Are Baseball Players Soft?

Gee, no elbow pads, no kidney pads, no forearm, no shoulder pads, no neck collars, no thigh pads, no spats, no flack jackets, and no knee braces. Yup, not even close.

Shin and knee guards, chest protector, neck protector and helmet, that should be enough for their position. They don't need shoulder and elbow pads (Gordie Howe) because they don't have to hit anybody.
 
Freedom_Summary.jpg


Apparently, these chairs will be installed in MLB dugouts in 2014 and relief pitchers will be driven to the pitching mound in golf carts.
 
Very funny/coincidental. I'm waiting for my SP with the Pats/Pit game on and they mentioned that one of the players was out with a thumb injury and would not return. Go figure.
 
Very funny/coincidental. I'm waiting for my SP with the Pats/Pit game on and they mentioned that one of the players was out with a thumb injury and would not return. Go figure.

Soft as cotton.
 
Shin and knee guards, chest protector, neck protector and helmet, that should be enough for their position.
Granted it may be enough, but your original assertion that "the catcher wears as much protection or more than...", was hugely inaccurate. That statement was incorrect. Man up.
 
He will play because he can still fulfill his duties and help his team, i.e. he can tackle (with his arms, hardly ever hands and block (arms and body--not hands as that is holding). A ballplayer with a broken thumb cannot hit. He cannot properly grip the bat with the splints/casts that are required for his treatment. He cannot fulfill his duties and is a liability to his team.

You don't seem to be able (more likely you are unwilling) to grasp this simple concept. Can a baseball player with a splint or cast properly grip a bat, even with zero pain?

I get that you are trying to minimize the inherent softness in baseball players by attempting to distinguish the difference between playing with an injury and the inability to compete because of that injury
It does not wash

Any injury will inhibit ones ability to compete at his highest level.
The toughness comes in play when an athlete wills himself to play through the pain and still compete.
A regular occurrence in the NBA, NFL and NHL. Not so much in MLB

Time for a reality check here.
How long would Dustin Padora last in an NFL, NHL or NBA game?
Padroa is one of baseballs best athletes and is often referred to as very durable and tough.
(He is also highly entertaining to watch)
In any of those other leagues he would become road pizza and quickly
 
I get that you are trying to minimize the inherent softness in baseball players by attempting to distinguish the difference between playing with an injury and the inability to compete because of that injury
It does not wash

Any injury will inhibit ones ability to compete at his highest level.
The toughness comes in play when an athlete wills himself to play through the pain and still compete.

A regular occurrence in the NBA, NFL and NHL. Not so much in MLB

Time for a reality check here.

This. Simple concept to grasp.
 
Time for a reality check here.
How long would Dustin Padora last in an NFL, NHL or NBA game?
Padroa is one of baseballs best athletes and is often referred to as very durable and tough.
(He is also highly entertaining to watch)
In any of those other leagues he would become road pizza and quickly

Well in the NFL he would probably based on his size be a place kicker. So he would most likely have a long career.

The NHL had smaller players that also had long and distinguished careers as well. Theo Fleury, Mats Naslund and Booby Lalonde come to mind. And presently Martin St.Louis is still a top notch player who has never resembled a pizza to my recollection.
 
The toughness comes in play when an athlete wills himself to play through the pain and still compete.
So you are saying that a baseball player with a cast on his hand for a broken thumb can can hit just fine if he wills himself to. Is that correct?
 
So you are saying that a baseball player with a cast on his hand for a broken thumb can can hit just fine if he wills himself to. Is that correct?

Now you are being deliberately obtuse. You know that's not what he means. The vast majority of baseball players sit out voluntarily due to simple soreness or some nagging minor injuries rather than play through the pain. This is why they are considered 'Soft' in comparison to other pro athletes in competing sports like Football, Basketball and Hockey. Those players consistently play through significant injuries, often for entire seasons before using off season for surgery.

Obviously if a ball player is wearing a cast on his thrumb, he ain't going to play a game that requires basic use of both hands. That's like saying a running back in football would play while wearing a full leg cast if he was really tough.
 
Bobby Baun !
 
I get that you are trying to minimize the inherent softness in baseball players by attempting to distinguish the difference between playing with an injury and the inability to compete because of that injury
It does not wash

Any injury will inhibit ones ability to compete at his highest level.
The toughness comes in play when an athlete wills himself to play through the pain and still compete.
A regular occurrence in the NBA, NFL and NHL. Not so much in MLB

Time for a reality check here.
How long would Dustin Padora last in an NFL, NHL or NBA game?
Padroa is one of baseballs best athletes and is often referred to as very durable and tough.
(He is also highly entertaining to watch)
In any of those other leagues he would become road pizza and quickly

What an asinine example
First of all its Dustin Pedoria. If you're using him as an example, it helps your credibility if you can spell his name right
Secondly, dude is like 5'7 tall. Pretty sure, no matter how tough he is, he would never play in the NBA or the NFL. Maybe in the NHL, if you know, he could skate.
Whether he could play in other leagues has absolutely nothing to do with his 'toughness' or 'softness'
 
What an asinine example
First of all its Dustin Pedoria. If you're using him as an example, it helps your credibility if you can spell his name right
Secondly, dude is like 5'7 tall. Pretty sure, no matter how tough he is, he would never play in the NBA or the NFL. Maybe in the NHL, if you know, he could skate.
Whether he could play in other leagues has absolutely nothing to do with his 'toughness' or 'softness'

Careful there, mur11, you might be opening up a Padora's Box criticizing LashLarue's spelling. :D
 
What an asinine example
First of all its Dustin Pedoria. If you're using him as an example, it helps your credibility if you can spell his name right
Secondly, dude is like 5'7 tall. Pretty sure, no matter how tough he is, he would never play in the NBA or the NFL. Maybe in the NHL, if you know, he could skate.
Whether he could play in other leagues has absolutely nothing to do with his 'toughness' or 'softness'

Actually, it's Dustin P-E-D-R-O-I-A.