Robocalls - Fraud occured during the election using the Conservative database

groggy

Banned
Mar 21, 2011
15,252
1
0
The Supreme Court has ruled on the robocall case. They didn't annul the election results, but did conclude that fraud occurred and that the parties who committed it used the conservatives CIMS database. They couldn't prove it was the conservatives, however.

The Council of Canadians may appeal this case, but there should now be pressure on the conservatives to explain why they haven't investigated how someone with high admin access committed electoral fraud and they haven't done anything in the least to investigate or aid an investigation.

http://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/story/2013/05/23/pol-federal-court-robocall-allegations.html
 
Told you it didn't affect the outcomes. Maybe you can now find some peace.....:D

So which union is funding the so called Council of Canadians ?
 
Told you it didn't affect the outcomes. Maybe you can now find some peace.....:D

So which union is funding the so called Council of Canadians ?

No, it'll just be added to the list crimes that the conservatives are trying to sweep under the carpet, as they are trying to do with Duffy.
As the court ruled:

hese proceedings have had partisan overtones from the outset. That was particularly evident in the submissions of the respondent MPs. In reviewing the procedural history and the evidence and considering the arguments advanced by the parties at the hearing, it has seemed to me that the applicants sought to achieve and hold the high ground of promoting the integrity of the electoral process while the respondent MPs engaged in trench warfare in an effort to prevent this case from coming to a hearing on the merits.

Despite the obvious public interest in getting to the bottom of the allegations, the CPC made little effort to assist with the investigation at the outset despite early requests. I note that counsel for the CPC was informed while the election was taking place that the calls about pollingstation changes were improper. While it was begrudgingly conceded during oral argument that what occurred was "absolutely outrageous", the record indicates that the stance taken by the respondent MPs from the outset was to block these proceedings by any means.

The preliminary stages were marked by numerous objections to the evidence adduced by the applicants. The respondent MPs sought to strike the applications on the ground that they were frivolous and vexatious, to have them dismissed as champertous and to require excessive security for costs, in transparent attempts to derail this case.

http://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/inside-politics-blog/2013/05/for-the-record-federal-court-ruling-on-robocalls-and-electoral-fraud.html

They ruled that there was fraud, the fraud used the conservative database with admin at the highest level and that the conservatives have only worked very hard to avoid investigation.
That's the kind of party you back?
 
No, it'll just be added to the list crimes that the conservatives are trying to sweep under the carpet, as they are trying to do with Duffy.
As the court ruled:



http://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/inside-politics-blog/2013/05/for-the-record-federal-court-ruling-on-robocalls-and-electoral-fraud.html

They ruled that there was fraud, the fraud used the conservative database with admin at the highest level and that the conservatives have only worked very hard to avoid investigation.
That's the kind of party you back?

Don't be so stupid. Every party in power has it's long list of questionable legal and ethical decisions.
 
Council of pinkos

Told you it didn't affect the outcomes. Maybe you can now find some peace.....:D

So which union is funding the so called Council of Canadians ?

Run by current and ex union leaders and teachers.

Obvious agenda here, and its has nothing to do with right or wrong.

I always get a kick out of these organizations that create a name that implies that every Canadian is in agreement with their politics.


FAST
 
the ruling is a harsh indictment of the conservatives. the only thing salvaged by them, was the court's hesitation to over turn an election as a direct causal link between the fraudulent activities and the results cannot be proven.
 
Run by current and ex union leaders and teachers.

Obvious agenda here, and its has nothing to do with right or wrong.

I always get a kick out of these organizations that create a name that implies that every Canadian is in agreement with their politics.


FAST

So you are ok with the fact that the supreme court of Canada found that electoral fraud was committed during the last election, using the conservatives database, and the conservatives were found to have worked very hard to avoid any investigations?

For that you blame unions?
 
No, it'll just be added to the list crimes that the conservatives are trying to sweep under the carpet,...

Not that I'm a fan of Harper, I could have sworn that if a judge rules that it wasn't an issue, the term 'crime' doesn't apply.
 
Not that I'm a fan of Harper, I could have sworn that if a judge rules that it wasn't an issue, the term 'crime' doesn't apply.

You should read the ruling.
He ruled that fraud occurred and it most likely used the conservative database, the only reason that he didn't annul the 6 ridings results was that it was unclear that there was enough evidence that the fraud changed the election results.

He did rule that a crime occurred.
 
You should read the ruling.
He ruled that fraud occurred and it most likely used the conservative database, the only reason that he didn't annul the 6 ridings results was that it was unclear that there was enough evidence that the fraud changed the election results.

He did rule that a crime occurred.

