Nuclear War in Our Lifetime

Do you believe you will see a nuclear war (or nuclear attack) in your lifetime?

  • Yes.

    Votes: 34 47.2%
  • No.

    Votes: 38 52.8%

  • Total voters
    72
  • Poll closed .
Sadly religious or ideological nutjobs have or soon will have their hands on nukes.
If these were rational people they would never use them
However these are not rational people.
 
No hun, it just proves I feel contempt for you and would never follow an order you gave me unless I felt like doing it LOL

it wasn't an order. it was me giving you a chance to show you are not an ignorant disrespectful child. you did exactly what i thought you would. so go on back to talking about something you claimed to not want to talk about. your words "something i am not interested in". carry on, i don't bother with disrespectful losers. i'll check back in a month, i will wait an actual month this time, i thought i could give you a chance early since i got done my day and had some time to kill. good day sir.
 
Well, if we're here to argue semantics about the question, I would have to assume that you are old enough to have seen the first one....... have you? If the answer is no, the question then becomes, do think you will see one in your lifetime.
I'm coming from the premise that I believe most of the membership haven't lived through that yet. I have not.

Personally, I find arguing semantics tiresome and distracting from meaningful conversation. Spelling police bother me too..... but I digress.

So...... with Iran and Israel. Pakistan and India. Islam and U.S.. Korea vs everyone.... What are your thoughts on you seeing someone nuclear arsenal being deployed before you kick the proverbial bucket?


I believe that the US proved beyond a doubt that they have already been willing to unleash that horror. It would not be logical to assume that no other countries would feel the same way. The real issue is will they be used as the tools of a few fanatics, or countries?

A fanatic is easily able to bear the pain they cause for others.
 
it wasn't an order. it was me giving you a chance to show you are not an ignorant disrespectful child. you did exactly what i thought you would. so go on back to talking about something you claimed to not want to talk about. your words "something i am not interested in". carry on, i don't bother with disrespectful losers. i'll check back in a month, i will wait an actual month this time, i thought i could give you a chance early since i got done my day and had some time to kill. good day sir.

Well I have no respect for you, so I refuse to pretend I do. PLease not bother checking back. I feel terrible having you do so and discover I still feel contempt for you :).
 
I believe that the US proved beyond a doubt that they have already been willing to unleash that horror.
Somehow I suspect that if you or CL had a ancestor or relative who was likely to have died during the Invasion of the Japanese Home Islands, you wouldn't find Hiroshima or Nagasaki quite so "horrible."
 
Actually, I hadn't felt the need to use a dictionary. Since you have yours out look up the definition of "war". It's kind of a key component in that definition.

Webster dictionary defines war as being hostilities openly declared between participants and nuclear war as being a war in which nuclear weapons are used. So technically WWII meets the definition of a nuclear war. I confess that had I been forced to define it prior to checking the dictionary I would have said it was where there was an exchange between the hostile parties.

Frankly I am surprised that a nuclear device has not been exploded by terrorists thus far. I do expect it will happen in my lifetime. I would not be surprised to have a nuclear exchange happen either. If I had to guess, my money would be on North Korea/China.
 
Webster dictionary defines war as being hostilities openly declared between participants and nuclear war as being a war in which nuclear weapons are used. So technically WWII meets the definition of a nuclear war. I confess that had I been forced to define it prior to checking the dictionary I would have said it was where there was an exchange between the hostile parties.

Frankly I am surprised that a nuclear device has not been exploded by terrorists thus far. I do expect it will happen in my lifetime. I would not be surprised to have a nuclear exchange happen either. If I had to guess, my money would be on North Korea/China.

My money is split on Iran/Isreal..Pakistan/India
but then again..fanatics come in all shapes and sizes...and religions!
and..does anyone really know how many nukes are un accounted for?
The amount of nuclear grade plutonium needed for a dirty bomb is all that much...
anyone care to guess how much spent fuel rods from the nuclear plants here in the D/R..travel up and down the highway each week?
 
My money is split on Iran/Isreal..Pakistan/India
but then again..fanatics come in all shapes and sizes...and religions!
and..does anyone really know how many nukes are un accounted for?
The amount of nuclear grade plutonium needed for a dirty bomb is all that much...
anyone care to guess how much spent fuel rods from the nuclear plants here in the D/R..travel up and down the highway each week?

Those are two other good bets for sure.
 
GsckQZZ.jpg


well i guess that means we are safe.
 
7093319_460s_v1.jpg


maybe not so safe after all. north korea just added ak47's to their cannon's.
 
Webster dictionary defines war as being hostilities openly declared between participants and nuclear war as being a war in which nuclear weapons are used. So technically WWII meets the definition of a nuclear war. I confess that had I been forced to define it prior to checking the dictionary I would have said it was where there was an exchange between the hostile parties.

Frankly I am surprised that a nuclear device has not been exploded by terrorists thus far. I do expect it will happen in my lifetime. I would not be surprised to have a nuclear exchange happen either. If I had to guess, my money would be on North Korea/China.

I think it is a 3 phase issue for terrorists.

1) Getting a thermonuclear device
2) Having the skills to modify it so they can detonate it with dying from the radiation
3) Having a way of delivering to a suitable target.

The alarmists say the terrorists already tried.

I agree with you someday it will occur.
 
