Is this an appropriate wedding gift?

No, exactly wrong.

I know you can't get your head around what I've just told you. (I can tell that up until this moment in your life, you had no idea. (So you learned something today!!)) You think that because you have chosen NOT to attend the wedding that you are off the hook for buying a wedding gift, but this is simply not the case.

Sorry, as I said, this is common courtesy.

And the example of inviting the entire city of Mississauga is absurd.

Do you know them?

Yes.

Did they invite you to their wedding?

Yes.

Then you get them a gift whether you attend their wedding or not.

No-one is forcing you to do anything. If you choose not to buy them a gift, that is your choice, but proper decorum is that you buy them a gift.

If it was me getting married and you were my "friend" and I invited you to my wedding and you chose not to attend and did not send a gift, I wouldn't say anything to you, but I sure as hell would take note of your cheapskate behaviour and it would forever be in my memory that you are cheap.


one - i have heard this nonsense before. and myself and Ms manners who is an expert on etitquette disagree with you. so all i have learned today is that you don't read my posts.

and two - just because you know someone doesn't obligate you to buy them a gift. you might feel compelled to do so- thats your choice. its not proper etiquette- you are doing it because you are afraid to be called cheap.
 
yes but not all etiquette people agree with you. so the rules are not so clear cut as you think.

you also are making an assumption about the relationship. I get lots of invites from business acquaintances and staff- we are not close and they just sent me the invitation because i have lots of money. a gift is just that - a gift- it can never be an obligation or a duty.

No, it's very clear.

Miss Manners is wrong.

I don't know how much money you have, or don't have. But I can tell that you had no idea of the proper accepted procedure for wedding invites until this very moment.

I'm not going to get into how much money I have, or my net worth vs. yours, but I will say that I've been invited to many weddings over my lifetime and I've always sent a gift whether I've attended or not. And I can honestly say, I've never been invited to a wedding of someone I didn't know.

But I've known the gift rule since I was about 18 when my mother explained it to me.

Up until today, you had no clue.

Trust me, if a couple invited you to their wedding and you know them, and you chose not to go and not to give a gift, they noticed and at some point in time, they called you a cheap cunt and snickered.
 
The correct response from the givers would have been "Gosh we are disappointed that our newlywed friends didn't appreciate our gift, but are more concerned that they seem to have thrown it out without first removing the $1000 cheque we included in the basket."
 
No, it's very clear.

The example of Miss Manners was a case where the person did not even like the bridge.

I don't know how much money you have, or don't have. But I can tell that you had no idea of the proper accepted procedure for wedding invites until this very moment.

I'm not going to get into how much money I have, or my net worth vs. yours, but I will say that I've been invited to many weddings over my lifetime and I've always sent a gift whether I've attended or not. And I can honestly say, I've never been invited to a wedding of someone I didn't know.

But I've known the gift rule since I was about 18 when my mother explained it to me.


good for you and your mom. but that doesn't make you right.

i am glad to hear you have never been invited to a wedding of people you don't know- i have- probably five or six a year. i have no obligation to give a wedding gift for a wedding i do not attend. especially true if the person is not close to me
 
well Ms Manners and I disagree.


since this is terb, I will be exagerate in a wild fashion

so if hitler and eva sent you an invitation and you couldn't attend because you were at dachau- you would send a gift?
Would a pair of table lamps be appropriate?
 
The aforementioned gift is more for an engagement party if you ask me. People are very greedy these days when it comes to receiving gifts on the other hand and its shameful IMO.
 
You do realize that even if you don't go to the wedding you are obligated to give a gift.

The article says "casual acquaintance". So, the guests were neither friend nor family, but for some odd reason they were invited. Some people do invite everyone they can think of to their weddings, sometimes ridiculously large numbers of people, but if you invite randoms to your wedding, don't be surprised if some of the randoms declines and sends no gift.

I agree that certainly if you attend, bring a gift, even if you are just a casual acquaintance.

