When Genocide is Permissible

name calling like that makes you a joke like Don Cherry

That comment extends to people who use phrases like "genocide" to describe a small number of civilian deaths. Anyone who engages in that sort of mindless name calling is a joke.
 
That comment extends to people who use phrases like "genocide" to describe a small number of civilian deaths. Anyone who engages in that sort of mindless name calling is a joke.
really ? I've heard Canada's treatment of natives referred to as "cultural genocide" yet that is far better than the treatment given Palestinians.
 
really ? I've heard Canada's treatment of natives referred to as "cultural genocide" yet that is far better than the treatment given Palestinians.

On the contrary, Palestinians are treated FAR better than natives in Canada were, and a far smaller number of Palestinians have been killed. In fact, for all the press it gets, the total number of Palestinian dead since the conflict began in 47 is quite low. Natives in Canada and the US had it much worse by ANY measure.

That said, genocide is an inappropriate term in a general sense for the treatment of natives in Canada and the US.

However there are some specific instances of actual genocide where an entire tribe was killed, or nearly all. THAT is genocide.
 
Israel tried appeasement with Hamas before and it doesn't work. Once Hamas is out of the picture a lot can be done to improve life in Gaza. Netanyahu is talking about reopening the ports and the airport if Fatah can replace Hamas in Gaza.

Lol....
So, Fatah in Gaza can get Netanyahu to reopen the ports, but Fatah in the West Bank can't get him to stop settlement expansion.
We believe you.
Go on.
 
Lol....
So, Fatah in Gaza can get Netanyahu to reopen the ports, but Fatah in the West Bank can't get him to stop settlement expansion.
We believe you.
Go on.

Or you could read a newspaper and see that Israel itself floated the idea that if Hamas is disarmed and the Palestinian Authority (ie
Fatah) assumes control of the territory that the crossings, sea port, and airport could all be reopened provided there were international inspectors on hand to watch for weapons smuggling.

Hamas rejected the proposal, so it won't happen, but it was an actual Israeli proposal.

Maybe time to rethink your horrific misconceptions about Israel.
 
Or you could read a newspaper and see that Israel itself floated the idea that if Hamas is disarmed and the Palestinian Authority (ie
Fatah) assumes control of the territory that the crossings, sea port, and airport could all be reopened provided there were international inspectors on hand to watch for weapons smuggling.

Hamas rejected the proposal, so it won't happen, but it was an actual Israeli proposal.

Maybe time to rethink your horrific misconceptions about Israel.

Lol....
 
And Hamas was born how?

There is only one way for the Israelis and the Palestinians to end this conflict. Stop fighting. Treat each other decently and equitably and resolve to live together peaceably.
...
You are right. Israel is mostly there. Last I saw, 2/3 of Israelis support a two state peace while just over half of Palestinians do. Unfortunately major Palestinian factions are dead set against accepting a peace that includes Israel existing in any form or even against Jews living in the region. The closest they have come is saying Jews that were there by the end of the Ottoman Empire could stay but not as full citizens.
 
Unfortunately major Palestinian factions are dead set against accepting a peace that includes Israel existing in any form or even against Jews living in the region. The closest they have come is saying Jews that were there by the end of the Ottoman Empire could stay but not as full citizens.
And that is not apartheid.
 
And that is not apartheid.

So you are against apartheid?
Then you must back either giving Palestine a state immediately or giving them full human rights under Israeli rule.
Because right now Palestinians in the occupied territories live under apartheid Israeli rule.
 
So you are against apartheid?
Then you must back either giving Palestine a state immediately or giving them full human rights under Israeli rule.
Because right now Palestinians in the occupied territories live under apartheid Israeli rule.

As you keep refusing to accept, 20% of Israelis have absolutely full rights and share ethnicity with West Bank Palestinians. Therefore the laws are clearly about citizenship, not race.

And as you also ignore, the Palestinians are clearly opposed to being Israeli citizens and clearly opposed to a one state solution.
 
So you are against apartheid?
Yes.
Then you must back either giving Palestine a state immediately or giving them full human rights under Israeli rule.
Because right now Palestinians in the occupied territories live under apartheid Israeli rule.
Israel already gave them Gaza. The pals should have formed a state. Oh, but wait. They would have to accept Israel's right to exist. Can't have that.

BTW, arab citizens of Israel are not subject to apartheid.
 
BTW, arab citizens of Israel are not subject to apartheid.

I take this as admitting that Palestinians living under Israeli military occupation are living under apartheid rule.

As for your claim about accepting Israel's right to exist, do you mean:
a) the right for their to be a democratic Israel (which the PA accepted years ago) with equal rights for all or
b) the right for their to be a racist Jewish Israeli state?
 
I take this as admitting that Palestinians living under Israeli military occupation are living under apartheid rule.
They are not citizens and they do not live in Israel, hence the term apartheid is not applicable.

All citizens of Israel are treated equally.
 
I take this as admitting that Palestinians living under Israeli military occupation are living under apartheid rule.
...

Israeli military occupation? Sure. But no matter how often you say it, race isn't the issue as can be attested to by almost 2 million Arabs with Israeli citizenship.