It's unfortunate that a child died. The yard was fenced off, but not the pond. Why was this child allowed to walk into a neighbors yards? The kid was being watched by the grandmother ???
I've see many houses with ponds,the yards are fenced off. Does this bylaw require an additional fence just around the pond ?
Should we put a fence around everything ?? I have a kids playset in my yard, I should fence if off just in case one of the neighorhood kids decided to jump off the highest point and break his neck.
Adults need to be responsible for their offspring !
Another repetition of a maxim no one has ever disputed.
The yard was fenced, but the gate was broken, and off its mounting. It had been broken and repaired previously, and was broken again. The broken gate had been reported to the owner some days previously, but he had not yet come to deal with it.
The by-law requires that there be a fence surrounding and enclosing a pond or pool. Openings must have gates/doors that are self-closing and latching. If the yard that the pool is in has all that stuff, everything's legal.
As to your backyard playset, no authority that I know has legislated a fence. That sort of silly hyperbole has only come from over-excited folks trying to equate the danger of a skinned knee with drowning. But by all means, if you're concerned, fence it off.
But along the lines of silly hyperbole, let me pose a counter-question. Suppose you move your playset to your unfenced front yard, near the sidewalk that kids come and go to school along. No one's at home at your house during the day and most of the little darlin's walk unsupervised, so predictably enough one of them falls off the playset, gashes his forehead on his buddy's skateboard and weeks later is still suffering from concussion. Was this a sensible or stupid set up for the set? What is your responsibility in the injury? What was your responsibilty to have prevented it? If you were aware of a dangerous defect, would that alter responsibility? Discuss pros and cons and justify your conclusion. (35marks)

