Quebec

Been a while since I heard anyone complain about those things, so it must be a small number.

Never said it was a majority or anywhere near the majority but it's disingenuous to pretend the sentiment isn't out there. There's no shortage of people in Canada who believe that the country's nose needs to be firmly planted in the ass of the UK (what's with all this emphasis on monarchy since Harper became PM?) or alternately since the UK is no longer a world power that we need to be boot licking their grandchild the USA. Remember Harper's outrage and letters of apology signed by him and Stockwell Day in the NY Times since Canada *gasp* wouldn't be participating in the folly that was Iraq?
 
I spend half my year working in Quebec and have been doing so for more than 12 years.

There is a large divide between Montreal and "the rest of the province". Those from in and around Quebec City view themselves as superior to those from Montreal because they are the true Quebecois whereas Montrealers are viewed as mutts. Montrealers don't really think about it very much (from what I can tell.)

Separatism is alive and well in Quebec. Don't ever kid yourself. But whether they ever choose to separate or not is a different story.

But to me, it's all about racism. Plain and simple (regardless of what Quebecers tell you about preserving their culture. That's just horseshit.) They may think that, but at the end of the day, it's really just good old fashioned distrust to outright hatred of anyone not exactly like them (the franco- Quebecers). If you don't think it's about racism - take a Quebecer (especially one from outside of Montreal) and bring him to Toronto and watch and listen to what they have to say. (I have and it's both funny and fucking shocking at the same time.) They are EXTREMELY small minded and racist. They are completely blown away when they come to the GTA by fact that there are so many different people. Example, I took a group of Quebecers to the Mandarin in Markham. They would not and could not shut up about the fact that there is a large population of Asians in Markham. One idiot was doing his best Charlie Chan impression (in Quebecois) right in the restaurant and the rest of them thought it was hysterical. I was mortified and before I could stop him, he was into it full blast. They are a narrow minded isolationist society. Although they may not be as isolated as they once were, they are still very isolated and their world is only Quebec and people who look and most importantly sound just like them. Example, you can speak French to them (and even if you speak excellent French) their faces will get all screwed up because you don't sound just like them. They have lived their whole entire life in these small Quebec towns and they have NEVER heard French being spoken with an accent. Everyone they know is just like them.

Now I'm not saying that they (Franco Quebecers) are not good people. They are. But there is a biggotry to them that has been bred into them over the centuries and it's not going to disappear any time soon.

What you say about many francophone Quebecers (outside of Montreal and perhaps Quebec City) may well be true, but ignorance and bigotry of the sort you describe is also very common in small-town communities across Canada, including many areas of Ontario outside of the GTA.
 
Never said it was a majority or anywhere near the majority but it's disingenuous to pretend the sentiment isn't out there. There's no shortage of people in Canada who believe that the country's nose needs to be firmly planted in the ass of the UK (what's with all this emphasis on monarchy since Harper became PM?) or alternately since the UK is no longer a world power that we need to be boot licking their grandchild the USA. Remember Harper's outrage and letters of apology signed by him and Stockwell Day in the NY Times since Canada *gasp* wouldn't be participating in the folly that was Iraq?

I didn't say it didn't exist, just that it's really small and not part of regular discussions. Remember the advice that you shouldn't worry about the small stuff. File this under small stuff along with those who belong to the Flat Earth Society
 
To be fair, the Catholic Quebecois did adopt many Irish Catholic orphans whose parents were brutally murdered by the English and Scots.
 
What you say about many francophone Quebecers (outside of Montreal and perhaps Quebec City) may well be true, but ignorance and bigotry of the sort you describe is also very common in small-town communities across Canada, including many areas of Ontario outside of the GTA.

Um. no.
 
I remember Bill Clinton was prez and visited Canada.

http://articles.baltimoresun.com/1999-10-10/news/9910100271_1_president-bill-clinton-quebec-canada

Basically, Clinton inferred that if Quebec separated, the new Quebec nation would have to sign separate treaty agreements with the USA that may not be an advantageous as the current agreements with the Commonwealth of Canada. If Quebec separates, the remaining Anglophones/braintrust will head to Ottawa/Toronto/hell, Vancouver and leave Quebec as the proudist third world country in the world.
 
