No rock frontman will ever compare....

Elton, Bolan,Ferry and Bowie were Freddy Mercury's peers.
You have no idea what you are talking about.

To repeat myself, FM and his glam rock showmanship was simply another act following in the footsteps of the true pioneers.

Queen's first album was in 1973 and they hit their stride in 1975 with Night At The Opera.

Elton John's first album was in 1969 and had 6 or 7 albums by 1973, the year he released Goodbye Yellow Brick Road. He was already outrageously glam as Queen were barely getting started.

David Bowie...first album 1967. Space Oddity--1969, Man Who Sold The World--1970, Hunky Dory--1971, Ziggy Stardust--1972. Queen had not made an album yet.

T-Rex...first album 1968. 7 albums by 1973 when Queen was in their infancy.

Roxy Music/Bryan Ferry are the closest to being a peer. 1st album--1972 and 3 albums by 1973.

Clearly all those acts were establishing glam rock showmanship well before anybody knew about Queen, including the members of Queen.

They may have been some overlap of recording careers, but those acts established the genre/style that FM adopted, years before Queen was a band. They were all huge influences on FM and he in no way had a reciprocal effect on their already well established acts. He was a copycat.

In light of the timelines, no intelligent person could argue those acts did not influence FM and to deny he copied them to a large extent wins you the Stupidest. Comment. In. This. Thread. You are in over your littlehead bigdik.
 
Shack's list shows he is just into what the media tells him is hip.. For 'hipsters' that is. :p

Just the opposite. Mainstream media is into Beyonce, Drake, Jayzee, Adele, Timberlake, Lady Gaga and other barf acts.

Your response is what I would expect from someone who may possibly know the music of 4 or 5 of the over 20 acts I listed. You are criticizing from a perspective of ignorance. Any archivist can add this post of yours to the other idiotic ones you've made this week, like in the Don Sterling thread.

You have very little credibility here.
 
Gaga is indisputably talented, especially compared to the mainstream attention whores promoted here as the idols of the 70s and 80s.

One big difference is the demise of network television and uniculture mass media. The whole concept of a counter culture in the sixties and seventies from which most of these acts get their cachet is predicated on a society that watched the same TV show every night.

Modern artists exist in an entirely different world, where mainstream media is going bankrupt, supplanted by a much more obliquely expressed YouTube culture.

The charade that the Stones pulled off was that they were against the primary culture while selling hundreds of millions of records and packing football stadium concerts. It was a fraud only possible in a network television world.

In the modern world true pop superstars like Gaga or Shakira command only a fragment of the expressed culture. David Guettas, Arcade Fires, Daft Punks, etc. occupy almost parallel universes and that is before you even get into the whole multi layered DJ scene.

The reality is that the days when everyone listened to the same top 40 music are gone, including the days of alternative top 40 charts. The world has splintered to the point where the mainstream is alternative.
 
I think kanye west is pretty talented.

OK, I backed you on your Curt comment giving you the benefit but seriously I am starting to doubt you after this comment and going back to your comment on the thread about if we regret things we post last year. Kanye is a jack ass, he is disrespectful, his music is garbage, and he does not have much talent....I would be tempted to throw eggs at him.
 
OK, I backed you on your Curt comment giving you the benefit but seriously I am starting to doubt you after this comment and going back to your comment on the thread about if we regret things we post last year. Kanye is a jack ass, he is disrespectful, his music is garbage, and he does not have much talent....I would be tempted to throw eggs at him.

His first album is a classic. I just listened to it last week, and he is doing things his own way. It sounded good. He produced the whole thing himself.
Im talking in terms of his genre.
 
You have no idea what you are talking about.

To repeat myself, FM and his glam rock showmanship was simply another act following in the footsteps of the true pioneers.

Queen's first album was in 1973 and they hit their stride in 1975 with Night At The Opera.

Elton John's first album was in 1969 and had 6 or 7 albums by 1973, the year he released Goodbye Yellow Brick Road. He was already outrageously glam as Queen were barely getting started.

David Bowie...first album 1967. Space Oddity--1969, Man Who Sold The World--1970, Hunky Dory--1971, Ziggy Stardust--1972. Queen had not made an album yet.

T-Rex...first album 1968. 7 albums by 1973 when Queen was in their infancy.

