Are Baseball Players Soft?

Or you could simply have said, oops typo, my bad, and moved on.
He could have, but I agree with him that pointing out spelling (a la Petzel) does nothing to advance an opinion of a topic at hand.

Personally, I am shocked and dismayed at the lack of spelling and grammatical skills on the board, but they prove nothing more than the failure of our increasingly lax educational system.
 
He could have, but I agree with him that pointing out spelling (a la Petzel) does nothing to advance an opinion of a topic at hand.

Personally, I am shocked and dismayed at the lack of spelling and grammatical skills on the board, but they prove nothing more than the failure of our increasingly lax educational system.

Sometimes the spellcheck monster attacks and it slips by, not a big thing, just ask for clarification.
 
Or he could have ignored it , moved on and added something of value to the post
Guys who point out useless shit like typos, adding in insulting remarks are trolls who often do have a sound logical response and deserve everything they get and more

...but aren't you the bigger/better man?
 
Personally, I am shocked and dismayed at the lack of spelling and grammatical skills on the board, but they prove nothing more than the failure of our increasingly lax educational system.

Yup. There's that bitter old man thing again. When will you be moving to Florida to sit on your wrinkled ass and complain about the government full-time grandpa tight ass? Let me guess - in your day, every student was a spelling bee champ and damn proud of their grammatical achievements....:rolleyes:

...and for all your whiny analogies in this thread, you STILL have done nothing to discount the widely held assertion that baseball players are soft in comparison to other major sports athletes. Sad, but true. Just accept it.

http://espn.go.com/blog/sweetspot/post/_/id/12054/are-baseball-players-soft
 
excuses, excuses excuses
A hockey player will not allow blisters to prevent him from playing
Basketball players have worn a face masks and played with a broken nose
Football players will tape up injuries and still trot out onto the field
All of these sports require finesse and the ability to apply precision to a shot or throw. Yet baseball stands alone in excusing their players from participating for minor injuries
Feel free to read my post again. I explained it and it should be easy to understand. A blister will never affect a hockey player's performance. A well placed blister will make the toughest pitcher next to useless.

I would grant catchers are generally tougher than the rest of the baseball world, however that position is no where near as physically demanding as a NHL goalie or a NFL lineman's job
I accept those other sports are more physically demanding. As I said before, the nature of baseball is that it is not as physical as some other sports. It does not necessarily mean that somebody playing catcher could not display the toughness required to play those other sports, given the chance. Another point that cannot be proven for either of our positions.


I read this three time and still do not understand what you are trying to communicate
It sounds like your are saying "Catchers are tough therefore all baseball players are tough"
That is not a logical conclusion
I agree, it is not logical but it is not what I am saying. I am saying that, as you've accepted, catchers in general display toughness, it stands to reason that there must be other (not all) players who are just as tough, but because their positions are not as physically demanding, we do not get to see that toughness. Another illogical conclusion is that catchers are the only baseball players that are tough. My point is that even though there admittedly are soft ball players, there are far more of them that have toughness. It is just not easy for us to see on full display. Some guy may be a genius but works a menial job that does not allow others to see his genius. Just because we don't see a ballplayer displaying toughness, it does not mean he isn't. He just doesn't have to show it on a consistent basis because baseball, aside from catching, is not that kind of sport.

Why ? Because you say so?
A blister will hurt a basketball player just as much as a baseball player and it will impact both of them when it comes down to throwing a ball
Disagree. A basketball player does not have to grip a ball in a precise way, with tension, dealing with finger position and protruding seams, and then having to precisely apply spin at a specific release point and at over 90 MPH. And the blister has been produced by repeating those manipulations which he now has to aggravate by repeating again. They may hurt the same sometimes, but not when they keep repeating the thing that caused the blister in the first place and is the pitcher's only function. Sorry if you don't understand the difference.

As far as me "saying so", I think I have produced many more concrete examples to support my position than you. Looking back on your posts, very few have been substantiated aside from you "saying so". You say "no ball player could play a month in the NBA or NFL" but when given examples of that being wrong you poo poo it and only repeat that ball players are soft because you say so. When I given solid reasons why identical injuries affect a ball player more severely and attempting to play through it will hurt his team (regardless of his toughness level) you dismiss it out of hand and just repeat your mantra that they should be able to play through. No substantiation. Only your opinion. Are you saying that if an offensive lineman can play just as effectively with a broken thumb that a baseball player with a broken thumb should be able to still be an effective hitter? If you say the answer is "yes" then I severely have to question your judgement. If you say "no" to my question then you have accepted that injuries will, in many cases be more debilitating to a ball player regardless of their toughness/softness. I would greatly appreciate a response to the bolded question.
 