Isn't it true that people in cosmopolitan cities and outside of the cities are different in most provinces and in most countries?
Look at the different attitudes and voting patterns between the 416 and outside of that in Ontario.
I used to work with a guy from Oshawa and I'll bet he had a white hooded uniform in his closet.
Look at the comments section of Toronto papers like the Sun or Star (more control there). You'll think you are in Mississippi in the '60s.

Read about Canadian history what happened in to French Canadians in Manitoba, Ontario, the Canadian west, the Acadians and you'll understand why the French
in Canada and Quebec are pre-occupied with language.

I think you are correct about rural vs urban but in my opinion it is more pronounced in Quebec. I do not think the current language issue , however, has the slightest thing to do with what ever happened in Manitoba, Ontario or the Canadian west.

Sad to say but today's Quebecers care about very little beyond their own borders.
 
Wonder if any one else got similar vibes about these issues in Quebec? Or did I just talk to a skewed cross-section of people?

I guess it depends on what language and accent you have. We spent sometime visiting last month. When I spoke English with my mild British accent I saw one set of beliefs being expressed. When I spoke French with my Parisian accent I received another. Often switching languages with the same person resulted in a significant change in their expressed beliefs.

And I have to agree the small communities and Quebec City and Montreal are completely different.
 
Did you talk to people in Quebec about the massive tax transfer payments the other provinces make to subsidize Quebec? How Ontarians and Albertans basically prop up Quebec and it's population? How ungrateful Quebecers are to the rest of Canada?

Do you mean the equalization payment from the 'have' to the 'have not' provinces? I wonder how the people in Newfoundland feel about subsidizing the have not provinces. I bet they are pissed that Ontario got $3.261 billion as a 'have not' in transfer payments this year. So tell me, how do you feel about living in a have not province and living off the charity of the richer provinces?

I wonder if they should make people born in Canada take the CANADIAN CITIZENSHIP TEST just like imigrants do so the average knowledge about Canada is more current and accurate? :)
 
... I am a mutt - half Brit, half white Russian, part Catholic, part Anglican, part Jew, part god knows what....

What part is Jewish? Was that the part that had to get a snip snip?
 
For the most part, when I'm in Quebec, I avoid getting into political discussions with Franco Quebecers. For one thing, I'm a "maudit Anglais" to them, even though I am a mutt - half Brit, half white Russian, part Catholic, part Anglican, part Jew, part god knows what. To them I am a 6'3" Englishman with black shiny shoes. For another, my French skills are no where good enough.

But on a couple of occasions, I've had a little fun with some separatists I work with. I usually start out with "what will you use for money if you separate?"

They will tell you that they will use the Canadian dollar.

Seriously. And they cannot understand why they would not or could not. I tell them, "well, if you want to use the Canadian dollar, that's fine, but Quebec will have no say on the monetary policy of Canada whereas right now you do. You will be led around like a dog on leash. They then retort that they will have their own dollar and I say, "well, then your dollar would be pretty much worthless because your debt situation will worse than Greece" It is at this point they usually get defensive with me. They have been sold a bill of goods by the Separatist leaders that if they separate from Canada that their lives will be so much better and that they will live in a Quebecois Utopia. A lot them believe it.

Your co-workers lack of knowledge must make it easier to win arguments. The Québec government's debt
as of March 31, 2012 was $183 780 million or about 55% of GDP. Greece is 144%. UK is 66%. The World is at 59.3 %, So they could ask you why would Quebec be worse off than say the US at 97% gross total government debt and 59% federal debt?

They could also argue that the biggest single uncontrollable impact on their total debt load is their share of the federal deficit every year.
 

OddSox, I am a multiracial individual who spent part of his life growing up in Oshawa, where I experienced ignorance and bigotry first-hand (both directed against myself and the few others who were "visible" i.e. non-white, minorities), so I know from which I speak (granted, Oshawa is not a small town, but it does have many of the same characteristics of such). And somehow, I don't think my experiences are unique.
 
Last edited:
What you say about many francophone Quebecers (outside of Montreal and perhaps Quebec City) may well be true, but ignorance and bigotry of the sort you describe is also very common in small-town communities across Canada, including many areas of Ontario outside of the GTA.

Yes and no.

