Teacher Appreciation Week? You've got to be joking!

i simply repeat there is a better answer

find a way to take the monies away from the rich 10-20% WITHOUT CAUSING THE MONIES TO FLEE
Oh, so you want to be able to steal money from a specific group without any consequences for you

The minute we do not respect property rights we are head down a very slippery slope towards communism


i am not an economist so i have no solutions but

You are correct, you are no economist

The very scenario you want so badly is playing in Cyprus right now
The govt , having spent way too much is attempting to steal from the rich (for the greater good)
The end result will be an economic disaster for Cyprus and possibly Europe
The Cypriate banking system will collapse & thousands of jobs will be lost throughout the economy

IF THIS TAKES A WORLD WIDE EFFORT AMONGST INDUSTRIAL NATIONS OR WHATEVER ( of course this will be called communism)

This will never happen as there will always be a country which will welcome foreign investment, with a hands off approach

i have two problems with the rich

1 they control social development with their investing. Why should they have such control over society ? your argument that capitalism reinvests into the economy wisely falls on deaf ears they reinvest where there is the most profit which may or may not be best for the economy and investors will even pull their monies from the market and cause recession (such as now as there are trillions sitting on the sidelines)

2 10% have 90% of all consumer products so they do not even reinvest a lot of their money unwisely but spend it on themselves

You seem to forget, it is their money and they earned it
You seem to be confusing consumer goods with luxury goods
You also grossly under estimate the amount of money which is being put to work sustaining jobs right now
Warren Buffet may be sitting on a pile of cash right now, however the majority of his wealth is invested in companies which employ hundreds of thousands of people


the bigger revolution will come when unequal distribution of wealth reaches its tipping point and the peasants start chopping off the heads of the rich and this revolution will be world wide and the rich will protect their monies with the the armed forces which they control

Are you a drama queen or what ?

not giving the working just enough to prevent revolution has been the downfall of the ruling class throughout history and it seems they are doomed to repeat this blunder
Over spending has been the downfall of governments throughout history and they appear doomed to repeat this blunder

in the mean time i will protect my tiny slice of the pie and hope that the revoluton you say will happen if we do not cut spending will evolve into the bigger revolution that i speak of
let us pray it is quick and bloodless

Why bother, if the anarchy you describe were to take place your slice of pie will become worthless.

You are way to focused on what you feel is wrong or unfair at a level you can not control
Fight the battles you can win
Better to spend your time and energy focusing what you can do to increase your wealth instead of whining about other peoples wealth
 
That article uses a historical example where classes were protected by laws
We have come a long way since 15th century Venice

A more optimistic view is presented here
http://articles.businessinsider.com...ctrem-millionaire-households-consulting-group

You really think we have come a long way? I suggest you take a look at what Nobel Laureate Joseph Stiglitz has to say:

http://www.vanityfair.com/society/features/2011/05/top-one-percent-201105#

As far as your article goes, you are far too optimistic. You do know that most millionaires made their money not through value creation but through value transference, don't you? Economists call it rent-seeking behavior.

The top 1% ( to be more exact, the top .1%) are extremely united when it comes to their collective self-interest, while the other 99% are busily tearing each other down.

We are falling for the age-old tactic: Divide and rule.
 
We are falling for the age-old tactic: Divide and rule.

it beats the hell out of the failed communist experiment
once again the minute we stop respecting property rights we are heading down that slippery slop towards the nightmare of communism
tax targeting any group does not respect property rights

governments need to solve their deficit & debt problems by controlling their spending, not by stealing from the 1%
paying teachers an average $83K, for 9 1/2 months work (if you dare to call it work) + $20 - $ 30 K in benefit costs is not controlled spending

You talk about value creation?
Paying teachers during the summer months creates value?
Allowing teachers to bank sick days at a cost of $40 + K per teacher creates value ?
Not in my book

Do you have any idea how many people are employed directly or indirectly employed by the 1% and / or their investments ?
Tax targeting the rich sounds like a ideal way to address some perceived social inequality issues, however, there will be unexpected and very negative consequences to the economy and employment (your job perhaps)
What is even worse is to continue to over compensate the public sector at twice the rate as the average taxpayer and using the 1% as a justification

The solution is to control costs, not to steal more from our most successful citizens
 
it beats the hell out of the failed communist experiment

The solution is to control costs, not to steal more from our most successful citizens

It is important to distinguish between value producing occupations from value transference occupations. In a properly functioning society, value producing occupations would be more valued than value transference occupations. When we reward ambulance chasing, patent trolling, and lobbying far more than doing productive work such as teaching, we are living under crony capitalism.

Before we start criticizing anyone else, we should ask ourselves are we in a value producing occupation or a value transference occupation. Crony capitalism is destroying us just as it did Venice. You don't believe it is teacher salaries that is destroying Greece, do you?

Here is an example of a value transference occupation par excellence, making billions for the cronies, contribute nothing to society, and almost destroy the financial system in the process:

http://www.thestar.com/business/2009/03/18/meet_the_man_whose_big_idea_felled_wall_street.html

I just hope you are not a value transferer, or a mouthpiece for one. From your above response, I am not very hopeful.
 
We are entitled

You don't believe it is teacher salaries that is destroying Greece, do you?

.

NO,... I don't think "teacher salaries that is destroying Greece",... but I do think that the same teachers philosophy regarding economics, is what is destroying Greece.

And I am not in the "value transference occupation", if I understand what you are referring to,...but I DO make money from that part of the economy,...as everybody who understands economics should.

FAST
 
Last edited:
The top 1% ( to be more exact, the top .1%) are extremely united when it comes to their collective self-interest, while the other 99% are busily tearing each other down.

