Pond Death

Rockslinger

Banned
Apr 24, 2005
32,764
0
0
Here is a lesson for all homeowners. Heard on the news yesterday that a Scarborough homeowner has been arrested on criminal negligence charges because a neighbour's 2 year old child drowned in his/her backyard pond. He or she might be facing a civil liability suit as well.
 
What's a 2 year old doing crawling around the yard all by himself?
By the OP's account he was crawling around the neighbour's yard. The story I read was not clear on that, perhaps because an extended family appears to be involved.

The story did make clear, at 600mm deep your little ornamental fond needs to be fenced. This one was not.
 
Exactly, and why were they not charged?

Seems in this country its everyone else's fault when something happens...
Do you know they were not? Or won't be? Seems in this country everyone's opinion has to be stated, no matter how half or quarter-baked and no one bothers with facts. But for now, let's just leave the parents grieving their kid's death, and the cops and other authorities to do their jobs properly, not like some knee-jerks.

Facts take a tad longer to gather than reading a coupla lines on a PoonPanel.

But to repeat known and easily measured facts: As far as ponds and water features go, if it's more than 600mm, it needs a fence. Which is why the pond's owner was charged.

Make sure yours is fenced, and that the fence meets the standard.
 
Don't recall if Canadian Tort Law includes Attractive Nuisance but that is what this involves.

Further, this was not a farm pond several hundred meters from the roadway but rather suburbia a few meters from the property line.
 
Google claims that 600 millimeters = 23.6220472 inches
Yep. As in the olden days—garden ponds have needed fences since forever—two feet deep needs a fence. And not just any fence; there's a legal requirement. Note also, the measurement is not the water depth. It's the maximum depth it could hold at overflowing.
 
Don't recall if Canadian Tort Law includes Attractive Nuisance but that is what this involves.

Further, this was not a farm pond several hundred meters from the roadway but rather suburbia a few meters from the property line.

We try to keep tort simple and would call this plain old negligence. And I would take that case in a heartbeat.
 
the parents were criminally negligent for letting the little 2 year old kid crawl off out of their sight. The trespassing would not have happened if they had been attentive and responsible parents.
 
the parents were criminally negligent for letting the little 2 year old kid crawl off out of their sight. The trespassing would not have happened if they had been attentive and responsible parents.

What facts do you know about this case that the media has not published?

Who had care and control of the child at the time of the incident?
 
I wonder if it is the backyard that needs to be fenced. I've never seen an in-ground pool
in an unfenced backyard. Fenced swimming pool in an unfenced backyard seems rare.
 
I wonder if it is the backyard that needs to be fenced. I've never seen an in-ground pool
in an unfenced backyard. Fenced swimming pool in an unfenced backyard seems rare.

You seem to be confusing swimming pools and ornamental ponds. This case involves a pond. I believe it's the same fence requirement. The difference is people bring home the pond kit from Home Depot and pay no attention to the part about checking your local bylaws.
 
You seem to be confusing swimming pools and ornamental ponds. This case involves a pond. I believe it's the same fence requirement. The difference is people bring home the pond kit from Home Depot and pay no attention to the part about checking your local bylaws.

If wasn't the pond , it might have been the kid crawling out onto the street or crawling up the porch steps and then falling off the deck onto a garden stake....the fact is...the kid was left unattended...either by the parents or the appointed guardian, nanny or granny.
 
I don't know the entire details, but I'm assuming that the kid decided to sneak into the neighbours backyard without permission. Sorry the kid got killed but charging the owner for negligence? its a fucking 25inch pond, in private property for god sakes xDD There is a huge pond, storm water retention pool steps away from my house, one that is dangerous for even an adult. Its not fenced. Who does one blame if one of the dozens of kids outside playing decide to venture in there and gets killed?

Watch your fucking kids parents! It wasn't like the pond was built into the public footpath. One should be allowed to have their entire backyard wired with live electrical wire or like without having to worry about getting charged if some random kid or person decides to trespass and gets killed. Isn't that the same as having a vicious pitbull to protect one's property?
 
If the neighbor charged with negligence does not end up in jail
he could still face civilian lawsuit from the parents of the
dead child. I hope the government will not have to fence Lake
Ontario as well as all the rivers and ponds to prevent future
water-related deaths. The neighbor deserves to be blamed not for his
negligence but for his being so cheap. He should be fined a bylaw
fee far in excess of the cost of fencing his backyard.
 
Yes the pond's owner violated something but the parents/guardians of a 2 year old have a damn large burden of neglect here. I believe that the law says something about that.
 
The neighbor deserves to be blamed not for his
negligence but for his being so cheap. He should be fined a bylaw
fee far in excess of the cost of fencing his backyard.
Agree. The criminal negligence causing death charge is over the top.

Here is a hypotectical(sp) example. Let say our friend OJ leaves his house in a rush and forgets to lock his front door. His neighbour's 2 year old kid wanders inside and is killed when he topples OJ's 30 year old 600 pound cathode tube TV which crushes his skull. Should OJ be charged with criminal negligence causing death or simply with violating the "lock your front door" bylaw?
 
.......
Property owner spends money and takes the time to build artificial pond with slippery plastic lined sloped sides on his property.

Fenced in yard with self-closing gate and latch is a long time, statutory legal requirement and common sense responsibility of property owners who have water features within their property. This law was specifically enacted to protect the children of both the property owner and those in the neighbourhood, who do not know enough to stay away from an attractive, but dangerous feature.
.............................................

Not to be argumentative, but I believe such law only requires fencing against entry from
the outside not from the inside which means children of the owner are left unprotected.
At least that is the case with in-ground swimming pool. I do think no one in his right mind
would leave a backyard with a pool or pond unfenced. But I suspect a fence surrounding
the backyard is only meant to keep people from trespassing on the mind of most people.
 
Last edited:
Ridiculous analogy that only serves to reinforce your initial prejudice.

How about this analogy.

Property owner spends money and takes the time to build artificial pond with slippery plastic lined sloped sides on his property.

Fenced in yard with self-closing gate and latch is a long time, statutory legal requirement and common sense responsibility of property owners who have water features within their property. This law was specifically enacted to protect the children of both the property owner and those in the neighbourhood, who do not know enough to stay away from an attractive, but dangerous feature.

Property owner's wooden fence is so rotten that the gate falls off its hinges. Man notices gate fell off, leaves gate leaned up against fence, intending to re-install it but neglects to do so. The rest of the man's property is a shambles of other junk and debris and other signs of neglect.

The property owner, knowing there are children living right next door and on the street, is, or ought to be aware of the hazard, and his responsibility to address known hazards.

As a result of his continuing neglect, a two year old child does exactly what the law has anticipated might happens and slips away from their caregiver and drowns.

A life is lost due to this negligence and therefore it becomes criminal in nature.

Read this http://www.cjc-ccm.gc.ca/english/lawyers_en.asp?selMenu=lawyers_cn_offence220_en.asp

how about......Kids parents should be charged for not keeping their kid at home, for not locking their door so their kid can't wander off and for not keeping their kid on a leash knowing they are careless parents who would rather do other things than keep their eye on their 2 year old. I thought it was common sense for parents to not turn their back on kids this young for even a few minutes.