Elliot Lake mall collapse

McGuinty was two hours away in Sudbury when this happened. He should have been a true leader and made things happen. This sort of thing should come instinctively. It unfortunately reminds me of the shameful non-reaction of GWB during the Katrina disaster. This is a low point in Ontario's history.

Then you know less about disaster response in the US than in Canada, but i'll let the US members fill you in.
 
Pretty messed up for whomever it was that decided to call off the search with survivors still in there.

The excuse that it is too dangerous is bullshit. I'm pretty confident that the people would have been willing to risk it and go try and rescue some people.
 
Cya

I'm not a Mcwimpy fan by any stretch, and admit to having no knowledge on how the system works in this case, BUT... one would think the response to this tragedy should NOT have been ....... have the premier of a province make a call to get things rolling.

Would have though there would be strategies in place to follow in such a case, regardless of what day of the week it is.

It was obvious in minutes what had happened, and if this is not automatic, its going to happen again.

We all like to blame the current person at the top for screw ups like this, BUT.... the system that was/is in place doesn't work.

And, also has NOTHING to do with the guys doing the front line work.

Last point, not that anybody gives a shit, the whole inspection thing really gives me a bad feeling, whether there was pay-offs, or just shoddy work.... heads should roll !!!!!

FAST
 
I'm not a Mcwimpy fan by any stretch, and admit to having no knowledge on how the system works in this case, BUT... one would think the response to this tragedy should NOT have been ....... have the premier of a province make a call to get things rolling.

Would have though there would be strategies in place to follow in such a case, regardless of what day of the week it is.

It was obvious in minutes what had happened, and if this is not automatic, its going to happen again.

We all like to blame the current person at the top for screw ups like this, BUT.... the system that was/is in place doesn't work.

And, also has NOTHING to do with the guys doing the front line work.

Last point, not that anybody gives a shit, the whole inspection thing really gives me a bad feeling, whether there was pay-offs, or just shoddy work.... heads should roll !!!!!

FAST

Too bad people have to die for the system to be evaluated.
 
Pretty messed up for whomever it was that decided to call off the search with survivors still in there.

The excuse that it is too dangerous is bullshit. I'm pretty confident that the people would have been willing to risk it and go try and rescue some people.


Would you feel different if they used heat sensors to detect signs life, or micro phones that can pick up the sounds of breathing or gas sensor that can pick up the tiniest presence of cadaverine, putrescine, indole, and skatole? Do you know that they didn't?

With all due respect FC, look up SPME and learn a little about the dead and dieing.

Yes, first responders like this will take risks, but calculated risks. I've seen first hand them being yanked off a mountain after dark fell. The danger is too great. Like I said earlier, few on here have sent people into dangerous situations like this. The fact you say it's BS, tells me you're not one of them.
 
Would you feel different if they used heat sensors to detect signs life, or micro phones that can pick up the sounds of breathing or gas sensor that can pick up the tiniest presence of cadaverine, putrescine, indole, and skatole?

Look up SPME and learn a little about the dead and dieing.

What are you saying? Are you suggesting that when they called it off there were no survivors?

I'm just basing this on stories of earthquake survivors found 7 days after. I think 7 days is about the max for a person trapped with no water. Could be wrong. But didn't they call it off after two days?

My understanding and this is second hand information was tht they could still hear tapping and that the search was called off due to the risk to the searchers.
 
What are you saying? Are you suggesting that when they called it off there were no survivors?

I'm just basing this on stories of earthquake survivors found 7 days after. I think 7 days is about the max for a person trapped with no water. Could be wrong. But didn't they call it off after two days?

My understanding and this is second hand information was tht they could still hear tapping and that the search was called off due to the risk to the searchers.

It's three to five days, 'IF' you're in good health and clear headed. IIRC, the bodies were found under heavy rubble. At best, under duress. At worst severely injured.
 
But didn't they call it off after two days?

So maybe they already knew something. After the two days, didn't they start using the term recovery and not rescue? Have you heard anything from the coroners report to give time of death yet. There is so much more to come, but there will always be some who will throw blame around based on so little knowledge.
 
