Assemble Your ALL-TIME Blue Jays Team

[shack]

OK, here's my 25 man roster for All-time Jays:

Batting:
CF - Moseby (Similar numbers to White. White won the WS but I'll give it to him for tenure)
2B - Alomar
3B - Bautista (yes, here instead of RF)
1B - Delgado
DH - Olerud (hey we can put anyone at DH, it doesn't have to be full-time position and EE just broke out this season)
RF - Carter
LF - Bell
SS - Fernandez
C - Whitt

Bench
C - Borders
IF UT - Gruber
IF UT - Damaso Garcia
OF UT - White

Starters
1 - Halladay
2 - Clemens (heck he won the CY both years he was here)
3 - Hentgen
4 - Steib
5 - Key

Pen
Closer - Henke
Setup - Ward
Long-man - Eichhorn
LH - Downs
RH - Frasor (for his tenure)
RH - Janssen
6th Starter/Long-man - Stottlemyre

Manager - Gaston

Great roster but I think you need to make room for Paul Molitor.

 

[Ironhead]

Ok, I'll start. Doc Halladay, RHP.

I assume the same 'rules' as the Leaf thread, player must have played with Jays at some point even if best season was not with Toronto.

I will start with pitchers

Pitching staff:
Halladay
Morris
Carpenter
Hentgen
Stieb

Relievers:
Stottlemyre
Key
Timlin
Ward, set up
Henke, closer

 

[Rockslinger]

Lyle Overbay could be backup 1B.

 

[Rockslinger]

Marco

 

[MyHobbyist]

a lot of good players getting left off these ALL-TIME teams

 

[Ironhead]

I assume the same 'rules' as the Leaf thread, player must have played with Jays at some point even if best season was not with Toronto.

I will start with pitchers

Pitching staff:
Halladay
Morris
Carpenter
Hentgen
Stieb

Relievers:
Stottlemyre
Key
Timlin
Ward, set up
Henke, closer

The Field;
2 Boaders
3 Olerud
4 Alomar
5 Gruber
6 Fernandez
7 Carter
8 White
9 Bautista

DH. Molitor

Bench;
Cecil Fielder
Barfield
Zaun

 

[alwayslooking]

I would definitely have Jesse in the outfield in the late innings for defensive purposes. No one in Jays history had a better arm than Jesse.

 

[smitherz]

CF Alex Rios
2B Frank menechino
3B Eric Hinske
RF Jose Canseco
1B Shea Hillenbrand
SS Russ Adams
LF Brad Wilkerson
DH Willie Greene
C ALberto Castillo

Rotation
Joey Hamilton
Josh Towers
Esteban Loaiza
MIke Sirotka
Tanyon Sturtz


Setup Kerry Lightenberg

Closer Billy Koch

Manager Tim Johnson
GM Gord Ash

:biggrin1:

 

[Rockslinger]

Marco

 

[RandyAndy2]

CF Alex Rios
2B Frank menechino
3B Eric Hinske
RF Jose Canseco
1B Shea Hillenbrand
SS Russ Adams
LF Brad Wilkerson
DH Willie Greene
C ALberto Castillo

Rotation
Joey Hamilton
Josh Towers
Esteban Loaiza
MIke Sirotka
Tanyon Sturtz


Setup Kerry Lightenberg

Closer Billy Koch

Manager Tim Johnson
GM Gord Ash

:biggrin1:

I'm trying to figure out: is this the all-disappointment team, or the all-mediocrity team?

 

[RandyAndy2]

Marco

Give it up Rock.

 

[Rockslinger]

You guys in SPORTS are no fun. When I said "Marco" in the CUPIDS contest thread, someone immediately stood up and said "Polo".