Is this an appropriate wedding gift?

... not to give a gift, they noticed and at some point in time, they called you a cheap cunt and snickered.

Well she probably did, unless you are whipped then you would have to agree and support her (I know a few guys who unfortunately wear those shoes...)

Most guys wouldn't give a rats ass if you even gave a gift and chances are have no idea who gave them what.
 
I don't make the rules folks. So don't shoot the messenger.

If you get invited to a wedding, (and I will qualify that as saying - a wedding involving a person with whom you have some sort of relationship with) proper etiquette says you give a gift whether you attend said wedding or not. Note, the amount of the gift is not specified, so I would assume that the individual giving the gift should be able to determine what is and what is not an appropriate gift.

As previously stated, a wedding gift is a gift to celebrate the marriage of two people. It is not an exchange for a free dinner and all the booze you can guzzle (though some mouth breathers in this thread seem to think that it is).
Most empatically, no.

If you are invited but decline the invitation, you are welcome to send a gift, but you are most certainly under no OBLIGATION to do so.

Just as the Happy Couple were under no obligation to send you the invitation in the first place.

Even if you attend, you are expected to bring a gift, but you are not obligated to do so. To be clear, the expectation of a gift is much greater if you attend than if you do not, but it would be the height of disrespect to their guests for the celebrants to put a price on your attendance: the invitation is for you to celebrate with them, nothing more.

Anyone who expects their guests to pay for their wedding are nothing but boors.
 
Most empatically, no.

If you are invited but decline the invitation, you are welcome to send a gift, but you are most certainly under no OBLIGATION to do so.

Just as the Happy Couple were under no obligation to send you the invitation in the first place.

Even if you attend, you are expected to bring a gift, but you are not obligated to do so. To be clear, the expectation of a gift is much greater if you attend than if you do not, but it would be the height of disrespect to their guests for the celebrants to put a price on your attendance: the invitation is for you to celebrate with them, nothing more.

Anyone who expects their guests to pay for their wedding are nothing but boors.

Ok, perhaps obligated is the wrong word.

"Expected" works though.

Doesn't change the rule though.

And anyone who shows up at a wedding without a gift (unless they are broke, or the wedding is "no gifts please") is joke material.
 
In this example, since I've known the guy for 20 years and see him regularly still, I would buy him a gift even if I couldn't make his wedding

I doubt he would expect me to, but I would anyway

Exactly.

But although your male friend might not expect you to give a gift, I'm sure he would notice if you did not.

Much better for your male friend to think, "mur11 is solid. He couldn't make my wedding, but he still sent a gift. Good guy"
 
I think it's fairly absurd that if you're invited to a wedding, you have to give a gift
Especially if it's a casual friend or co-worker. Not all people invited to a wedding, especially if it's a large wedding, know the bride and groom very well. Heck, sometimes they don't know the bride or groom at all. They're invited simply because of workplace politics, or to fill out the venue. So if I get an invite to a wedding of people I barely know, and I RSVP no, on time, I still have to buy them a gift? That's just stupid.
I would say if you RSVP yes, and then don't show up, for whatever reason, you should buy a gift and make sure it gets delivered to the happy couple. That's fair since they (or their famliies) paid for the food that you would have had as well as other costs.
But to pay simply because you were invited to a wedding, is idiotic. I can see if you are truly close friends or family with the couple and can't make the wedding, then it's a classy gesture to buy them a gift. Hell, it's a classy move anyway. But to be obligated to buy a gift, or to say it's a breach of etiquette to buy a gift, regardless of attending the wedding or your RSVP status? Hell no

If you do attend I see the logic in expecting to cover the cost of your plate with cash or an equivalent value gift. If you don't like paying that you ought to decline the invite.

The notion you need to send a gift even if you decline is what seems off to me. Sure if it is genuine family or friend but not randoms from work or whatever.
 
Here is the link to the original story in The Hamilton Spectator on June 19, :http://www.thespec.com/news-story/3...ass-wedding-gift-spat-spirals-out-of-control/ Frankly one of the things that astonished me about this story was the cost of the meal ($100 per person) according to one of the "brides" who texted the gift givers. I don't know what was served at this wedding but you can get a hell of a meal for $100 a person even if you're going to an expensive restaurant. Who the hell has a wedding where it tops out at $100 (or more) per plate? That's just crazy!
 
Here is the link to the original story in The Hamilton Spectator on June 19, :http://www.thespec.com/news-story/3...ass-wedding-gift-spat-spirals-out-of-control/ Frankly one of the things that astonished me about this story was the cost of the meal ($100 per person) according to one of the "brides" who texted the gift givers. I don't know what was served at this wedding but you can get a hell of a meal for $100 a person even if you're going to an expensive restaurant. Who the hell has a wedding where it tops out at $100 (or more) per plate? That's just crazy!

I can tell you don't go to too many expensive restaurants.

Good luck getting out for a buck a person in an "expensive restaurant"
 
they may have added other costs in the $100 a person amount. who knows. weddings are generally expensive that is for sure.

regardless of where we each land on the whole 'obligated to give a gift' issue I think we can all agree that is was very poor taste to complain about the gift and act like the purpose of inviting guests is to cover the costs of the event.
 
they may have added other costs in the $100 a person amount. who knows. weddings are generally expensive that is for sure.

regardless of where we each land on the whole 'obligated to give a gift' issue I think we can all agree that is was very poor taste to complain about the gift and act like the purpose of inviting guests is to cover the costs of the event.

I agree with this.
 
This why I hate weddings nowadays. This expectation that you will cover the plate with a financial gift is becoming more and more common. I've been invited to 3 weddings in the past 2 years by people I don't even know all that well. I didn't go to any of them, just made some crappy excuse that they probably didn't believe lol. My friend went to one of them and it ended up costing him about $400 with the gift and cost of hotel, plus he had to take the afternoon off work.

Agreed. You could always rsvp regrets.
 
The amount the couple spent on the wedding has absolutely ZERO impact on the value of the gift I give (and how would I know what they spent anyway until I'm at the wedding or after the fact?). My relationship to the married couple determines that.