Never mind cbc website gave a pretty in depth timeline. Will have to have a talk with the friend who over dinner gave me the wrong info, lol

Personally, I think the search stops on day 7. From what I googles living that long without water is rare or a miracle but still possible. Day 8 forget about it.
 
So maybe they already knew something. After the two days, didn't they start using the term recovery and not rescue? Have you heard anything from the coroners report to give time of death yet. There is so much more to come, but there will always be some who will throw blame around based on so little knowledge.

Are you just arguing for the sake of it?!!!??? What is your point? What could they have known on day 2? When you have to start justifying things by saying "maybe this or that" you're stretching.

I'm not pretending to know the specifics of the collapse but in general in situations where people are trapped like that search and rescue attempts seem to go longer than 2 days. I'm just basing it on past news stories about earthquakes and landslides.
 
Never mind cbc website gave a pretty in depth timeline. Will have to have a talk with the friend who over dinner gave me the wrong info, lol

Personally, I think the search stops on day 7. From what I googles living that long without water is rare or a miracle but still possible. Day 8 forget about it.

Yes, if you're not injured. Miracles do happen, but that is why I say they must have known something by not getting any signs of life and getting readings of the presence of any or all the chemicals I mentioned earlier. The latter is how cadaver dogs find buried corpses.

If you are traveling through Tennessee and have a little time on hand, see if you can take a tour of the U of Tenn. Body Farm. It's not on any tour maps.
 
You know forget it. A person can survive up to a week without water (based on my internet search) as such I am an optomist and think that search and rescue should last 7 days.

It's really just an opinion based on what I know about chances of survival and what I would hope for if I were trapped or a family member was trapped.

Also, I wouldn't want to be the guy to call things off before all hope is lost. Now way I could look those families in the eyes.
 
Yes, if you're not injured. Miracles do happen, but that is why I say they must have known something by not getting any signs of life and getting readings of the presence of any or all the chemicals I mentioned earlier. The latter is how cadaver dogs find buried corpses.

If you are traveling through Tennessee and have a little time on hand, see if you can take a tour of the U of Tenn. Body Farm. It's not on any tour maps.

So it's not possible that in the collapse the rubble falls in such a way that a pocket large enough for a human could be?
 
Yes, if you're not injured. Miracles do happen, but that is why I say they must have known something by not getting any signs of life and getting readings of the presence of any or all the chemicals I mentioned earlier. The latter is how cadaver dogs find buried corpses.

If you are traveling through Tennessee and have a little time on hand, see if you can take a tour of the U of Tenn. Body Farm. It's not on any tour maps.

Are those tests you suggested only good for finding corpes?
 
Would you feel different if they used heat sensors to detect signs life, or micro phones that can pick up the sounds of breathing or gas sensor that can pick up the tiniest presence of cadaverine, putrescine, indole, and skatole? Do you know that they didn't?

With all due respect FC, look up SPME and learn a little about the dead and dieing.

Yes, first responders like this will take risks, but calculated risks. I've seen first hand them being yanked off a mountain after dark fell. The danger is too great. Like I said earlier, few on here have sent people into dangerous situations like this. The fact you say it's BS, tells me you're not one of them.

Well these people signed up for a dangerous job so some risk is part of the job.
 
Anyways, one things for sure. Neither you nor I can guarantee that everyone was dead when they called it off.
 
Are you just arguing for the sake of it?!!!??? What is your point? What could they have known on day 2? When you have to start justifying things by saying "maybe this or that" you're stretching.

I'm not pretending to know the specifics of the collapse but in general in situations where people are trapped like that search and rescue attempts seem to go longer than 2 days. I'm just basing it on past news stories about earthquakes and landslides.

What I'm saying is that there is all sorts of procedures that can be done and may have been done that wasn't reported that would aid them in making the decisions they did. We just don't know 500 miles away.

What could they have known at the end of day 2? That there was no signs of life and there was evidence of death.