Nuclear War in Our Lifetime

Do you believe you will see a nuclear war (or nuclear attack) in your lifetime?

  • Yes.

    Votes: 34 47.2%
  • No.

    Votes: 38 52.8%

  • Total voters
    72
  • Poll closed .

poker

Everyone's hero's, tell everyone's lies.
Jun 1, 2006
7,699
6,016
113
Niagara
Simple question.

Do you believe we will see a nuclear war in our (your) lifetime?
 
Not in ours. I think it will happen in the lifetime of the generation alpha though.


My grandmother's generation went through the last nuclear war.

So don't you mean another nuclear war?
 
That wasn't a nuclear war. That was just nuclear bombs being tested. Now that everyone has them, things are going to get interesting.

Two nuclear bombs were dropped on civilian targets in Japan. They exploded. People died. Pretty much a classic definition of a nuclear war.
 
Go back to the Kennedy / Khrushchev era. Look how intense it got with only 2 countries. They nearly flinched out of fear the other would fire 1st. How many countries have it now. How many terrorist organizations strive for it..... I don't think it will start with rockets. I see it as more of a dirty bomb. Comes in on a container ship and goes off in a major port. Then what? restraint? or does everyone flinch?
 
Two nuclear bombs were dropped on civilian targets in Japan. They exploded. People died. Pretty much a classic definition of a nuclear war.

One country using a nuclear weapon doesn't make it a nuclear war. You would need at least 2 countries using nukes.
 
Go back to the Kennedy / Khrushchev era. Look how intense it got with only 2 countries. They nearly flinched out of fear the other would fire 1st. How many countries have it now. How many terrorist organizations strive for it..... I don't think it will start with rockets. I see it as more of a dirty bomb. Comes in on a container ship and goes off in a major port. Then what? restraint? or does everyone flinch?

In England this Christmas there were rumors that a few hundred thermonuclear warheads were missing from USSR inventory. Why a dirty bomb when so many fully functional devices are floating around?
 
One country using a nuclear weapon doesn't make it a nuclear war. You would need at least 2 countries using nukes.


So if a country with nuclear weapons decides to level another country and they cannot launch their own nuclear weapon there is no nuclear war?

Like North Korea blast the 6 biggest south korean cities to dust, it is not a nuclear war? I am sorry that makes no sense to me.
 
My grandmother's generation went through the last nuclear war.

So don't you mean another nuclear war?
you misunderstood the original question based on this answer. he asked about a nuclear war in our generation, not your grandmothers. we can't have another nuclear war in our generation if we have not had one yet.
 
Terb demographics span 3 or 4 generations, so the premise of the question is confusing.

I don't think anyone can make a reasoned analysis of this probability.

Back in the old war, you had two superpowers, which were reasonable and made strategic decisions.

now, the risk isn't coming from responsible, reasonable threats. The nuke holders may be radicals, ideologues or just plain nut cases. How do you predict the actions of a nut bar?
 
it is possible in our generation. i really hope not and whoever is thinking about launching knows one will be coming back. no point in killing off your enemy if you are dead and can't enjoy the win.
 
you misunderstood the original question based on this answer. he asked about a nuclear war in our generation, not your grandmothers. we can't have another nuclear war in our generation if we have not had one yet.

Well he actually said "Do you believe you will see a nuclear war (or nuclear attack) in your lifetime?". He did not say generations but none the less at least 2 generations out there already saw a nuclear war. Since many people alive today have already seen a nuclear war, or at least a few nuclear attacks, in their life times already the term should be "another nuclear war", or perhaps "a third nuclear attack".

I was just pointing out the genie was already let out of the bottle.

:)
 
Well he actually said "Do you believe you will see a nuclear war (or nuclear attack) in your lifetime?". He did not say generations but none the less at least 2 generations out there already saw a nuclear war. Since many people alive today have already seen a nuclear war, or at least a few nuclear attacks, in their life times already the term should be "another nuclear war", or perhaps "a third nuclear attack".

I was just pointing out the genie was already let out of the bottle.

:)

in your lifetime, not someone else's lifetime. either way you word it you misunderstood the question. your lifetime is shorter than my lifetime and i haven't seen or experienced one, so you haven't either. so do you think it will happen in your lifetime ?
 
That would be considered a nuclear attack and an act of war. Until someone else starts throwing bombs back it really isn't a nuclear war.

LOL OK. So if the North Koreans use nuclear weapons to blow the shit out of South Korea is NOT a nuclear war. And if you get shot by a mugger it is not gun violence unless you shoot back.

Still does not make any sense to me, but not worth having an argument about.
 
in your lifetime, not someone else's lifetime. either way you word it you misunderstood the question. your lifetime is shorter than my lifetime and i haven't seen or experienced one, so you haven't either. so do you think it will happen in your lifetime ?

Sorry hun, you are just being argumentative and silly again. But feel free to believe anything you want. :)
 
Definitely in my lifetime, don't know about the rest of you.
 
Sorry hun, you are just being argumentative and silly again. But feel free to believe anything you want. :)

no i was pointing out you misunderstood the question, that is not an attack or argument, just a simple fact. he asked about your lifetime, not your grandmothers. you are younger than me so you have not ever seen or lived through or experienced a nuclear war. do you think from this day forward to your last day will you see or experience one ?
 
Its called Nuclear deterent.
both sides know...NO ONE wins in a nuclear war...it'll be some fanatic who has no rationale for launching who will destroy the world
there are plenty of countries with nuclear programs..some cant stand eachother...but have held off pulling the trigger ....im not worried about a country with many...
im more worried about a fanatical individual with 1..!!!!!( i think that was a line from the peacemaker..nicole kidman/george clooney)...so true!
didnt schwartzkopf wanna drop a nuke on saddam??
 
Last edited:
no i was pointing out you misunderstood the question, that is not an attack or argument, just a simple fact. he asked about your lifetime, not your grandmothers. you are younger than me so you have not ever seen or lived through or experienced a nuclear war. do you think from this day forward to your last day will you see or experience one ?

Whatever simon.

I wanted to remind people this would be the second time a country used nuclear weapons on civilian targets. Any thinking adult already absorbed and digested the fundamental fact. They also have thought to themselves, "Oh ya. For most North Americans it had little effect."

I do not enjoy arguing semantics with you. So whatever you are going on about, you must be right and if I agree with you you might shut up :). So of course you are right.