Quebec

milehigh

Active member
Feb 15, 2003
1,994
2
38
I recently had a visit there. This time I really got to talking to people about things going on.

The separatist movement is stronger than I thought it was...I hear less radicalism and more " we want to preserve our culture." I wonder what Canada would be like without Quebec, but my gut feeling is, if that is what they really want, why stand in their way?

I talked to a lot of students as well, and although a lot of them do not condone the actions of some, they are really sticking together and making a point. I do like their commitment.

On one hand, education is not supported the way it should be - students should not come out with massive debts after finishing school.

However on the other hand, I do believe there should at least be some "demand" for the areas of study that are susidized.

Wonder if any one else got similar vibes about these issues in Quebec? Or did I just talk to a skewed cross-section of people?


Going off on a tangent here to end.....mister man, the women in Montreal - were they ever smoking hot!
 
I recently had a visit there. This time I really got to talking to people about things going on.

Wonder if any one else got similar vibes about these issues in Quebec? Or did I just talk to a skewed cross-section of people?


Going off on a tangent here to end.....mister man, the women in Montreal - were they ever smoking hot!

This depends greatly on where in Quebec you spoke to people. People in rural Quebec often have a very different outlook on things than people in the greater Montreal area.

And yes, the women are, and always have been, smokin' hot.
 
This depends greatly on where in Quebec you spoke to people. People in rural Quebec often have a very different outlook on things than people in the greater Montreal area.
And yes, the women are, and always have been, smokin' hot.

Boy do you ever have that right. The rest of Quebec is less tolerant of minorities for one thing. Read in the paper today where the the Quebec language police were worried because they couldn't invent french words fast enough for terms such as "tweet". lol . I think that, as recent polls have indicated, the rest of Canada is over Quebec and most don't really care if they seperate.
I grew up there and I've given up caring as long as I can continue to go to Montreal.
Students have been quiet recently - wonder if that will change in September or whether it will wither like the "Occupy" movement did.
And yes the women in Montreal, particularly in summer, are spectacular.
 
I spend half my year working in Quebec and have been doing so for more than 12 years.

There is a large divide between Montreal and "the rest of the province". Those from in and around Quebec City view themselves as superior to those from Montreal because they are the true Quebecois whereas Montrealers are viewed as mutts. Montrealers don't really think about it very much (from what I can tell.)

Separatism is alive and well in Quebec. Don't ever kid yourself. But whether they ever choose to separate or not is a different story.

But to me, it's all about racism. Plain and simple (regardless of what Quebecers tell you about preserving their culture. That's just horseshit.) They may think that, but at the end of the day, it's really just good old fashioned distrust to outright hatred of anyone not exactly like them (the franco- Quebecers). If you don't think it's about racism - take a Quebecer (especially one from outside of Montreal) and bring him to Toronto and watch and listen to what they have to say. (I have and it's both funny and fucking shocking at the same time.) They are EXTREMELY small minded and racist. They are completely blown away when they come to the GTA by fact that there are so many different people. Example, I took a group of Quebecers to the Mandarin in Markham. They would not and could not shut up about the fact that there is a large population of Asians in Markham. One idiot was doing his best Charlie Chan impression (in Quebecois) right in the restaurant and the rest of them thought it was hysterical. I was mortified and before I could stop him, he was into it full blast. They are a narrow minded isolationist society. Although they may not be as isolated as they once were, they are still very isolated and their world is only Quebec and people who look and most importantly sound just like them. Example, you can speak French to them (and even if you speak excellent French) their faces will get all screwed up because you don't sound just like them. They have lived their whole entire life in these small Quebec towns and they have NEVER heard French being spoken with an accent. Everyone they know is just like them.

Now I'm not saying that they (Franco Quebecers) are not good people. They are. But there is a biggotry to them that has been bred into them over the centuries and it's not going to disappear any time soon.
 
Did you talk to people in Quebec about the massive tax transfer payments the other provinces make to subsidize Quebec? How Ontarians and Albertans basically prop up Quebec and it's population? How ungrateful Quebecers are to the rest of Canada?
 
For the most part, when I'm in Quebec, I avoid getting into political discussions with Franco Quebecers. For one thing, I'm a "maudit Anglais" to them, even though I am a mutt - half Brit, half white Russian, part Catholic, part Anglican, part Jew, part god knows what. To them I am a 6'3" Englishman with black shiny shoes. For another, my French skills are no where good enough.

But on a couple of occasions, I've had a little fun with some separatists I work with. I usually start out with "what will you use for money if you separate?"

They will tell you that they will use the Canadian dollar.

