No More Free Speech?

http://news.nationalpost.com/2014/04/11/trinity-western-university/

The Gay Community, even though they are special, will have to learn (like the rest of us) that they can't get everything they want.

"The Gay Community", like virtually all communities, doesn't have a single voice that speaks for it. You'll find a myriad of differing opinions on a variety of subjects within that group, as you will within any other.

As a whole, however, they aren't asking for much: Equality under the law. Up until the mid- the late-1900's, interracial marriage illegal was illegal in much of the civilized world. It defiled the sanctity of marriage they said. Those in interracial relationships were, initially, told they were sinners, told they were a disgrace, told what they were doing was shameful, and so on. When the rights movements would speak up on issues like this, they were told to keep their private lives private, that no one wanted to see it, that "we" (meaning those who weren't engaged in their "lifestyle choice") didn't need to see it. Sound familiar yet?

Do you know what "the gays" and the "gay community" is in everyone's face? Because that's what works. Until such time as you realize they aren't a "gay community" and are really just people, they'll continue to need to be in your face. And perhaps someday the equality that's didn't used to be but now is extended to women, minorities and interracial couples will be extended to them to.

For those of us who don't judge others based on what gender they happen to be attracted to, we look forward to that day. Those who don't will talk about fire and brimstone that won't come, just like it didn't come when we started letting good white Catholic women marry the heathen blacks. Frankly, the idea that some people not only have no problem with, but actively fight against changing, the notion that there exists people in society that aren't equal under the law is appalling to me.
 
"The Gay Community", like virtually all communities, doesn't have a single voice that speaks for it. You'll find a myriad of differing opinions on a variety of subjects within that group, as you will within any other.

As a whole, however, they aren't asking for much: Equality under the law. Up until the mid- the late-1900's, interracial marriage illegal was illegal in much of the civilized world. It defiled the sanctity of marriage they said. Those in interracial relationships were, initially, told they were sinners, told they were a disgrace, told what they were doing was shameful, and so on. When the rights movements would speak up on issues like this, they were told to keep their private lives private, that no one wanted to see it, that "we" (meaning those who weren't engaged in their "lifestyle choice") didn't need to see it. Sound familiar yet?

Do you know what "the gays" and the "gay community" is in everyone's face? Because that's what works. Until such time as you realize they aren't a "gay community" and are really just people, they'll continue to need to be in your face. And perhaps someday the equality that's didn't used to be but now is extended to women, minorities and interracial couples will be extended to them to.

For those of us who don't judge others based on what gender they happen to be attracted to, we look forward to that day. Those who don't will talk about fire and brimstone that won't come, just like it didn't come when we started letting good white Catholic women marry the heathen blacks. Frankly, the idea that some people not only have no problem with, but actively fight against changing, the notion that there exists people in society that aren't equal under the law is appalling to me.
I don't disagree with a lot of what you said but let's not forget who is the victim here.

It is not the gays who lost the referendum and still got gay marriage.

It is the CEO who was on the winning side in the referendum and lost his CEO job and maybe career (doesn't matter if he jumped or was pushed).
 
As important members of the community, I would like to see more CEO's exercise their constitutional free speech rights to publicly express their views on a multitude pf social issues, WITH FEAR OF RETRIBUTION.

BTW: Just because one disagrees with a gay, doesn't mean one is anti-gay.
That is exactly what Eich did. And you seem to be saying his position made his speech all the more significant, because he was a CEO. Whether or not he was foolish, he clearly didn't fear the consequences of speaking out. So far no one has identified anyone who was muzzled and had their free speech interfered with. What happened was that a speaker aroused such vigorous opposition widespread enough to cost him the trust of his company had in his ability to continue heading their enterprise. Like you, they heard him speaking as their CEO, not just as a citizen.

That does not qualify as 'retribution' by any definition I am aware of. He spoke on matters of opinion that he felt were important to the body politic in an effort to affect others, and the opinion came down against him, and affected him. Just as his opinions were part of the earlier success of the unconstitutional Prop 8, which resulted in evil consequences for many Californians.

He wanted his speech to have negative consequence s for others; others wanted their speech to have negative consequences for him. Everyone got to have their say, and the history is that everyone successfully had their bit of influence on the opinions and actions of others, just as they wanted. If speech has no consequence, why speak at all?

You and others seem to be having great trouble clearly articulating what it is that you think went wrong in this story. Perhaps if you were to focus on how we could improve things you might make your point more clearly.

