Bill C-36 How Long Do We Have?

A judge won't waste his/her time. Nor will the police. In a small town of 1,000 people where judges and cops have nothing to do, maybe, but I don't see it happening in a busy city like Toronto.

It all depends. Once you are caught and charged, I believe they may be allowed to go through everything you have to collect evidence.

Will they do the NSA spying thing on you to see if you are communicating with a SP and then bust you… that I would highly doubt.

As for the police and a big city, they spent a lot of money and time hunting Rob Ford. Imagine if you get a mayor (lets say Olivia Chow for fun) and she decides to make it a pet project and directs the police to focus on closing down SPs, agencies and MPs. Then what?
 
If you are convicted, then yes, it goes on your criminal record. It won't be on your criminal record if you are discharged, although the charge will still be there.

….

Thats also a problem for many. If if you are charged and found not guilty. It still shows up in a criminal record check. Which is wrong no matter how you look at it. Sadly that is a reality at the moment ( see the Star article in message #28).
 
Pretty heavy penalty. I think it's generally only a misdemeanor for both sides in the US with a very low fine. May depend on the state.
Looks like personal freedom is taking a big hit in Canada.

Does anyone really know about the licensed MP side? Someone mentioned a court ruling about a hand release during the performance
of a massage not being considered a sexual act. I notice Muse and other MP's have been a little quiet. Since they are licensed you
would think the municipality they operate in would be obligated to give them some information as to their ability to stay open. If the
license is for a certain time and they stay within the licensing requirements how can they be put out of business? Hey, MP's have any
response to provide?

Also what about independent MP's like Alona M and Allison Elm? Where do they stand? They provide no FS and will even provide
nonerotic massage.

Think about it non-erotic versus erotic massage. I pay for a massage at my hotel from either their employee or contractor or have
an MP come in. Who's to know what happens. This where these kinds of laws become unenforceable. Many people are really
totally satisfied with a non-erotic massage. But not everyone. Sticky.
 
Under what circumstances can LE get at emails, texts, phone calls? My sense is that they have to have a really good reason, like they suspect terrorist activity... otherwise they need something from a judge. Is it likely a judge would grant this over this kind of "crime?"

http://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Canadi...izure/Warrantless_Searches/Incident_to_Arrest

The law regarding police procedure for searching cell phones is a developing issue in Canada.

In many cases police seize cell phones from suspects and search them following an arrest. Police are permitted to search people for weapons of evidence related to the reason of arrest immediately following an arrest. These searches may only be performed where police have reason to believe that relevant evidence will be found that could otherwise be lost or destroyed. This is called search incident to arrest, and the rules concerning this procedure arise from Caslake [SUP][1][/SUP], and Cloutier v. Langlios [SUP][2][/SUP] .

At this stage, if a police officer finds an unlocked phone, they may perform a cursory search of its contents. The term 'cursory' search has been called "too vague" and whether these searches will continue to be allowed on cell phones, and under what circumstances, is subject to debate in Canadian,[SUP][3][/SUP]; however, these searches have been permitted with little argument in the past. [SUP][4][/SUP]

In other examples, warrantless incident to arrest searches of cell phones have been held valid where the search is carried out reasonably, and for a valid purpose related to the offence.[SUP][5][/SUP] In another example, a cursory search of a cell phone incidental to arrest was lawful where it was used to determine identity and whether the phone was stolen.[SUP][6][/SUP]

In these types of searches, the reason to search the phone has to be somehow connected to the investigation. A search of a cell phone during an arrest for curfew breach, for example, was found to be a violation of s.8.[SUP][7][/SUP]

There are many cases where police then take a cell phone into the station, or send it away to a lab, for computer assisted searches. This has been permitted in the past without a warrant. [SUP][8][/SUP] New cases have cropped up, which are tied to Supreme Court of Canada discussion surrounding privacy interests that people have in their computers and smart phones, [SUP][9][/SUP], that point to a new requirement for police to obtain warrants before subjecting a smart phone to a computer assisted search or a search involving the copying of a phone's contents. [SUP][10][/SUP]

Providing particularly good summary discussion on this issue are leading provincial court cases: in British Colubmia, R. v. Vye, (2014) BCSC 93, and in Nova Scotia R. v. Hiscoe, (2013), NSCA 48.
 
It all depends. Once you are caught and charged, I believe they may be allowed to go through everything you have to collect evidence.

