US Senate Wimps Out

The shooter at the CT school shooting stole his weapons from his mother. A new enhanced background check for mental illness would not have prevented his mother from legally owning her guns, nor would it have prevented her mentally ill son from stealing them to use. As I said, I support keeping guns from mentally ill people, but it would have done nothing to prevent the CT school shooting.

The point wasn't to stop further massacres. The point was to bring some common sense legislation to gun ownership (that perhaps it ISN'T a good idea for just ANYBODY to own a gun and MAYBE the government should be doing the BARE MINIMUM to stop them from doing so).

Why do gun owners need to be anonymous anyway? Why is it such a bad thing that the authorities know you have a tool capable of annihilating human life?

What are you afraid of? The "unnecessary hassle" of having to wait a couple of days while a universal background check is done?
 
The assault rifle ban was just full on retarded and wasn't ever going to do any good.

It is too bad they didn't pass the mandatory background checks. I think it would be possible to construct a background check regime that does not invade anyone's privacy and does not result in a registry of gun owners. Just have the police produce certificates that an individual has passed a background check, and allow individuals who wish to purchase firearms to present those certificates. There are lots of reasons why someone might get a police background check and only some of them involve purchasing firearms. Others would be applying for security sensitive positions, or filling out a visa to emigrate to another country. The police don't need to know why you got a background check.

I just don't see why anyone would object to that. Maybe the way it was being implemented.
 
There are lots of reasons why someone might get a police background check and only some of them involve purchasing firearms. Others would be applying for security sensitive positions, or filling out a visa to emigrate to another country. The police don't need to know why you got a background check.

I had to get a criminal background check before renting a specific apartment once. My wife needed a criminal background check before she could be hired in her field (which involved working with children). My father needed one to be allowed into the Nexus program. A cousin of mind needed one so he could work as an engineer for a certain power company.

It's ludicrous that one would object to a universal background check for purchasing a firearm.

Fuji and I vehemently disagree on what an adequate level of gun legislation is (or what USEFUL gun legislation is), so I think it says a lot when we can both agree that this particular bit of gun legislation was a no-brainer.
 
Question for the US legal/constitution experts here: I know states often have a sort of referendum on various issues at election time. Could there be a federal version of that? Could the House/Senate/White House ask for a national vote on this (or any other) issue?
There is no provision for such, and there would likely need to be Constitutional Amendment to allow for it.
 
Somewhere Adam Lanza is laughing.

Rightly so I may add.

There's already several laws on the books regarding gun ownership and/or the purchase of guns....

Except at gun shows, except private sales, except internet sales, except checking up on gun dealers, ...
 
There is no provision for such, and there would likely need to be Constitutional Amendment to allow for it.

Thanks Aardie, I sort of figured as much. Pity, but given the US history of strong state rights, I'm not all that surprised.
 
Apparently upwards of 40% of gun acquisitions in the US are done without proper background checks...http://factcheck.org/2013/03/guns-acquired-without-background-checks/

I am surprised it is only 40%. I have never bought a gun in a gun shop. All my purchases are done through online orders, or private purchases off other gun owners.

In fact with guns private purchases are a really big deal, because a well kept gun will last well over 100 years. One of my rifles, in perfectly good working condition, was made in 1943 and has seen a lot of use ever since, and still works perfectly well. As a result private sales are commonplace--why buy new, when you can buy a perfectly good used gun from someone else?

I don't really understand the opposition in the US to background checks. I haven't looked into it--maybe the particular implementation of this check was odious. Maybe it was an attempt to establish a federal registry of all firearms owners, or something like that, rather than a decentralized requirement to have a police certificate in hand in order to transact.

Gun owners quite rightly view any attempt to create a registry of any kind as a first step towards confiscation, and perhaps this was an attempt to create a registry in disguise? There are indeed ways to implement background checks that do not result in having any lists of gun owners around, and I just can't see the objection to that.
 
I think it was simply the NRA (and their supporters) declaring their usual "slippery slope" to arms restrictions...
 
I did some digging and yes, the NRA's fear is that universal background checks is a step towards creating a registry of firearm owners. It also seems they are not wrong about that--the major groups lobbying in favour of the background checks seem to have exactly that in mind.

That said to a guy like me it seems there is a reasonable middle ground--allow the transfer of firearms to anyone who can produce any ID that proves they have passed a background check, like a nexus card, a government security clearance, or simply a certificate from the police stating it.

Why has that not been proposed? Such reasonable proposals aren't interesting to either side. The anti-gun lobby really is interested in working towards eventual registration and so really isn't interested in a proposal like that. Obviously the NRA isn't going to champion it either.

So once again reasonable schemes that would not infringe rights do not get implemented because they get lost in the shoving between two groups of extremists.
 
I did some digging and yes, the NRA's fear is that universal background checks is a step towards creating a registry of firearm owners. It also seems they are not wrong about that--the major groups lobbying in favour of the background checks seem to have exactly that in mind.

Of course they had that in mind. But it doesn't mean that a gun registry was ever going to happen. Most law abiding gun owners can't stand the idea of a gun registry (I personally disagree with them, but that's not the point). And it sure isn't a good enough reason to not allow in some "common sense" legislation (the idea that there one day might be a STRICT legislation brought in).

It's absolutely asinine. There's no justifiable reason that buying a gun needs to be as easy as buying a pack of cigarettes.
 
Note that the anti side is also responsible for the failure to bring common sense legislation. They brought a proposal designed to be a first step towards registration rather than one that could not used that way.

Both sided brought an agenda to the table and left common sense at home.

There was no willingness to work together to craft a background check regime that answered the concerns of those who fear federal interference.
 
I did some digging and yes, the NRA's fear is that universal background checks is a step towards creating a registry of firearm owners. It also seems they are not wrong about that--the major groups lobbying in favour of the background checks seem to have exactly that in mind.

Seems entirely reasonable that guns should have at least as much legislation and rules around them as cars.
Register them and make owners pay for insurance in case their guns kill somebody, either through theft, accident or crime.
 
Seems entirely reasonable that guns should have at least as much legislation and rules around them as cars.

So, since you don't need a background check to buy a car, I take it you feel that is unnecessary. Firearms licenses should be like drivers license--based on a simple safety test, without any criminal background inquiry. This is according to your logic that they should be just like car driving licenses.

At any rate, I agree with background checks. I was just pointing out that the NRA's reason for opposing background checks. My real point is I think if both sides would step down from their extreme positions they actually could find a way to implement background checks WITHOUT raising the spectre of registering all gun owners. That would actually likely pass in the senate and congress and be an improvement in the US.

But since the anti side is actually trying to do what the NRA fears it is trying to do, it's lead to deadlock.
 
don't need a background check to buy a car,
Actually, I think we should have a background check for people who buy cars, in addition to having licenses and extend this to gun ownership as well. Back in the bad old days, people weren't required to have a background check to work with kids, this all changed because we wised up.
 
So, since you don't need a background check to buy a car, I take it you feel that is unnecessary.

The 'criminal' check is taken care of by insurance companies for cars. Too many points off and you won't get insured.
For guns that should definitely be done at point of sale.

Where they should also check your facebook and terb accounts to see how often you support shooting children and civilians before you are allowed guns.
It would keep us safe from people like you.