Seriously. And they cannot understand why they would not or could not. I tell them, "well, if you want to use the Canadian dollar, that's fine, but Quebec will have no say on the monetary policy of Canada whereas right now you do. You will be led around like a dog on leash. They then retort that they will have their own dollar and I say, "well, then your dollar would be pretty much worthless because your debt situation will worse than Greece" It is at this point they usually get defensive with me. They have been sold a bill of goods by the Separatist leaders that if they separate from Canada that their lives will be so much better and that they will live in a Quebecois Utopia. A lot them believe it.
 
Ontario should separate!

Cheers!
 
The doctrine of the separatist leaders is keep them poor and ignorant and they will never stray far from home. They keep Quebeckers taxed into poverty and feed them lies about how Canada screws them over. Separation is a manufactured crisis that is used to pull more money out of Canada and more powers out of the Federal government. I have no use for Quebec. I left it shortly after their last referendum and never looked back. I often get a chuckle out of reading the Montreal Gazette online when there is a story about how the language police are clamping down. It is beyond ridiculous. So I say, let them separate and take their massive debt with them. They are the Greece of Canada and I would not be surprised with the bolstered confidence in the West, if the rest of Canada just says go next time around. However, the Federal government is rife with francophones so the government efforts to keep the union alive may overshadow the collective Canadian will.
 
This time I really got to talking to people about things going on.
When you spoke to a male/female couple, did the female do most of the talking? Haven't been to Montreal or Quebec since 2004.

Quebec is to Canada what Greece is to the EU.
 
I love going to Quebec and talking Separatism. I have family there and yes they are worried about losing their French-Canadian "culture" while being snowbirds.
I often point out Parizeau's comment about Canada being "divisible" while they all agree with that comment they disagree with the statement made by the natives that Quebec too is therefore "divisible".

Usually the arguments end with a lot of shouting and profanity with me usually declaring that they should go. But when they do they have to leave "un cheque" and that "Les paiements de tranfert sont terminees" .

Yes, that is always another good conversation to have with separatists - the idea that Quebec is divisible, or more accurately partition.

For some reason, the separatists figure that Canada is divisible, but Quebec is not. The fact of the matter is that I highly doubt that Montreal would want to be part of an independent Quebec and definitely not the northern part (native) of the province. The aboriginals want nothing to do with an independent Quebec.

Quebec without Montreal or the north would be positively 3'rd world.

If the western regions of the province were to vote to remain part of Canada, what then?

As far as I can tell, the money and the get up and go is in Montreal and the north.
 
I would never want to see Quebec separate, or the country broken up. It is inconceivable to me.

Though Quebec can be a pain in the ass sometimes, the fact is that we are stronger united than we are fragmented. Canada is the greatest country in the world. We have more freedom, more opportunity, a better form of responsible government with better infrastructure and social services, and justice for all than any other country in the world. It is madness to think about ruining that.

The one startling difference between Quebec and Ontario is that Quebecers (the French ones) are very Quebec centric. Their outlook is only about Quebec (even the non PQ'ists). You will often hear, "it will be good for Quebec" or "it won't be good for Quebec"

Ontario on the other hand has always wanted a strong and united Canada. One country for all, one set of laws and everyone equal before the law. Ontarians are Canadians first. Quebecers are Quebecers first.
 
Last edited:
They'll have a bigger fight on their hands if they decide to go this route again. I beleive the Cree don't want any part of separation and will claim large tracts of the province.

I'm with you J t k, I don't want them to separate or even try again.
 
If Quebec separates, Canada will shorten it's name to Cana....because the DA has left!
 
I recently had a visit there. This time I really got to talking to people about things going on.

The separatist movement is stronger than I thought it was...I hear less radicalism and more " we want to preserve our culture." I wonder what Canada would be like without Quebec, but my gut feeling is, if that is what they really want, why stand in their way?

The country bumkins outside the city do not have any idea of what is really going on in the city, the separatist in the city are all getting old and dying off one by one. The young people are not interested in separatism.

I talked to a lot of students as well, and although a lot of them do not condone the actions of some, they are really sticking together and making a point. I do like their commitment.

On one hand, education is not supported the way it should be - students should not come out with massive debts after finishing school.

Quebec has the lowest university tuition in North America, If the students want free education and to be debt free when they graduate, they might suffer the consequences in the future when they become earners and pay the higher taxes to fund later generations.

I say give the ones that have a grade over 85% free tuition, the rest pay and the ones that repeat course will have to pay a extra fee.


However on the other hand, I do believe there should at least be some "demand" for the areas of study that are susidized.

Wonder if any one else got similar vibes about these issues in Quebec? Or did I just talk to a skewed cross-section of people?

You only sampled the opinions of a small group of people. The idea of separation is old peoples politics, if you find a separatist they will probable be in their 50s to 70s and were rock throwing and flag waving 30 years ago. during the separatist years there were big gatherings at the concerts on the plains of Abraham near Quebec City every year attracting crowds of 500,000 and more to see separatist performers. This year there were 3000 people because it was cold and raining and now there is a restriction on drinking so most people stayed away.


