Quebec

Uh, no.

Quite the opposite.

Same with Ontario. We are now a "have not" province for the first time in 144 years. Quebec receives equalization payments and so does Ontario. It's basically federal government welfare to the provinces.

First of all, when did Ontario become an official "have not" province?

Second, do you know of any links outlining the criteria used to determine whether a province should be classified as "have" or "have-not"?
 

I was being sarcastic. I wouldn't expect you to get it.

Wow, you guys are quick to play the racist card aren't you?

If such a comment was applied to any white group vs a non white group with the particulars changed there would be hell to pay. One could draw the implication that anglo Canada is lacking in the attributes mentioned which are mostly positive.


He also played it and ducked, not bothering to explain it. SOP for Fattie and FAST

You posted at 4:14 and then at 5:09

You really expected a response in under an hour
. Really. I am not surprised you seem to expect people to keep a journal of your comments. You are one sad pathetic little man. Which does explain BTW why recently I tend to drop out of conversations. I saw something, someone like you responds with WHALUPEWHALUPEWHALUPEWHALUPEWH**ALUPE and then I am required to make a choice.

Do I completely waste my time trying to explain the obvious to the retarded, or do I just give up and go away.

I would do the old bit about how arguing on the internet is like competing in the special olympics in that even if you win, you are still retarded, however it really doesn't fit. The Special Olympics have a point and there is a winner and in a way those who lose are still winners. Arguing with the likes of you on the internet has no point and even if one "wins" one has wasted ones life is a loser.

I am sure you have seen my invading Russia comparison which is more apt, you were on the thread, but in case of senility.

This is why I drop out of threads.

Arguing on the internet is much like invading Russia

No matter how deep you go [Moscow 1812]
Now matter how brilliant you are. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Von_Manstein WWII
You can even win. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brest-Litovsk_Treaty 1918
In the end you will just end up stuck in the muck and mire. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rasputitsa
And lose. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Congress_of_Vienna and http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treaty_of_Versailles and http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fuhrerbunker

Came up with this one evening. If I were not so demotivated, I'd make a poster about it.

germans-stuck-mud-russian-rains-ww2-003.jpg

Just say no, it isn't worth it.

I can't speak for FAST and his motivations but my dropping threads proves that I am a superior to you.
That I reply to you and the Fuji's of the world at all shows that I still have room to improve.
 
I was being sarcastic. I wouldn't expect you to get it.



If such a comment was applied to any white group vs a non white group with the particulars changed there would be hell to pay. One could draw the implication that anglo Canada is lacking in the attributes mentioned which are mostly positive.




You posted at 4:14 and then at 5:09

You really expected a response in under an hour
. Really. I am not surprised you seem to expect people to keep a journal of your comments. You are one sad pathetic little man. Which does explain BTW why recently I tend to drop out of conversations. I saw something, someone like you responds with WHALUPEWHALUPEWHALUPEWHALUPEWH**ALUPE and then I am required to make a choice.

Do I completely waste my time trying to explain the obvious to the retarded, or do I just give up and go away.


I am sure you have seen my invading Russia comparison which is more apt, you were on the thread, but in case of senility.

This is why I drop out of threads.

I expect an answer with the initial post. You say it's racist with nothing else and members are supposed to know you're kidding. No smilies or the usual disclaimers. Considering some of the other bigoted comments from other members, your comment was not outside of the realm of being serious.

The rest of this response is little more than you entertaining yourself, but knock yourself out.
 
First of all, when did Ontario become an official "have not" province?

Second, do you know of any links outlining the criteria used to determine whether a province should be classified as "have" or "have-not"?

About 3 years ago, Ontario became a have not province.

There is a criteria that the Feds work with to determine whether or not a province gets equalization payments. It boils down to the feds want to ensure that each province has enough cash to spend a bare minimum on each of its citizens. Ontario recently fell short in that regard - and hence we began receiving equalization payments.

Basically, we have lost 300,000 manufacturing jobs since 2008. Hard to recover from that.
 
I'm guessing you've not spent much time in northern ontario let alone Manitoba and the Territories. There is a reason there are no roads running to James Bay and Hudsons Bay and that's the terrain. There is one limited use rail line to both, but they aren't able to handle anywhere near the load that would be expected. I don't know about the Moosenee run but the up keep on the Churchill line is horrendous. It not just permafrost but also tundra, read bog. Look at a map and try and spot the gravel gravel roads north of Cochrane and Red Lake. You can build a road, but it can't handle heavy traffic loads. The Dempster Highway in the Yukon is a perfect example of what will happen. It's a 500 mile gravel road constantly in repair with very light traffic. You can be driving on it, able to 10 km in front and back and not see a single vehicle, yet this traffic causes the toad to need repairs from wear and tear because of the climate. The roads you're thinking of would be the same.

