Over the past 25 years I've been a member of...
Bally Matrix - Long closed
Muscle Factory - Long closed
Goodlife (Eaton center, Yonge St Clair) - Its a alright gym if you are looking for a basic gym at a decent price. IMO the machine's are lacking compared to other more modern gym's. Another thing I didn't like was at both locations the dumbbell's were always scattered throughout the gym. It was very frustrating to me when I finished a set and returned my pair of dumbbell's only to find the next weight that I was looking for was taken but not returned or there were only one dumbbell:frusty:left in the rack. Dumbbell's, curling bar's, weight plates were never put back in the proper spot after members used them so I was always hunting around the gym floor looking for the stuff I wanted to use. A huge waste of time and dangerous becus the floor was littered with gear a few times I almost tripped over stuff with heavy dumbbell's in my hands.
Extreme Fitness (Yonge/Shepp) very, very crowded not good air circulation plus the low ceiling made for a stinky gym (lack of sq feet). For some reason it always smelt like pepperoni and hot sausage to me. Not going to start a race war but the certain clientele that frequented that gym really reeked when they sweat. I'm not talking about average sweat smells like myself but musty sausage smells that make you want to finish your workout as fast as possible and get the hell ouuta there. Can't recommend
Pure Fitness at 939 Eglinton Avenue East
http://www.purefitnesscanada.com/contact-us.php
I was a member there for 4 years and for the money I think it is the best gym in the city. I paid $45. a month which is a fair price since it is a very clean gym with high ceiling's, good air circulation and a neat and tidy dumbbell/free weight area. All the weights are organized and put back where they belong after use by the members and even staff. The gym is spacious with enough cardio equip and the men's change room is clean and tidy. The gym never smells due to the space size and quality air ventilation system. I really enjoyed my workouts at this gym and the only reason I changed gyms was becus I moved and unfortunately there's only 1 purefitness gym. IMO the best low key non crowded gym in the city.
If you want a gym that is clean, has good air ventilation, free weight area tidy, lots of good free parking, decent membership rate, modern equipment and good cardio machines. I would say check out purefitness it's close to Eglinton and Laird. I think the membership rate is about $45-$60 a month but just haggle with them and whine about Goodlife offering you a $45. corp rate and they will hook you up, I doubt you'll pay more then $50 a month which is fair imo compared to what you get.
I've always looked at purefitness as a great undercover gym since not allot of people know about it so it's not packed like other gyms'.
Good luck