Teacher Appreciation Week? You've got to be joking!

as a teacher I would like to move to the bizarro world where JohnLarue lives where the average teacher makes 83k plus a year, what colour is the sky there? are there unicorns, leprechauns and vampires too? Because it's not the one I live on and none of the teachers I know unless they have a decade minimum of experience along with their 5 years of university education.

http://www.nucleuslearning.com/node/3158

As a taxpayer I would like to point out how disapointed I am that you would dare to challenge what is saddly a fact
That $ 83 K is probably closer to $100K cost once the cost of the outrageous benefits are included

I will assume you do not have the experience deemed a requirement to extort that much from taxpayers.
A secondary concern is that you appear mis-informed wrt how much your union costs the province
A third is a teacher not understanding the critical issue in such a well publicized dispute.
We can only hope you are better informed about the subject matter you are teaching

A decade of experience is nothing and the 5 years of university education gets you an interview in the private sector (maybe) , but not $83K + gold plated benefits + the summer off

Yet Teachers feel that extra-ciricular activities are asking too much?
Shame on the lot of you for using kids as pawns in your extortion of the taxpayer

The average taxpayer in Ontario makes $43-48K.
Please do not lose sight of the fact that it takes the full year Ont taxes of three average taxpayers to fund the average teacher during the summer months when the average teacher addeds zero value.
This is maddness and will need to be corrected
 
The average taxpayer in Ontario makes $43-48K.
Please do not lose sight of the fact that it takes the full year Ont taxes of three average taxpayers to fund the average teacher during the summer months when the average teacher addeds zero value.
This is maddness and will need to be corrected


This is a metric that needs to be more widely used to communicate what things really cost.
 
i said

extraciricular work is volunteer

weather teachers are overpaid or underpaid is a different disscussion

You are on glue
They are grossly overpaid and is the critical issue relavant to any discussion wrt teachers and the service they do or do not deliever


they have graciously worked for free and now they say no more free work and you dump on them with false arguments instead of thanking them for the free work the have done in the past
they also work overtime helping students (at least the good ones do) and they get no thanks for that either
they also work in a crap environment where all students, the bright, the troublemakers, the dumb, the nerds, the macho slobs and racists etc are thrown together in an absurd environment and they have to teach in that nonsense
full school vouchers for all
public schools can compete for those vouchers with private education and learn to swim or sink

Graciously ? What a pile of shit
They are better at extortion than preparing our youth for the future

False arguements?
No it is an average of $83K
That is a fact

problem solved

Far from solved
The province is broke and can no longer afford to keep compensating this group at this level.
That is a fact which you do not seem to able to comprehend
Perhpas your economics teacher in high school did not educate you properly
 
For the students

Just in time for March break, nice. Hope they keep it up and stop taking out their frustration with the Liberal Government on the kids. Talk about losing the support of parents and in the court of public opinion.

But teachers go in and do "preperation" etc. etc, during March break don't they ???

FAST
 
the question is would school vouchers actually result in better education than forced public schools

I doubt it. As it is we practically have a voucher system now where schools with affluent parents have fundraising for all the things the school needs, moving into new school districts, or finding ways to lie about their home address, while the others have 15 year old computers. Vouchers would end up with some schools with too many applicants based on the perception of the school, not the reality and will become selective in admissions. It will still end up being rich areas having better schools. If you took the programs and even the teachers from a rich kid school and move the program to a poor area the new school won't have the same results because when it comes down to it, parents have far more impact on kids success than anything else. Parents who are home for dinner, help their kids with homework, provide academic role models, and provide any resources or tutoring they need tend to have better results than kids who's parents work two jobs and don't have the time or money available or kids who's parents just don't give a damn. Vouchers won't fix that problem and will actually make it worse since public school boards make an attempt to spread resources more evenly.
 
Just in time for March break, nice. Hope they keep it up and stop taking out their frustration with the Liberal Government on the kids. Talk about losing the support of parents and in the court of public opinion.

You are upset that teachers are once again VOLUNTEERING their time? I'm sure you've been out there volunteering as well.


(And yes, outside my private sector job, I find the time for a few hours a week volunteering)
 
JohnLarue said:
The average taxpayer in Ontario makes $43-48K.
Please do not lose sight of the fact that it takes the full year Ont taxes of three average taxpayers to fund the average teacher during the summer months when the average teacher addeds zero value.
This is maddness and will need to be corrected
This is a metric that needs to be more widely used to communicate what things really cost.