Would teachers be in the top 1% ? Would expect if not, than they are very close to it. Few people have the ability to retire in their 50's on a 50K/year pension that is indexed to inflation. All paid for by the average taxpayer making $45K or less, paying half their income in one tax or another to support these government workers incomes and pensions, now looking forward to retiring at 67. Want to talk about a reason for a revolution...


The top 0.1% have the ability to sail away with their money.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/wor...uper-rich-yachters-sail-away-from-taxman.html
 
NO,... I don't think "teacher salaries that is destroying Greece",... but I do think that the same teachers philosophy regarding economics, is what is destroying Greece.

And I am not in the "value transference occupation", if I understand what you are referring to,...but I DO make money from that part of the economy,...as everybody who understands economics should.

FAST

This is what happen when the elites engage in rent-seeking behavior. If they can give themselves bonuses of 18 billion dollars for putting the world's economy at the verge of collapse, why shouldn't people who do their jobs well get a raise?

http://www.forbes.com/2009/02/04/stimulus-obama-daschle-opinions-columnists_0205_dan_gerstein.html

This is one of the best write-ups I have seen on value transference, or more properly known as rent-seeking behavior:

http://www.dailyprogress.com/opinio...cle_1facda30-7e7b-11e2-906a-001a4bcf6878.html
 
Would teachers be in the top 1% ? Would expect if not, than they are very close to it. Few people have the ability to retire in their 50's on a 50K/year pension that is indexed to inflation. All paid for by the average taxpayer making $45K or less, paying half their income in one tax or another to support these government workers incomes and pensions, now looking forward to retiring at 67. Want to talk about a reason for a revolution...

The teachers are not even close to be in the top 1%. To do so, they would have to have household income in the neighborhood of 1.3 million dollars and household net worth of 16 million.

http://www2.ucsc.edu/whorulesamerica/power/wealth.html

Most likely they fall within the top 60-80 percentile range. Americans are totally clueless about this sort of thing, so I am not surprised that you don't know either.
 
A question

This is what happen when the elites engage in rent-seeking behavior.


So "rent-seeking behavior" is behind Greece's financial troubles,...NOT living beyond their means ???

FAST
 
The teachers are not even close to be in the top 1%. To do so, they would have to have household income in the neighborhood of 1.3 million dollars and household net worth of 16 million.

http://www2.ucsc.edu/whorulesamerica/power/wealth.html

Most likely they fall within the top 60-80 percentile range. Americans are totally clueless about this sort of thing, so I am not surprised that you don't know either.

The average salary for an Ont Teacher is 83K
This article pegs the top 5% of all Canadian Earners @ $89K
http://www.ctvnews.ca/canada-s-top-earners-make-89k-or-more-statscan-1.257561

My guess is most of the 5% work a full 12 months & do not receive the gold plated benefits teachers do
I would bet a $1,000 most of the 5% do not try and bank sick days and none of them would use children as negotiating pawns to get this excess
I would also guess most of the 5% drive revenue for their organization and would be gone if they do not continue to grow that revenue

I have yet to meet a teacher who is even close to being an elite 5% type of person.
This is so messed up.
No way teachers are worthy of the compensation their union has extracted from the taxpayer
This has to change
 
It is important to distinguish between value producing occupations from value transference occupations. In a properly functioning society, value producing occupations would be more valued than value transference occupations. When we reward ambulance chasing, patent trolling, and lobbying far more than doing productive work such as teaching, we are living under crony capitalism.

Before we start criticizing anyone else, we should ask ourselves are we in a value producing occupation or a value transference occupation. Crony capitalism is destroying us just as it did Venice. You don't believe it is teacher salaries that is destroying Greece, do you?

Here is an example of a value transference occupation par excellence, making billions for the cronies, contribute nothing to society, and almost destroy the financial system in the process:

http://www.thestar.com/business/2009/03/18/meet_the_man_whose_big_idea_felled_wall_street.html

I just hope you are not a value transferer, or a mouthpiece for one. From your above response, I am not very hopeful.

Blah, Blah & more Blah
Sorry Teach, no way teacher are worthy of $83K + +++
Ontario is running deficits
Paying such an excessive salary is insane & it has to stop
 
Doesn't change CTSblues's original point
Teachers still don't make anywhere close to qualify for the 1%

I included benefits, and said, if not in 1%, close to it. People in the private sector do not receive these benefits.

How much you would have to put away per year, over a teachers average 26 years working, to collect a 50K/year pension that is indexed to inflation for an average of 32 years? Plus sick days, benefits, and they work for 9 months of the year. What is all that worth?
 
well they certainly are close to the top 5%
that is unacceptable

In your opinion. (And granted, a few other opinion's as well)
But, clearly you are biased to a comical degree on this topic as you've proved time and time again with 90% of your total posts. You have a few good points, but the disrespect and contempt that you show teachers clouds your judgement
 
So "rent-seeking behavior" is behind Greece's financial troubles,...NOT living beyond their means ???

FAST

It is corruption that does it. Rent-seeking is part of that corruption. Transparency International has done surveys in this area for a long time. Here are some recent rankings:

http://www.guardian.co.uk/news/datablog/2012/dec/05/corruption-index-2012-transparency-international

Now, I am sure you notice that as a whole, there is a negative correlation between a nation’s wealth and its level of corruption. Some researchers are able to show that for a given level of wealth, some countries are more corrupt than others. Look at where Greece is.

http://cires.colorado.edu/~bilham/NatureCorruption/CorruptionNature2011.pdf

Brilliant, isn't it?