Elliot Lake mall collapse

Are those tests you suggested only good for finding corpes?

They can detect gases given off by dead tissue such as that cause by gangrene, but then it's a matter of concentration of the same gases. A corpse will give off more gas more quickly than a gangrenous or infected wound.

Death and taxes are the only guarantees in life.
 
frankcastle said:
Anyways, one things for sure. Neither you nor I can guarantee that everyone was dead when they called it off.

The only word that fits is "inept".

I remember thinking the day it happened, why is this not a bigger news story? Where's the premier?

Something about it being the middle of nowhere gave people in government, the media, and the response team the idea that it was not as serious as it was.

Public inquiry has rightly been called.
 
They can detect gases given off by dead tissue such as that cause by gangrene, but then it's a matter of concentration of the same gases. A corpse will give off more gas more quickly than a gangrenous or infected wound.

Death and taxes are the only guarantees in life.

Okay that's what I thought. So the test can tell you that there are corpses but doesn't tell you if there are survivors.
 
I don't know anyone personally on the Toronto HUSAR, but I believe they were involved in the collapse of some building a few years back at Bloor and Yonge and have been to Haiti. I'd have to check, but I believe HUSARs are also located in Winnipeg, Vancouver, and Halifax.

HUSAR is untested, as I've stated, HUSAR was not called in, Toronto Fire was the primary agency in control of this scene.. That building was under demolition at the time and heavy equipment was on scene.
As for HUSAR being in other cities. I believe only Toronto received federal funds to form such an agency and they are required to be deployed if needed across Canada or wherever else the feds would like them to go. As stated, HUSAR has not been fully deployed and are still untested.

Wow, a high hoe! If they got to the bodies on day 5, they could have got to the, hopefully, live bodies on day 2, if they had requested the high hoe on day 1.
\

Again, a high hoe in capacity for demolition is not used for "search" purposes. Only for clearing debris as they can cause further harm or death to someone trapped.


McGuinty was two hours away in Sudbury when this happened. He should have been a true leader and made things happen. This sort of thing should come instinctively. It unfortunately reminds me of the shameful non-reaction of GWB during the Katrina disaster. This is a low point in Ontario's history.

The local authorities need to ask for help. The province just doesn't step in, they would be overstepping their authority if they did so.


Pretty messed up for whomever it was that decided to call off the search with survivors still in there.

The excuse that it is too dangerous is bullshit. I'm pretty confident that the people would have been willing to risk it and go try and rescue some people.

If the site is deemed too dangerous you have to trust that it was. The role of the rescue team is to determine if the site is safe enough to affect rescue or call it off. You don't want the rescuers to become in need of being rescued themselves or to needlessly put their lives in jeopardy. I would hazard to guess that there was no real signs of survivors to take further risks.
Letting amateurs in to facilitate rescue and they become trapped or killed would open up those in charge to gross negligence.

Well these people signed up for a dangerous job so some risk is part of the job.

You don't take needless chances.



Anyways, one things for sure. Neither you nor I can guarantee that everyone was dead when they called it off.

Nobody will ever really know.
 
Last edited:
Okay that's what I thought. So the test can tell you that there are corpses but doesn't tell you if there are survivors.

... but you forget the other monitoring processes I mentioned, mics and infra-red, that would give certain readings if their were survivors and others if not..
 
Responsibility

The only word that fits is "inept".

I remember thinking the day it happened, why is this not a bigger news story? Where's the premier?

Something about it being the middle of nowhere gave people in government, the media, and the response team the idea that it was not as serious as it was.

Public inquiry has rightly been called.


As I have already said, this CAN'T be about the premier making a call.

There HAS to be an automatic and appropriate response to an event of this magnitude, regardless of were it is, and what FRKN day it is.

And, I have to ask, WHY does it take a tragedy to happen before governments say, .....looks like we will have to look into this..... BULL SHIT.

And again, it has NOTHING to do with the people sent there, but a lot to do with how the system responded, and the incompetent people who set it up,.... but rest assured, nobody in what ever section of government responsible with be fired, or sued.

FAST
 
As I have already said, this CAN'T be about the premier making a call.

There HAS to be an automatic and appropriate response to an event of this magnitude, regardless of were it is, and what FRKN day it is.

And, I have to ask, WHY does it take a tragedy to happen before governments say, .....looks like we will have to look into this..... BULL SHIT.

And again, it has NOTHING to do with the people sent there, but a lot to do with how the system responded, and the incompetent people who set it up,.... but rest assured, nobody in what ever section of government responsible with be fired, or sued.