Or he could have ignored it , moved on and added something of value to the post
Guys who point out useless shit like typos, adding in insulting remarks are trolls who often do have a sound logical response and deserve everything they get and more

Bring it on, or are you not done with your temper tantrum just yet?
 
Yup. There's that bitter old man thing again. When will you be moving to Florida to sit on your wrinkled ass and complain about the government full-time grandpa tight ass? Let me guess - in your day, every student was a spelling bee champ and damn proud of their grammatical achievements....:rolleyes:

...and for all your whiny analogies in this thread, you STILL have done nothing to discount the widely held assertion that baseball players are soft in comparison to other major sports athletes. Sad, but true. Just accept it.
As I see. No substance. Just insults. Let me know when you have something to add to the discussion at hand. I've posted lots of substantive examples to support my position, You? Nothing other than, they are soft, they are soft, they are soft.
 
Yup. There's that bitter old man thing again. When will you be moving to Florida to sit on your wrinkled ass and complain about the government full-time grandpa tight ass? Let me guess - in your day, every student was a spelling bee champ and damn proud of their grammatical achievements....:rolleyes:

...and for all your whiny analogies in this thread, you STILL have done nothing to discount the widely held assertion that baseball players are soft in comparison to other major sports athletes. Sad, but true. Just accept it.

http://espn.go.com/blog/sweetspot/post/_/id/12054/are-baseball-players-soft

You do know that link was posted waaaaaaaay back in post#8, right?
 
Yup. There's that bitter old man thing again. When will you be moving to Florida to sit on your wrinkled ass and complain about the government full-time grandpa tight ass? Let me guess - in your day, every student was a spelling bee champ and damn proud of their grammatical achievements....:rolleyes:
BTW, why did you leave out the part where I agreed that pointing out grammar etc. did nothing to advance the discussion.

I guess you just see what you want to see.

As well, I didn't mention you. It was a comment on the educational system but you sure took it to heart.:Cry::confused:
 

I think Kirk Gibson was tough. It should be noted that Gibson was also a football player in university.

This is really a stupid argument because compared to yesteryear almost all of today's athletes are soft. Look at the number of rounds a Jack Johnson fight was. Even 30 years ago there were 15 round fights. How does anyone think today's NHLers or MLB players would respond to taking a train for all travel instead of a chartered private jet? The influx of Europeans(soccer mentality) into the NHL and especially the NBA has increased the amount of "soft" athletes.
 
This is really a stupid argument because compared to yesteryear almost all of today's athletes are soft. Look at the number of rounds a Jack Johnson fight was. Even 30 years ago there were 15 round fights. How does anyone think today's NHLers or MLB players would respond to taking a train for all travel instead of a chartered private jet? The influx of Europeans(soccer mentality) into the NHL and especially the NBA has increased the amount of "soft" athletes.
Good point. A hockey player got his bell rung and he was back out there for his next shift. Now they stay out for weeks or longer.
 

This is tough

Side note Jesse sure had a cannon of an arm in right field

Also nice effort by Gorman Thomas
 
Baseball is played on grass or man made turf. In open air stadiums or in domes where they can continue playing regardless of weather conditions.
There are nine men on defense scattered through out the field of play.
The pitcher can throw the ball with incredible accuracy. Some do throw a lot harder(faster) then others who may have more finesse.
Catchers receive the ball thrown by the pitcher. They are also required to occasionally block the plate which may result in a collision at the plate area.

Offense is when the other team comes to bat.
One player comes to bat at a time. There may be one, two or three teammates 'on base' when he is at bat which could result in anywhere from one to four runs being scored on a base hit.



Now I think I demonstrated that I know something about baseball players.

They are soft !


P.S.
Now ... where is Frank Thomas right now ? I have something to tell him face to face.
 
Feel free to read my post again. I explained it and it should be easy to understand. A blister will never affect a hockey player's performance. A well placed blister will make the toughest pitcher next to useless.

