excuses, excuses excuses
A hockey player will not allow blisters to prevent him from playing
Basketball players have worn a face masks and played with a broken nose
Football players will tape up injuries and still trot out onto the field
All of these sports require finesse and the ability to apply precision to a shot or throw. Yet baseball stands alone in excusing their players from participating for minor injuries
Feel free to read my post again. I explained it and it should be easy to understand. A blister will never affect a hockey player's performance. A well placed blister will make the toughest pitcher next to useless.
I would grant catchers are generally tougher than the rest of the baseball world, however that position is no where near as physically demanding as a NHL goalie or a NFL lineman's job
I accept those other sports are more physically demanding. As I said before, the nature of baseball is that it is not as physical as some other sports. It does not necessarily mean that somebody playing catcher could not display the toughness required to play those other sports, given the chance. Another point that cannot be proven for either of our positions.
I read this three time and still do not understand what you are trying to communicate
It sounds like your are saying "Catchers are tough therefore all baseball players are tough"
That is not a logical conclusion
I agree, it is not logical but it is not what I am saying. I am saying that, as you've accepted, catchers in general display toughness, it stands to reason that there must be other (not all) players who are just as tough, but because their positions are not as physically demanding, we do not get to see that toughness. Another illogical conclusion is that catchers are the
only baseball players that are tough. My point is that even though there admittedly are soft ball players, there are far more of them that have toughness. It is just not easy for us to see on full display. Some guy may be a genius but works a menial job that does not allow others to see his genius. Just because we don't see a ballplayer displaying toughness, it does not mean he isn't. He just doesn't have to show it on a consistent basis because baseball, aside from catching, is not that kind of sport.
Why ? Because you say so?
A blister will hurt a basketball player just as much as a baseball player and it will impact both of them when it comes down to throwing a ball
Disagree. A basketball player does not have to grip a ball in a precise way, with tension, dealing with finger position and protruding seams, and then having to precisely apply spin at a specific release point and at over 90 MPH. And the blister has been produced by repeating those manipulations which he now has to aggravate by repeating again. They may hurt the same sometimes, but not when they keep repeating the thing that caused the blister in the first place and is the pitcher's only function. Sorry if you don't understand the difference.
As far as me "saying so", I think I have produced many more concrete examples to support my position than you. Looking back on your posts, very few have been substantiated aside from you "saying so". You say "no ball player could play a month in the NBA or NFL" but when given examples of that being wrong you poo poo it and only repeat that ball players are soft because you say so. When I given solid reasons why identical injuries affect a ball player more severely and attempting to play through it will hurt his team (regardless of his toughness level) you dismiss it out of hand and just repeat your mantra that they should be able to play through. No substantiation. Only your opinion.
Are you saying that if an offensive lineman can play just as effectively with a broken thumb that a baseball player with a broken thumb should be able to still be an effective hitter? If you say the answer is "yes" then I severely have to question your judgement. If you say "no" to my question then you have accepted that injuries will, in many cases be more debilitating to a ball player regardless of their toughness/softness. I would greatly appreciate a response to the bolded question.