Roxy Music/Bryan Ferry are the closest to being a peer. 1st album--1972 and 3 albums by 1973.

Clearly all those acts were establishing glam rock showmanship well before anybody knew about Queen, including the members of Queen.

They may have been some overlap of recording careers, but those acts established the genre/style that FM adopted, years before Queen was a band. They were all huge influences on FM and he in no way had a reciprocal effect on their already well established acts. He was a copycat.

In light of the timelines, no intelligent person could argue those acts did not influence FM and to deny he copied them to a large extent wins you the Stupidest. Comment. In. This. Thread. You are in over your littlehead bigdik.

David Bowie released Space Oddity in '69. He went "Glam" in '72 when he debuted Ziggy Stardust.

Elton John was around for a long time before he was Elton. He is considered to have briefly been a "Glam Rocker" around the time of Goodbye Yellow Brick Road. He soon evolved into a Rock Liberace.

T-Rex was actually Tyrannosaurus Rex until 1970, and were folk rockers until '71 when they released Electric Warrior. Bolan also played Lead Guitar, which makes him less a traditional "frontman".

Roxy Music is more "Art Rock" than "Glam".

Which brings us to Queen, formed in 1970 when Freddie Mercury joined Smile. They are not considered a "Glam Rock" act as much as a Rock Band.

It's difficult to see much influence in Freddies performances from any of the great artists you've noted. There's a lot more Mick there than any of your references.
I suppose he also copied the four octave range from Bowie?
 
Of course Freddie was influenced by many great showmen before him, as they also borrowed from the greats. James Brown is the biggest that hasn't been mentioned.
But none of them had the bold operatic sound and style Freddie Mercury brought to rock.
 
You have very little credibility here.
No your statement applies to you and only you considering the topic.

None of those other singers you've mentioned commanded a stage or sang with the range Mercury had so your post is what i've said it was.

Yes mainstream media is into Beyonce etc.. and like i told you the acts you listed are acts 'hipster' idiots/media prop up all the time.. Next you'll be yapping you like Timbra or Goyte. Both already forgotten one hit wonders as i knew they would be when they first got noticed around 3yrs ago.
 
David Bowie released Space Oddity in '69. He went "Glam" in '72 when he debuted Ziggy Stardust.

Elton John was around for a long time before he was Elton. He is considered to have briefly been a "Glam Rocker" around the time of Goodbye Yellow Brick Road. He soon evolved into a Rock Liberace.

T-Rex was actually Tyrannosaurus Rex until 1970, and were folk rockers until '71 when they released Electric Warrior. Bolan also played Lead Guitar, which makes him less a traditional "frontman".

Roxy Music is more "Art Rock" than "Glam".

Which brings us to Queen, formed in 1970 when Freddie Mercury joined Smile. They are not considered a "Glam Rock" act as much as a Rock Band.
Thank you for agreeing their flamboyant styles were around for FM to emulate before he had any influence.
 
No your statement applies to you and only you considering the topic.

None of those other singers you've mentioned commanded a stage or sang with the range Mercury had so your post is what i've said it was.

Yes mainstream media is into Beyonce etc.. and like i told you the acts you listed are acts 'hipster' idiots/media prop up all the time.. Next you'll be yapping you like Timbra or Goyte. Both already forgotten one hit wonders as i knew they would be when they first got noticed around 3yrs ago.

Still no list of your own? Figured.
 
No and no.

Yes and yes because they both were all the rage from the media and hipsters around 3yrs ago and both are not talked about anymore except among hipsters that are glad they are not big so they can boast: 'they didn't sell out'.

You do know hipsters usually are into obscure acts right? Kinda like alot of your list.
 
Yes and yes because they both were all the rage from the media and hipsters around 3yrs ago and both are not talked about anymore except among hipsters that are glad they are not big so they can boast: 'they didn't sell out'.

You do know hipsters usually are into obscure acts right? Kinda like alot of your list.
It used to be hip to be into Queen, doesn't take away how great they were.
 
Name one big performer alive today that can go up on stage all alone with one instrument (well.. two if you include vocals..) and do this...[/QUOTE]

His list was the first post of this thread, be smart.

A list of one; shallow, short sighted and narrow minded, then apparently the rest of the contributors see it differently and he blows it with these contributions.

And that folks... Is the first stupid comment in this thread.


The debate is over.....