Oh come on now, a blister in leather hockey gloves will not affect a player ability to roof daddy that puck into the top corner in a split second?
A blister on the catching hand of a goalie will not sting like a bastard when he snares a 100+ mph slap shot?

Sure it will
You just do not hear them whining about it or taking a game off because of it
Why?
The culture of hockey demands they be TOUGHER than that and suck it up buttercup
The culture in baseball dictates they go on the DL



I accept those other sports are more physically demanding. As I said before, the nature of baseball is that it is not as physical as some other sports. It does not necessarily mean that somebody playing catcher could not display the toughness required to play those other sports, given the chance. Another point that cannot be proven for either of our positions.

Since it can not be proven , then it is not relevant to either argument. i.e. moot point that is just confusing the issue



I agree, it is not logical but it is not what I am saying. I am saying that, as you've accepted, catchers in general display toughness, it stands to reason that there must be other (not all) players who are just as tough, but because their positions are not as physically demanding, we do not get to see that toughness.

What I have accepted is catchers are tougher than other baseball players.
I have not stated that catchers in general display toughness.
Please be far more exacting if you are going to infer I have agreed to anything

If we do not get to see that toughness, then it impossible to state with 100% certainty that it exists for those player who do not display it (ie pitchers s on the DL with hang nails)

Disagree. A basketball player does not have to grip a ball in a precise way, with tension, dealing with finger position and protruding seams, and then having to precisely apply spin at a specific release point and at over 90 MPH. And the blister has been produced by repeating those manipulations which he now has to aggravate by repeating again. They may hurt the same sometimes, but not when they keep repeating the thing that caused the blister in the first place and is the pitcher's only function. Sorry if you don't understand the difference.

Perhaps basketball is not your game, however the mechanics of shooting to swish a hoop are very precise, yet basketball player adjust as need be
I doubt a MLB pitcher could adjust his mechanics enough to compensate for the pounding they would take after a determined and charging LeBron ruins over them on the way to the basket or after an elbow to head from Kevin Garnett

. Are you saying that if an offensive lineman can play just as effectively with a broken thumb that a baseball player with a broken thumb should be able to still be an effective hitter? I would greatly appreciate a response to the bolded question.[/QUOTE]

No what I am saying is the lineman will play with a broken thumb, the softer more delicate baseball player goes on the DL (I am sure there is an exception and some MLB player has played with a broken thumb)
 
Our paths will cross again & you just might regret pointing out typos because you are at loss for some relevant and intelligent arguments

That sound cyber-ominous*.







*I made up that word, no criticism allowed of the spelling.
 

This is tough
We remember the Martinez (and the Fosse) collisions simply because they happen so rarely (maybe a few times a decade). Contrast that with the collisions in football and hockey each game.

Querty: Why are some guys on this thread having a pissing match over typos?
 
No what I am saying is the lineman will play with a broken thumb, the softer more delicate baseball player goes on the DL (I am sure there is an exception and some MLB player has played with a broken thumb)
He will play because he can still fulfill his duties and help his team, i.e. he can tackle (with his arms, hardly ever hands and block (arms and body--not hands as that is holding). A ballplayer with a broken thumb cannot hit. He cannot properly grip the bat with the splints/casts that are required for his treatment. He cannot fulfill his duties and is a liability to his team.

You don't seem to be able (more likely you are unwilling) to grasp this simple concept. Can a baseball player with a splint or cast properly grip a bat, even with zero pain?
 
We remember the Martinez (and the Fosse) collisions simply because they happen so rarely (maybe a few times a decade). Contrast that with the collisions in football and hockey each game.

Querty: Why are some guys on this thread having a pissing match over typos?

Football players are more heavily padded than baseball player as are hockey players, basically in armour protecting the tender bits. That mitigates many of the results of the collisions. Try rugby some day. Up until recently no padding save for the cup.
 
Football players are more heavily padded than baseball player as are hockey players, basically in armour protecting the tender bits.
However, I think the catcher in baseball wears as much protection or more than a football or hockey player. Interesting that it was the catcher, with all his protective gear, that got hurt in the Martinez and Fosse collisions, perhaps because they were basically stationery whereas Pete Rose had a full head of steam.

Query: Is it true that ballet dancers are complaining about dancing on hard floors because hard floors are hard on their legs and feet? Apparently, they will be asking for natural grass floors in their next contract. Just kidding!