As for replacing the product and cheaper, you're guessing pure and simple.

The ONR has a line that runs from Cochrane to Moosonee (their Island Falls Subdivision). There is combined freight and passanger on that line.

The "road" if you want to call it that, comes off of Hwy 11 around Smooth Rock Falls and runs north to Fraiserdale where there is an automated OPG station (Abitibi Canyon). Cross over the dam and the road becomes a gravel road and ends at the next OPG Dam - Otter Rapids. From there, the only surface transit north is the ONR to Moosonee.

The ONR's Moosonee line (Island Fall Subdivision) is in fair condition, but the rail size is light and it cannot handle the heavier loads (It can handle 263 kip loads, but not 286 kip loads). The line could easily be upgraded to handle heavier traffic, but current usage does not warrant it. That said, the Ontario government has recently announced it wants to sell ONR. My guess would be that CNR wants to buy it since they were going to buy it 10 years ago when Mike Harris was trying to sell the ONR, only to have McGuinty cancel the deal when CNR would not offer up job guarantees to the ONR employees. Now, 10 years later, McGuinty wants to sell ONR. My guess is that CNR wants the line from Moosonee to Cochrane because CNR is currently carrying out preliminary designs for a new major east west line way north of the ring of fire. The most logical line for CNR to tie into is the ONR's Island falls subdivsion. What is up there, I have no idea, but something is and CNR wants to move it.

Cliffs mining is currently developing the ring of fire and believe it or not, they are going to build a gravel road to haul the ore from north of Geraldton down to Sudbury where they want to build a chromite smelter. I can't believe that they would not be hauling by rail. Cliffs is currently playing games with OPG because they (Cliffs) could get hydro power in Quebec at about half the cost that they can buy it for in Ontario. Apparently a Chromite smelter uses massive amounts of electricity and Cliffs could save millions a year in hydro if they built the smelter in Quebec, but Cliffs (an American company) does not want anything to do with Quebec or Quebec politics. So they are trying to badger OPG into giving them a discounted rate if they build their smelter in Sudbury. As far as I am aware, OPG has told them no, that everyone gets the same rate and if OPG gave Cliffs a deal on power then they would need to give everyone a deal and OPG doesn't want to do that.

As far as the line to Churchill - that is an old CNR line that CNR sold off (maybe they want to buy it back, who knows) to a shortline operator out of Colorado and they now operate the (HBR).
 
The ONR has a line that runs from Cochrane to Moosonee (their Island Falls Subdivision). There is combined freight and passanger on that line.

The "road" if you want to call it that, comes off of Hwy 11 around Smooth Rock Falls and runs north to Fraiserdale where there is an automated OPG station (Abitibi Canyon). Cross over the dam and the road becomes a gravel road and ends at the next OPG Dam - Otter Rapids. From there, the only surface transit north is the ONR to Moosonee.

The ONR's Moosonee line (Island Fall Subdivision) is in fair condition, but the rail size is light and it cannot handle the heavier loads (It can handle 263 kip loads, but not 286 kip loads). The line could easily be upgraded to handle heavier traffic, but current usage does not warrant it. That said, the Ontario government has recently announced it wants to sell ONR. My guess would be that CNR wants to buy it since they were going to buy it 10 years ago when Mike Harris was trying to sell the ONR, only to have McGuinty cancel the deal when CNR would not offer up job guarantees to the ONR employees. Now, 10 years later, McGuinty wants to sell ONR. My guess is that CNR wants the line from Moosonee to Cochrane because CNR is currently carrying out preliminary designs for a new major east west line way north of the ring of fire. The most logical line for CNR to tie into is the ONR's Island falls subdivsion. What is up there, I have no idea, but something is and CNR wants to move it.

Cliffs mining is currently developing the ring of fire and believe it or not, they are going to build a gravel road to haul the ore from north of Geraldton down to Sudbury where they want to build a chromite smelter. I can't believe that they would not be hauling by rail. Cliffs is currently playing games with OPG because they (Cliffs) could get hydro power in Quebec at about half the cost that they can buy it for in Ontario. Apparently a Chromite smelter uses massive amounts of electricity and Cliffs could save millions a year in hydro if they built the smelter in Quebec, but Cliffs (an American company) does not want anything to do with Quebec or Quebec politics. So they are trying to badger OPG into giving them a discounted rate if they build their smelter in Sudbury. As far as I am aware, OPG has told them no, that everyone gets the same rate and if OPG gave Cliffs a deal on power then they would need to give everyone a deal and OPG doesn't want to do that.