BTW, you are quite right that disagreeing with someone doesn't make you prejudiced. However choosing to single out a personal characteristic, attribute it to the entire group you disagree with and add a criminal label certainly suggests it. Please don't take it personally, some of my best friends are part of the anti-gay mafia.
 
He wanted his speech to have negative consequence s for others; others wanted their speech to have negative consequences for him.
Let's be blunt. Almost everything you or I say will offend somebody somewhere. For example, where do you stand on abortion, assisted suicide, gun control, prostitution, etc. ? Doesn't matter where you stand, you will offend somebody somewhere. Does that mean you should lose your livelihood?
 
I don't disagree with a lot of what you said but let's not forget who is the victim here.

It is not the gays who lost the referendum and still got gay marriage.

It is the CEO who was on the winning side in the referendum and lost his CEO job and maybe career (doesn't matter if he jumped or was pushed).
When the unconstitutional and unlawful Proposition 8 was temporarily operative, it created all sorts of victims. Eich may be whining (and for all we know the Board's bitching about losing him) about his frustrated hopes for his time at Mozilla, but he and the corporation did agree about his departure, and still do. Jumped or pushed neither side's trying to undo anything.

Everywhere along the line free people speaking and deciding freely. What should have been done differently, and who should have done it?
 
Let's be blunt. Almost everything you or I say will offend somebody somewhere. For example, where do you stand on abortion, assisted suicide, gun control, prostitution, etc. ? Doesn't matter where you stand, you will offend somebody somewhere. Does that mean you should lose your livelihood?

And when you are CEO, and what you say is hurtling your company towards bankruptcy, the shareholders have every right to give you the boot and hire somebody better for the company.
 
When the unconstitutional and unlawful Proposition 8
Unconstitutional and unlawful, eh? I guess then that all the people who organized and ran Proposition 8 should also lose their jobs and be prosecuted to the full extent of the law.

Reason for edit: Changed the example.
 
Yes, somebody who will keep his/her opinion on social issues to him/herself. Thank goodness for free speech.

Are you saying that the shareholders don't have the right to express their opinion and vote as they see fit?
 
I don't disagree with a lot of what you said but let's not forget who is the victim here.

It is not the gays who lost the referendum and still got gay marriage.

It is the CEO who was on the winning side in the referendum and lost his CEO job and maybe career (doesn't matter if he jumped or was pushed).

He's not a "victim". He was unable to fulfill the requirements of his multi-million dollar job because of his opinion is now going to go off and get another multi-million dollar job. His opinion made him ineffective in his role. He could have switched roles, instead he chose to leave the company. He's not a "victim" of anything but capitalism.

"The gays" didn't lose anything. Many boycotted the vote because it was unconstitutional. It was a publicity stunt for the "family values" politicians.
 
Yes, somebody who will keep his/her opinion on social issues to him/herself. Thank goodness for free speech.

Why is it so hard for you to understand? I'll try explaining it one more time before I give up.

A CEO, like a soldier, doesn't have "his/her opinion", they have the opinions of the company/military/service, or they keep their mouths shut. That's the job. I thought everyone knew that was the job but apparently there are people like you that don't.
 
Unconstitutional and unlawful, eh? I guess then that all the people who organized and ran Proposition 8 should also lose their jobs and be prosecuted to the full extent of the law.

Reason for edit: Changed the example.

You clearly don't understand how law works. An unconstitutional law doesn't make the act of organizing and running a referendum on that law illegal. Perhaps your lack of understanding of the law is why you're so confused about how freedom of speech only applies to government, how Eich choosing to leave is very different from being fired insofar as the law is concerned, how a representative for a group or organization is accountable for things they did even in their private affairs and even before they were representatives, and why organizing and tabling a law struck down as unconstitutional isn't illegal either.
 
A CEO, like a soldier, doesn't have "his/her opinion", they have the opinions of the company/military/service, or they keep their mouths shut. That's the job.

"Our organizational culture reflects diversity and inclusiveness," the statement goes on. "We welcome contributions from everyone regardless of age, culture, ethnicity, gender, gender-identity, language, race, sexual orientation, geographical location and religious views. Mozilla supports equality for all." But the company is plainly taking the position that it won't employ, in leadership positions, anyone who publicly holds orthodox Christian or Muslim views on gay marriage.
Source:http://www.theatlantic.com/politics...e-litmus-test-violates-liberal-values/360156/
 
Unconstitutional and unlawful, eh? I guess then that all the people who organized and ran Proposition 8 should also lose their jobs and be prosecuted to the full extent of the law.

