Teacher Appreciation Week? You've got to be joking!

I'm not a teacher and work a job that often goes well beyond 9-5 but still find time to volunteer. I do work with kids outside of schools fairly regularly and do a few weekends a year for other charities. I used to do more when my job allowed but the changes didn't stop me from finding time. It's a choice. You could easily find an hour a month to volunteer somewhere if you cared. There are many organizations that need volunteers at all sorts of different times of day. I'm sure they'd be glad if you gave some time.

If teachers end up volunteering for things because they want to and it helps the kids that's great. Kids often need it because not too many people like you will unless their own kids are involved. If they don't want to that not a problem for me. It just shows that there is a problem with our society that needs to be addressed instead of relying on the goodness of people's hearts.

If you really think it should be part of the job, lobby your MPP and compensate the teachers who do volunteer more time.

Find an hour a month to volunteer? I might be able to but I'm someone you could hardly call selfish. I have a wife and kids and 2 elderly parents (90+) who I look after on a daily basis. This includes putting out their meds every day, grocery shopping, making sure they have 3 meals a day, taking them to doctors' appointments, doing their laundry and the list goes on. Did I mention I have a my family? So yes, finding an hour a month to volunteer for me, is a big deal.
 
You do know the teachers offered a wage freeze, but were forced to take a pay raise, right?

then what are whinning about?
Why are they using students as pawns?
Exactly what is required to get these people to do their jobs?
 
then what are whinning about?
Why are they using students as pawns?
Exactly what is required to get these people to do their jobs?

Sick leave. The government cut it in half. Yet teachers are exposed to every germ and if they work sick, they risk spreading it to everyone. Maybe not a big deal for teenagers, but with little kids, that can be really harmful. Every teacher I know was upset about sick leave.

For the record, Bill 115 talks about pay freezes, but my teacher friends have told me they all got a pay raise with the contract, followed by a pay freeze going forward. I can't seem to find info either way, but I don't see close friends lying to me. In any case, collective bargaining failed while the teachers offered a pay freeze but were countered with half the sick leave and a pay raise. So no matter how you slice it, the teachers were willing to take no raise in exchange for being able to stay home when they get sick.
 
Sick leave. The government cut it in half. Yet teachers are exposed to every germ and if they work sick, they risk spreading it to everyone. Maybe not a big deal for teenagers, but with little kids, that can be really harmful. Every teacher I know was upset about sick leave.

For the record, Bill 115 talks about pay freezes, but my teacher friends have told me they all got a pay raise with the contract, followed by a pay freeze going forward. I can't seem to find info either way, but I don't see close friends lying to me. In any case, collective bargaining failed while the teachers offered a pay freeze but were countered with half the sick leave and a pay raise. So no matter how you slice it, the teachers were willing to take no raise in exchange for being able to stay home when they get sick.

Don't take this the wrong way, but I can't help reading your post without picturing one of our gay friends frantically waving his arms as he says that. lol

Oh shit... Just read it again and laughed even harder. :D
 
that they now build alternative schools is admittance of systematic gross incompetence for the 150 years they did not have the common sense to build them

as well these alternatives, which the system itself finally admite is needed, are hardly available to all just a few lucky individuals who live in the right part of toronto


no the public schools are extremely inflexible at adopting creative models for teaching and when they have tried it they fuck it up


i find it impossible to believe that being forced to learn stuff, 80% of which you will forget and never use,
is the ideal education for anyone

everyone can now afford private school as the monies that would have been spent on their public educaton are now given to them in the form of vouchers

All of this is based on teh assumptions that private offers a better education, that special interest schools are doing things differently than regular schools, and that nothing innovative is going on in public schools and that things are the same as when you were in school.

Having kids in the family who are going through all three systems I can say that I don't see much difference. But my sample size is small.
 
That's my problem too. When talks break down, the next step is arbitration. Even binding arbitration is more fair than the employer unilaterally just forcing a contract on the employees.

I don't care who you are, if your boss walked in and unilaterally changed the terms of your employment contract, you'd be pissed and bitching about how unfair it is. I think too many people don't get that. Why did they pass a law instead of going to arbitration?
 
not sure how full school voucher would solve the problem.

Currently there are ways to get your kid to go to a school outside of your zone.

And many of the "top" schools are that way, not because of great teachers but because of the community. It the community is we;; educated/affluent/appreciate school you'll see that reflected in test scores. Similarly, the worst schools are usually associated with less affluent/less educated communities.

