Hey , I am not one to put full blame or conversely give full credit to GM's for their teams record.
For example, Theo Epstein, then Boston's boy wonder made some terrible personal/contract decisions on the way to the Sox winning 2 WS titles (see Edgar Renteria, Julio Lugo, Dice-K, Lackey, Jenks, Becket contract extension)... BUT due to some great decisions (rebuilding the farm system was one). and new ownerships commitment to building a winner they made it to the top.
Was Theo perfect? Of course not, but they did achieve results. And continue to do so after he left. The legacy of the draft and develop strategy has led the Red Sox having many integral pieces who are home grown like Lester, Buchholz, Pedroia and the now departed Ellsbury. In the last few years, it is hard to find a Jays farmhand who is making a significant difference here or on another team thru a trade.
According to many/most Jays fans I know, the GM here is one of the best in the league. Results have not borne this out based on simple facts not my opinion.