When Genocide is Permissible

sure that is one way but not the only....... I wont play the game of proposing things I am just pointing out that you seem to have a binary view on things if this is your only solutiion

It really is binary. Hamas have pledged never to stop attacking Israel. The most they are even prepared to discuss is at most a ten year truce. So long as they have weapons they will eventually attack again and we will be right back into this again.

There are temporary deals that can be negotiated but the only long term solution is to disarm the people who refuse to consider peace. That is the only approach which doesn't include a certainty of future violence and therefore is the only solution that allows Gaza to get to some sort of normal border and security policy.
 
What's needed is Reconciliation between people who must share a small and harsh land, not just dividing lines. But as you say, even that pro tem sort of progress is still distant

Agreed.

Create one state with equal rights for all and let time heal the wounds.
If Rwanda and Ireland can do it, even Israel should be capable.
 
Are you serious? Israelis need permission to destroy terrorists tunnels that run into their country? :frusty: Stick to massage reviews

So you think that Gaza is inside Israel?
Why do you support a blockade so severe that tunnels are necessary for the basic needs of life?
 
Do you support Hamas?

Stupido, a plague on both Hamas and the Zionists.

This is a war Israel cannot win, the more Palestinians they kill the more the world will turn against. And Israel doesn't have the manpower for manifest destiny. It's time to give up Zionist propaganda, Biblical Israel will never return. The Palestinians have nothing to lose and will continue to fire rockets indefinitely. If Israel doesn't find the stones to negotiate a just peace, it's future looks bleak. This is a war Israel cannot win, this will be the Middle East's version of The Troubles.
 
Israel has offered a just peace many times, starting in 47 when Israel agreed to the UN plans and the Palestinians rejected it, and again multiple times since. The most recent being Olmert's fantastic offer.

Just recently Israel floated the idea of reopening all the Gaza crossings, port, and airport if Hamas disarmed and was replaced by a Palestinian Authority force. Hamas again rejected it, just as Hamas rejected the Egyptian truce at the start of the conflict that Israel had accepted.
 
Are you serious? Israelis need permission to destroy terrorists tunnels that run into their country? :frusty: Stick to massage reviews

my point was that they knew full well that destruvtion of the tunnels would create violence for them to justify further actions
 
my point was that they knew full well that destruvtion of the tunnels would create violence for them to justify further actions

Destroying the tunnels was not optional. Hamas was trying to use those tunnels to infiltrate heavily armed death squads into Israeli communities.
 
Are you serious? Israelis need permission to destroy terrorists tunnels that run into their country? :frusty: Stick to massage reviews

Who are you?!?!?

Ahhhhhh now I understand you are a non reviewer with a hard on for middle east politics.

I can't find one thread you started in the review sections.

Pathetic
 
There would have been no Palestinian casualties if Hamas had allowed Israelis to peacefully enter Gaza to destroy the tunnels. Instead Hamas started to shoot the Israelis and the Israelis shot back (which any rational person would do).

Or even a step further, If Hamas accepted the idea of peace and spent money on helping Gazan people instead of rockets and tunnels.
 
But considering the tunnels were the only way the people of Gaza could avoid the blockade, that was always a fairytale possibility....

1) The tunnels into Israel were not used for trade. The tunnels into Egypt were. (And Hamas has been using the tunnels instead of the crossing into Egypt as a way of monopolizing trade and profiting themselves)

2) The blockade only existed since Hamas began using Gaza to launch attacks. When Hamas took over Gaza there was no blockade.
 
Or even a step further, If Hamas accepted the idea of peace and spent money on helping Gazan people instead of rockets and tunnels.

This is your assessment?
I know, if you just get the last word in, you think it makes you right.
 
...
What's needed is Reconciliation between people who must share a small and harsh land, not just dividing lines. But as you say, even that pro tem sort of progress is still distant

Yet a partition with internationally recognized borders is better than the federal or binational states where both sides believe the other is advantaged. It didn't work out in the Balkans and it isn't working well in Lebanon.

Yes, there are groups on both sides who won't be happy with the partition. In Israel it is a small group that will be defeated in elections. In Palestine, major government factions are opposed to any partition that includes Israel existing.
 
Stupido, a plague on both Hamas and the Zionists.

This is a war Israel cannot win, the more Palestinians they kill the more the world will turn against. And Israel doesn't have the manpower for manifest destiny. It's time to give up Zionist propaganda, Biblical Israel will never return. The Palestinians have nothing to lose and will continue to fire rockets indefinitely. If Israel doesn't find the stones to negotiate a just peace, it's future looks bleak. This is a war Israel cannot win, this will be the Middle East's version of The Troubles.

Seems to be focused on one side allegedly refusing peace despite having made repeated offers over the decades. You do know that a peace deal involves two sides, one of whom outright refuses the concept of peace with Israel.
 
my point was that they knew full well that destruvtion of the tunnels would create violence for them to justify further actions

The violence was the reason the tunnels existed. There is nothing Israel can do that will make Hamas happy except to destroy itself. All the justification Hamas needs for violence is that Israel exists.