Reason for edit: Changed the example.
Why? What unlawful act did they commit that they should be prosecuted for? As suffering consequences at work, I'm sure there were many folks on both sides of that polarizing issue who found their Monday mornings at work uncomfortable because of it.

But don't prove you're one of the intolerant by attributing your extremist imaginings like 'should lose their' jobs to others if you want to be taken seriously.
 
"Our organizational culture reflects diversity and inclusiveness," the statement goes on. "We welcome contributions from everyone regardless of age, culture, ethnicity, gender, gender-identity, language, race, sexual orientation, geographical location and religious views. Mozilla supports equality for all." But the company is plainly taking the position that it won't employ, in leadership positions, anyone who publicly holds orthodox Christian or Muslim views on gay marriage.
Source:http://www.theatlantic.com/politics...e-litmus-test-violates-liberal-values/360156/

No. That's the position you are reading into the words, which in no way support it. In fact that last sentence: "Mozilla supports equality for all" should have warned Eich that his 'Marriage is only for my kind' position was contrary to Mozilla's. Why would they want, or tolerate a CEO who believed in such inequality, not just privately, but publicly advocated it, and actively worked and paid from his own pocket to achieve it?

Speech has consequences; that is why we speak.
 
Last edited:
You said that Proposition 8 was unconstitutional and unlawful.
Actually a judge said it was, which is why it is not part of California law, in spite of getting all those votes.

To advocate it's passage, or to vote for it was always quite legal, if stupid, intolerant and thoughtless. It was just wasted effort because the Proposition was unconstitutional, and therefore unlawful. I was responding to AK (still posting after promising he'd done his last) who seemed to think there was such a law prohibiting such exercise of free speech and so wanted to know why the Prop8 guys weren't jailed.

Sorry you didn't get it either.
 
And when you are CEO, and what you say is hurtling your company towards bankruptcy, the shareholders have every right to give you the boot and hire somebody better for the company.

Well no, not "every right".

The "rights", here, do not favour the shareholders of a corporation. The CEO, being an employee of the corporation is, like every other employee, not subject to being fired by shareholders.

Of course, the CEO can be fired (e.g for incompetence, or for acting against the corp's interests) -- just not by the shareholders.

There is no statute that says an employee cannot be fired (although some work-contracts have that effect.) The statute gives employees the right to receive money compensation if they are discriminated against on one of the forbidden grounds.


The Ontario Human Rights Code contains these provisions (presumably, cal. has similar.)
Employment
5. (1) Every person has a right to equal treatment with respect to employment without discrimination because of sexual orientation, gender identity, gender expression, age, record of offences, marital status, family status or disability.
Harassment in employment
(2) Every person who is an employee has a right to freedom from harassment in the workplace by the employer or agent of the employer or by another employee because of race, ancestry, place of origin, colour, ethnic origin, citizenship, creed, sexual orientation, gender identity, gender expression, age, record of offences, marital status, family status or disability.

Announced intention to discriminate
13. (1) A right under Part I is infringed by a person who publishes or displays before the public . any notice, sign, symbol, emblem, or other similar representation that indicates the intention of the person to infringe a right under Part I or that is intended by the person to incite the infringement of a right under Part I.
Opinion
(2) Subsection (1) shall not interfere with freedom of expression of opinion.


So, if a CEO of a corporation articulates publicly that he is against gay marriage, an employee of the corp who is, or is looking to become, a gay spouse, just might possibly have a cause of action against the corp, on the grounds that he (the employee) is likely to be discriminated against by the corp -- but, presumably, not unless the CEO goes beyond merely saying he is against it, and says he will ding any employee of his corp that enters a gay-marriage. Merely stating an opinion does not generally amount to announcement of an intention to follow that opinion up with hostile action. It's just an expression of opinion.

The remedies for breach of the Ontario HRC employment safeguards are in the form of money damages to be paid by the employer (the corp) to the discriminated-against employee. So, in effect, a corp is free to discriminate against an employee on the forbidden grounds, provided they are prepared to pay compensation to the employee. In fact, well-heeled bigoted employers do this all the time.

Of course, the employee need not actually be fired by the corp. If the corp allows the employee to be subjected to harassment, whereupon he leaves voluntarily, that can amount to constructive dismissal, and the corp is just as liable for damages as if they had fired him. This is true for the CEO, as for any employee.