But if some "casual acquaintance" of mine invited me to a wedding, a friend of a friend, or some work contact I don't really know very well--and I didn't care enough about them to want to bother going, I wouldn't send a gift either, and if they didn't like that, I wouldn't care, because after all, they aren't anyone to me.

Certainly if a friend or relative invited me to a wedding and circumstances conspired to prevent me from attending, I would send a nice gift along with my apology for not being able to be there, but in that case I would have WANTED to be there, but for some reason, couldn't make it. (Or at least I'd pretend I wanted to be there.)
 
Brides: “Weddings are to make money for your future … not to pay for peoples meals. Do more research. People haven’t gave gifts since like 50 years ago! You ate steak, chicken, booze, and a beautiful venue.”

Wonder what she thinks husbands are for. :Eek:
 
Brides: “Weddings are to make money for your future … not to pay for peoples meals. Do more research. People haven’t gave gifts since like 50 years ago! You ate steak, chicken, booze, and a beautiful venue.”

Wonder what she thinks husbands are for. :Eek:

She wouldn't know what husbands are for. It was a lesbian wedding. :)

Also, I wonder how the beautiful venue tasted... NOM NOM NOM... :D
 
It's called Etiquette.

If you are invited to a wedding you are supposed to give a gift whether you choose to go or not.

In the past, I have always attended friends and relatives weddings when invited and given the appropriate gift of cash (only). On the couple of occasions when I could not make it, I gave a gift of the same amount as if I had attended the wedding. I can't say I've ever been invited to a wedding where I didn't really know the person.


while normally I would be all for bringing etiquette back I think that it is rather bold to think that you can speak for all matters relating to the subject. obviously some experts disagree with you - so you might want to soften the tune there capt. manners.

p.s. my definition of an obligation is way different from yours.
 
Dear Abby,
I have 2 weddings I've been invited to this summer: 1 is a longtime friend and the other a distant relative. I intend to attend the first wedding but not the second. Gift advice? :D
 
I think it's fairly absurd that if you're invited to a wedding, you have to give a gift
Especially if it's a casual friend or co-worker. Not all people invited to a wedding, especially if it's a large wedding, know the bride and groom very well. Heck, sometimes they don't know the bride or groom at all. They're invited simply because of workplace politics, or to fill out the venue. So if I get an invite to a wedding of people I barely know, and I RSVP no, on time, I still have to buy them a gift? That's just stupid.
I would say if you RSVP yes, and then don't show up, for whatever reason, you should buy a gift and make sure it gets delivered to the happy couple. That's fair since they (or their famliies) paid for the food that you would have had as well as other costs.
But to pay simply because you were invited to a wedding, is idiotic. I can see if you are truly close friends or family with the couple and can't make the wedding, then it's a classy gesture to buy them a gift. Hell, it's a classy move anyway. But to be obligated to buy a gift, or to say it's a breach of etiquette to buy a gift, regardless of attending the wedding or your RSVP status? Hell no
 
I only attend weddings where 2 people I know wants me to show up w/ or w/o gifts. w/ or w/o a date. People who are genuinely happy of my presence. But of course I give my gifts. If I can afford to shell out $120 for a handjob that has no guarantee of greatness. what's an $80 gift to friends?
 
I don't make the rules folks. So don't shoot the messenger.

If you get invited to a wedding, (and I will qualify that as saying - a wedding involving a person with whom you have some sort of relationship with) proper etiquette says you give a gift whether you attend said wedding or not. Note, the amount of the gift is not specified, so I would assume that the individual giving the gift should be able to determine what is and what is not an appropriate gift.

As previously stated, a wedding gift is a gift to celebrate the marriage of two people. It is not an exchange for a free dinner and all the booze you can guzzle (though some mouth breathers in this thread seem to think that it is).
 
The article says "casual acquaintance". So, the guests were neither friend nor family, but for some odd reason they were invited. Some people do invite everyone they can think of to their weddings, sometimes ridiculously large numbers of people, but if you invite randoms to your wedding, don't be surprised if some of the randoms declines and sends no gift.