Same goes for private schools.... the teachers are no better there. In some cases the parent is paying for a good mark (i.e. inflated) and many cases the parent is paying for less qualified teachers as the rules for hiring is more lax. Again success in that scenario is more to do with the parent than the school their kid went to. If they have the 15 to 30k to spend on private school.... they could easily pay for tuturs and whatever else if their kid went to public school.... hell some of them pay the tuition and still get tutors and other extracurriculars outside of the school.

So yes a voucher would allow people to choose a school but ultimately the kid's success is strongly rooted in their parents. But I will admit that for kid who might get into the wrong crowd this might help but that asumes there's a school with only nice kids and I find that hard to believe.

I was gonna remain relatively quiet and simply +1 this comment. Then I saw 'who' posted it and look who it is..? FC.

+2
 
Sick leave. The government cut it in half. Yet teachers are exposed to every germ and if they work sick, they risk spreading it to everyone. Maybe not a big deal for teenagers, but with little kids, that can be really harmful. Every teacher I know was upset about sick leave.

For the record, Bill 115 talks about pay freezes, but my teacher friends have told me they all got a pay raise with the contract, followed by a pay freeze going forward. I can't seem to find info either way, but I don't see close friends lying to me. In any case, collective bargaining failed while the teachers offered a pay freeze but were countered with half the sick leave and a pay raise. So no matter how you slice it, the teachers were willing to take no raise in exchange for being able to stay home when they get sick.

1. The number of sick days a teacher currently gets is excesive 20 -30 (please correct me if you know the specific number), even if they spend time with snot filed little germ generators.
The private sector the norm is 5 days a year
2. The ratio of sick days available to days worked for teachers is then inflated further by the fact that there is less than 200 teaching days in a year vs 250 working days in the private sector.
3. The real issue was the banking of this excessive benefit for a cash payout for half a years pay.
4. In the private sector if sick days are not used in a calander year they can not be ank & no way in hell can you cash them out.

Given the provinces dire financial state, eliminating this wasteful and absurd perk was long over-due

Teachers should have been thanking their lucky stars that a wage frezze and elimination of the sick days banking were the only restraint o their excessive compensation
I would been far more aggressive in restructuring thier comp package to reflect a more equitable use of taxpayers hard earned dollars

So teachers are using kids as pawns because they are being prevented from abusing the taxpayer one last time via the banking of sick days?

It is pretty obvious we need
a) a new agreement with teachers
b) or a completly new group of people to accept resonsibility for educating our youth.
The current group is obviously more preoccupied with extorting the taxpayer instead of developing young minds
 
1. The number of sick days a teacher currently gets is excesive 20 -30 (please correct me if you know the specific number), even if they spend time with snot filed little germ generators.
The private sector the norm is 5 days a year
2. The ratio of sick days available to days worked for teachers is then inflated further by the fact that there is less than 200 teaching days in a year vs 250 working days in the private sector.
3. The real issue was the banking of this excessive benefit for a cash payout for half a years pay.
4. In the private sector if sick days are not used in a calander year they can not be ank & no way in hell can you cash them out.

Given the provinces dire financial state, eliminating this wasteful and absurd perk was long over-due

Teachers should have been thanking their lucky stars that a wage frezze and elimination of the sick days banking were the only restraint o their excessive compensation
I would been far more aggressive in restructuring thier comp package to reflect a more equitable use of taxpayers hard earned dollars

So teachers are using kids as pawns because they are being prevented from abusing the taxpayer one last time via the banking of sick days?

It is pretty obvious we need
a) a new agreement with teachers
b) or a completly new group of people to accept resonsibility for educating our youth.
The current group is obviously more preoccupied with extorting the taxpayer instead of developing young minds

They get 20 a year. I work private sector, I get over two weeks of sick leave a year, I can bank it and it's paid out on retirement, and I'm only exposed to 30 or so people in my job. So...you can't say private can't bank or payout...some can. Just because you can't doesn't mean that's how things should be.

This is my problem with people sticking their nose in other people's bargaining: if they don't get it, no one should. I get it, your jealous of teachers' benefits. Instead of trying to take away from them, though, why don't you just try and add to yours? I had the same problem when my company was in the news asking the government for pension relief. Every single comment was about how pensions are unaffordable, how they bankrupt companies, how no one else has a pension and how I should lose mine. None of these outsiders had the facts. My pension fund is overfunded (almost 120% and increasing year on year), my company is protected from bankruptcy. The issue is that the government changed how some calculations were made and money needed to be rebalanced. That's all. When my company asked for pension relief, they were asking for relief on regulations. Instead of rebalancing by Sept 1st, they asked for an extra year to meet new government regulations based on how the math is done, with nothing to do about asking for money from the government.