That sounds like an argument for communism.
 
Looks around. Sees nothing new. Bites tongue. Leaves.
 
You are upset that teachers are once again VOLUNTEERING their time? I'm sure you've been out there volunteering as well.


(And yes, outside my private sector job, I find the time for a few hours a week volunteering)

I'm not upset that teachers are starting to once again VOLUNTEER their time, I'm pissed that they've punished the kids as a result of a beef with the government. They never had a problem VOLUNTEERING before!

If I was a teacher and had a week off at Christmas, a week off for March break, PA days and the summer off, I'd be happy to volunteer for a few hours a couple days a week. It's funny how teachers only stopped "volunteering" when they didn't get their way. When parents stepped up and offer to volunteer their time for extracurricular activities, they were told it's against school policy. How absurd!

I would gladly offer to volunteer my time for other causes, but my personal situation doesn't afford me the time.
 
Last edited:
I'm not upset that teachers are starting to once again VOLUNTEER their time, I'm pissed that they've punish the kids as a result of a beef with the government. They never had a problem VOLUNTEERING before!

If I was a teacher and had a week off at Christmas, a week off for March break, PA days and the summer off, I'd be happy to volunteer for a few hours a couple days a week. It's funny how teachers only stopped "volunteering" when they didn't get their way. When parents stepped up and offer to volunteer their time for extracurricular activities, they were told it's against school policy. How absurd!

I would gladly offer to volunteer my time for other causes, but my personal situation doesn't afford me the time.

To be perfectly fair here, there is no action teachers can take that doesn't punish the kids. Strike, work to rule, cut out extras....their job is 100% for the kids. What would you suggest they do?

Here's the problem I have with what happened: the teachers were forced to accept a deal through legislation instead of the proper avenues of collective bargaining. We would and should be pissed if themgovernment did that to us. It matters not who your employer is, the government can do it to any of us. What I want to know is why, when two sides couldn't reach agreement, wasn't binding arbitration gone to as per the norm?

Better yet, you claim to be upset about compensation, yet the teachers proposed a wage freeze and were forced to take a pay raise.

I live in a democratic society, not communist China. So explain to me why the government is passing legislation instead of following the democratic practice of collective bargaining. My company is involved in pension debates because they're expensive. My company also posts record profits and our pension is overfunded. N arbitrator would ever take away a pension that's properly funded. But what's to stop the government from just passing a law and taking it away anyway?

We, the people, are the only thing that will stop it. But not if we selfishly put our head in the sand and decide some groups are overpaid so whatever happens to them we're going to cheer the government for putting them in their place. No one is issued at the goernment because they think teachers are underpaid. They are pissed because the government bypassed the democratic process workers in Canada have and went straight to barking orders.
 
This is the assmuption that all teachers didn't do anything but the bare minimum. And for some the bare minimum of teaching their kid to read and write is still pretty good and doing after school activities is just gravy or not even relevant. Think about it for a minute how many kids does extracurriculars affect? For the ones that were affect it was a shame no doubt about it but clearly it was not enough otherwise it would have been a more effective bargaining tool than it worked out to be.
 
teachers do not get paid for extraciricular so how can you be mad at them for refusng to work for free ????


that seems totally unreasonable

It seems clear to me that extracurricular activities need to become part of the curriculum or part of the labour contract the government has with the teacher unions. Obviously they will not like it so legislate it.
 
Extracurriculars are part of the social contract between public school teachers and the public who pay the bill for their services. The job of being a teacher includes as responsibility to the children, regardless of whether every minute spent with students is paid or not.

Being allowed to negotiate was also part of the social contract. It's the only leverage the teachers had because they couldn't withhold anything that htey were contractually obligated to do.

and the teacher''s responsibility to a child is from a little before school starts and ends unless on a field trip that goes beyond the school day. Being respponsible for a kid during extracurriculars only occurs if the teacher agrees to take on the voluntary task.
 
Because the aveage parent makes $45K for working 12 months a year, while a teacher makes $83 + excessive benefits for working 9 1/2 months
The parents should expect far more value for thier hard earned tax dollars

You are not very bright are you ?

So basically all government employeees should make in and around the avergae Canadian?
 
Yes, I appreciated the 20% of my teachers who were awesome educators, but the union protected the 80% who were slackers or incompetent.[/FONT][/COLOR]

So then let's address that problem. The problem being the union protecting deadwood. To me it's not an issue of salary. I'm fine with what they make, I'm not fine with less than adequate people taking spots from better deserving people. The pool is deep enough that you could have better teachers on average if firing the dead wood.
 
