Teacher Appreciation Week? You've got to be joking!

Blah, Blah & more Blah
Sorry Teach, no way teacher are worthy of $83K + +++
Ontario is running deficits
Paying such an excessive salary is insane & it has to stop

So you are a rent-seeker...does it bother you at all?

You miss my point completely. Under crony capitalism, anyone with political clout is overpaid, and the ones with the most political clout are the most overpaid. The way to end it is to eliminate social programs and allow individual taxpayers to channel their spending to areas that are important to them. If you need open-heart surgery, you pay for it; you need schooling for your children, you pay for it; you use the highways; you pay for it.

To put it simply, social spending is like having ten people sharing the same credit card, and each one responsible for 1/10 of the debt. Under such a scenario, you would be a fool not to spend like a madman, because you know the other nine will. It is the system that is at fault.

I have this funny feeling most people who claim to the conservatives are closet socialists. What they want is to privatize their earnings and socialize their expenses. Are you at least with me on that?
 
If you need open-heart surgery, you pay for it;

So if you can't afford it, you die. Nice.

you need schooling for your children, you pay for it....

So if you can't afford it, your children suffer for it. That's fair.


I can understand your frustration with the system, but there's a reason developed countries have social programs: because anything else is archaic.
 
Hangover

It is corruption that does it. Rent-seeking is part of that corruption.

I have to agree with you regarding "rent-seeking" and Greece,...that is what every citizen of Greece did to acquire their unsupported standard of living.

And now, like Cyprus, they are suffering withdrawal symptoms from an addiction to a financial narcotic.

FAST
 
Oh, so you want to be able to steal money from a specific group without any consequences for you

The minute we do not respect property rights we are head down a very slippery slope towards communism




You are correct, you are no economist

The very scenario you want so badly is playing in Cyprus right now
The govt , having spent way too much is attempting to steal from the rich (for the greater good)
The end result will be an economic disaster for Cyprus and possibly Europe
The Cypriate banking system will collapse & thousands of jobs will be lost throughout the economy



This will never happen as there will always be a country which will welcome foreign investment, with a hands off approach



You seem to forget, it is their money and they earned it
You seem to be confusing consumer goods with luxury goods
You also grossly under estimate the amount of money which is being put to work sustaining jobs right now
Warren Buffet may be sitting on a pile of cash right now, however the majority of his wealth is invested in companies which employ hundreds of thousands of people




Are you a drama queen or what ?


Over spending has been the downfall of governments throughout history and they appear doomed to repeat this blunder



Why bother, if the anarchy you describe were to take place your slice of pie will become worthless.

You are way to focused on what you feel is wrong or unfair at a level you can not control
Fight the battles you can win
Better to spend your time and energy focusing what you can do to increase your wealth instead of whining about other peoples wealth

no it is not their money and they did not earn it

bill gates earned his millions by creating value but by reinvesting his millions into the highest return is not creating value it is money changing



no i am not a drama queen

karl marx predicted the great wealth of capitalism and that it would spread world wide

he also prerdicted the inequalities would force capitalism to lurch from crises to crises each one getting greater as the inequalities get greater until it implodes

everything he has said has proven correct and his ideas are not dead as he put no time limit on the great collapse

he also never presented an alternative other than worker control (i am not a marxist is his quote) which was not the case in russia or present cuba as they had and have a controlling elite



you just cant get it


a fair distribution of wealth is not stealing

you should get paid by the value you create

earning interest from interest until you own it all is nuts and only the rich have freedom


if a law was passed that said freedom of speech was limited to the rich it would make zero difference to 99% who have no access to the media controlled by the wealthy


we have freedom to work or not (if there is work) and make the rich richer and to fight their fucking wars
 
Last edited:
I can understand your frustration with the system, but there's a reason developed countries have social programs: because anything else is archaic.

Remember this quote, attributed to Alexander Tyler?

"A democracy is always temporary in nature; it simply cannot exist as a permanent form of government. A democracy will continue to exist up until the time that voters discover they can vote themselves generous gifts from the public treasury. From that moment on, the majority always votes for the candidates who promise the most benefits from the public treasury, with the result that every democracy will finally collapse due to loose fiscal policy, which is always followed by a dictatorship."

We have social programs because people wanted something for nothing. We either drop the programs or increase taxes. There is no other way out.

The thought that peeling back teacher salary would make the problem magically disappear is absurd.
 