But no one cared...because they don't have a pension, neither should I.

Sorry, that's absolute horseshit, as is your argument that non-teaching jobs don't have this sick leave. Guess what? If they're non-teaching jobs, you're comparing apples and oranges. If the teachers demands really are unrealistic and not in line with the economic situation and comparable industries, an arbitrator will take that away.

But the government knew arbitration wouldn't get them everything they wanted. So instead of doing that, following democratic process and bargaining rights, they passed a law instead. Maybe 20 days is too much, maybe the should be a limit on what's bankable...but how would a politician know? Let the bargaining committees do their jobs, and if it fails, go to arbitration. Why do you feel it's ok for the government to take away their rights? Why do you feel arbitration wasn't feasible? Or are you simply jealous they get better benefits and want to see the, taken away?
 
Economics 101

Originally Posted by FAST
NO,...but their wage should NOT be determined simply by black mailing individual citizens and weak governments.

FAST



And their new contract should NOT be determined without negotiation.

OK FRANK and dtjohnst,...got a question for ya,...how would you describe the outcome of the "negotiaions" that recently transpired between the BIG 3 and the unions ???

FAST
 
OK FRANK,...got a question for ya,...how would you describe the outcome of the "negotiaions" that recently transpired between the BIG 3 and the unions ???

FAST

The point is that there's a process in place when talks fail, particularly for public employees, where an expert is brought in, hears both cases, and then makes a ruling. Where was this process? Why did the government just pass a law instead?
 
Real world economics 101

The point is that there's a process in place when talks fail, particularly for public employees, where an expert is brought in, hears both cases, and then makes a ruling. Where was this process? Why did the government just pass a law instead?

You did not answer my question !!!

An "expert",...in what,...???

FAST
 
I just wanted to add Dr. John's input as an outsider who isn't a teacher is spot on, most of JohnLarue's nonsense is just rhetoric and hate on a group that he seems as getting goodies that he should be entitled to. Also years back during the Harris government, the teacher unions offered to give up the right to strike forever in return for every time there was a labour dispute it would have gone to an arbitrator. The government refused seeing that the majority of the time the arbitrator sides with the employees.
 
You did not answer my question !!!

An "expert",...in what,...???

FAST

Labour relations within that field. You do know arbitrators are highly speciaized, right? An erbitrator specializing in education knows what the results of contract talks are the world over, they know what benefits exist everywhere, they know the economic situation of where they work, they have information on sick leave bank sizes and usage rates, how many are certified by doctors, they know vacation usage, etc.

Is that "expert" enough for you? It is for me. If you need more info, just look into binding arbitration. My company, for example, has a list of arbitrators. If we can't reach an agreement, we (the bargaining group) go thorough their list and select one. We also have some room to move if we don't like their list (though their list is very comprehensive, so we don't usually have a problem).
 
Find an hour a month to volunteer? I might be able to but I'm someone you could hardly call selfish. I have a wife and kids and 2 elderly parents (90+) who I look after on a daily basis. This includes putting out their meds every day, grocery shopping, making sure they have 3 meals a day, taking them to doctors' appointments, doing their laundry and the list goes on. Did I mention I have a my family? So yes, finding an hour a month to volunteer for me, is a big deal.

And are there teachers with families and elderly parents who need constant care? Should those teachers be forced to volunteer when you aren't?
 
If teachers only want to be paid for their work. . .
Then put a time clock at the front door and punch them in & out. Therefore a teacher working 6 hours a day for 194 days would receive at $83,000 per year $71.30 per hour. As for all the preparation time, if you teach grade 4 then teach grade 4 for the next thirty years and you should have it down pat.
Secondly, I would like to see a middle-aged teacher take their English or History BA out on the market and see what sort of job they could receive. I f I was hiring for my business I would rather employ a 2 year graduate with a business diploma and no experience compared to a union-schooled thirty year veteran of the ETFO. I know which one would get along with the public better.
Lastly consider this;
194 school days in the year @ 6 hours per day = 1,164 hours
24 hrs/ day x 365 = 8,760 less two weeks holiday = 8,424 hours
Therefore schools are functioning for 13.8% of the year. The other 86% are paying fixed costs with no results.
If this were a business I would close the schools and outsource education to the Chinese!
 
