Does Fuji speak for you?

Does Fuji speak for you?

  • Fuji Speaks for me

    Votes: 16 50.0%
  • Fuji does not speak for me

    Votes: 16 50.0%

  • Total voters
    32
  • Poll closed .
Not sure how quoting Hamas's charter helps your argument when I already laid out why it's ignorant to say that this principle of Hamas is why the Saudi plan was rejected. You need to stick to actual arguments made instead of irrelevant point scoring

The mythical right of ancestral return that is magically supposed to flow down through generations? A right not stated anywhere in any international law, UN resolution, or treaty, and not enjoyed by refugees anywhere else?

The UN Declaration of Human Rights gives everyone a right to return to their own country, the one they have citizenship in. It does not confer citizenship on people who don't already have it.

Palestinians born in Israel have a right to return there, though there is a UN resolution stating they first have to be "willing to live at peace", and so far they have not agreed to peace.

Their foreign born descendants do not have any right of "return".

This is one of the great problems of the peace negotiations. Everybody knows there is no universal right of return, but the PLO has been lying to Palestinians in refugee camps for generations about it.

The Palestinians need new leaders who are willing to be honest that the refugees are not Israeli citizens, except for the few elderly people who were born there.
 
...
The reason I don't denounce "atrocities" committed by Palestinians in the same breath as I denounce Israeli war crimes is because it creates a parallel or dichotomy where there is none.

I agree with that.


...Palestinians are victims....

And this is the flaw in your argument.

Did the Palestinians accept peace in 1948? Have they accepted even the merest concept of peace now? Were the Palestinians attacking Israel before Israel occupied the West Bank?

The Palestinian leadership is as much to blame as anyone else.

Now yes, the Palestinians were victims when their state was stolen from them in 1948 - by Jordan. The Palestinians are victims when they are locked in Lebanese and Jordanian prison camps. They are not victims when they make their conscious choice for war over peace.
 
While obviously killing children in any case is morally unjustifiable, the parents of that child are equally to blame. ...

Are you suggesting that the guys who crept into the house and slit the kids throats don't hold the majority of the blame? The fact that someone could consider themselves at all human while slicing the throat of a sleeping child is repugnant.
 
First off Amy, the Saudi Plan had no mention of a law of return but did have a just solution to the Palestinian refugee problem included in it. The Israelis rejected the initiative not based on that but based on the fact that it cancelled negotiations. As for why I quote the charter of Hamas...because, as the governing body of the Gaza Strip it shows what Israel has to deal with. Also, Fatah's charter is the PLO charter which is more or less the same...calling for the destruction of the state of Israel.
 
Not so. A five year old child, for example, is guilty of nothing whatsoever.

More to the point, the law you are citing makes the POLICY of population transfer Illegal (not "colonization", there is no such crime). The only ones accused are those in government who authorize the policy.

The transferred population itself is not even accused.

You have listened to very biased, partisan sources which gloss over the details of the law in order to justify their own war crimes and atrocities.

The correct legal remedy is compensation for those who have suffered losses. By analogy, the natives in Caledon do not have a right to murder the families of home owners there, even though the homes are built on land subject to a native land claim.

My, my.....looks like we've caught you peddling fiction again. The settlements are illegal according to the ICRC

"The ICRC commentary on the Fourth Geneva Convention makes clear that Article 49 (6), like the convention as a whole, aims to protect the local population in the occupied territory and not the population of the occupying state. Furthermore, international humanitarian law prohibits any action by an occupying power aimed at altering the intrinsic characteristics of the occupied territory, including any measures that affect its demographic, cultural or social composition.

Contrary to what the Levy report maintains, from the viewpoint of international law the West Bank is occupied by Israel. This assertion, like the ICRC's position that the Israeli settlements in the West Bank are unlawful, is based entirely on the relevant provisions of international humanitarian law".[33]"

Hopefully, you won't continue to repeat what you know to be false.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Levy_Report
 
My, my.....looks like we've caught you peddling fiction again. The settlements are illegal according to the ICRC

"The ICRC commentary on the Fourth Geneva Convention makes clear that Article 49 (6), like the convention as a whole, aims to protect the local population in the occupied territory and not the population of the occupying state. Furthermore, international humanitarian law prohibits any action by an occupying power aimed at altering the intrinsic characteristics of the occupied territory, including any measures that affect its demographic, cultural or social composition.

Contrary to what the Levy report maintains, from the viewpoint of international law the West Bank is occupied by Israel. This assertion, like the ICRC's position that the Israeli settlements in the West Bank are unlawful, is based entirely on the relevant provisions of international humanitarian law".[33]"

Hopefully, you won't continue to repeat what you know to be false.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Levy_Report

None of the above is an allegation against the civilian settlers. It is an allegation against the occupying power. Huge difference.
 
None of the above is an allegation against the civilian settlers. It is an allegation against the occupying power. Huge difference.

Wrong again, little man. It says the settlements are illegal. It says the changed demographic is illegal. It says the change social composition is illegal. It says the cultural change is illegal. What I did like, was this: "the convention as a whole, aims to protect the local population in the occupied territory and not the population of the occupying state."

None of these protections are extended to the population of the occupying state. That's go to hurt!
 