FAST

Exactly what magnitude are you talking about? I was surprise at how small an area the collapse was contained in. It was simply a single section of concrete floor giving way and collapsing on another and then I believe a third, finally resting on an escalator and the lowest floor. It was a large amount of debris on a very small area. Yes, two people died and that's tragic, but the collapse was actually quite small.

So I ask, when does it become sufficient 'magnitude' to 'automatically' call in everyone? The recent Downsview collapse luckly killed only one person, was actually bigger, involving more debris, but they didn't 'automatically' call in everyone yet no one is crying foul
 
As I have already said, this CAN'T be about the premier making a call.

There HAS to be an automatic and appropriate response to an event of this magnitude, regardless of were it is, and what FRKN day it is.

And, I have to ask, WHY does it take a tragedy to happen before governments say, .....looks like we will have to look into this..... BULL SHIT.

And again, it has NOTHING to do with the people sent there, but a lot to do with how the system responded, and the incompetent people who set it up,.... but rest assured, nobody in what ever section of government responsible with be fired, or sued.

FAST

It's not as if there was a bomb that went off and there was a significant building collapse. This was a contained collapse, but still hard to get into to determine if there were survivors.

Again, unless asked, the premier cannot overstep his authority here and take charge of the situation. There is already a level of government in place, municipal, that has jurisdiction and authority in this matter. They need to make the call wheteher they can handle this or not, obviously they did, as HUSAR was deployed. It would then be up to that team on the ground to assess the situation and proceed from there as to what course of action they are taking. It's obvious now that their initial efforts found no survivors and it became a body recovery, hence the heavy equipment coming in.
 
As I have already said, this CAN'T be about the premier making a call.

You're right, there have to be automatic processes in place. However, the lack of attention BOTH from the premier's office and also honestly from the media was symptomatic of the general way the whole thing was just not taken seriously. I had expected that it would be plastered all over every front page and that it would be the lead story on every news cast--in fact, I would have expected them to switch to on the ground coverage, at the expense of other programming. None of that happened.

So the rescue responders were working in a context where they did not perceive what they were doing was a core priority for Ontario, and therefore, probably felt reluctant to ask for help or resources that they may have wanted, but which might not prove to be strictly necessary. Had the Premier and the media been there on the ground putting focus on the issue, then I doubt very much anybody would have hesitated to start plan B ahead of finding out that plan A was going to fail.

Do you remember the mine disaster in Chile? They had THREE separate operations going to try and get those guys out of there. They did not try plan A, fail, try plan B, fail, and then try plan C. They put plan A, B, and C in to effect all at the same time. That is the sort of response I would expect.

I'd have expected this conversation among the engineers and emergency scene managers: "We think we can do this job with what we have on hand, maybe only a 20% chance that structure will prove too unstable for us to proceed." "20% chance of failure huh? Then what would happen." "Well in that case we'd need heavy equipment, but it'll take a day to get here." "Ok, well get started immediately with what you have on hand, I'll order the heavy equipment just in case."
 
This is not within the provinces jurisdiction to step in and take over unless asked to do so or in the case of gross negligence from the municipal authorities in charge. They obviously did ask for help, that's why HUSAR was there. I don't see what the Premier can do and why he should drop everything for what was a minor collapse.

To equate this tradgedy to what happened in Chile is like comparing apples and oranges. Two very different situations, your comparison would be that of another building collapse, not from bombing, but a structural failure, minor in nature. Mines have plans to rescue workers in case of collapse. The Chilean miners were in a safe haven within the mine in case of such an accident. They already have plans in place and know from experience that secondary plans need to be formulated and put into action in tandem with other efforts.

To say you need an automatic process in place is a fools wish. Who would be the overseeing authority for this and who is to determine when they are called in? If this is your model, there would be a lapse in time before they hit the ground and determine what the problem is, ie; are there survivors or strictly recovery, what the specific problems are and a myriad of other issues. This lapse in time until the overseeing branch determines the best course of action delays all else. The overseeing authority is the first responders within that municipality and this was outside of their scope and would be for many municipalities, even here in the GTA.
 
This is not within the provinces jurisdiction to step in and take over unless asked to do so or in the case of gross negligence from the municipal authorities in charge. They obviously did ask for help, that's why HUSAR was there. I don't see what the Premier can do and why he should drop everything for what was a minor collapse.

To equate this tradgedy to what happened in Chile is like comparing apples and oranges. Two very different situations, your comparison would be that of another building collapse, not from bombing, but a structural failure, minor in nature. Mines have plans to rescue workers in case of collapse. The Chilean miners were in a safe haven within the mine in case of such an accident. They already have plans in place and know from experience that secondary plans need to be formulated and put into action in tandem with other efforts.

