Another Tree Question

SkyRider

Banned
Mar 31, 2009
17,546
2
0
Do I have the right to trim overhanging branches from my neighbor's trees? Yes, many of the branches from her trees are overhanging on my property.
 
Do I have the right to trim overhanging branches from my neighbor's trees? Yes, many of the branches from her trees are overhanging on my property.

Its a catch-22 scenario.. yes you can trim, but if you damage the tree, you are liable.
Speak to your neighbor first!

Question Can I prune the branches from my neighbour's tree, that overhang my property?
Answer Three main points to remember when dealing with trees on adjacent private property are that:

Assuming you live in Toronto or GTA (same by-laws)
http://www.toronto.ca/faq/trees.htm#q2

1. You cannot trespass onto your neighbour's property;
2. You cannot damage your neighbour's property (in this case a tree); and
3. You have the right to maintain your property in a safe condition

* It is therefore best for property owners to come to an agreement between themselves with respect to trees overhanging property lines.
* If you are unable to reach an agreement with your neighbour and want to determine your legal rights, you should contact a lawyer.
* The act of pruning trees on neighbouring private property affects private property rights and is a civil issue between private property owners.
* The City has no jurisdiction with respect to such issues.
* Where a tree on private property is protected under the provisions of the Private Tree Bylaw, pruning of the tree is permitted provided the pruning is in accordance with good arboricultural standards. Otherwise, a permit would be required to injure or destroy the tree.
* A qualified tree expert should always be retained to carry out tree pruning.
 
Its a catch-22 scenario.. yes you can trim, but if you damage the tree, you are liable. Speak to your neighbour first…edit…
What? Be reasonable!?! What will they think of next?
 
Last edited:
So I'm good if I drop a Beaver in my neighbours yard to get rid of his dam pine tree?
 
or you could be like my former a-hole neighbour and call the city to complain. The trees overlooking his 20ft backyard are 50-60 tall and are impossible to reach. He complained they were unsafe because of some dead limbs that were present. I did my best to trim them but the city property inspector is a moron and the nightmare continued for years. The city couldn't even tell me which branches were a problem but threatened to take care of it and bill me. After all the bs, I told them to go screw themselves and do what they think they have to do. I guess they figured out how inaccessible the area is and dropped the matter.
 
What? Be reasonable!?! What will they think of next?

You need to read the city by-laws around trees more.
Did you know that once a tree goes beyond 30 cms, legally you can't cut any limbs without city approval? A hefty fine from $500 to $100K per tree, if any city protected tree is cut without a permit...even if its in your backyard.
 
You need to read the city by-laws around trees more.
Did you know that once a tree goes beyond 30 cms, legally you can't cut any limbs without city approval? A hefty fine from $500 to $100K per tree, if any city protected tree is cut without a permit...even if its in your backyard.
Thanks, I did know, although the City's arborist who assessed my tree said the critical decision-making caliper was 10". Nonetheless, pruning for the tree's health or safety is still entirely do-able as long as it doesn't endanger the tree.[See your own post, which I was reacting to with the words you quoted above]

That's only reasonable, so is talking to the tree's owner about it's effect on you and your property, what you'd like them to do, what you want to do and how to agree on what's needed to improve things. Reasonable people should have little difficulty.

And we citizens of Toronto have such fine examples of 'reasonable' civic behaviour inspiring us, do we not?
 
Assuming you live in Toronto or GTA (same by-laws)
http://www.toronto.ca/faq/trees.htm#q2
Thanks, it does appear that trees have a special status in Toronto. I called City Hall to-day and was advised that the City has no bylaws or policies regarding how many trees a neighbor can plant or how close to the property line. Theoretically, your neighbor can plant 100 trees an inch away from the property line.
 
Thanks, it does appear that trees have a special status in Toronto. I called City Hall to-day and was advised that the City has no bylaws or policies regarding how many trees a neighbor can plant or how close to the property line. Theoretically, your neighbor can plant 100 trees an inch away from the property line.
Except that sort of planting would very likely be considered a fence under the Fence By-law:
FENCE — A barrier, including one for noise attenuation, or any structure, except a structural part of a building, that wholly or partially screens from view, encloses or divides a yard or other land, or marks or substantially marks the boundary between adjoining land, and includes any hedge or shrub that has the same effect. [Amended 2000-10-05 by By-law No. 869-2000; 2004-06-24 by By-law No. 557- 2004; 2008-07-17 by By-law No. 793-2008]
and apart from botanical disputes about whether a given plant was a tree or shrub, it would predictably offend by growing over the property line.

You don't get to order your neighbour to be reasonable, and when the authorities do exercise their powers to enforce legally defined reasonableness it seldom makes anyone happy. If you and your neighbour don't personally have what it takes to find compromises you can both live with then you do need to get help, if not from actual mediation services, then perhaps from another neighbour you both can trust. Or a lawyer, if all efforts at a two-way dialogue fail.
 
You need to read the city by-laws around trees more.
Did you know that once a tree goes beyond 30 cms, legally you can't cut any limbs without city approval? A hefty fine from $500 to $100K per tree, if any city protected tree is cut without a permit...even if its in your backyard.

the bylaw is 30 cm in diameter measured four feet from the ground. that is to cut the tree down.
 
Thanks, it does appear that trees have a special status in Toronto. I called City Hall to-day and was advised that the City has no bylaws or policies regarding how many trees a neighbor can plant or how close to the property line. Theoretically, your neighbor can plant 100 trees an inch away from the property line.

well if its on their property why not? you can trim any branches hanging over your property