No More Free Speech?

Then what is the point of having referendums or freedom of speech if a vocal minority with a different POV pressures your company to fire you?

What is your position on abortion, assisted suicide, Quebec independence, death penalty, prostitution, marijuana, women in combat role, bike lanes, black only schools, dogfighting, masturbation, etc.? Whatever is your position on these and other issues, I can virtually assure you there will be other people who will disagree with you. Is it acceptable for these other people to try and get you fired?

BTW: There is now a petition to get Michael Vick fired because he used to support dogfighting. The guy went through due process and served his time. Shouldn't people leave him alone now?
If someone had been fired, you'd perhaps have a point.

Please look again at the article you cited to start this thread; it clearly states that Eich stepped down, nowhere does it say he was fired.

Neither you nor I can stop anyone from over-reacting to an opinion they do not like, as long as they stay within the laws. If they advocate firing someone from a non-political job for their political views—being a communist sympathizer for example—they should be resisted or ignored. Eich chose not to ignore the political controversy he had publicly joined and aroused and to give in to those who objected instead. An over-reaction in response to an over-reaction. That's his right, just as much as it was their right to object.

Supporting dogfighting is like supporting torture as entertainment. It's unfortunate we cannot re-build the minds and feelings of people who are so twisted. One can hope and imagine Virk made some progress himself due to the punishment he got, but history has shown punishment is largely ineffective as a reform tool.

I have no idea what he job he does now that people want to have him fired from, but they clearly believe either he hasn't been punished enough, or that the risk of re-offending should be separated from the the job he does. Are you now proposing their speech should be limited? To be consistent with your OP, shouldn't you be rather be asking whether his employers should be listening to or ignoring such opinions?

And what if those opinions translate into financial harm for the employer? Who will make that good? For how long? What do you propose we the people should do with our laws? Whose freedom of choice, speech and action should we limit and forbid?

There's no way free speech can be a right for one person but not for another who disagrees. You are free to argue, not listen, or to ignore when people disagree with your free speech. But you cannot compel them to be silent, nor to say only what you want to hear.
 
No dude, I'm busy at work. Not much time to read entire wiki pages. My post was correct though, a judge overruled a democratically voted upon proposition which didnt want gay marriage.

I'll get to your other post later
And as the page you posted without reading said, that proposition was unconstitutional. No one, not even a high court judge can 'overrule' a measure that never was valid in the first place.
 
You're incredibly stupid if you dont see whats going on here. Eich is generally respected in software community because he started Java-whatever. He was politely asked to quit so he could save face.

If he had refused he wouldve been fired.
To me, and anyone else with half a brain, thats exactly the same thing as being fired
But evaluated with a whole brain, they are two different things. If they were not, (accepting your account of the events) he would have been just fired. But it mattered to him and to Mozilla that the other route should be taken. As you said.

If you want free speech, you gotta accept that sometimes the pressure of it is going to be more than you choose to endure. The only other option is to limit that free speech. What would you like to add to our libel, slander, obscenity and hate-speech laws to accomplish that?
 
If someone had been fired, you'd perhaps have a point.

Please look again at the article you cited to start this thread; it clearly states that Eich stepped down, nowhere does it say he was fired.

Neither you nor I can stop anyone from over-reacting to an opinion they do not like, as long as they stay within the laws. If they advocate firing someone from a non-political job for their political views—being a communist sympathizer for example—they should be resisted or ignored. Eich chose not to ignore the political controversy he had publicly joined and aroused and to give in to those who objected instead. An over-reaction in response to an over-reaction. That's his right, just as much as it was their right to object.

Supporting dogfighting is like supporting torture as entertainment. It's unfortunate we cannot re-build the minds and feelings of people who are so twisted. One can hope and imagine Virk made some progress himself due to the punishment he got, but history has shown punishment is largely ineffective as a reform tool.

I have no idea what he job he does now that people want to have him fired from, but they clearly believe either he hasn't been punished enough, or that the risk of re-offending should be separated from the the job he does. Are you now proposing their speech should be limited? To be consistent with your OP, shouldn't you be rather be asking whether his employers should be listening to or ignoring such opinions?