To say you need an automatic process in place is a fools wish. Who would be the overseeing authority for this and who is to determine when they are called in? If this is your model, there would be a lapse in time before they hit the ground and determine what the problem is, ie; are there survivors or strictly recovery, what the specific problems are and a myriad of other issues. This lapse in time until the overseeing branch determines the best course of action delays all else. The overseeing authority is the first responders within that municipality and this was outside of their scope and would be for many municipalities, even here in the GTA.

Well put.
 
Sikorski Helicopers (flying cranes) could have been onsite in hours.

Those hotshots at HUSAR should change their names to "Light Urban Search & Rescue"

Unfortunatly, if this were to happen again in five years the rescuers may simply not announce when they give up and give a superficial effort until life signs cease.
 
Sikorski Helicopers (flying cranes) could have been onsite in hours.

Those hotshots at HUSAR should change their names to "Light Urban Search & Rescue"

Unfortunatly, if this were to happen again in five years the rescuers may simply not announce when they give up and give a superficial effort until life signs cease.

Now back to the real world. How many flying cranes are there in Ontario? As for how much, they were a steal for the US Army at $2 million+ each. Who keeps and maintains them? Any that are around are probably fight fires somewhere in North America, quite possibly in Colorado. what exactly would they do when they get there?

As for your predictions five years from, you're calling them unprofessional and undedicated. Screw you. You are probably in that muster of crows I mentioned earlier that think fireman are headline seeking adrenalin junkies.
 
Lacking

To say you need an automatic process in place is a fools wish. Who would be the overseeing authority for this and who is to determine when they are called in? If this is your model, there would be a lapse in time before they hit the ground and determine what the problem is, ie; are there survivors or strictly recovery, what the specific problems are and a myriad of other issues. This lapse in time until the overseeing branch determines the best course of action delays all else. The overseeing authority is the first responders within that municipality and this was outside of their scope and would be for many municipalities, even here in the GTA.

Glad your happy with how this was "handled",......... the next time your family is in a mall, and a you hear the roof has collapsed ????????????

"lapse in time",...... so your happy with the lapse in time that occurred this time.......... next time your family is in a mall...........

"first responders within that municipality and this was outside of their scope"..........exactly THE point.

"fools wish".......... ya I guess I am a fool to wish that this was handled better.

The FRKN roof collapsed on people, how many, who the hell knows, ..... this is NOT complicated here, the local "overseeing authority" calls an established agency, immediately are flown out, people "trained" for this, make an assessment, the next thing that happens, is the correct and quick reaction.

The system in place now, if you could call it that, does NOT work.

FAST
 
No improvement needed

Exactly what magnitude are you talking about? I was surprise at how small an area the collapse was contained in. It was simply a single section of concrete floor giving way and collapsing on another and then I believe a third, finally resting on an escalator and the lowest floor. It was a large amount of debris on a very small area. Yes, two people died and that's tragic, but the collapse was actually quite small.

So I ask, when does it become sufficient 'magnitude' to 'automatically' call in everyone? The recent Downsview collapse luckly killed only one person, was actually bigger, involving more debris, but they didn't 'automatically' call in everyone yet no one is crying foul

"Exactly what magnitude are you talking about?"...........your right blackrock...........it was "only" two people, BUT could have been more, hind site is great!!!!!.

"'automatically' call in everyone".............were the hell did i say that ..........blackrock.

I said, that the current system.........obviuosly does NOT work, ..........unless of course ........your happy with the outcome.

FAST
 
Fast,

No I am not happy with how things were handled. It is, what it is and to arm chair quarterback is easy and to pick apart what was done is easy.

First responders scope. This would be out of scope for most municipalities, even within the GTA.

Lapse in time, is just that. Time passes while things are being done, whether you like it or not and while things are being sorted out and decisions are being made, time passes, this is something which cannot be stopped.

Fools wish, Again, you weren't there to see what decisions were being made and it's real easy to be an arm chair quaterback, especially when you don't know what the rescue team was up against.

Local overseeing authority, would be the local authorities in any case. You are unhappy with the lapse in time that occured here, yet you want to take time to fly someone to the scene and make an assessment and as you state the correct and quick reaction will take place, again, there will be a lapse in time here. There is no heavy lift aircraft standing by to bring in any of the gear these guys use, so what now?

The system in place, well there isn't one.

As for mall roofs collapsing on my family, I don't worry over needless things, especially those outside of my control.


The model you seek is what the United States has in FEMA, which Canada does not have, we have the Canadian Centre for Emergency Preparedness. HUSAR is Canada's equivalent in the SAR field, but they are untested because Canada does not suffer from some of the same things that affect the US like earthquakes and tornadic activity, which do cause building collapses.