There is ignorance and bigotry everywhere I acknowledge, however, Quebecers are a more homogeneous society than the rest of Canada. You can travel across the rest of Canada into the small towns and you'll find people who's family backgrounds are Anglo, Germanic, Northern European, Eastern European. By and large white, but from all over and of differing religions.

Quebec? Not so.

They are all French Catholics.

In fact, they are all stem from a few Regions in France (Western France).
 
Your co-workers lack of knowledge must make it easier to win arguments. The Québec government's debt
as of March 31, 2012 was $183 780 million or about 55% of GDP. Greece is 144%. UK is 66%. The World is at 59.3 %, So they could ask you why would Quebec be worse off than say the US at 97% gross total government debt and 59% federal debt?

They could also argue that the biggest single uncontrollable impact on their total debt load is their share of the federal deficit every year.

Uh, at 55 percent, they are the most endebted province in Canada.

You think that's good?

Ontario is 35% and that's a disaster. Quebec is a trajedy.

And that's provincial debt.

Add to that their fair share of the federal debt and you are well over 100 percent.

Add to that the fact that Quebec receives about 8 billion a year in equalization payments and you start to get the picture.
 
Uh, at 55 percent, they are the most endebted province in Canada.

You think that's good?

Ontario is 35% and that's a disaster. Quebec is a trajedy.

And that's provincial debt.

Add to that their fair share of the federal debt and you are well over 100 percent.

Add to that the fact that Quebec receives about 8 billion a year in equalization payments and you start to get the picture.

Moody's tells us Ontario and Quebec are both Aa2. Equal credit rating and risk of going under and not paying their debts.

And Ontario gets the second biggest equalization payment.
 
Yes and no.

There is ignorance and bigotry everywhere I acknowledge, however, Quebecers are a more homogeneous society than the rest of Canada. You can travel across the rest of Canada into the small towns and you'll find people who's family backgrounds are Anglo, Germanic, Northern European, Eastern European. By and large white, but from all over and of differing religions.

Quebec? Not so.

They are all French Catholics.

In fact, they are all stem from a few Regions in France (Western France).

You do have a point regarding the ethnic backgrounds of the small towns in various parts of Canada (particularly in the western provinces, where there are large communities of people of German, Dutch, Scandinavian and Eastern European descent). However, that heterogeneity also varies depending on what areas of rural Canada you happened to be located.

There are many small-town communities in southern Ontario and in the rural regions of the Atlantic provinces where the overwhelming majority of the people are of British (English, Scottish, Irish) descent, many of whom are either descended from United Empire Loyalists (i.e. American colonists who sided with the British during the American Revolution and fled to Canada) or from settlers who arrived in the late 18 or th early 19th century. This is even more true for people from Newfoundland, where 99% of the people are descended from English (mainly from western England) and Irish settlers who arrived starting from the 17th to the early 19th century, with very little admixture from outsiders .

In fact, I would argue that Newfoundlanders are just as homogeneous as Quebecers. In fact, the relative isolation of both groups have led to the development of unique dialects of English (for Newfoundland) and French (for Quebec).
 
You do have a point regarding the ethnic backgrounds of the small towns in various parts of Canada (particularly in the western provinces, where there are large communities of people of German, Dutch, Scandinavian and Eastern European descent). However, that heterogeneity also varies depending on what areas of rural Canada you happened to be located.

There are many small-town communities in southern Ontario and in the rural regions of the Atlantic provinces where the overwhelming majority of the people are of British (English, Scottish, Irish) descent, many of whom are either descended from United Empire Loyalists (i.e. American colonists who sided with the British during the American Revolution and fled to Canada) or from settlers who arrived in the late 18 or th early 19th century. This is even more true for people from Newfoundland, where 99% of the people are descended from English (mainly from western England) and Irish settlers who arrived starting from the 17th to the early 19th century, with very little admixture from outsiders .

In fact, I would argue that Newfoundlanders are just as homogeneous as Quebecers. In fact, the relative isolation of both groups have led to the development of unique dialects of English (for Newfoundland) and French (for Quebec).

JFK puts a lot of credence in the fact that the majority of Quebecer's were born French Catholic and of course that means they live the life of a French Catholic 'til they die. Something tells me that not the case. Oh, ya my in-laws. Many would be surprised if I was to tell you that less than half would be considering practicing RC?