Somehow I suspect that if you or CL had a ancestor or relative who was likely to have died during the Invasion of the Japanese Home Islands, you wouldn't find Hiroshima or Nagasaki quite so "horrible."

Nagasaki was about the only Christian city in Japan. And hardly a strategic military target. I find it horrible because it was selected as a sitting duck to hurt civilians.

Actually my ancestors were abused by the Japanese. And my maternal grand parents still hates them


I also find it horrible that LL is poised to make a fortune if a major regional war starts.
 
Why worry about someone lobbing Nukes around? I'd be far, far more concerned by the release of bio weapons. Now my money would be on India & Pakistan, followed by India & China. Terrorist could easily deploy a dirty bomb in any major city, kind of surprised it hasn't happened yet.
 
Why worry about someone lobbing Nukes around? I'd be far, far more concerned by the release of bio weapons. Now my money would be on India & Pakistan, followed by India & China. Terrorist could easily deploy a dirty bomb in any major city, kind of surprised it hasn't happened yet.

I think bio weapons are harder to make, and once deployed harder to prevent from killing off your own people :). like letting rabid rats loose in the trenches. Bad for everyone
 
I think bio weapons are harder to make, and once deployed harder to prevent from killing off your own people :). like letting rabid rats loose in the trenches. Bad for everyone

Are you kidding? Biological weapons are easy to make, and there is a central watersupply in all major cities.
 
Are you kidding? Biological weapons are easy to make, and there is a central watersupply in all major cities.

danmand, a bio weapon is a living organism. Something that reproduces and spreads itself. To weaponize a disease you need a rather sophisticated lab and the technology to modify it's genetic make up so it functions as a effective weapon. If you ever walk into a lab that is working on vaccines ( a much safer type of research) you will be amazed at the complexity and cost of what is needed to stop the researchers from getting infected. In addition the "suicide gene" has not been perfected. So if it is released it is almost impossible from stopping it from destroying your own people.

By any chance are you thinking of chemical weapons? Like poisons?
 
danmand, a bio weapon is a living organism.

By any chance are you thinking of chemical weapons? Like poisons?

If you're going to be picky on definitions, realize that viruses and biotoxins are also considered bioweapons, and that not all nuclear weapons are of a thermonuclear type (especially not the two bombs set off in WWII.)
 
If you're going to be picky on definitions, realize that viruses and biotoxins are also considered bioweapons, and that not all nuclear weapons are of a thermonuclear type (especially not the two bombs set off in WWII.)

Yes I am guilty of sloppy posting. Well also ignorance in the case of all weapons not being thermonuclear in nature. Indeed an important distinction since North Korea does not have thermonuclear devices. Just nuclear weapons, no "H" bombs. I did not know the distinction till I asked this morning.

I do however know that bacteria, viruses, rickettsiae, fungi, toxins, and a handful of other biological agents can all be considered useful in creating biological weapons.

My statement of the difficulties in weaponizing them is still true.

I assume you mentioned viruses because they straddle the definition life. They do exist as 'virions' clearly not living, but when infecting a host they have all the characteristics of life. Although I never have been involved in weaponizing a virus ;), I do know that developing vaccines must be done in their living state. So I would guess the same applies to modifying a virus for use as a weapon. And I do know the problems of working on them are even more significant than with bacteria.

I guess biotoxins (poison extracted from living organisms) is considered a bio weapon. However to extract enough for attacking a large group of people is difficult. Even if someone could extract a few kilos of ricin from castor waste or even castor beans, the CDC considers it a chemical. Great for murder, possibly useful for panic, but a chemical. So this one I leave to the military ones to classify. I wonder if they change the classification if it a synthetic chemical instead of one extracted from a plant?


But yes you are right, viruses and biotoxins are considered bioweapons. And I was wrong assuming all nuclear bombs are thermonuclear. Fusion bombs exist as well. Thank you for flagging that.
 
Nagasaki was about the only Christian city in Japan. And hardly a strategic military target. I find it horrible because it was selected as a sitting duck to hurt civilians.

Actually my ancestors were abused by the Japanese. And my maternal grand parents still hates them


I also find it horrible that LL is poised to make a fortune if a major regional war starts.
Kokura was the primary target of the August 9 bombing raid, however the about ¾ cloud cover over the city meant that they moved on to the secondary target Nagasaki, which was a city of of major industrial importance including the Mitsubishi Shipyards builder of the IJNS Musashi, second ship of the Yamato class.

You are of course right about the strong influence of the Roman Catholic church on Kyushu and particularly Nagasaki.

I don't think anyone is joyful about either the war or the atomic bombings, however, I certainly feel no need for guilt over it.
 
Last edited:
Kokura was the primary target of the August 9 bombing raid, however the about ¾ cloud cover over the city meant that they moved on to the secondary target Nagasaki, which was a city of of major industrial importance including the Mitsubishi**Shipyards builder of the IJNS Musashi, second ship of the Yamato class.

You are of course right about the strong influence of the Roman Catholic church on Kyushu and particularly Nagasaki.

I don't think anyone is joyful about either the war or the atomic bombings, however, I certainly feel no need for guilt over it.

I am not trying to guilt trip anyone over it. Just pointing out that a country already used nuclear weapons against helpless people. So it is a little hypocritical to assume others will not do it again.