3) What if the Americans lost the Battle of Midway?
Yeah, win or lose, Midway had no real influence on the course of the Pacific war-from the American pov. The attrition battles in the Solomons destroyed Japanese aviation and, by the time of Leyte, Americans faced virtually naked and blind Japanese fleet with hardly any aircraft. In less than two years, American economy dwarfed Japanese navy in numbers and quality. As Claire Chennault once said " Japan lost the war the moment it attacked Pearl Harbor".
I think if we had been having these discussions in mid-1942, we might not have been so confident that the Allies would prevail.
And it could very well have happened that the Americans did indeed lose the Battle of Midway.
Picture the situation at 10.20am on the morning of 4 June 1942. On the four JP aircraft carriers, there was complete happiness. Several squadrons of US torpedo bombers had been fought off, every US plane shot down, and not one of the JP ships so much as scratched.
But now, with the JP navy convinced of its invincibility (having just seen proof of that very thing), three squadrons of US dive-bombers arrived overhead. This was pure chance. The US planes were basically lost, low on fuel, and about to turn back, when they spotted a lone JP destroyer, the wake of which gave them direction.
They arrived just at the critical moment when the four carriers were more or less defenceless. The JP CAP fighters, having done their work against the US torpedo squadrons, were down at low level, and needing to land to refuel and re-arm. Plus, the decks of the carriers were stacked with torpedoes and bombs from previous changes to their attack missions.
By 10.30am, Akagi had been hit by one 1000-lb bomb – Kaga by one 1000-lb and three 500-lb – Soryu by three 1000-lb bombs. All three were on fire and finished. A few hours later, the remaining carrier Hiryu was hit by four 1000-lb bombs.
This was the moment when it could now be said that, becasue of US industrial strength, the war in the Pacific was over, bar the shouting.
Pearl Harbour had taken place 6 months earlier. Several US battleships sunk or damaged. In the Pacific, Japan invading and wiping out country after country, China, Philipines, more or less the whole of East Asia. India, Australia next. Crippling losses of ships in the Atlantic. Europe almost completely in German hands. Russia on the brink of annihilation. The Allies retreating everywhere, losing battle after battle, with no sign of a turn of fortunes.
At 10.20am 4 june 1942, any one who looked at the state of the world, and said it was inevitable that the Axis powers would surrender unconditionally, would need his head examined. The Battle of Midway was unfolding just like all the others -- disastrously. Picture Roosevelt at that moment. Tell me he wasn't thinking: There is no light at the end of the tunnel. I'm gonna have to give the Japs the whole of East Asia, to make them stop. Probably Australia as well.
Then, 10 minutes later, Japan has disappeared as an aggressive naval force. Now the war of attrition starts, which anyone can see,
now, the Allies are bound to win.