That sounds like an argument for communism.
If communism means commen sence - then sign me up.
That sounds like an argument for communism.
If communism means commen sence - then sign me up.
not sure how full school voucher would solve the problem.
Currently there are ways to get your kid to go to a school outside of your zone.
And many of the "top" schools are that way, not because of great teachers but because of the community. It the community is we;; educated/affluent/appreciate school you'll see that reflected in test scores. Similarly, the worst schools are usually associated with less affluent/less educated communities.
Same goes for private schools.... the teachers are no better there. In some cases the parent is paying for a good mark (i.e. inflated) and many cases the parent is paying for less qualified teachers as the rules for hiring is more lax. Again success in that scenario is more to do with the parent than the school their kid went to. If they have the 15 to 30k to spend on private school.... they could easily pay for tuturs and whatever else if their kid went to public school.... hell some of them pay the tuition and still get tutors and other extracurriculars outside of the school.
So yes a voucher would allow people to choose a school but ultimately the kid's success is strongly rooted in their parents. But I will admit that for kid who might get into the wrong crowd this might help but that asumes there's a school with only nice kids and I find that hard to believe.
You are on glue
They are grossly overpaid and is the critical issue relavant to any discussion wrt teachers and the service they do or do not deliever
Graciously ? What a pile of shit
They are better at extortion than preparing our youth for the future
False arguements?
No it is an average of $83K
That is a fact
Far from solved
The province is broke and can no longer afford to keep compensating this group at this level.
That is a fact which you do not seem to able to comprehend
Perhpas your economics teacher in high school did not educate you properly
I doubt it. As it is we practically have a voucher system now where schools with affluent parents have fundraising for all the things the school needs, moving into new school districts, or finding ways to lie about their home address, while the others have 15 year old computers. Vouchers would end up with some schools with too many applicants based on the perception of the school, not the reality and will become selective in admissions. It will still end up being rich areas having better schools. If you took the programs and even the teachers from a rich kid school and move the program to a poor area the new school won't have the same results because when it comes down to it, parents have far more impact on kids success than anything else. Parents who are home for dinner, help their kids with homework, provide academic role models, and provide any resources or tutoring they need tend to have better results than kids who's parents work two jobs and don't have the time or money available or kids who's parents just don't give a damn. Vouchers won't fix that problem and will actually make it worse since public school boards make an attempt to spread resources more evenly.
Radically different, indeed. The public system would have to compete for students. Education would become commercialized.
I'm all for capitalism. But the balance would be delicate. There would be very real danger that the public system collapses because its social responsibilities.
1 it would help outsiders like gays be allowed to go to a gay friendly school , as well as the bright go to a school where "it is cool to be smart", as well as religious schools as well as athletic schools, as well a cultural schools, as well as ....
no more melting pot educational concepts unless that is what you want the then free enterprise will supply it
2 alternative educational concepts like montessori and waldorf will be affordable to everyone and other alternative educational concepts will now flourish now that public schools no longer have a stranglehold on 90% of all educational monies
look if the private school is a bad school do your research and do not go as with freedom comes responsibility there is no way around it
it just makes sense freedom is better than government forced anything as people will choose with the ultimate vote that of the $$$$$$
i may be wrong but
my question is why has not this possibility of educational freedom been deeply studied by the big brother that has forced public schools upon us then claims they want only the best educational system possible while refusing to study all possibilities that does not include them !????!
TDSB has a gay friendly school, there are schools with enriched programing and academifcs, and there are catholic schools and there are athletic schools and as for culture well that's sort of there.... e.g. certain schools are predominantly certain races..... oh and there's the all black school in Toronto.
In short they exist and if you want to go there you can. There are simple ways around being forced to go to the school in your area. The abusive side of it is kids who go to a certain school to be a part of a team. I don't really care one way or the other just saying it can and does happen (the concept of free to choose your school). Most parents don't do it because it means having to find a way to get their kid to a school outside of their area.
