It's not over yet. This bill will get struck down as it still does not address the safety of sex workers, which why the first one got struck down the first place. I hope I have confidence in that.
Canada just became Saudi Arabia
Come on guys, don't get your panties in a bunch over this. Harper's majority isn't the end of the conversation, there are still judges in Canada who know how to read the constitution, even if the Conservative Party doesn't. The law won't pass third reading in its current state, and whatever scraps make it through the committee process will promptly be struck down by the courts. It won't take five years, it won't require an injunction from Bedford, it won't even require a constitutional challenge. The first judge who looks at it will strike it down, and the appeal courts will quickly agree.
As for advertising, the newspapers are already preparing challenges under the consitutional right to free speech. As long as sex work remains legal - which is does - there's no legitimate way to criminalize the advertising of sexual services. The government is just pandering to their evangelical base, they know full well that this legislation has no chance of staying on the books - they're just doing it to say they did it, so they can look tough and moral in the eyes of their supporters. Some of the lawyers who worked on the Bedford case have already come out and stated that the new legislation violates the Charter the same way the old laws did:
http://www.pivotlegal.org/the_new_sex_work_legislation_explained
The sky isn't falling, guys - tomorrow, it'll still be business as usual.
There is an easy way around this law. You place the envelope in a locked mailbox. No evidence that the cash was linked to you.
So, where are all the optimists who thought we we're over-reacting with our doom and gloom predictions, saying that the sky is falling? Well, the sky just fell.
Lovelatinas--great point. All these lovely women, currently making more than lawyers/hour, are now "liberated" from their "victimhood" by the white knights Mackay and Harper, and now have the pleasure of applying to corporate slavery jobs paying minimum wage, with a resume that is basically empty of "job experience". God I hate these people.
We all need to complain loudly and forcefully.
Personally, I've already sent off an e-mail to Peter MacKay. For those who may wish to adapt for their own use, here's what I sent:
It does not. You don't get off of drug trafficking charges by claiming to be a vendor of journeys to the inner mind and psyche.
It could be years before this is passed and by then many changes will occur.
Why would you say that?
The Reform Party (whoops, I mean the "Conservative Party of Canada" has a majority in parliament.
I doubt it will take more than a few weeks to pass.
Did you include your real name in the email?
I think this is, pure and simple, the PCs trying to impose a fundamentalist Christian view of sexuality on the country. It clearly does not address the safety of sex workers, and clearly does not respect the current laws under which sex work is legal....only certain activities associated with it are not. It may force the street trade further under cover, it will make a lot of the current escorting practices illegal, and it can essentially give the power to arrest a sex worker or a customer any time anywhere....because someone under 18 could reasonably be present almost anywhere.
It is clear that the intent is to prevent any sort of sex for money. Dechert made it clear that the intent or the hope would be to bring a total end to the disgusting practice of prostitution.
These people just thought they could do an end run around the intent of the court.....just make it illegal, which they effectively are doing....and then there will be no debate around safety.
Come on guys, don't get your panties in a bunch over this. Harper's majority isn't the end of the conversation, there are still judges in Canada who know how to read the constitution, even if the Conservative Party doesn't. The law won't pass third reading in its current state, and whatever scraps make it through the committee process will promptly be struck down by the courts. It won't take five years, it won't require an injunction from Bedford, it won't even require a constitutional challenge. The first judge who looks at it will strike it down, and the appeal courts will quickly agree.
As for advertising, the newspapers are already preparing challenges under the consitutional right to free speech. As long as sex work remains legal - which is does - there's no legitimate way to criminalize the advertising of sexual services. The government is just pandering to their evangelical base, they know full well that this legislation has no chance of staying on the books - they're just doing it to say they did it, so they can look tough and moral in the eyes of their supporters. Some of the lawyers who worked on the Bedford case have already come out and stated that the new legislation violates the Charter the same way the old laws did:
http://www.pivotlegal.org/the_new_sex_work_legislation_explained
The sky isn't falling, guys - tomorrow, it'll still be business as usual.
Most of the emphasis is on selling and purchasing sexual services in public places where children could be present. I believe that is where LE will be mostly targeting.
I blame the fools who gave Harper the Majority...
The sky isn't falling, guys - tomorrow, it'll still be business as usual.[/SIZE][/FONT][/I]
Those who voted for Harper just don't make the same x2 by voting for Hudak.EXACTLY.
And lots of those fools reside right here on TERB ironically enough.
Fuji has been pointing this out for years. (And I've been agreeing with him.)
Chances are it won't pass before they rise for the summer and it has to be passed by December as per SCOC, so there's your window. As sure as shootin', there will be another SCOC challenge and I suspect another smackdown for the same reason as before. Whether the election plays a part is anyine guess.