Going off on a tangent here to end.....mister man, the women in Montreal - were they ever smoking hot!

I never believed that Rene Levesque, Jacques Parizeau or Pauline Marois ever believe or did believe that there would be separation.
It was just an excuse to move the masses of lower class people to rally around a cause and so that they would stay in power.
 
Wow! I am totally with you, JT Kirk! Incredible! I am from Montreal and am considered an allophone. Let's just say that I hate les separatistes and they hate me.

I've pointed this out before, the attitude is if you're not le vraie laine then you don't belong in Quebec.
 
cut a cheque for $50 billion,they cant use anything that is OURS(currency,passports,stamps,whatever else),build a big fence like they do in the US southwest for mexican illegals and let them rot.
Their failed ideology and government spending,they will end up close to a 3rd world nation,france will not be much of a trade partner for them or bail them out,they will end of as the north american version of greece and in 5-10 years they will want back in.
 
I spend half my year working in Quebec and have been doing so for more than 12 years.

There is a large divide between Montreal and "the rest of the province". Those from in and around Quebec City view themselves as superior to those from Montreal because they are the true Quebecois whereas Montrealers are viewed as mutts. Montrealers don't really think about it very much (from what I can tell.)

Separatism is alive and well in Quebec. Don't ever kid yourself. But whether they ever choose to separate or not is a different story.

But to me, it's all about racism. Plain and simple (regardless of what Quebecers tell you about preserving their culture. That's just horseshit.) They may think that, but at the end of the day, it's really just good old fashioned distrust to outright hatred of anyone not exactly like them (the franco- Quebecers). If you don't think it's about racism - take a Quebecer (especially one from outside of Montreal) and bring him to Toronto and watch and listen to what they have to say. (I have and it's both funny and fucking shocking at the same time.) They are EXTREMELY small minded and racist. They are completely blown away when they come to the GTA by fact that there are so many different people. Example, I took a group of Quebecers to the Mandarin in Markham. They would not and could not shut up about the fact that there is a large population of Asians in Markham. One idiot was doing his best Charlie Chan impression (in Quebecois) right in the restaurant and the rest of them thought it was hysterical. I was mortified and before I could stop him, he was into it full blast. They are a narrow minded isolationist society. Although they may not be as isolated as they once were, they are still very isolated and their world is only Quebec and people who look and most importantly sound just like them. Example, you can speak French to them (and even if you speak excellent French) their faces will get all screwed up because you don't sound just like them. They have lived their whole entire life in these small Quebec towns and they have NEVER heard French being spoken with an accent. Everyone they know is just like them.

Now I'm not saying that they (Franco Quebecers) are not good people. They are. But there is a biggotry to them that has been bred into them over the centuries and it's not going to disappear any time soon.

But if you were from a member of a minority ethnic group that the majority treated as second class in all respects (and is anyone going to pretend that that wasn't the case up until the end of the Diefenbaker years?) would you have warm and fuzzy feelings about the majority? And lets no kid ourselves into pretending that people in small-town Ontario or Alberta are multiculturalism-embracing polyglots either, cause I've got news for you.
 
I would never want to see Quebec separate, or the country broken up. It is inconceivable to me.

Though Quebec can be a pain in the ass sometimes, the fact is that we are stronger united than we are fragmented. Canada is the greatest country in the world. We have more freedom, more opportunity, a better form of responsible government with better infrastructure and social services, and justice for all than any other country in the world. It is madness to think about ruining that.

The one startling difference between Quebec and Ontario is that Quebecers (the French ones) are very Quebec centric. Their outlook is only about Quebec (even the non PQ'ists). You will often hear, "it will be good for Quebec" or "it won't be good for Quebec"

Ontario on the other hand has always wanted a strong and united Canada. One country for all, one set of laws and everyone equal before the law. Ontarians are Canadians first. Quebecers are Quebecers first
.

And if it weren't for Quebec you'd be clinging and identifying with some imagined British identity, not your Canadian-ness. It's 2012 and there are still people in English Canada who harp about things like the Red Ensign having been replaced, and Dominion Day having been renamed Canada Day. The sentiment in English Canada was that Canada was more or less a glorified colony of the UK and should be at its beck and call. There was no interest in just being Canadian until the Quiet Revolution and Quebec nationalism made it clear carrying-on with the status quo would result in the end of Canada.
 
And if it weren't for Quebec you'd be clinging and identifying with some imagined British identity, not your Canadian-ness. It's 2012 and there are still people in English Canada who harp about things like the Red Ensign having been replaced, and Dominion Day having been renamed Canada Day. The sentiment in English Canada was that Canada was more-or-less a colony of the UK and should be at its beck-and-call. There was no interest in just being Canadian until the Quiet Revolution and Quebec nationalism made it clear carrying-on with the status quo would result in the end of Canada.

Been a while since I heard anyone complain about those things, so it must be a small number.