the US. This outcome would have been wonderful for Eastern Europe.
 
The History Channel is running a series of programs on WW II leading up to Remembrance Day. For the history buffs on the board, here are some what ifs questions?

1) What if the escape from Dunkirk was an unmitigated disaster?

2) What if the Russian Winter arrived later and less brutal than usual in 1941?

3) What if the Americans lost the Battle of Midway?

4) What if the Greeks were unable to delay the Nazi invasion of Russia with their resistance?

5) What if Truman decided not to drop the a-bombs? What if Germany or Japan developed the a-bomb first?

6) What if the U.S. had spotted the Japanese Pearl harbor attack fleet in advance of the attack?

I think the Russian winter is a neutral issue. If the winter had been later the Germans would still have been bogged down in mud longer. It would also have made it much easier for the Russians to mover their industries, which were done under appalling conditions, but which ultimately won the war.

If the Americans lost the battle of Midway, the war would have taken a bit longer to win, the US would have made up any carrier losses within 1 year.

Not using the bomb would not have lengthen the war IMHO as the Japanese surrender had more to do with the Russians crushing them in Manchuria then the a-bombs. If the US had spotted the Japanese fleet and sunk them, then the war would have been shorter...
 
I think the Russian winter is a neutral issue. If the winter had been later the Germans would still have been bogged down in mud longer. It would also have made it much easier for the Russians to mover their industries, which were done under appalling conditions, but which ultimately won the war.

If the Americans lost the battle of Midway, the war would have taken a bit longer to win, the US would have made up any carrier losses within 1 year.

Not using the bomb would not have lengthen the war IMHO as the Japanese surrender had more to do with the Russians crushing them in Manchuria then the a-bombs. If the US had spotted the Japanese fleet and sunk them, then the war would have been shorter...
Yeah, win or lose, Midway had no real influence on the course of the Pacific war-from the American pov. The attrition battles in the Solomons destroyed Japanese aviation and, by the time of Leyte, Americans faced virtually naked and blind Japanese fleet with hardly any aircraft. In less than two years, American economy dwarfed Japanese navy in numbers and quality. As Claire Chennault once said " Japan lost the war the moment it attacked Pearl Harbor".
 
I was under the impression (perhaps false) that Nazi Germany and Imperial Japan by the late 1930's had a large professional standing army prepping for war. In fact, Japan had already attacked Korea, Manchuria and large parts of Northeastern China by 1938.

Japan perhaps, although I'm sure they ramped up conscription as soon as they started a war with the western powers. Germany was bound by the Treaty of Versailles to have an army of only 100,000 men and only started to build it up in 36, again through conscription and with the constraint that they had to select and train officers and NCO's first to form a cadre. As late as 39, its army was little bigger than Poland's.
 
Unlike Hitler, the German military knew the war was a lost cause by late 1944 and decided better to surrender to the Americans than die fighting the Russians. Many of Hitler's orders to destroy, kill and die were ignored after late 1944. Paris was not burned and Innsbruck (apparently the basis for the Inglorious Bastards movie) was surrendered without a shot being fired.

What is shocking is the bitter fighting and bloodshed in the Battle of Berlin. Didn't the Germans in the city know that the war was a lost cause and Hitler and his entourage had already committed suicide?

A lot of the German troops in Berlin attempted to break out to the West and surrender to the Americans, not the Russians.
 
3) What if the Americans lost the Battle of Midway?

Yeah, win or lose, Midway had no real influence on the course of the Pacific war-from the American pov. The attrition battles in the Solomons destroyed Japanese aviation and, by the time of Leyte, Americans faced virtually naked and blind Japanese fleet with hardly any aircraft. In less than two years, American economy dwarfed Japanese navy in numbers and quality. As Claire Chennault once said " Japan lost the war the moment it attacked Pearl Harbor".

I think if we had been having these discussions in mid-1942, we might not have been so confident that the Allies would prevail.

And it could very well have happened that the Americans did indeed lose the Battle of Midway.

Picture the situation at 10.20am on the morning of 4 June 1942. On the four JP aircraft carriers, there was complete happiness. Several squadrons of US torpedo bombers had been fought off, every US plane shot down, and not one of the JP ships so much as scratched.
But now, with the JP navy convinced of its invincibility (having just seen proof of that very thing), three squadrons of US dive-bombers arrived overhead. This was pure chance. The US planes were basically lost, low on fuel, and about to turn back, when they spotted a lone JP destroyer, the wake of which gave them direction.

They arrived just at the critical moment when the four carriers were more or less defenceless. The JP CAP fighters, having done their work against the US torpedo squadrons, were down at low level, and needing to land to refuel and re-arm. Plus, the decks of the carriers were stacked with torpedoes and bombs from previous changes to their attack missions.

By 10.30am, Akagi had been hit by one 1000-lb bomb – Kaga by one 1000-lb and three 500-lb – Soryu by three 1000-lb bombs. All three were on fire and finished. A few hours later, the remaining carrier Hiryu was hit by four 1000-lb bombs.

This was the moment when it could now be said that, becasue of US industrial strength, the war in the Pacific was over, bar the shouting.

Pearl Harbour had taken place 6 months earlier. Several US battleships sunk or damaged. In the Pacific, Japan invading and wiping out country after country, China, Philipines, more or less the whole of East Asia. India, Australia next. Crippling losses of ships in the Atlantic. Europe almost completely in German hands. Russia on the brink of annihilation. The Allies retreating everywhere, losing battle after battle, with no sign of a turn of fortunes.

At 10.20am 4 june 1942, any one who looked at the state of the world, and said it was inevitable that the Axis powers would surrender unconditionally, would need his head examined. The Battle of Midway was unfolding just like all the others -- disastrously. Picture Roosevelt at that moment. Tell me he wasn't thinking: There is no light at the end of the tunnel. I'm gonna have to give the Japs the whole of East Asia, to make them stop. Probably Australia as well.

Then, 10 minutes later, Japan has disappeared as an aggressive naval force. Now the war of attrition starts, which anyone can see, now, the Allies are bound to win.
 
I think if we had been having these discussions in mid-1942, we might not have been so confident that the Allies would prevail.
Before Midway, the Americans and allies knew only defeats, after Midway, the allies knew nothing but victories. Did you know that Joseph Kennedy bought a lot of land in Manhattan in 1942 at "we will lose the war" prices?