Pond Death

It's unfortunate that a child died. The yard was fenced off, but not the pond. Why was this child allowed to walk into a neighbors yards? The kid was being watched by the grandmother ???

I've see many houses with ponds,the yards are fenced off. Does this bylaw require an additional fence just around the pond ?

Should we put a fence around everything ?? I have a kids playset in my yard, I should fence if off just in case one of the neighorhood kids decided to jump off the highest point and break his neck.

Adults need to be responsible for their offspring !

Another repetition of a maxim no one has ever disputed.

The yard was fenced, but the gate was broken, and off its mounting. It had been broken and repaired previously, and was broken again. The broken gate had been reported to the owner some days previously, but he had not yet come to deal with it.

The by-law requires that there be a fence surrounding and enclosing a pond or pool. Openings must have gates/doors that are self-closing and latching. If the yard that the pool is in has all that stuff, everything's legal.

As to your backyard playset, no authority that I know has legislated a fence. That sort of silly hyperbole has only come from over-excited folks trying to equate the danger of a skinned knee with drowning. But by all means, if you're concerned, fence it off.

But along the lines of silly hyperbole, let me pose a counter-question. Suppose you move your playset to your unfenced front yard, near the sidewalk that kids come and go to school along. No one's at home at your house during the day and most of the little darlin's walk unsupervised, so predictably enough one of them falls off the playset, gashes his forehead on his buddy's skateboard and weeks later is still suffering from concussion. Was this a sensible or stupid set up for the set? What is your responsibility in the injury? What was your responsibilty to have prevented it? If you were aware of a dangerous defect, would that alter responsibility? Discuss pros and cons and justify your conclusion. (35marks)
 
But my question is ... IF the pond had been a foot deep would he still be liable .
Actually, OldJones already answered this question in an earlier post. We now live in the age of the "blame game". Lots of money to be made by blaming others (like Chris Brown suing the club for not stopping Drake from beating him up).

That OldJones is quick on the keyboard. Just noticed he responded already.
 
Actually, OldJones already answered this question in an earlier post. We now live in the age of the "blame game". Lots of money to be made by blaming others (like Chris Brown suing the club for not stopping Drake from beating him up).

That OldJones is quick on the keyboard. Just noticed he responded already.
As I'm not a lawyer, what I may say on liability is just my opinion; on pond depth, the law only says it must be fenced IF the pond is more than a specified depth. Period and full stop. Only irresponsible, obstructionist idiots would demand the honkin' thick statute that would result from specifying in minute detail all aspects and variations of measurement, depth, slope and so forth. And so, as you intimated above, if your pond was 599.999999 mm deep—and you could prove it, as such a defence would undoubtedly require—then you would get off on the minor charge of not fencing the pool.

That silly millimetre would do nothing to lighten either your guilty regret that you could easily have prevented the a drowning, nor would it much help you in whatever liability case grieving parent plaintiffs might make, although having the fence would have. In fact many would say scrimping on the fence, because of that silly millimetre was like White Star scrimping on lifeboats for the Titanic. The law only sets the minimum for the worst people, you and I are supposed to do our best., or at least a reasonable effort at living in society

It's particularly bizarre to read people railing against nanny laws who imagine they're somehow scoring by pointing out the law isn't nanny enough. Perhaps they should think of it this way: Everyone else is much stupider than you, especially parents of small children. Unless you take measures, they will annoy, endanger and irritate you. Fence your pond and spare yourself the inconvenience of finding a dead two-year old floating in it when you come back from the cottage.

Much more practical than imagining the kid's parents will learn from your complaints about on TERB. And, hey! you'll avoid a bylaw ticket.
 
Imagine if the defense claims the pond was drained to legal realty but an unexpected raised.fall raised it.....hmmmm
 
The myth is that accidents happen, and therefore what happens is an accident. Just as you imagine that attentive parents would have saved the kid, I know a fence built to the prescribed standard would have. I also know that not minding him, and not having the fence means that this child's death was no accident. It was entirely and easily preventable. Those who could have, should have, and did not live up to their responsibility to prevent it must face the consequences.

Nothing more needs to be said.

