WW II - What Ifs?

This is a starting statistic. I heard that Russia lost 20-28 million people in WW II and perhaps another 20 million to Stalin purges but one would have thought that they would have replaced those lost souls in the 70 years since 1945.

I should explain that the current day stat doesn't include the Baltics, Belarus, Ukraine, Finland, Poland, etc, all of which were part of the Russian Czarist Empire. It just includes that current actual country of Russia.

Add in HUGE losses in the Russian Civil War, Lenin's Terror, Stalin's Terrors and the Holodmyr, World War Two (about 20,000,000) and a declining birth rate which isn't countered by high immigration like the Western countries.

When you consider how massive the Russian population was in 1914, you really understand the whole legend of the "Russian Steamroller" and why Germany and Austria feared Russia so much.
 
So that scene in Patton (starring George C. Scott) where a German officer refers to him as 'an anachronism', in reference to Julius Caesar, is an exaggeration?

It's a fun movie, but I think it's more geared toward the Patton Myth than what the guy actually accomplished in reality.
 
It's a fun movie, but I think it's more geared toward the Patton Myth than what the guy actually accomplished in reality.

He boasted that if given enough fuel and supplies, that he could've gone straight to Moscow.
 
Add in HUGE losses in the Russian Civil War, Lenin's Terror, Stalin's Terrors and the Holodmyr, World War Two (about 20,000,000) and a declining birth rate which isn't countered by high immigration like the Western countries.

When you consider how massive the Russian population was in 1914, you really understand the whole legend of the "Russian Steamroller" and why Germany and Austria feared Russia so much.

So, more Russians died in the 30 years after the Russian Revolution than in the 100's of years before 1917?

I remember reading a heart breaking letter a soldier in the British Army wrote to his mom in the U.K. He and his fellow soldiers were tasked with repatriating captured Russian soldiers and civilians back to Russia after the war and how so many of them threw themselves under the trains than return to the "Motherland".
 
Patton had one big moment - when he raced across France in 3 weeks in August 44 because the German army had been trapped at Falaise and didn't exist anymore.
Don't forget how he whipped the Nazis in the Battle of the Bulge. The Nazis feared Patton so much that they concentrated their forces around Calais instead of Normany.
 
Don't forget how he whipped the Nazis in the Battle of the Bulge. The Nazis feared Patton so much that they concentrated their forces around Calais instead of Normany.

The Battle of the Bulge was pretty much a group effort of all the senior American generals.
 
No. The deal was that they figured they had to beat France first because Russia was so large and populous that it would take a lot of work to defeat it....

I know that's what they figured but it quite possibly was wrong headed thinking. The German military was a good step ahead of the French in both technology and tactics. With their fort system, heavy use of machine guns and probably the most advanced artillery it wouldn't have taken a huge force to defend their own border leaving most of the army still free to operate in the East.

Of course I doubt they fully realized how close Russia and their military were to falling apart so they couldn't count on a quick end there but hindsight shows it would likely been the better move for Germany.

The Russians had a huge population to draw on but an extremely poor transportation network to get them to the front lines, the industrial base to quickly arm all those troops, and between corruption and leadership based solely on nobility of birth poor Generals and a poor supply system.

The Germans on the other hand had a professional officer corp, an extremely organized quartermaster corp, and a massive (by the standards of the time) train network.

It would likely have taken a couple years of Russian defeats in battle but a defensive stance in the West would have allowed them to focus on Russia. Add in the fact that they weren't fully at war with the Brits then there wouldn't have been a sea blockade limiting German industrial output.
 
Don't forget how he whipped the Nazis in the Battle of the Bulge....

I'd say that the 101 holding up the drive and the weather clearing for Allied air superiority had a bigger impact. IMO Patton just hurried the collapse.
 
I'd say that the 101 holding up the drive and the weather clearing for Allied air superiority had a bigger impact. IMO Patton just hurried the collapse.

I heard there is a great book (which I haven't read) titled "Citizen Soldiers". It all about how the American military in WW II was composed of mostly civilians in uniform. Yes, a bunch of school teachers, bank tellers and accountants beat the Nazis and Imperial Japan. Bless them all.
 
