Banning Items to Save lives

Banning which of the following would save the most lives in the US?

  • "Assault" Weapons

    Votes: 6 24.0%
  • Cigarets

    Votes: 12 48.0%
  • Alcohol

    Votes: 2 8.0%
  • Cats

    Votes: 5 20.0%

  • Total voters
    25
We need a push for cats. They are in second. Don't forget, gun proponent Ted Nugent sang "Cat Scratch Fever". He knew even back then the danger that's been lurking.
 
We need a push for cats. They are in second. Don't forget, gun proponent Ted Nugent sang "Cat Scratch Fever". He knew even back then the danger that's been lurking.

Not to mention the danger of cat guns.

How come there's not so much talk on this thread of the danger from others armed with these items. Sure, people die from tobacco smoke, but it takes 10 or 20 years of second hand smoke to kill someone else (unless you aim for the eyes with a lit cigarette after you've slowed them down with your cat gun). And booze? Sure drunk drivers take out some and angry drunks kill each other some time, but generally I'm not too worried about drunks getting me. But cat guns? Now we're talking danger.
 
Many states have banned smoking in public places or even indoors? Huge amounts of money go into anti-smoking campaigns and there is significant governmental and public backing for it.

p.s. Which government is planning on banning guns?

Huge amounts of money go into anti-smoking campaigns when the evidence is strong that diesel pollution causes lung cancer.

p.s. The Obama Administration, for one.
 
Glad to see that I'm not the only one to see the idiocy of the poll. It was OTB's attempt at making some weird point only he knew about.
 
So your answer is do nothing about a confirmed problem (gun deaths) until another problem is corrected first.

My answer is that banning something "assault" rifles, that will have no effect on gun deaths isn't doing something about a problem and that there are things that could be banned that would have far larger impact.

OTB
 
Glad to see that I'm not the only one to see the idiocy of the poll. It was OTB's attempt at making some weird point only he knew about.

No, your in the TERB majority... just look around and you decide if that's a good thing.

OTB
 
No, your in the TERB majority... just look around and you decide if that's a good thing.

OTB

As said earlier, the poll is just wrong. You are making a point with it, but not what you think.

I can't remember the last time someone was terrorized by a cat, car, or cigarette, but guns are used for that purpose all the time. You don't have to actually shoot them for a gun to make it's mark on a persons health.

One more time, but I'll type slowly if it will help, very few people are asking for a total gun ban.
 
As said earlier, the poll is just wrong. You are making a point with it, but not what you think.

I can't remember the last time someone was terrorized by a cat, car, or cigarette, but guns are used for that purpose all the time. You don't have to actually shoot them for a gun to make it's mark on a persons health.

One more time, but I'll type slowly if it will help, very few people are asking for a total gun ban.

Type as slow as you like (something tells me that isn't your problem), try reading the first option in the poll.... does it refer to a total gun ban?
 
My answer is that banning something "assault" rifles, that will have no effect on gun deaths isn't doing something about a problem and that there are things that could be banned that would have far larger impact.

OTB

You really think banning assault rifles won't have ANY impact on gun deaths?? That's weird.

Cigarettes are deadly very deadly to those that use them.. They CAN be deadly to those around them, which is why smoking inside and around most public places has been BANNED..

I'm all for assault rifle owners shooting themselves in the face.. I'd rather they not be able to shoot up a school full of children.. Seeing as how nobody buys an assault rifle to shoot themselves in the face, they should probably be banned.. You know just in case (and I know you're pretty sure it's a long shot) they're used to kill some innocent people..
 
... Who wants to bet we're going to get the "Cars kill people, should we ban THEM too?" argument from the Yank?
 
The difference is in whether the item kills the user, by accident or design, or whether the item is designed to kill others, by the user.
Kill yourself if you like, but killing others is still considered a crime (except by cat).
 
The difference is in whether the item kills the user, by accident or design, or whether the item is designed to kill others, by the user.
Kill yourself if you like, but killing others is still considered a crime (except by cat).

And cigaret and Alcohol.....

OTB
 
You really think banning assault rifles won't have ANY impact on gun deaths?? That's weird.

Not weird at all, well proven out in a 10 year ban earlier....

Did the law have an effect on crime or gun violence? While gun violence did fall in the 1990s, this was likely due to other factors. Here’s the UPenn study again: “We cannot clearly credit the ban with any of the nation’s recent drop in gun violence. And, indeed, there has been no discernible reduction in the lethality and injuriousness of gun violence.”