Let's not forget a couple of key sentences in paragraph 245:

In reaching this conclusion, I make no finding that the CPC, any CPC candidates, or RMG and RackNine Inc., were directly involved in the campaign to mislead voters.

There is no evidence to indicate that the use of the CIMS database in this manner was approved or condoned by the CPC.

Tough ruling for Maude Barlow to swallow.
 
Let's not forget a couple of key sentences in paragraph 245:

Tough ruling for Maude Barlow to swallow.

Not really, he also says that fraud was committed, it was most likely committed with use of the conservative database, the conservatives have been impeding all investigations.
They only got off because they couldn't prove who did it or prove definitively that the election results were changed by the fraud.

Tough ruling for the conservatives, they will be hearing more about this in the days to come.
Next in line, Guelph.
 
Not that I'm a fan of Harper, I could have sworn that if a judge rules that it wasn't an issue, the term 'crime' doesn't apply.
Not how I interpret it.

Fraud was committed and fraud is a crime. They can't prove who committed it.
 
Not that I'm a fan of Harper, I could have sworn that if a judge rules that it wasn't an issue, the term 'crime' doesn't apply.

He foubd that a crime did occur that it wasn't serious enough to change the election result and that there was no reason to think the party was officially complicit.

If Pierre Poutine can be identified he can be charged, as an individual whose zeal for the Conservatives seems to have included unsanctioned criminal activity.
 
the ruling is a harsh indictment of the conservatives. the only thing salvaged by them, was the court's hesitation to over turn an election as a direct causal link between the fraudulent activities and the results cannot be proven.
You really should try and read the ruling first and not rely on the mental midgets like groggy.
 
He foubd that a crime did occur that it wasn't serious enough to change the election result and that there was no reason to think the party was officially complicit.

If Pierre Poutine can be identified he can be charged, as an individual whose zeal for the Conservatives seems to have included unsanctioned criminal activity.

Well it's been two years now fuji . Guess you are happy that you didn't bet on this one.
 
You really should try and read the ruling first and not rely on the mental midgets like groggy.

You really should read the ruling first, lest you appear a fool.
The judge said fraud occurred during the election and that it most likely used the conservative database and that the conservatives have been working very hard to avoid any investigation.
 
He foubd that a crime did occur that it wasn't serious enough to change the election result and that there was no reason to think the party was officially complicit.

If Pierre Poutine can be identified he can be charged, as an individual whose zeal for the Conservatives seems to have included unsanctioned criminal activity.

Pierre Poutine certainly isn't an NDPer
 
You really should read the ruling first, lest you appear a fool.
The judge said fraud occurred during the election and that it most likely used the conservative database and that the conservatives have been working very hard to avoid any investigation.

So tell us groggy how did you assess how hard the Conservatives were working to avoid investigation? Having read the ruling I see no mention of that. So do you think the unions got good use of there funds when everyone with half a brain knew that the results were not affected.
 
So tell us groggy how did you assess how hard the Conservatives were working to avoid investigation? Having read the ruling I see no mention of that. So do you think the unions got good use of there funds when everyone with half a brain knew that the results were not affected.

The court ruling mentions the ridiculous charges the conservatives put out to try to stop the court case and/or make it too expensive to continue, as well as notes that the conservatives have stymied all possible investigations and have never themselves looked into who used their database to commit fraud.
If you like, I'll find some time over the next few days to find the quotes for you.

By the way, why haven't the conservatives followed up on their promise to toughen up rules and increase charges on electoral fraud?
 
Some quotes from the ruling:

In writing his judgment, Mosley felt it necessary to note these obstructionist tactics.
"These proceedings," he wrote, "Have had partisan overtones from the outset. That was particularly evident in the submissions of the respondent [Conservative] MPs ... [It] has seemed to me that the applicants sought to achieve and hold the high ground of promoting the integrity of the electoral process, while the respondent MPs engaged in trench warfare in an effort to prevent this case from coming to a hearing on the merits."

"Despite the obvious public interest in getting to the bottom of the allegations," Mosely wrote in his judgment, "The Conservative Party of Canada made little effort to assist with the investigation --[even] at the outset -- despite early requests."

"I note that counsel for the Conservative Party of Canada was informed while the election was taking place that the calls about polling station changes were improper. While it was begrudgingly conceded during oral argument that what occurred was 'absolutely outrageous,' the record indicates that the stance taken by the respondent [Conservative] MPs from the outset was to block these proceedings by any means."

"The evidence presented in these applications," the Judge wrote, "Points to a concerted campaign by persons who had access to a database of voter information maintained by a political party."
That political party, Mosley said, was the Conservative Party of Canada.