There are no accidents.
The parents failed to watch the child.
ANYthing & EVERYthing that happened to that child after their failure is entirely due to their failure.
The details of what happened after the parents failed doesn't even merit discussion.
Full stop.
Period.
Nothing more needs to be said.
 
Actually, OldJones already answered this question in an earlier post. We now live in the age of the "blame game". Lots of money to be made by blaming others (like Chris Brown suing the club for not stopping Drake from beating him up).

That OldJones is quick on the keyboard. Just noticed he responded already.

Civil liability is debatable, but the real problem here is the criminal charges laid against the pond owner. That is really over the top.
 
There are no accidents.
The parents failed to watch the child.
ANYthing & EVERYthing that happened to that child after their failure is entirely due to their failure.
The details of what happened after the parents failed doesn't even merit discussion.
Full stop.
Period.
Nothing more needs to be said.

Really? So parents fail to watch their child and a drunk driver runs the kid down and the drunk driver walks?

Nothing more needs to be said?
 
Civil liability is debatable, but the real problem here is the criminal charges laid against the pond owner. That is really over the top.

Read the occupier's liability act, read some of the cases on it. Civil liability is a slam dunk.

The criminal charge does seem a little hefty to me (as I mentioned before).
 
Really? So parents fail to watch their child and a drunk driver runs the kid down and the drunk driver walks?

Nothing more needs to be said?

OMG... If you're too stupid to see the difference between the 2 situations then YES let the DD fucking walk..... If everything has to be so simple for your brain to follow that's easier than explaining a thing called subtlety.

To those with BRAINS I'll answer with some detail. If the DD was driving on a PUBLIC road then yes he should be held responsible. If he was just on his own property & had no intention of leaving it in that condition (like a private racetrack or whatever) then absolutely not...NO...
 
both the property owner and the parents / guardian / nanny are held accountable for this "tresspasser's" death. None of this would've happened if:
Parents/guardian/nanny was paying attention to the tot...
Owner followed the guidelines or wasn't cheap enought to put on some fence. There are a lot of homeowners who doesn't give a shit about guidelines and safety because of the thought..."fuck it! nothing's going to happen"...until something does.
They can point fingers but I think in this case the Crown will put all their heads in a spike.
 
OMG... If you're too stupid to see the difference between the 2 situations then YES let the DD fucking walk..... If everything has to be so simple for your brain to follow that's easier than explaining a thing called subtlety.

To those with BRAINS I'll answer with some detail. If the DD was driving on a PUBLIC road then yes he should be held responsible. If he was just on his own property & had no intention of leaving it in that condition (like a private racetrack or whatever) then absolutely not...NO...

The good news mexi is that in the real world of Ontario, your opinion holds no sway. You may dream of some strange utopia where negligent people get off the hook for doing negligent acts that kill young people...but we don't govern ourselves that way.

You see the law in common law countries has reflected the principle for centuries that you must act in a way that prevents forseeable harm to your neighbours. It really works well actually.
 
Forseeable being the operative word: Like the fence was there because the owner foresaw that without one, adults wouldn't know where not to go. And the gate was there because he foresaw that not everyone is an adult, polite enough to ask before entering.
 
Last edited:
LKD has convinced me. I want to build a bear trap in my back yard. Anyone who falls in the pit and dies on the metal spikes at the bottom should not have been trespassing and any curious neighbourhood kids are the responsibility of their parents.

1.1289252340.nope-its-a-spike-trap.jpg
 
"Death by misadventure". Every year I hear reports of death by misadventure. Adults die because they are drunk or foolish. Kids die because their parents or guardians lost track of them. Unless we ring fence every water fountain, every lake, every escalator, every mountain, etc. people will continue to suffer death by misadventure.

Not sure if the kid died, but this 10 year old kid was riding up the escalator on the handrail until he fell. Maybe the mall owner should have installed safety nets to catch falling kids or adults.
 
"Death by misadventure". Every year I hear reports of death by misadventure. Adults die because they are drunk or foolish. Kids die because their parents or guardians lost track of them. Unless we ring fence every water fountain, every lake, every escalator, every mountain, etc. people will continue to suffer death by misadventure.