And what if those opinions translate into financial harm for the employer? Who will make that good? For how long? What do you propose we the people should do with our laws? Whose freedom of choice, speech and action should we limit and forbid?

There's no way free speech can be a right for one person but not for another who disagrees. You are free to argue, not listen, or to ignore when people disagree with your free speech. But you cannot compel them to be silent, nor to say only what you want to hear.

OJ, you make many valid points but all we are saying is:

People should be able to freely express their opinions without fear of retribution.
 
You're incredibly stupid if you dont see whats going on here. Eich is generally respected in software community because he started Java-whatever. He was politely asked to quit so he could save face.

If he had refused he wouldve been fired.
To me, and anyone else with half a brain, thats exactly the same thing as being fired

So now you can predict the future. Nice.

Here's the thing, if he had refused and been fired, he could have sued. Then it would be up for the courts to decide if what happened was wrong or not. Because he chose to leave, we'll never now what the outcome was. He might not have been fired. When I was asked to leave a job and refused, I didn't get fired. In my limited experience (of 1 time, which I think still greatly exceeds the average number of times for most people), you're asked to leave when they know they can't fire you. If they could, they'd just do it.
 
OJ, you make many valid points but all we are saying is:

People should be able to freely express their opinions without fear of retribution.

And that's mostly true... Unless you spread hate speech or any other form of speech that limits your right, or unless you're the representative of a company, like CEO, in which case your job is to represent that company. In that case, your opinion is the company's opinion. And if the company doesn't like it, you've failed at your job. So even if Eich had been fired, which he wasn't, there is no guarantee that what happened would've been unfair, unconstitutional or wrong.
 
OJ, you make many valid points but all we are saying is:

People should be able to freely express their opinions without fear of retribution.

This just occurred to me...

I fly a plane with a large number of people. As the Captain, I represent my company, I think that's fair to say. Should I be allowed to say, "Gentleman welcome to BlueLaser Airlines flight 101 with service to Paradise Cove. We'll be cruising at an altitude of 32,000 feet today and anticipate a flight time of just over 2 hours. Women, you will find the kitchen located at the rear of aircraft, please proceed there when I switch the seat belt sign off since that's where you belong. If you're black, the washroom at the rear aircraft are for your use, please refrain from using the ones near the first class, I've taped a sign to them indicating 'WHITES ONLY' to make it clear. If you're gay or a Jew, God hates you so you will not find flotation devices under your seats."? Surely, I have the freedom of speech, I shouldn't be fired for that, right? Or if you think that's too drastic (which it is, just as your examples where), what if I said, "If you're a Republican, please don't use the entertainment systems, they're only for people who are able to think, not morons."? Is that ok?
 
I fly a plane with a large number of people. As the Captain, I represent my company, I think that's fair to say. Should I be allowed to say, "Gentleman welcome to BlueLaser Airlines flight 101 with service to Paradise Cove. We'll be cruising at an altitude of 32,000 feet today and anticipate a flight time of just over 2 hours. Women, you will find the kitchen located at the rear of aircraft, please proceed there when I switch the seat belt sign off since that's where you belong. If you're black, the washroom at the rear aircraft are for your use, please refrain from using the ones near the first class, I've taped a sign to them indicating 'WHITES ONLY' to make it clear. If you're gay or a Jew, God hates you so you will not find flotation devices under your seats."? Surely, I have the freedom of speech, I shouldn't be fired for that, right? Or if you think that's too drastic (which it is, just as your examples where), what if I said, "If you're a Republican, please don't use the entertainment systems, they're only for people who are able to think, not morons."? Is that ok?

What you do and/or say on the job is not the same as what you do and/or say in your private life when you are representing only yourself.

Just because you voted yea or nay in a government organized referendum is not hate speech.

Sometimes personal values and professional reponsibilities do overlap. For example, I know a doctor who refuses to perform abortions. Should he be targeted by the pro-choice folks and be fired or forced to resign from the hospital? Is it illegal to refuse to perform abortions?
 