Remember this quote, attributed to Alexander Tyler?

"A democracy is always temporary in nature; it simply cannot exist as a permanent form of government. A democracy will continue to exist up until the time that voters discover they can vote themselves generous gifts from the public treasury. From that moment on, the majority always votes for the candidates who promise the most benefits from the public treasury, with the result that every democracy will finally collapse due to loose fiscal policy, which is always followed by a dictatorship."

The thought that peeling back teacher salary would make the problem magically disappear is absurd.

Peeling back public sector salaries to be on more equitable ground with their private counterparts would be a start, as would peeling back social programs. I'm all for both of those actions. Eliminating public sector workers and social programs would be a disaster, not to mention a heinous act that would lead to the misery of tens of millions of people.

That quote is a good one, however, and it has basis in our current system of doing things (obviously). Is democracy the highest level of society? Or is merely the highest that we know? Democracy is under real threat at the moment, and there is very little political or societal will to fix it.
 
Responsible

Remember this quote, attributed to Alexander Tyler?

"A democracy is always temporary in nature; it simply cannot exist as a permanent form of government. A democracy will continue to exist up until the time that voters discover they can vote themselves generous gifts from the public treasury. From that moment on, the majority always votes for the candidates who promise the most benefits from the public treasury.."

So thats why the Conservatives won the election,... because they give hand outs to the general public,...I think not.
Just because a government makes an effort to control spending,...does NOT make it a dictatorship,...but I'm sure thats what the teachers are calling responsible government


We have social programs because people wanted something for nothing. We either drop the programs or increase taxes. There is no other way out.

We have so called social programs,...because its simply what a responsible government does.
Maybe the loony left think that you get something for nothing,...but the average citizen is wiser than you think.
Also,...you don't have to drop the programs,...if you have a responsible government that limits excess spending on a salaries.

FAST
 
In your opinion. (And granted, a few other opinion's as well)
But, clearly you are biased to a comical degree on this topic as you've proved time and time again with 90% of your total posts. You have a few good points, but the disrespect and contempt that you show teachers clouds your judgement

No
I am a tax payer and want those tax dollars spent responsibly
It is not just teachers, all public sector employees that feel public coffers are bottomless deserve the same disrespect and contempt
 
So you are a rent-seeker...does it bother you at all?

You miss my point completely. Under crony capitalism, anyone with political clout is overpaid, and the ones with the most political clout are the most overpaid. The way to end it is to eliminate social programs and allow individual taxpayers to channel their spending to areas that are important to them. If you need open-heart surgery, you pay for it; you need schooling for your children, you pay for it; you use the highways; you pay for it.

To put it simply, social spending is like having ten people sharing the same credit card, and each one responsible for 1/10 of the debt. Under such a scenario, you would be a fool not to spend like a madman, because you know the other nine will. It is the system that is at fault.

I have this funny feeling most people who claim to the conservatives are closet socialists. What they want is to privatize their earnings and socialize their expenses. Are you at least with me on that?

You are over complicating this

There are three very simple relevant facts
1. The province is running deficits
2. the average taxpayer makes $43k
3. the average teacher makes $83K

The average 12 year old could tell you the above three facts spell a disaster and a change is needed

You can talk about rent-seekers all you want. That babble is irrelevant
 
I included benefits, and said, if not in 1%, close to it. People in the private sector do not receive these benefits.

How much you would have to put away per year, over a teachers average 26 years working, to collect a 50K/year pension that is indexed to inflation for an average of 32 years? Plus sick days, benefits, and they work for 9 months of the year. What is all that worth?

All that information is factored into the study. As I already showed in a previous thread, a police officer can get that and more with 3 months of training, and they are still not in the top 1%.

The study said it all. They are bankers, doctors, dentists, managers and vets. This is similiar to what they found in the US as well, at least at the bottom of the top 1% anyway:

http://www2.ucsc.edu/whorulesamerica/power/investment_manager.html
 
We have so called social programs,...because its simply what a responsible government does.
Maybe the loony left think that you get something for nothing,...but the average citizen is wiser than you think.
Also,...you don't have to drop the programs,...if you have a responsible government that limits excess spending on a salaries.

FAST

I did not choose my diction carefully. Instead of "something for nothing", I should have said I-want-my-cake-and-eat-it-too behavior.

