Tough call...
You got baseball ...which has turned players into situational stars...I.e long relievers ...Set up guys..closers in pitching
defensive specialists...I.e late inning players, used for their defence ...
offensive players...switch hitters..pinch hitters...and the like...so baseball is out...unless there is 1a player who won the triple crown and also won gold gloves in more than 1 position
Hockey...hmmm..scorers...players who are muckers ..defensive forwards ...offensive defencemen...defensive defenceman.....penalty killers....
in hockey it would have to be a player skilled at more than 1of these...and again a multiple leader in some categories
I would lean towards a basketball player who can play all 3 forward positions very well...plus some back court skills too....so I would say either lebron or maybe D. Howard.....