I didn't read the entire thread (sorry!) so if this has already been commented on, my apologies! But I have to point this out in case someone else didn't... So let me get this straight... a woman who is a 'high-achiever' career wise, and makes more money than you is a 'bitch' and probably ugly? Wow.
What women like most in a man is: CONFIDENCE. Not arrogance, confidence. So many people confuse the two and end up coming off like assholes. Confidence, a good sense of humour, intelligence and a good heart. Being good looking always helps, but I don't care if you're a millionaire and the hottest guy ever, if you're an idiot and a dick I could care less about you. Of course there are girls out there that are obsessed with finding a 'hot' guy or someone with a ton of money. But there are a lot of women out there, good looking, smart women, who would prefer what I mentioned above over some vapid mannequin to parade around.
This is my view on it anyway, and anytime this topic has come up amongst my girlfriends and I it's pretty much unanimous. And yes, all my friends are hot!

They can be as picky as they want.
One last point: one of my best friends is on the shorter side (he's about 5'7", maybe a bit less) has an average job, is cute but not 'hot' per se, doesn't drive, but always dates the hottest chicks! Like I mean HOT. And it's because he has all the qualities I mentioned above.