Will they do the NSA spying thing on you to see if you are communicating with a SP and then bust you… that I would highly doubt.

As for the police and a big city, they spent a lot of money and time hunting Rob Ford. Imagine if you get a mayor (lets say Olivia Chow for fun) and she decides to make it a pet project and directs the police to focus on closing down SPs, agencies and MPs. Then what?

What would it depend on, getting a total prude as a judge? One so prudish they would put the system in motion to this extent? If they've "caught" you, isn't that the evidence needed to convict? Do you suggest that they'd be going through your emails for "evidence" of prior solicitations? Then add up all the times they think you've made an arrangement, assume that each time the act actually happened, charge you with all those crimes, and send you to jail for the max on each instance? Or any of the above?

As for Rob Ford - they spent a lot of money, pretty much know what was happening, and no charges. Yet anyway. And he's the mayor, biggest of the big fish. They don't have the money to go after little fish. Even a very few of them.

As for Olivia, she seemed OK with her husband going to the massage parlor - she's not the kind to go that way.

As for the police - it wouldn't look good on them to be chasing anything other than true cases of trafficking/underage/coercion. We aren't a city of prudes. Gay pride proves that.

I think your imagination is getting the better of you.
 
Interesting. But that is after an arrest, and makes sense if there is suspicion of serious crime.

I'm more concerned about, say, surveillance on a phone line to an escort agency. I can imagine that happening on a line they suspect is connected to underage/coerced/trafficked prostitution, but looking for regular johns like me, or Mayor Ford? Not (so) sure.

That would be up to a judge. That kind of surveillance would need a warrant for sure.

I don't see why the police would be monitoring an individual John. An escort agency, perhaps.
 
That would be up to a judge. That kind of surveillance would need a warrant for sure.

I don't see why the police would be monitoring an individual John. An escort agency, perhaps.

So my nightmare scenario is they decide to monitor, say, the Cupid's email account. I am hopeful that the agencies will be thinking about this and looking for ways around it... and of course if this DID happen it would be a pretty big deal. I am sure there are patrons of these agencies that are in powerful positions... like maybe judges. And then what? They only have a suspicion of crime even then, they'd still need evidence that the crime occurred. No, wait - communication is now a crime. Eeeek!

But it still seems outlandish to me. I like to entertain the odd nightmare scenario, but I generally don't think they are likely.
 
So my nightmare scenario is they decide to monitor, say, the Cupid's email account. I am hopeful that the agencies will be thinking about this and looking for ways around it... and of course if this DID happen it would be a pretty big deal. I am sure there are patrons of these agencies that are in powerful positions... like maybe judges. And then what? They only have a suspicion of crime even then, they'd still need evidence that the crime occurred. No, wait - communication is now a crime. Eeeek!

But it still seems outlandish to me. I like to entertain the odd nightmare scenario, but I generally don't think they are likely.

Your scenario is not impossible. Improbable perhaps. But not impossible.
 
I feel even more for the SP’s. I for one will not be risking a criminal record and will have to leave this hobby, I know others will too. I have a profession and personal responsibilities and I do not want to and can’t break the law and get a record.

I don’t mean to generalize here but I’ve seen comments from terbites who do not care and will break the law. I'm guessing that’s not your average worker on bay st. The clientele of our SP’s will be significantly downgraded. Maybe that’s the point too.
 
I feel even more for the SP’s. I for one will not be risking a criminal record and will have to leave this hobby, I know others will too. I have a profession and personal responsibilities and I do not want to and can’t break the law and get a record.

I don’t mean to generalize here but I’ve seen comments from terbites who do not care and will break the law. I'm guessing that’s not your average worker on bay st. The clientele of our SP’s will be significantly downgraded. Maybe that’s the point too.


Can I ask something if you don't mind?

What is the difference between now and when the bill gets past? I mean, I get that things are little more extreme for clients now, but you could still have been arrested before, given a criminal record before, etc. Most men hobbying do so via incalls. Which still could have had you arrested should you have been caught in one.

Again, I get that the risks are higher now for clients, but people seems to acting like there was no laws regarding the sex trade until now and even more so are acting like if the law is passed, now is the only time they could be busted. There was a criminal risk even for clients this whole time.

Is it the degree of it now that makes you think twice or where you not aware of the risk already involved?