Settlers are targeted by Palestinian armed groups who, according to Human Rights Watch, say that settlers are a legitimate target because they have forfeited their civilian status by residing in settlements that are illegal under international humanitarian law.[184] Both Human Rights Watch and B'tselem rejected this argument on the basis that the legal status of the settlements has no effect the civilian status of their residents.[184][185] Human Rights Watch said "prohibition against intentional attacks against civilians is absolute".[184] B'tselem said "The settlers constitute a distinctly civilian population, which is entitled to all the protections granted civilians by international law. The Israeli security forces' use of land in the settlements or the membership of some settlers in the Israeli security forces does not affect the status of the other residents living among them, and certainly does not make them proper targets of attack."[185]

Fatal attacks on settlers have included firing of rockets and mortars and drive-by shootings, also targeting infants and children. Violent incidents include the murder of Shalhevet Pass, a ten-month-old baby shot by a Palestinian sniper in Hebron,[186] and the murder of two teenagers on 8 May 2001, whose bodies were hidden in a cave near Tekoa.[187] In the Bat Ayin axe attack, children in Bat Ayin were attacked by a Palestinian wielding an axe and a knife. A 13-year-old boy was killed and another was seriously wounded.[188] Rabbi Meir Hai, a father of seven, was killed in a drive-by shooting.[189][190] In August 2011, 5 members of the same family were killed in their beds. The victims were the father Ehud (Udi) Fogel, the mother Ruth Fogel, and three of their six children—Yoav, 11, Elad, 4, and Hadas, the youngest, a three-month-old infant. According to David Ha'ivri,[191] and as reported by multiple sources[192] the infant was decapitated.[193]

Notice the part where it says they are still civilians and not justifiable targets because they are in settlements?
 
Wrong again, little man. It says the settlements are illegal. It says the changed demographic is illegal. It says the change social composition is illegal. It says the cultural change is illegal. What I did like, was this: "the convention as a whole, aims to protect the local population in the occupied territory and not the population of the occupying state."

None of these protections are extended to the population of the occupying state. That's go to hurt!

None of the above are allegations against the settlers, they are allegations against the government.
 
None of the above are allegations against the settlers, they are allegations against the government.

No, it says the settlements are illegal. It's right there in black and white. And it says that these rights are not extended to the population of the occupying states....you know, the illegal Jewish infiltrators.
 
International law states that they are still civilians and as such are supposed to be afforded the same protections. Miss that part? Oh wait, no you probably saw it, you just don't care.
 
No, it says the settlements are illegal. It's right there in black and white. And it says that these rights are not extended to the population of the occupying states....you know, the illegal Jewish infiltrators.

These are allegations against the government.

Settlers are civilians who are protected btw the Geneva Conventions against armed attack, regardless of the status of the settlement policy.
 
These are allegations against the government.

Settlers are civilians who are protected btw the Geneva Conventions against armed attack, regardless of the status of the settlement policy.

Changing your story again? First you said it was just the transfer that was illegal. But oops, you were caught lying about that. Now you've been forced to admit that the settlements are illegal as well...and that means settlers. That's why it says that these rights are not extended to the population of the occupying states....you know, the illegal Jewish infiltrators.
 
Do your research. Some of the settlements are considered illegal while many others are not. More importantly, the 4th geneva convention affords the protection of all civilians, wether or not they are in settlements, legal or illegal.
 
Changing your story again? First you said it was just the transfer that was illegal. But oops, you were caught lying about that. Now you've been forced to admit that the settlements are illegal as well...and that means settlers. That's why it says that these rights are not extended to the population of the occupying states....you know, the illegal Jewish infiltrators.

The settlements and the settlers are not illegal. There are allegations against the government that the policy of transfer is illegal.

In any case, this is all irrelevant to the present discussion: armed attacks on non combatant civilians are always illegal, even if you think the civilians have broken some law.
 
The settlements and the settlers are not illegal. There are allegations against the government that the policy of transfer is illegal.

In any case, this is all irrelevant to the present discussion: armed attacks on non combatant civilians are always illegal, even if you think the civilians have broken some law.

Sorry but we've got it in black and white. It's been documented. The ICRC has determined that the settlements are illegal. That means the Jewish infiltrators are there illegally.
 
Sorry but we've got it in black and white. It's been documented. The ICRC has determined that the settlements are illegal. That means the Jewish infiltrators are there illegally.

What you have in black and white is that the policy of population transfer is illegal. You have been trying to stretch that into a justification for attacks on innocent civilians ever since. You are fucked up.
 
What you have in black and white is that the policy of population transfer is illegal. You have been trying to stretch that into a justification for attacks on innocent civilians ever since. You are fucked up.

You must learn to read:

"The ICRC commentary on the Fourth Geneva Convention makes clear that Article 49 (6), like the convention as a whole, aims to protect the local population in the occupied territory and not the population of the occupying state. Furthermore, international humanitarian law prohibits any action by an occupying power aimed at altering the intrinsic characteristics of the occupied territory, including any measures that affect its demographic, cultural or social composition.

Contrary to what the Levy report maintains, from the viewpoint of international law the West Bank is occupied by Israel. This assertion, like the ICRC's position that the Israeli settlements in the West Bank are unlawful, is based entirely on the relevant provisions of international humanitarian law".[33]"

Hopefully, you won't continue to repeat what you know to be false.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Levy_Repor
 
And you keep missing the point of wether settlements are legal or illegal, it cannot be used as justification for killing the civilians of those settlements. How thick is your head?