I heard there is a great book (which I haven't read) titled "Citizen Soldiers". It all about how the American military in WW II was composed of mostly civilians in uniform. Yes, a bunch of school teachers, bank tellers and accountants beat the Nazis and Imperial Japan. Bless them all.

Technology wins wars, not men. Largely the case then and definitely the case these days.
 
Technology wins wars, not men. Largely the case then and definitely the case these days.
True to some extent but not always. The Iraqi soldiers armed with the best weapons money could buy drop their weapons and ran when confronted with a rag tag group of armed men known as ISIS. The Viet Congs defeated the French and then the Americans without even having airplanes.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizen_Soldiers
 
"The Third Army claimed to have killed, wounded, or captured 1,811,388 German soldiers, six times its strength in personnel.[SUP][166][/SUP] Fuller's review of Third Army records differs only in the number of enemy killed and wounded, stating that between August 1, 1944 and May 9, 1945, 47,500 of the enemy were killed, 115,700 wounded, and 1,280,688 captured, for a total of 1,443,888.[SUP][167]"

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_S._Patton[/SUP]
 
Have you seen Fury? Quite entertaining. The scene of Shermans against a lone Tiger tank was gripping.
Nope, haven't seen the movie but the Sherman was not a very good tank. The Nazi Tiger tank was the best WW II tank until the Russian T-34 arrived on the battlefield.
 
I heard there is a great book (which I haven't read) titled "Citizen Soldiers". It all about how the American military in WW II was composed of mostly civilians in uniform. Yes, a bunch of school teachers, bank tellers and accountants beat the Nazis and Imperial Japan. Bless them all.

I guess you could say that ALL the large armies in WW2 - including Japan and Germany - were citizen armies. The German bank tellers, school teachers and accountants got beaten by their US counterparts.
 
Nope, haven't seen the movie but the Sherman was not a very good tank. The Nazi Tiger tank was the best WW II tank until the Russian T-34 arrived on the battlefield.

The Sherman was better than the T-34 and had no problem defeating it in Korea. The T-34 was often badly built - a communist failing - had horrible optical equipment and an unreliable engine. It was so cramped that westerners wondered how a crew could fight efficiently in that environment. The only way the T-34 got radios that functioned was that the Soviets essentially just installed US lend-lease radio units in their tanks. Essentially, the T-34 was a quantum leap in tank design in 1940 when it first emerged. By 1945, it had fallen badly behind.
 
Have you seen Fury? Quite entertaining. The scene of Shermans against a lone Tiger tank was gripping.

It's supposed to be fun, although some of the guys on my military hobby board have said it's "Hollywood" and its grasp of tactics is weak. OTOH, they enjoyed the fact that in-tank procedures appeared accurate. I should make a point of going out to see it.
 
"The Third Army claimed to have killed, wounded, or captured 1,811,388 German soldiers, six times its strength in personnel.[SUP][166][/SUP] Fuller's review of Third Army records differs only in the number of enemy killed and wounded, stating that between August 1, 1944 and May 9, 1945, 47,500 of the enemy were killed, 115,700 wounded, and 1,280,688 captured, for a total of 1,443,888.

Given the fact that the German army collapsed in 45 and surrendered en masse, you could probably show similar numbers for all the Allied armies.

I guess I could add that the US 1st Army (initially under Bradley) took the brunt of the fighting in Normandy, including Omaha Beach, the Drive on St Lo, the capture of Cherbourg, Operation Cobra and the Mortain counter offensive. Patton's Army drove to Falaise and then across France, but that was exploiting a German Army that was disintegrating and running like a jackrabbit for the Rhine. That reduces the loss ratio that 3rd Army suffered.

IIRC, 3rd Army also escaped other grueling slogs like the Huertgen Forest fiasco, the initial desperate fighting in the Battle of the Bulge (including Bastogne) and the Rhineland.
 
Nope, haven't seen the movie but the Sherman was not a very good tank. The Nazi Tiger tank was the best WW II tank until the Russian T-34 arrived on the battlefield.

Yes I know, but that's what makes that particular scene nail biting. I'm of the Combat T.V. series generation, so I've seen plenty of WWII shows or movies. But I noticed the teenager sitting next to me, that he was at the edge of his seat in that scene.