I agree that certainly if you attend, bring a gift, even if you are just a casual acquaintance.

But if some "casual acquaintance" of mine invited me to a wedding, a friend of a friend, or some work contact I don't really know very well--and I didn't care enough about them to want to bother going, I wouldn't send a gift either, and if they didn't like that, I wouldn't care, because after all, they aren't anyone to me.

Certainly if a friend or relative invited me to a wedding and circumstances conspired to prevent me from attending, I would send a nice gift along with my apology for not being able to be there, but in that case I would have WANTED to be there, but for some reason, couldn't make it. (Or at least I'd pretend I wanted to be there.)

I'm not disagreeing with you, however, I can honestly say that I've never been invited to a wedding of just a casual acquaintance. Generally speaking people don't do that because hosting a wedding these days is a very expensive proposition. It's been either family or close friends for the entire course of my life and I have always given a gift whether I am able to attend the wedding or not. (And never thought twice about it.)
 
Here's a hypothetical question for the peanut gallery........

What if your friend whom you've known for 20 years is getting married.

You are good friends and have known each other since middle school (Say). Life may have taken you in different directions, but you still make a point of seeing each other a few times a years, etc. You're definitely not casual acquaintences.

For whatever reason, you cannot attend his wedding, so you RSVP your regrets.

Question:

Since you are not going to his wedding, do you still buy him a wedding gift, or do you believe that because you have not gone to the wedding that you do not have to buy him a wedding gift?
 
It doesn't matter whether you disagree or not, the correct etiquette is that if you are invited to a wedding, you give a gift whether you go or not. Not everyone knows this, but this is the rule. (I will bet that the work friends who invited you to their wedding knew the rule and they think you're a cheapskate because you didn't follow proper etiquette.)

The article says "casual acquaintance". So, the guests were neither friend nor family, but for some odd reason they were invited. Some people do invite everyone they can think of to their weddings, sometimes ridiculously large numbers of people, but if you invite randoms to your wedding, don't be surprised if some of the randoms declines and sends no gift.

I agree that certainly if you attend, bring a gift, even if you are just a casual acquaintance.

But if some "casual acquaintance" of mine invited me to a wedding, a friend of a friend, or some work contact I don't really know very well--and I didn't care enough about them to want to bother going, I wouldn't send a gift either, and if they didn't like that, I wouldn't care, because after all, they aren't anyone to me.

Certainly if a friend or relative invited me to a wedding and circumstances conspired to prevent me from attending, I would send a nice gift along with my apology for not being able to be there, but in that case I would have WANTED to be there, but for some reason, couldn't make it. (Or at least I'd pretend I wanted to be there.)

I only attend weddings where 2 people I know wants me to show up w/ or w/o gifts. w/ or w/o a date. People who are genuinely happy of my presence. But of course I give my gifts. If I can afford to shell out $120 for a handjob that has no guarantee of greatness. what's an $80 gift to friends?

So I will throw an entirely new spin on this who's compensating me for attending your wedding ? Hotel room, new outfits for the family, etc on the low end it's gonna cost me a grand and you want me to buy you a gift on top of it. In the future I think I will put all my receipts in an envelope with a note that says Your Welcome !
 
Here's a hypothetical question for the peanut gallery........

What if your friend whom you've known for 20 years is getting married.

You are good friends and have known each other since middle school (Say). Life may have taken you in different directions, but you still make a point of seeing each other a few times a years, etc. You're definitely not casual acquaintences.

For whatever reason, you cannot attend his wedding, so you RSVP your regrets.

Question:

Since you are not going to his wedding, do you still buy him a wedding gift, or do you believe that because you have not gone to the wedding that you do not have to buy him a wedding gift?
In this example, since I've known the guy for 20 years and see him regularly still, I would buy him a gift even if I couldn't make his wedding

I doubt he would expect me to, but I would anyway