As far as the line to Churchill - that is an old CNR line that CNR sold off (maybe they want to buy it back, who knows) to a shortline operator out of Colorado and they now operate the (HBR).

Everything you say is true, and a road won't replace a 4/6 lane Series 400 highway and the Saint Lawrence Seaway traffic.
 
But speaking of Quebec racism, does anyone remember Jan Wong who used to be a columnist with the Globe and Mail.

She wrote an article in 2006 called "Get under the Desk" in which she argued that racism in Quebec was at least partly responsible for the 3 shootings at the 3 colleges in Quebec (Polytechnic, Dawson College and Concordia). In a nutshell, her argument was that these kinds of shootings only seem to happen in Quebec. Why? And why were all 3 shooters of non-francophone heritage (Marc Lepine was Algerian, Valery Fabrikant was a Russian Jew, and Kimveer Gill was of Indian heritage.

Wong's arguement was that they had been ostracised by the larger "pure laine" Quebecois culture and that it resulted at least in part for their actions.

Now I think Wong may have been reaching a bit, but there is definitely a truth to the Quebecois culture of racism. Racism that I have personally seen myself.

But what is FASCINATING was the reaction of the Quebec political and cultural leaders. They destroyed Jan Wong. She was hung drawn and quartered in media and in government. The Globe and Mail threw her under the bus. She received death threats, shit in the mail, and racist cartoons were published depicting her with thick glasses and buck teeth.

The old line, "The lady doth protest too much" comes to mind when every egg-head in Quebec starts writing open letters about how wrong Jan Wong was on the issue of racism in Quebec.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jan_Wong_controversy
 
To start with Wong's premise was wrong. She seems to forget the high school shooting out west in Taber. She can be rather abrasive in her reporting, but gets some slack from me recently because of her ordeal in Afghanistan.
 
There are Quebecois racist that think that Canada is sucking the province dry and there are Anglo racist that think that there is a guerrilla warfare in the streets of Montreal where people are shooting at each other from the rooftops.
 
In Canada, the federal government makes payments to less wealthy Canadian provinces to equalize the provinces' "fiscal capacity"—their ability to generate tax revenues. In 2009-2010, six provinces received $14.2 billion in equalization payments from the federal government.Until the 2009-2010 fiscal year, Ontario was the only province to have never received equalization payments; in 2009-2010 Ontario will receive $347 million, while Newfoundland, which has received payments since the program's creation, is now a so-called "have" province, and is now a net contributor that does not receive Equalization payments.
 
.......and there are Anglo racist that think that there is a guerrilla warfare in the streets of Montreal where people are shooting at each other from the rooftops.

I assume you are exaggerating to make a point.
 
To start with Wong's premise was wrong. She seems to forget the high school shooting out west in Taber. She can be rather abrasive in her reporting, but gets some slack from me recently because of her ordeal in Afghanistan.

I'm not saying she was right. (Not at least with respect to the shooters.) But she does have a point with respect to racism in Quebec.

And what is completely amazing to me is just how she was put on a train and run out of town by the powers that be.
 
I'm not saying she was right. (Not at least with respect to the shooters.) But she does have a point with respect to racism in Quebec.

And what is completely amazing to me is just how she was put on a train and run out of town by the powers that be.

I've referred to them in the past as petulant teenagers, even to their face, and it interesting to see their reaction. I'm still breathing and don't have to have someone taste my food first, so you could say they handled it reasonably well, but racist? If you think Quebecers are racist, how do you describe Parisians?
 
I've never had an problems in Paris when I've been there to be honest.

But I don't live in France, so I really cannot formulate an accurate opinion.
 
Agar (toronto sun) had an interesting blurb about what's going on in Montreal a few weeks ago...

http://www.torontosun.com/2012/06/25/you-cant-always-get-what-you-want

"...Or, nightly, in the case of the rioting students in Montreal, who would rather while away their summer evenings throwing Molotov cocktails at police cars than go to work to raise the 80¢ a day the government proposes to hike their extremely low tuition rates next year.

This sense of entitlement exists despite the fact Quebec’s per-capita debt is the highest in the country and fifth-highest in the developed world.

If Quebec ever separates, it will immediately become Greece, going from needing transfer payments to foreign aid. ..."


Good article actually.

Cheers!
 
I've never had an problems in Paris when I've been there to be honest.

But I don't live in France, so I really cannot formulate an accurate opinion.

To put it bluntly, if your not Parisian you're on a rung lower than them, it's only a matter of how far down. There are exception but few and far between. Maybe it's my joual.