One reason is that assault weapons were never a huge factor in gun violence to begin with. They were used in only 2 percent to 8 percent of gun crimes. Large-capacity magazines were more important — used in as many as a quarter of gun crimes. But, again, the 1994 law left more than 24 million magazines untouched, so the impact was blunted.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs...ow-about-banning-assault-weapons-in-one-post/

Cigarettes are deadly very deadly to those that use them.. They CAN be deadly to those around them, which is why smoking inside and around most public places has been BANNED..

I'm all for assault rifle owners shooting themselves in the face.. I'd rather they not be able to shoot up a school full of children.. Seeing as how nobody buys an assault rifle to shoot themselves in the face, they should probably be banned.. You know just in case (and I know you're pretty sure it's a long shot) they're used to kill some innocent people..

Most exposure to second hand smoke, the killing of others with cigarettes, is done at home.

I'm not for anyone shooting themselves, your a bit of a monster on that topic I'm afraid, I just don't think, and the data, quite inconveniently for you is on my side here, a ban of "assault" rifles will have any impact.

OTB
 
Not weird at all, well proven out in a 10 year ban earlier....

Did the law have an effect on crime or gun violence? While gun violence did fall in the 1990s, this was likely due to other factors. Here’s the UPenn study again: “We cannot clearly credit the ban with any of the nation’s recent drop in gun violence. And, indeed, there has been no discernible reduction in the lethality and injuriousness of gun violence.”

One reason is that assault weapons were never a huge factor in gun violence to begin with. They were used in only 2 percent to 8 percent of gun crimes. Large-capacity magazines were more important — used in as many as a quarter of gun crimes. But, again, the 1994 law left more than 24 million magazines untouched, so the impact was blunted.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs...ow-about-banning-assault-weapons-in-one-post/

Aren't you really saying that the problem with the 1994 law was that there were too may exclusions?
 
Aren't you really saying that the problem with the 1994 law was that there were too may exclusions?

I'm saying that in a country with 200M guns and billions of rounds of ammo that any ban will have too many exclusions and that the only people you'll be impacting are those least likely to harm someone.

OTB
 
I'm saying that in a country with 200M guns and billions of rounds of ammo that any ban will have too many exclusions and that the only people you'll be impacting are those least likely to harm someone.

OTB

So why not start with reducing or elimination the number of exclusions. By your logic that will increase the effectiveness.
 
One reason is that assault weapons were never a huge factor in gun violence to begin with. They were used in only 2 percent to 8 percent of gun crimes. Large-capacity magazines were more important — used in as many as a quarter of gun crimes. But, again, the 1994 law left more than 24 million magazines untouched, so the impact was blunted.[/I]


They were only used in 2% to 8% of gun crimes? In a country with how many gun related deaths? Sounds like a lot of people might have lived (or not been shot so many times or with such ferocious accuracy) if these weapons weren't sold in the first place.

I don't suppose you'd care to address why these particular guns SHOULD be in the hands of common civilians?
 
I'm saying that in a country with 200M guns and billions of rounds of ammo that any ban will have too many exclusions and that the only people you'll be impacting are those least likely to harm someone.

OTB

If you wanted to get rid of guns you could do it.
Make all gun crimes punishable by life.
Make all ammo sales registered.

If you wanted to, it could be done.
 
Here are some quotes you decided not to include in your post

Experts who have studied the law tend to agree that it was rife with loopholes and generally ineffective at curbing gun violence — though it might well have reduced mass shootings.

There was, however, an important exception. Any assault weapon or magazine that was manufactured before the law went into effect in 1994 was perfectly legal to own or resell. That was a huge exception: At the time, there were roughly 1.5 million assault weapons and more than 24 million high-capacity magazines in private hands.

Did the 1994 law have loopholes? Yes, lots. Even after the ban took effect, it was not difficult for someone to get their hands on an assault weapon or high-capacity magazine.

Would it be possible to tighten the law? In theory, yes. Back in 1996, Australia imposed a much stricter version of the assault weapons ban after a mass shooting. The Australian version avoided many of the loopholes in the U.S. law: Not only did the country ban all types of semiautomatic rifles and shotguns, but it also spent $500 million buying up nearly 600,000 existing guns from private owners.
As Wonkblog’s Sarah Kliff pointed out, Australia’s law appears to have curbed gun violence. Researchers in the British Medical Journal write that the ban was “followed by more than a decade free of fatal mass shootings, and accelerated declines in firearm deaths, particularly suicides.”

What data was on your side again?