This just occurred to me...

I fly a plane with a large number of people. As the Captain, I represent my company, I think that's fair to say. Should I be allowed to say, "Gentleman welcome to BlueLaser Airlines flight 101 with service to Paradise Cove. We'll be cruising at an altitude of 32,000 feet today and anticipate a flight time of just over 2 hours. Women, you will find the kitchen located at the rear of aircraft, please proceed there when I switch the seat belt sign off since that's where you belong. If you're black, the washroom at the rear aircraft are for your use, please refrain from using the ones near the first class, I've taped a sign to them indicating 'WHITES ONLY' to make it clear. If you're gay or a Jew, God hates you so you will not find flotation devices under your seats."? Surely, I have the freedom of speech, I shouldn't be fired for that, right? Or if you think that's too drastic (which it is, just as your examples where), what if I said, "If you're a Republican, please don't use the entertainment systems, they're only for people who are able to think, not morons."? Is that ok?
No, this is different because Eich supported a government sponsored bill called proposition 8.

If you have a beef it should be with proposition 8 itself, not with people who voted for it

Just because you voted yea or nay in a government organized referendum is not hate speech
Exactly. Its amazing Liberals don't get this
 
OJ, you make many valid points but all we are saying is:

People should be able to freely express their opinions without fear of retribution.
And there should be lemonade fountains and peppermint trees.

Dream worlds aside, was no retribution in this case, so there's nothing for you to get het up about. It would be nice if everyone was so tolerant that they didn't get aroused to overstatement by ordinary happenings and utterances, but this very thread provides clear examples that we haven't evolved that far. It would also be nice if people with convictions they think worth encouraging and supporting had the courage to face the disapproval of others and it would be nice if pusillanimity wasn't the survival factor it is in our commercial world. But all that gets us right back to The Big Rock Candy Mountain.

In the real world speech is free. In the real world that free speech will either be ignored or have consequences. No other options. Of course you knew that, and so did Eich. It's why you spoke, because you wanted to be heard, to influence thinking and change opinions. Are you seriously advocating only agreeable speech should be free?

Since there was no actual retribution in the case you cited, please either suggest the social mechanisms we need to change humanity, the new speech laws we need to enact, or a different illustrative example of the sort of protection for free speech, or prohibition of censorship we should enact.
---------
As an afterthought: How naive does one have to be to imagine there will be no consequences from speaking for and financially supporting a measure which is passionately dividing your state and which proposes to deprive people of the right to establish families which they presently enjoy after a long struggle to get it. One could imagine the CEO of a not-for-profit that depends on enthusiastic volunteers for its labour force and on the public's good will for finances would be more conscious of distancing his personal expressions from the firm he fronts.
 
OJ, you make many valid points but all we are saying is:

People should be able to freely express their opinions without fear of retribution.

I think we've been derailed somewhat by framing this as a debate about freedom of speech.

Freedom of speech is about freedom from state censorship. It doesn't apply to how an employer treats an employee who expresses controversial views.

The real issue, I believe, is intolerance towards unpopular views. Even though Eich's right to freedom of speech remains intact, that doesn't mean he was treated fairly. It's a different discussion.
 
What you do and/or say on the job is not the same as what you do and/or say in your private life when you are representing only yourself.

Just because you voted yea or nay in a government organized referendum is not hate speech.

Sometimes personal values and professional reponsibilities do overlap. For example, I know a doctor who refuses to perform abortions. Should he be targeted by the pro-choice folks and be fired or forced to resign from the hospital? Is it illegal to refuse to perform abortions?

I covered this elsewhere in this thread, but as a salaried employee and figurehead of a company, he's always on the job. I'm technically only paid when the doors are closed and the engines are running, so one could argue I'm technically only "on the job" during those times. Does that mean if I sit at the gate, in uniform, talking to my co-pilot, and make those same comments about women, segregation, gays and jews, I should be free from disciplinary action from my company? Anytime you are in a position where you can be seen as representing your company, you are "on the job" and your words and actions are "part of the job". Eich was CEO. That's what you keep missing. 24/7, he was "on the job" representing Mozilla.
 