As for alternative models I'd like to see proof that they were more effective.... otherwise the public system would adopt it.
If you want to get rid of the "monopoly" of public school it's quite simple get rid of it. But then the problem becomes if you can't afford a good school you are screwed.
So basically all government employeees should make in and around the avergae Canadian?
You've thought about it? Well, think some more about it, and how to actually MAKE such a suggestion work in real life. There's NO possible way.
I suggest you've not thought this through - just figure everyone should do something additional outside of the classroom.
Your reply regarding my possible scenario is interesting. The issue is NOT about unions, it is about addressing the possibility of having a teacher being FORCED to do an activity they know nothing about. As far as remember, teachers would run activities that they enjoyed running, and they knew something about those activities. Not all teachers would run afterschool activities.
I'm not a teacher and work a job that often goes well beyond 9-5 but still find time to volunteer. I do work with kids outside of schools fairly regularly and do a few weekends a year for other charities. I used to do more when my job allowed but the changes didn't stop me from finding time. It's a choice. You could easily find an hour a month to volunteer somewhere if you cared. There are many organizations that need volunteers at all sorts of different times of day. I'm sure they'd be glad if you gave some time....
If I was a teacher and had a week off at Christmas, a week off for March break, PA days and the summer off, I'd be happy to volunteer for a few hours a couple days a week....
...
it just makes sense freedom is better than government forced anything as people will choose with the ultimate vote that of the $$$$$$...
perhaps but i can not see this happening myself...
To be perfectly fair here, there is no action teachers can take that doesn't punish the kids. Strike, work to rule, cut out extras....their job is 100% for the kids. What would you suggest they do?
.
There is already a pseudo-voucher system in place where the wealthy and powerful compete to get their kids into programs and schools they think are better. The news just had a story about a couple that moved into a more expensive area to get their kids into a French immersion program. Of course these schools perceived as better will fill up meaning that many will have to go elsewhere and as frank noted, the academic reputation is based more on the wealth of the students than any programs the school offers. My high school was filled with unmotivated teachers and very few who ran extra-curricular programs and most of whom sprinted out the door at 3:15. Being in a well off area though, the school still managed to have a high graduation rate, a high percentage of Ontario Scholars, and a good reputation that had nothing to do with the school itself. Vouchers won't change that, just take money away from programs that help those without the benefit of living with Ward and June Cleaver.
Public schooling is a part of society that ensures that everyone has equal access to education. Of course it doesn't do a perfect job of it but taking money out of the system to benefit special interest groups is just going to make it worse.
I suggest teachers
a) put the interest of the students first and foremost
b) stop using kids as pawns (that is so dispicable-shame on the lot of them)
c) recognize they are extremely well compensated
d) recognize there is no chance in hell they could command such a compensation anywhere else
e) recognize the province will soon face huge increases in health care costs and must get its expenses under control
f) recognize taxpayers have zero appetite for tax increases to continue overpaying teachers or any other public employees
e) quit whining
john your argument of economic disparity makes sense but ...
i find it stunning that intelligent right wingers like you will scream about a worker ant making a few $ more than other worker ants because they belong to a union while the wealthy own so much and yet you defend the rich
if you believe this inequality can go on then you are the one on glue and tearing apart unions is not the solution to social inequality
QUOTE]
You are dreaming in technicolor
Overpaying the public sector is not a solution to social inequality
Just look at the results
The province is broke
1/3 of the expenses go to education, the majority of that sum goes to teachers
The province is going to face huge increases in Health care costs in the next 5 years
Unless public service unions become more reasonable, we will have a health care crisis
If you think asking over-paid teachers to take a wage freeze for two years is a form of social inequality, then I suspect you will be very alarmed, when your Aunt has to wait six- nine months or pay for her exploratory surgury.
You can not have both and fools like you ignore the reality there is a cost for every social agenda.
Are you willing to sacrific the health care safety net of the province to ensure teachers contine to be over-paid?
Make no mistake, this is the choice