It is very hard for a government to limit spending on salaries fairly and consistently because of rent-seeking behavior. Those with the political clout will simply get more and more of the shrinking pie.
 
You are over complicating this

There are three very simple relevant facts
1. The province is running deficits
2. the average taxpayer makes $43k
3. the average teacher makes $83K

The average 12 year old could tell you the above three facts spell a disaster and a change is needed

You can talk about rent-seekers all you want. That babble is irrelevant

You do realize that "the average taxpayer" means a lot more people to gather data from then teachers, also....teachers are taxpayers as well. Also, in the star today is an article on how 40% of cops are above 100k.
P
 
The study said it all. They are bankers, doctors, dentists, managers and vets. This is similiar to what they found in the US as well, at least at the bottom of the top 1% anyway:

http://www2.ucsc.edu/whorulesamerica/power/investment_manager.html

Your link to the American site has people in the lower half of the 1% hoping to retire on 50K/year from investment income. Teachers retirement income starts at about 50K, and would approach 100K towards the end of their retirement assuming modest inflation.

Bankers, doctors, dentists, managers generally work more than 9 months of the year. The teachers may not be in the top 1%, but when their benifits and pension are factored in , they are close to it.

This thread is on teachers, but these pensions are for most or all government workers. Got to wonder where the money is going to come from to pay out these freedom 55 pensions. Our new liberal premier is talking about jacking up taxes, maybe they will increase retirement for the average taxpayer from 67 to 70.
 
Special

I did not choose my diction carefully. Instead of "something for nothing", I should have said I-want-my-cake-and-eat-it-too behavior.

It is very hard for a government to limit spending on salaries fairly and consistently because of rent-seeking behavior. Those with the political clout will simply get more and more of the shrinking pie.

This may explain why so many people are anti teachers and civil servant unions in general,...what ever term we want to use,...."rent-seeking behaviour",....bullying etc,...is something the majority of the working public DO NOT have the resources to use,...we do not have a union.
Well we do get some leverage from the Conservatives,...but that’s it.

And what this means is,... "the shrinking pie" is not divided "fairly".

FAST
 
You do realize that "the average taxpayer" means a lot more people to gather data from then teachers, also....teachers are taxpayers as well. Also, in the star today is an article on how 40% of cops are above 100k.
P

Cops put their lives on the line, but even then I think they are also over-payed.

It's really scary to look at the massive bill public sector workers are racking up for taxpayers. And yes, I understand public sector workers are taxpayers too, but it's a little odd to lump them in with private sector workers when the taxes they pay go directly to paying their salaries! The average public sector worker will get paid out between $1 million and $1.5 million in pensions. That's a huge dollar amount when you multiply that by the number of public sector workers. Public sector workers already enjoy a huge surplus in salaries over their private counterparts, and their benefits blow private workers out of the water.

So lets summarize. Public sector workers make much more than private sector workers. Public sector workers have numerous and extensive benefits that many private sector workers don't have. Public sector workers have an outrageous and absolutely guaranteed (unless our country goes under) pension plan that the majority of private sector workers can only dream of. All of this is put on the back of taxpayers, but since public sector workers are reaping the benefits, it's really only screwing over the private sector.

Honestly, it's past time something was done about this to make things more equitable between public and private. This discrepancy is hurting our country.
 
You do realize that "the average taxpayer" means a lot more people to gather data from then teachers, also....teachers are taxpayers as well. Also, in the star today is an article on how 40% of cops are above 100k.
P

you realize that we are accumulating debt to overpay all employees in the public sector
We are going to be in one big mess in a few years when the health care costs escalate and interest rates move up
I guess you will be able to sleep well knowing most teachers will have their future taken care of, while the rest of us have to deal with the mess via very painful tax increases

cops @ 100k are overpaid as well, however please do not equate teachers & police
1. Two wrongs do not make a right
2. Teachers do not put their lives on the line
3. Police do not use children as negotiating pawns
4. Cops do not take the summer off
5. Cops do not insists that they only deal with two or three crimes a day
 
As a matter of fact there are more teachers killed in the US by gunfire than cops every year. Look at the recent shooting at Sandy Hook

Cops make more than teachers
Cops can claim overtime
Cops are eligible for a fatter pension in a shorter amount of time
Cops get a 4 day weekend - every week. 4 days on, 4 days off.
Cops average 6 weeks vacation a year


You really do need to do your homework before putting your fingers on the keyboard, john