I think we've been derailed somewhat by framing this as a debate about freedom of speech.

Freedom of speech is about freedom from state censorship. It doesn't apply to how an employer treats an employee who expresses controversial views.

The real issue, I believe, is intolerance towards unpopular views. Even though Eich's right to freedom of speech remains intact, that doesn't mean he was treated fairly. It's a different discussion.

I don't see how we can be derailed, the topic of the thread makes it about freedom of speech.
 
I don't see how we can be derailed, the topic of the thread makes it about freedom of speech.

No, the case cited in the original thread raises interesting questions about whether organizations should be more accepting of diverse views.

However, freedom of speech is about having the right to express your views without fear of state censorship. There was no state censorship in this case.
 
Ok, here is a personal example. As a young man, I studied, worked and lived in Montreal for part of my adult life. Yes, I voted in one of the referendums on separation as is my democratic right in this great country Canada. A few days after the referendum, spray painted on our building were the words "English Go Home". I guess we were lucky there was no lynch mob screaming for the head of our CEO. I guess that is the consequence of exercising our democratic rights. Solely our fault for voting the wrong way in the referendum.
 
I think we've been derailed somewhat by framing this as a debate about freedom of speech.

Freedom of speech is about freedom from state censorship. It doesn't apply to how an employer treats an employee who expresses controversial views.

The real issue, I believe, is intolerance towards unpopular views. Even though Eich's right to freedom of speech remains intact, that doesn't mean he was treated fairly. It's a different discussion.
In what way was his treatment unfair? That his board thought his public advocacy had a harmful impact on their company and said it put his overall business wisdom in serious question and made it difficult for them to deal with him? Isn't that just the sort of thing boards are there to decide? Are they not free to say so? And was he not free to say he believed they could work together, and that the company would weather the storm under his leadership and so he intended to stay, although they could of course dismiss him. Was he not free to decide for himself?

Your point about the real issue being tolerance is well taken; clearly pro-gay rights sympathizers gave him a taste of the intolerance in the business world that Proposition 8 was to the family lives of gay people. Sadly such extremism has been fertilized by the ease with which the internet connects and spreads such ideological cant, often to those who cannot govern either their speech or their acts with any wisdom. We definitely need the XXIC version of Miss GoodyTwoShoes teaching us all the value of considerateness and thoughtful behaviour.

In the free speech realm, for those who still can't let go of that frail reed mistakenly grasped, the way it works is that you and everyone is free to speak as you wish. Even to shout "Fire" in a theatre where there is none, to lie about a public official's computer misdeeds, or their drug-taking, or to show kiddy-porn on your Dundas Square billboard. But there will be consequences afterwards. You'll be punished for the disturbance, or sued for libel for your untruths, and face criminal obscenity charges. What makes speech free, is that we do not censor beforehand (although no law compels the billboard company to rent you space) and there are no governmental prohibitions/penalties except for a few instances of criminally harmful speech.

It's for those on this particular bandwagon to do what they have pointedly not done yet: Tell us not just how the man's freely uttered words somehow improperly, unexpectedly and wrongfully altered his life when all he innocently intended was that they alter the lives of others, and just how such a future 'injustice' would be prevented/prohibited in future. Just whose speech wasn't free? How do we make it free in future? A Human Rights Tribunal?

-----------------
Not that I want to argue the 'merits' of this strawman case but is anyone really saying that the speeches and donation Eich gave were done with private citizen anonymity, and that no one tried to increase their influence and persuasiveness by saying they came from the renowned developer of NetScape and Firefox, the CEO of Mozilla Corp?
 
You guys are all wrong. Especially oldjones.
At least learn California law before you post endless drivel.

To fire someone for their political beliefs is illegal in California. So what I suspect happened was Eich was asked to "quit", he probably received a huge severance package, and the only condition was he kept quiet about his "firing".