And what's the big deal much like extracurriculars was voluntary so is teacher appreciation. There's no pressure to give a gift. There is not 100% compliance for xmas or end of year in elementary and far less given out in high school if anything at all.
 
That article read more like an editorial but chalk it up to the Sun to call this news. That article was biased by the writer's opinions. Print it but let's put it in the right section.
 
not sure how full school voucher would solve the problem.

Currently there are ways to get your kid to go to a school outside of your zone.

And many of the "top" schools are that way, not because of great teachers but because of the community. It the community is we;; educated/affluent/appreciate school you'll see that reflected in test scores. Similarly, the worst schools are usually associated with less affluent/less educated communities.

Same goes for private schools.... the teachers are no better there. In some cases the parent is paying for a good mark (i.e. inflated) and many cases the parent is paying for less qualified teachers as the rules for hiring is more lax. Again success in that scenario is more to do with the parent than the school their kid went to. If they have the 15 to 30k to spend on private school.... they could easily pay for tuturs and whatever else if their kid went to public school.... hell some of them pay the tuition and still get tutors and other extracurriculars outside of the school.

So yes a voucher would allow people to choose a school but ultimately the kid's success is strongly rooted in their parents. But I will admit that for kid who might get into the wrong crowd this might help but that asumes there's a school with only nice kids and I find that hard to believe.
 
Piratos,

Well, it is NOT clear to me. Think about it: You CAN'T make volunteering a forced part of a contract (or "part of the curriculum"???!!!).

Imagine at the next prinicipal's meeting with 63 year old Mrs. Jones (who has only taught English for the last 35+ years, and has no athletic ability whatsoever)

"Mrs. Jones, I need someone to coach Senior Boy's Football.
I know you don't have any experience, but, there's nobody else on staff that does.
They've all chosen other clubs and sports to supervise, so the only thing left is Football.
Since it's part of your contractual obligations, you're going to have to coach the Senior Boys Football team this year. Good Luck!"
-----------

Yeah, right. I wanna know what you boys have been drinkin' – I'm lookin' for somthin' good.


Think about it: You CAN'T make volunteering a forced part of a contract (or "part of the curriculum"???!!!).

Thought about it. By definition it wouldn't be "volunteering" any longer would it?

"Mrs. Jones, I need someone to coach Senior Boy's Football.
I know you don't have any experience, but, there's nobody else on staff that does.
They've all chosen other clubs and sports to supervise, so the only thing left is Football.
Since it's part of your contractual obligations, you're going to have to coach the Senior Boys Football team this year. Good Luck!"

Good point. I sure that in protest the unions would do all in their power to encourage such a situation.
 
You've thought about it? Well, think some more about it, and how to actually MAKE such a suggestion work in real life. There's NO possible way.
I suggest you've not thought this through - just figure everyone should do something additional outside of the classroom.

Your reply regarding my possible scenario is interesting. The issue is NOT about unions, it is about addressing the possibility of having a teacher being FORCED to do an activity they know nothing about. As far as remember, teachers would run activities that they enjoyed running, and they knew something about those activities. Not all teachers would run afterschool activities.

This is a good point.

There was a point a page or so back from Celticman (I think?) regarding it becoming customary practice for teachers to do extracurricular activities. This is true. Also, it's the expectation of all students going into teachers college, I'm sure. I can't imagine anyone going into the teaching profession not having been inspired to do so by at least one selfless and generous teacher in their past. This volunteered time notion isn't, in the least!, forced upon anyone. Nor is it an unreasonable thing for us to expect of the profession. At all.

The union is an enormous.... ENORMOUS business. Look up the companies of which it's a big shareholder or even owner. I admit, I haven't, but I know of at least one big telecom company it helped take over.

The teaching profession include expectations to be a role model. A role model to young people. Good role models are generous with their time and energy. It's a LESSON they teach students... Students who sometimes go on to be teachers... Students expect it and parents expect it and we expect it because we should.

Right now only 10% of students at teachers college can expect teaching jobs. You know why? Because of cutbacks in schools and fewer jobs. One (not the only) reason these jobs are scarce is the way the union has bullied their way to overcompensation for teachers over the years.

The same thing happened with manufacturing and the entitlement brought on by the overpowered unions.

I'm looking forward to sending my kids to school where their teachers are gonna Skype their lessons from India.

Yay over fed unions!