They get 20 a year. I work private sector, I get over two weeks of sick leave a year, I can bank it and it's paid out on retirement, and I'm only exposed to 30 or so people in my job. So...you can't say private can't bank or payout...some can. Just because you can't doesn't mean that's how things should be.
That is the first exampl of anyone in the private sector being able to bank sick days
It certainly is not the norm

This is my problem with people sticking their nose in other people's bargaining: if they don't get it, no one should. I get it, your jealous of teachers' benefits.

Not jealous.
I just do not want to fund such an excess through my taxes
It takes a full years Ont taxes from six or seven average taxpayers to fund the banked sick days payout for one teacher
Or it takes the last seven years of Ont taxes from one average taxpayer to fund one payout
That is madness and it has to stop
This is a concept public sector employees can not seem to grasp

Instead of trying to take away from them, though, why don't you just try and add to yours?
That is economicaly unfeasable
If every employee in Ont were to recieve this excess, thousands of jobs would vanish and many small companies would fold

This excessive benefit should never have been granted in the first place

I had the same problem when my company was in the news asking the government for pension relief. Every single comment was about how pensions are unaffordable, how they bankrupt companies, how no one else has a pension and how I should lose mine. None of these outsiders had the facts. My pension fund is overfunded (almost 120% and increasing year on year), my company is protected from bankruptcy. The issue is that the government changed how some calculations were made and money needed to be rebalanced. That's all. When my company asked for pension relief, they were asking for relief on regulations. Instead of rebalancing by Sept 1st, they asked for an extra year to meet new government regulations based on how the math is done, with nothing to do about asking for money from the government
.

Again you are expecting me to fund your pension through my taxes
No thanks
Wht is that so difficult to understand ?

But no one cared...because they don't have a pension, neither should I.
That is a simplistic and incorrect child like view

Sorry, that's absolute horseshit, as is your argument that non-teaching jobs don't have this sick leave. Guess what? If they're non-teaching jobs, you're comparing apples and oranges.

It is not horseshit.
It is irresponsible of the govt to waste taxpayers hard earned tax dollars on any excessive benefit for any public employee group

oh, they are teachers, lets give them
a) transportation allowance to get them to work on time
b) a breakfast and lunch allowance- lord knows they should have to eat caferteria food
c) a reinbursement for the tuition fees and living expenses they spent to gain thier qualifications
Why ?- because they are teachers and will not do their job if they do not get what they want. i.e it is a teaching job

Can the government afford all of these benefits?
That is not at all relavant, if and only if you are a public empolyee

QUOTE]If the teachers demands really are unrealistic and not in line with the economic situation and comparable industries, an arbitrator will take that away. [/QUOTE]

The province is broke and running deficts
Teachers total compensation is double that of the average taxpayer (remember the ones who have to fund the banking of sick days, the excessive salary ($83K), the 10 weeks vacation and the gold plated pension)
Only a fool or someone with a vested interest will not recognize this demand is excessive

But the government knew arbitration wouldn't get them everything they wanted. So instead of doing that, following democratic process and bargaining rights, they passed a law instead. Maybe 20 days is too much, maybe the should be a limit on what's bankable...but how would a politician know? Let the bargaining committees do their jobs, and if it fails, go to arbitration. Why do you feel it's ok for the government to take away their rights? Why do you feel arbitration wasn't feasible?
The government passed a law for the benefit of all in Ontario including future generations
Wasteful excessive spending is not sustainable

Do teachers feel they are above the law?
Do teachers think using students as pawns will get the law changed?

Or are you simply jealous they get better benefits and want to see the, taken away

I will spell it out for one more time
I expect my tax dollars to be spent responsibly
 
I just wanted to add Dr. John's input as an outsider who isn't a teacher is spot on, most of JohnLarue's nonsense is just rhetoric and hate on a group that he seems as getting goodies that he should be entitled to. Also years back during the Harris government, the teacher unions offered to give up the right to strike forever in return for every time there was a labour dispute it would have gone to an arbitrator. The government refused seeing that the majority of the time the arbitrator sides with the employees.

Please specifiy exactly what you think is rhetoric?


Lets be clear, this is not about jelously, it is about responsible use of tax dollars, especially when running deficts

Re arbitrator sides with employees the majoriy of the time
then there is something a-miss about the arbitration process
a 50:50 split would be expected, statistically
 
Teachers total compensation is double that of the average taxpayer

Would think the teacher’s total compensation was closer to 4x the average taxpayer when benefits are included. Not many taxpayers have summers off and can retire in their mid 50s on about 50K/year pension that’s indexed to inflation.