Banning Items to Save lives

Banning which of the following would save the most lives in the US?

  • "Assault" Weapons

    Votes: 6 24.0%
  • Cigarets

    Votes: 12 48.0%
  • Alcohol

    Votes: 2 8.0%
  • Cats

    Votes: 5 20.0%

  • Total voters
    25
lol

At the bottom of the article you sited there's a link to another article..

Here are some quotes from that article
“Since 1982, there have been at least 61 mass murders carried out with firearms across the country, with the killings unfolding in 30 states from Massachusetts to Hawaii,” they found. And in most cases, the killers had obtained their weapons legally:

The Harvard Injury Control Research Center assessed the literature on guns and homicide and found that there’s substantial evidence that indicates more guns means more murders.

Last year, economist Richard Florida dove deep into the correlations between gun deaths and other kinds of social indicators. Some of what he found was, perhaps, unexpected: Higher populations, more stress, more immigrants, and more mental illness were not correlated with more deaths from gun violence. But one thing he found was, perhaps, perfectly predictable: States with tighter gun control laws appear to have fewer gun-related deaths.

Maybe next time you shouldn't be quoting from the Washington Post to support your wild minded right-wing claims?
 
lol

At the bottom of the article you sighted there's a link to another article..

Here are some quotes from that article






Maybe next time you shouldn't be quoting from the Washington Post to support your wild minded right-wing claims?

And what do you think the weapon of choice is for mass murderers. At least recently.
 
lol

At the bottom of the article you sited there's a link to another article..

Here are some quotes from that article






Maybe next time you shouldn't be quoting from the Washington Post to support your wild minded right-wing claims?

So nothing on "Assault" rifles then eh.... that's the point of this conversation, that these laws will have no impact on a country with 200M guns...

OTB
 
So nothing on "Assault" rifles then eh.... that's the point of this conversation, that these laws will have no impact on a country with 200M guns...

OTB

No, the point you were trying to make was that ANY ban on assault rifles would be pointless..
My answer is that banning something "assault" rifles, that will have no effect on gun deaths isn't doing something about a problem and that there are things that could be banned that would have far larger impact.

As I illustrated in post # 60, that's not the case. The Australian government banned assault rifles (properly) and saw a huge reduction in gun related deaths.

So, no, you are wrong. A ban on assault rifles (if done properly) WOULD result in fewer gun related deaths.

Your argument now seems to be that it is impossible for the United States to get their shit together and actually go about banning assault rifles properly.. And that's also not true.. It's not IMPOSSIBLE, just highly unlikely given your problematic ratio of rednecks to regular people.

Maybe what your government wants to do is a waste of money.. Big deal.. It's money wasted trying to save lives.. It's not like the other side is coming up with a better way.. At most your best argument is "Why bother doing anything.. We're spiraling out of control so quickly now there's no stopping us."
 
And what do you think the weapon of choice is for mass murderers. At least recently.

Bombs? Certainly those who carry off the biggest murders use bombs.

I don't think Timothy McVeigh would have been able to kill 168 people and wounded a further 450 with only an AR-15.
 
Bombs? Certainly those who carry off the biggest murders use bombs.

I don't think Timothy McVeigh would have been able to kill 168 people and wounded a further 450 with only an AR-15.

Fortunately explosives are heavily watched and regulated, so these kinds of attacks are very, very rare.
Guns?
Easy peasy.
 
My answer is that banning something "assault" rifles, that will have no effect on gun deaths
That is debatatable.


that there are things that could be banned that would have far larger impact.OTB
One might think so, but as you can see with what's happening in the U.S. the people are concerned about guns, not your other dangerous activities. Sounds like you might need lobbyists for these other dangers but right now the people are demanding that guns be dealt with.

Once again, this proves that comparisons with other dangerous scenarios mean absolutely nothing because the people have already made their choice. Guns and only guns is on their mind.
 
That is debatatable.

The studies have concluded it had no impact... but your correct, it's debatable - oddly enough that's never the debate, it's always an emotional anecdote capped with "no one needs......"


One might think so, but as you can see with what's happening in the U.S. the people are concerned about guns, not your other dangerous activities. Sounds like you might need lobbyists for these other dangers but right now the people are demanding that guns be dealt with.

Once again, this proves that comparisons with other dangerous scenarios mean absolutely nothing because the people have already made their choice. Guns and only guns is on their mind.

This tends to be a fickle issue and in the past it's been dangerous for a politician, due to people having made up their mind, to vote this way.

OTB
 
The studies have concluded it had no impact...
OTB

The studies proved NO SUCH THING! The "study" proved that THAT particular assault rifle ban had no effect on gun related deaths.. The article you sited also went on to illustrate why... Basically it wasn't a ban, it was an irritant that the gun manufacturers had to deal with for a while.

I'm telling you that if you were able to get assault rifles out of the hands of Americans there would be fewer gun related deaths.
 
I'm telling you that if you were able to get assault rifles out of the hands of Americans there would be fewer gun related deaths.

You're trying to solve a problem that already kills fewer people every year than lightning strikes do. I think you are over-selling this claim that it will lead to fewer gun related deaths.

If you want to do something about gun crime in the United States, and you want it to be statistically significant, it is somehow going to have to impact gang related shootings with handguns. Nothing else really will show up in the stats...
 
Which of these would you consider to be an assault rifle?

A:
m1a.jpg



B:
m1a_sage_ebr_c.gif


Neither? Both? One or the other?

They are the same rifle, with a different stock attached.
 
You're trying to solve a problem that already kills fewer people every year than lightning strikes do.
The problem is with guns not lightning.

The people want something done about guns, and apparently assault rifles are a part of the gun family. The president proposed a number of strategies yesterday. It was a package and assault rifles are part of that package. The results to look at will be how the overall package performs and probably thereafter fine tune it as needed.

It is a complex problem with many causes and it is impossible to get a perfect solution right away. But something must be attempted as opposed to the gun advocates who support no idea as being effective and in effect support a status quo. The American public is not happy with the status quo even if lightning causes more deaths.
 
(Besides lightning being a highly regulated area) How many people each year are victims of lightning crimes? 260,000 Americans are victims of gun crimes each year.
 
Because you say so?

I think it is reasonable to say that something that kills fewer people than lightning is not really a problem at all.

About 115,000 Americans were killed by gunfire over the last decade.
Its a bit of a problem.
 
About 115,000 Americans were killed by gunfire over the last decade.
Its a bit of a problem.

However the topic was mass shootings with assault rifles, which results in fewer deaths than lightning strikes.

If you want to reduce the other gun deaths then it will take action to reduce gang activity in general.
 
(Besides lightning being a highly regulated area) How many people each year are victims of lightning crimes? 260,000 Americans are victims of gun crimes each year.

But not with assault rifles, or are you planning to blame handgun deaths on assault rifles?
 
Because you say so?
Absolutely not, which is my point.

It is the American public that's saying they are concerned about guns. They are not concerned about lightning. They are driving the agenda. Their perception ends out becoming the reality.
 
However the topic was mass shootings with assault rifles, which results in fewer deaths than lightning strikes.

If you want to reduce the other gun deaths then it will take action to reduce gang activity in general.

Sorry, that's just a stupid distinction.
Why not limit the debate to only one caliber or something equally as cherry picking?
 
Sorry, that's just a stupid distinction.
Why not limit the debate to only one caliber or something equally as cherry picking?

So then presumably you reject the assault rifle ban as "a stupid distinction" and "cherry picking".

Well we agree on that!

However if you do want to talk about such a ban then perhaps it is relevant to point or we are talking about very few of the gun homicides.