See California law: http://market-ticker.org/akcs-www?post=228921

So You Want To Fire Mozilla's CEO Eh?

Recently the CEO of Mozilla (the free software folks that produce, among other things, Firefox) was "fired" because, allegedly, he donated money in 2008 to a political campaign to pass Proposition 8.

That proposition would have banned same-sex marriage; it passed but was struck down by a court.

When this came out into the public eye it was met with immediate loud calls for Eich to be forced out. Various left-wing pundits have pontificated that this is really about promoting a "divisive" man to lead the company; witness what Think Progress said:

The important distinction lost in the conversations since Eich stepped down is that this was a protest about Mozilla more than it was about Eich. The company violated its commitment to openness and inclusion by promoting Eich to be its figurehead, and Eich himself decided that Mozilla’s work could only proceed if he stepped down.

Uh huh.

Here's the problem for the Gay Lobby folks: The very laws that they demanded and got passed to protect gay people from discrimination apply here, and that "resignation", which was quite-clearly coerced, almost-certainly violated California law.

Specifically:

§ 1101. Political activities of employees; prohibition of prevention or control by employer

No employer shall make, adopt, or enforce any rule, regulation, or policy:

(a) Forbidding or preventing employees from engaging or participating in politics or from becoming candidates for public office.

(b) Controlling or directing, or tending to control or direct the political activities or affiliations of employees.

§ 1102. Coercion or influence of political activities of employees

No employer shall coerce or influence or attempt to coerce or influence his employees through or by means of threat of discharge or loss of employment to adopt or follow or refrain from adopting or following any particular course or line of political action or political activity.


Well well.

Donating money to a political cause is, of course, fundamental to political activity. Indeed there is little that one can state is more fundamental than the act of voting itself.

But now the so-called "tolerance groups" are doubling down on their claims. From the same article:

Eich’s resignation represents the increasingly heightened standard for “equality.” For Mozilla’s community, 99 percent equality — the company’s inclusive policies and Eich’s commitment to upholding them — was not enough. He did not apologize for his Prop 8 donation and he refused to say whether he’d give to an anti-gay campaign again in the future.

He has no duty to apologize. Not only that, his political activity is protected speech under California law and he is entitled to engage in it without being penalized in the workplace for doing so, just as it is equally-protected to lobby for or donate to political causes that advocate for same-sex marriage.

That sauce for the goose tastes awful good on the gander.....
 
So now you can predict the future. Nice.

Here's the thing, if he had refused and been fired, he could have sued. Then it would be up for the courts to decide if what happened was wrong or not. Because he chose to leave, we'll never now what the outcome was. He might not have been fired. When I was asked to leave a job and refused, I didn't get fired. In my limited experience (of 1 time, which I think still greatly exceeds the average number of times for most people), you're asked to leave when they know they can't fire you. If they could, they'd just do it.

to be clear, they can fire you for no reason at all. they don't need to document any type of behaviour or give you a reason or have a reason. they can fire you at any time. the only thing to be decided is the extent of damages.
 
you say this...

And there should be lemonade fountains and peppermint trees.

Dream worlds aside, was no retribution in this case, so there's nothing for you to get het up about..

In the real world speech is free. In the real world that free speech will either be ignored or have consequences. No other options. Of course you knew that, and so did Eich. It's why you spoke, because you wanted to be heard, to influence thinking and change opinions. Are you seriously advocating only agreeable speech should be free?

QUOTE]


and this...
If someone had been fired, you'd perhaps have a point.

Please look again at the article you cited to start this thread; it clearly states that Eich stepped down, nowhere does it say he was fired.

..

i am not sure why people are being coy about his resignation. he was forced to resign- which is the same as being fired. it was a constructive firing. i am not sure why those that support the peer pressure which caused this to happen, shy away and pretend he woke up one day and thought "oh i don't like being ceo, I am going to quit". he was forced out because of the mob. some people thinks thats ok and some don't but don't pretend he wasn't fired, or that downloading isn't stealing or that wearing your pants with your underwear showing doesn't mean you are not an idiot.