Or maybe you are an outcall guy, I don't know. This is just something that has had me curious.
 
I feel even more for the SP’s. I for one will not be risking a criminal record and will have to leave this hobby, I know others will too. I have a profession and personal responsibilities and I do not want to and can’t break the law and get a record.

I don’t mean to generalize here but I’ve seen comments from terbites who do not care and will break the law. I`m guessing that’s not your average worker on bay st. The clientele of our SP’s will be significantly downgraded. Maybe that’s the point too.

Yeah, I feel for them too. I`m actually really worried, some of these women are pretty much friends of mine. These women have their lives and their living at stake. There`s a thread about supporting SPs through a campaign by Maggies, looking for money to help fight the good fight. Check it out. https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthread.php?484226-Do-you-support-the-rights-of-sex-workers
 
If you are convicted, then yes, it goes on your criminal record. It won't be on your criminal record if you are discharged, although the charge will still be there.

In reality, for a first time offender and for a crime like this, you will probably get diversion, which means you get some education and/or do some community service and then the charge is withdrawn. No criminal record.

It's not dissimilar to, for example, if you are charged with a DUI, show remorse and no one else was injured, there's a good chance you would get diverted to get alcohol counseling and then after completing it, the charges would be dropped. If you did it again though, the Crown won't be so nice to you the second time.

discharge is not available if you are found guilty of an offence which has a minimum punishment

re DUI - there is no chance you get diverted, unless you blow very close to the norm (i.e. 80mg) and plead to a careless under HTA and even that is an uphill battle in many jurisdictions. Second DUI is minimum 30 days jail by the way.
 
Can I ask something if you don't mind?

What is the difference between now and when the bill gets past? I mean, I get that things are little more extreme for clients now, but you could still have been arrested before, given a criminal record before, etc. Most men hobbying do so via incalls. Which still could have had you arrested should you have been caught in one.

Again, I get that the risks are higher now for clients, but people seems to acting like there was no laws regarding the sex trade until now and even more so are acting like if the law is passed, now is the only time they could be busted. There was a criminal risk even for clients this whole time.

Is it the degree of it now that makes you think twice or where you not aware of the risk already involved?

Or maybe you are an outcall guy, I don't know. This is just something that has had me curious.

Good question

I was obviously ok with outcall however, I did do incall for the majority of my sessions. Even though I knew I was taking a risk there was an air of stability around the sex trade since we had years of experience and we knew the level of risk of being caught in a bawdy house not being charged for buying sex. I preferred to use indies/agencies who frequent nice hotels or well know condos where the practice had been incident free for years.

With this new law there is a lot of uncertainty and in terms of prosecution, I am the target. I was never the target before and it’s a risk I will not take.
 
discharge is not available if you are found guilty of an offence which has a minimum punishment

re DUI - there is no chance you get diverted, unless you blow very close to the norm (i.e. 80mg) and plead to a careless under HTA and even that is an uphill battle in many jurisdictions. Second DUI is minimum 30 days jail by the way.

If you are diverted, you will not be found guilty of any offence, right? That's what diversion is. But you have to pass John School. Really not sure I could endure that, I'd probably beg to go back to court...
 
Good question

I was obviously ok with outcall however, I did do incall for the majority of my sessions. Even though I knew I was taking a risk there was an air of stability around the sex trade since we had years of experience and we knew the level of risk of being caught in a bawdy house not being charged for buying sex. I preferred to use indies/agencies who frequent nice hotels or well know condos where the practice had been incident free for years.

With this new law there is a lot of uncertainty and in terms of prosecution, I am the target. I was never the target before and it’s a risk I will not take.

I have always done incalls. When I first started hobbying I was always nervous about getting busted but after a year or so I got used to it.

Because its new, when this law passes I think after the first year or so everything will go back to "normal" (LE will concentrate on catching pimps, stop trafficking, underage etc.).
 
Good question

I was obviously ok with outcall however, I did do incall for the majority of my sessions. Even though I knew I was taking a risk there was an air of stability around the sex trade since we had years of experience and we knew the level of risk of being caught in a bawdy house not being charged for buying sex. I preferred to use indies/agencies who frequent nice hotels or well know condos where the practice had been incident free for years.

With this new law there is a lot of uncertainty and in terms of prosecution, I am the target. I was never the target before and it’s a risk I will not take.

Thank you. That answers it for me.