Not sure if the kid died, but this 10 year old kid was riding up the escalator on the handrail until he fell. Maybe the mall owner should have installed safety nets to catch falling kids or adults.

While cannot prevent all deaths by misadventure, we do promote regulations that try to cut the rate if the cost and engineering is reasonable.

I guess you want to do away with the building code, speed limits, helmet laws...all must seem pretty silly to you. Until you have to deal with the consequences.
 
You know very well no one is saying that. But what has been re-iterated is the guardian is responsible for their child. The law is trying to do something it isn't capable of.

Actually that is exactly where Rockslinger's logic leads. He argues death by misadventure cannot be eliminated so don't bother trying.

A guardian is responsible for a child. And the neighbour is also responsible for having a danger on his property. The difficulty is that people are thinking in absolutes, which are rarely of any value. Is it not possible for more than one person to be responsible? Could the guardian be 75% responsible and the neighbour 25%?

How about applying the classic "but for" test? How does it work here?

The law is trying to do something it is perfectly capable of. It is trying to regulate conduct in a manner that can reduce bad outcomes. Exactly what our law is for.
 
You know very well no one is saying that. But what has been re-iterated is the guardian is responsible for their child. The law is trying to do something it isn't capable of.
No one disputes that responibilty. The law says so, although it is clearly not capable of making parents responsible. Again no one disputes that. It like wise speaks to the responsibility of property owners. They are required to take reasonable preventive measures to eliminate serious, forseeable dangers to others.

In case they—like this owner—are too lazy, slipshod or unthinking to figure the details out themselves, various specific laws actually spell some of them out. Like how to build so the house doesn't crash down on its neighbours, how to keep your dangerous dog, or store flammables and poisons, or how to secure access to a pond or pool. It can't prevent you from doing bad things, but it can warn you and we hope deter you through fear

If "The law … trying to do something it isn't capable of" was a reasonable argument for not using it, we wouldn't have laws against murder. Doing what we can to prevent wanton, unnescessary death is an almost universal use of law. Why ever would you be advancing an argument against it?
 
The good news mexi is that in the real world of Ontario, your opinion holds no sway. You may dream of some strange utopia where negligent people get off the hook for doing negligent acts that kill young people...but we don't govern ourselves that way.

You see the law in common law countries has reflected the principle for centuries that you must act in a way that prevents forseeable harm to your neighbours. It really works well actually.

tic toc..
 
The problem is 1) that it does not work and 2) forseeable is not really quantifiable.

1) It does not work because people simply don't know. Anyone that knows, not a problem.

2) An escalator net is really really cheap, but it looks ugly. A front fenced yard is a good idea, but it too doesn't look consistent and is too much expense for a home owner.

REAL ponds have no fence.

1) what makes you say that? do you have stats for the number of drownings or drowning related injuries have remained the same since the various by-laws have been passed? Do you think builders and contractors and homeowners don't know the requirements of the law? If "not knowing" is the real problem, isn't the answer education rather than removing the law?

2) I expect that escalators are also fairly regulated, and that their safety has been the subject of significant study that resulted in those regulations. I have no idea how many children are injured in escalator falls. Some numbers or trends is so much more useful than single incidents when trying to discuss policy of this type.

REAL ponds are not located in residential neighbours where the density of children is expected to be high.
 
lol -really? - Well I submit to you that it can't regulate conduct punitively or by waving a magic wand and ignorantly passing laws.

If that were the case there would be fewer and fewer people both in jail and going through the legal system. This is clearly not the case. The message is not being received or understood.

Punitive regulation is the norm. Speeding tickets, fines, jail sentences. It almost sounds like you want to abandon the rule of law completely.

What number of people do we have to have in jail before we know that we are over-regulated? Are you really suggesting that most people in jail, or even a large proportion of them did not know their actions were illegal? Is that what you are really suggesting?

Have you looked at say...the injury reduction we have by seatbelts? Or by building code regulations? Do you think they don't reduce injuries and deaths? What about workplace safety and hazardous materials handling? How about pollution laws? All useless? Really?