Elliot Lake mall collapse

Casey.xox

New member
Nov 29, 2011
112
0
0
Kitchener
Yesterday they tried to tell the close knit community of Elliot Lake that they were calling off the search and rescue. What did they think would happen? Its a mining community, like Colbalt. No one got left behind in the mines, did they think loved ones would just say ok? Especially with signs of life? C'mon. If provincial services don't want to take the risk, a concerned community is willing to do it. Growing up there, it breaks my heart that this preventable accident happened. That mall had not been fixed since I was born, but the strength of the community shows the length they are willing to go for innocent victims. All too often we don't help others because of the potential cost/risk to ourselves. I hope this rubs off on other communities.
Search has been put back on after an immediate volunteer list was put together to do what they thought was too risky.

I for one would take the risk to save a loved one, or someone close to me, and I hope others would too!! Would you?
 
Yesterday they tried to tell the close knit community of Elliot Lake that they were calling off the search and rescue. What did they think would happen? Its a mining community, like Colbalt. No one got left behind in the mines, did they think loved ones would just say ok? Especially with signs of life? C'mon. If provincial services don't want to take the risk, a concerned community is willing to do it. Growing up there, it breaks my heart that this preventable accident happened. That mall had not been fixed since I was born, but the strength of the community shows the length they are willing to go for innocent victims. All too often we don't help others because of the potential cost/risk to ourselves. I hope this rubs off on other communities.
Search has been put back on after an immediate volunteer list was put together to do what they thought was too risky.

I for one would take the risk to save a loved one, or someone close to me, and I hope others would too!! Would you?


I totally agree and well put.
 
The bureaucrats and cops should back off and let willing searchers go in and try to rescue. They are willing to sign waivers so the bureaucrats won't be held liable. This is a time for real men to stand up and act, not be held back by cautious pen pushers. and paranoid regulators. There are people stuck in there praying for help who will die soon if no one answers.
 
This was tragic. I remain supprised that if at this point civil order hasn't been able to cope that the DND hasn't been asked to send in Sappers or alternatively that the governors of Michigan or Wisconsin haven't been asked if they have Engineer units.
 
friend of mine and his daughter were caught in that. she got away perfect but a little dirty, he got a cut on his cheek from a piece of glass or something.
 
It's hard to call off a search such as this. Every possible effort should be made to determine if there are any survivors and if so to rescue them if possible. The biggest problem with a scenario such as this is the fact that there are many willing parties who will do whatever it is they can, in order to help out, sometimes risks are taken in order to rescue those who need it. With a building collapse you have alot of unknowns involved, unlike a mine where it's stricly earth/rock in that needs to be moved and shored up a building is a twisted mess with very large chunks of concrete and steel that are impossible to move or if moved can cause further collapse. It's this situation that confounds people as to why every effort isn't being made to rescue or why the recue has been called off, but you don't want the rescuers in need of being rescued because then all recue efforts cease for those they were trying to find. Without being able to ascertain the condition of the collapse, it is difficult to see why the rescue effort has been called off, I would hazard a guess to say that the stability of the collapse is in question, making entry inside too hazardous to conduct stabilizing efforts in order to conduct a proper search. Without positive proof of life inside the collapse the further risking of life would be unwarranted for a cadaver search, considering the state of the collapse. The unfortunate part is that these missing people are all part of families and the small community. It is a sad day.
 
With a building collapse you have alot of unknowns involved, unlike a mine where it's stricly earth/rock in that needs to be moved and shored up a building is a twisted mess with very large chunks of concrete and steel that are impossible to move or if moved can cause further collapse.

I agree with what most of you say, except that in a collapsed mine situation it is NOT just earth and rock. Gone are the days of digging by hand with shovels by candle light lol. Mines these days are huge, hundreds of feet under neath, thousands of pounds of twisted steel supports, hundreds of huuuge 2 tonne mining trucks/drillers/excavators etc... Not to mention some stocks of explosives and there's always the threat of digging upon a gas pocket. Mines are a lot more complicated than just 'earth and rocks'.
 
As a side comment

There are some questions that have to be answered.

This building was given a structural clean bill of health just one month ago.

Incredible.
 
It's hard to call off a search such as this. Every possible effort should be made to determine if there are any survivors and if so to rescue them if possible. The biggest problem with a scenario such as this is the fact that there are many willing parties who will do whatever it is they can, in order to help out, sometimes risks are taken in order to rescue those who need it. With a building collapse you have alot of unknowns involved. . . .
All true, but the same happens in earthquakes and this is but one mall, how much easier to send in the specialists for one building (and in the summer at that) than for an earthquake.

I wonder, and this is an honest I don't know what has been asked, whether the Province or Federal Govenment have asked for the assistance of those types of specialists.
 
This building was given a structural clean bill of health just one month ago.
Our infrastructure is crumbling. Bridges falling down in Quebec. Gardiner is falling apart. Have you ever notice when there is a tornado, it is the newer houses that lose their roofs. Workmanship today is so shoddy. These condos built in Toronto will fall apart well before my 600 year old house does. Window panes are already falling off office and residential buildings in downtown Toronto. If you are up in a tall office building, do not, repeat, do not stand near the window.
 
There are some questions that have to be answered.

This building was given a structural clean bill of health just one month ago.

Incredible.

Incredibly scary that a month ago it was deemed a safe building. Wonder how those people are feeling now?
 
Yesterday they tried to tell the close knit community of Elliot Lake that they were calling off the search and rescue. What did they think would happen? Especially with signs of life? C'mon. If provincial services don't want to take the risk, a concerned community is willing to do it.

.Search has been put back on after an immediate volunteer list was put together to do what they thought was too risky.

Horrible decision made to call off the rescue. If the situation was indeed dangerous, then make the rescuers aware of the fact and focus their efforts on finding other solutions - The last thing you want to do is quit and give up hope for the friends/families who have loved ones trapped beneath the rubble.
 
Not only was it retarded to call off the rescue, it's unfathomable that it wasn't a higher profile response from day one. It looks like it was left in the hands of local administrators who simply do not have the management skills to cope with a disaster like this, and it took 2 or 3 days before the people who actually can organize an effective response took over and began to do so.

Heavy equipment should have been inbound within hours of the accident happening, not days later.
 
Not only was it retarded to call off the rescue, it's unfathomable that it wasn't a higher profile response from day one. It looks like it was left in the hands of local administrators who simply do not have the management skills to cope with a disaster like this, and it took 2 or 3 days before the people who actually can organize an effective response took over and began to do so.

Heavy equipment should have been inbound within hours of the accident happening, not days later.

This rescue should have been outsourced offshore.
 
Elliot Lake mall collapse

1st the disaster happened in a remote part of Ontario (check the map)
2nd the disaster happened on a weekend so weekend staff were involved in assessing the situation

result, uhhh what should we do?
uhhh
 
Why didn't the military respond sooner?
Aren't they trained to go into 'dangerous' situations?
How would you feel if your mom, sister or son was one of the trapped?
 
Our infrastructure is crumbling. Bridges falling down in Quebec. Gardiner is falling apart. Have you ever notice when there is a tornado, it is the newer houses that lose their roofs. Workmanship today is so shoddy. These condos built in Toronto will fall apart well before my 600 year old house does. Window panes are already falling off office and residential buildings in downtown Toronto. If you are up in a tall office building, do not, repeat, do not stand near the window.

That's simply because our various levels of government spend their time and (our) money on social design and experimentation rather than on providing the basic services that Canadians need to live normal lives.